[Anime]Doraemon (Renewal 2005)

Anime total pnts rank=Avg x Eval	Rank 3,592/in 3,597 titles(Total -358/Deviation -2.69)	Rank 3,591<= => Rank 3,593
Anime avg pnts(minimum:10 evals)	Rank 1,921/in 2,003 titles(Average -1.23=Bad/291 reviews)	Rank 1,920<= => Rank 1,922
Anime total pnts rank of 2005	Rank 171/in 171 titles	Rank 170<=

2008/06/18 Good(+1 pnt) [Edit/Delete/Suggest to delete/Show only this review or post sympathy comment/(Everyone can)]
by HUNGRY SPIDER (Skip) Review history[Good:1(25%) Normal:1(25%) Bad:2(50%)] / Provider: 4807 Host:4558 Browser: 7395
[What is good]

Sometimes, This animation surprises me....how similar to Comic it is!
The reason why such similarity is good point of this work is,
original Doraemon has many aspect, comedy heartful-drama, SF etc....
And it involve hard poison. In short, original is too deep.
Although not perfect, this animation expresses such various aspect.
Old version was too different from original, and I often felt that
"Is it a Doraemon?" So, I'm satisfied with this work roughly.

And I'll talk about CV for a moment.
I think Sizuka's CV is nice! Because she is not a graceful girl,
but a charming and flesh girl. And new CV raises this point.
Good job, this Sizuka is so pretty.

[What is bad]

Hit or Miss
Sometimes, this animation makes me feel that "Please pay back time."
In other words, it is like a gamble. Good time is Very Good,
but bad time is Very bad.

[Summary]
Maybe, readers feel that this reviewer is a believer of New-Dora.
I know, I can't deny it. But, I want to emphasize that this version is
like a comic version, and this animation esteems for comic.
I think Doraemon(comic) is the best work, and I'm glad to have a chance
to see this animetion, conveying that great comic.
So, I want to say, "This animation is good."

2005/05/28 Normal(+0 pnt) [Edit/Delete/Suggest to delete/Show only this review or post sympathy comment/(Everyone can)]
by TAKARAYA (Skip) Review history[Good:78(58%) Normal:57(42%) Bad:0(0%)] / Provider: 34674 Host:34625 Browser: 3646
In Japan, the cast of Doraemon was renewed from April, 2005.
Did the cast of Doraemon need to be renewed?
I cannot but feel so.
But it will be unrelated when this animated cartoon is broadcast in foreign countries.
This renewed Doraemon became classic as compared with old Doraemon.
It is difficult to become accustomed to new Cast.
Especially the voice of renewed Doraemon completely differs from the voice of old Doraemon.
The voice of Nobita, Sizuka, Jaian, and Suneo is comparatively good.
Especially the voice of Jaian is ideal.
The voice actor who takes charge of the voice of Jaian is a junior high school student.
He will be a voice actor able probably.
The voice of new Sizuka is attractive.
The hair of Sizuka was changed into black from brown.
Sizuka of black hair is comparatively good.
In Japan, not only the main casts but all the casts were renewed.
The voice of the parents of Nobita is also comparatively good.
The image quality of Doraemon improved further.
I do not have dissatisfaction about it.
New Doraemon is comparatively wonderful.
But, the voice of new Doraemon is not desirable.
It is somewhat regrettable.

Post to this review list Easy post what you felt Post to fan bbs