Japanese works database(How to join/Help)
Top page: All/Only Reviews 		Others
Site map
AllAnimeGameComicNovelDramaSp. effectJP movieMovieInfo:voice,machine..Reviewer sorted byDiary
Search / Outside DB:
Anime ranking in Japan: Rank 71/in 2,637 titles (Total 183.25/Deviation 69.21) Rank 70 <= => Rank 72
Anime average points ranking in Japan: Rank 897/in 1,377 titles (Average 0.49(Good)/Deviation 47.48) Rank 896 <= => Rank 898 (more than 10 evaluatoin were posted)
Anime ranking of 2003 in Japan: Rank 4/in 99 titles Rank 3 <= => Rank 5

Fullmetal Alchemist (Hagane no Renkinjyutsu shi: TV series)(Anime)


[Other version: RSS/Japanese version]


Other media
Game:FullMetal Alchemist and the Broken Angel / Comics:Fullmetal Alchemist / Novel:Fullmetal Alchemist
All
Reviews(Post)		ForumImagesGoods
(DVD)
Latest DVD: 2008/03/11 ():Fullmetal Alchemist - Season 2, Part 2 Box Set $98
DVD(38hit)
Sales/Latest		Books(100hit)
Sales/Latest		Toys(152hit)
Sales/Latest		Music(23hit)
Sales/Latest		VideoGames(9hit)
Sales/Latest
Rank:2910
Fullmetal Alchemist The Movie - The Conqueror of Shamballa

Tag:$98
2006/09/12
()
Eval.:*****
1.Interesting continuation		 Rank:2998
Fullmetal Alchemist - Season 2, Part 2 Box Set

Tag:$98
2008/03/11
()
Eval.:*****
1.FMA review		 Rank:3110
Fullmetal Alchemist - Season 2, Part 1 Box Set

Tag:$98
2008/02/05
()
Eval.:*****
1.The Best Of Fullmetal Alchemist Stories Ever		 Rank:3348
Fullmetal Alchemist: Season 1, Part 1 Box Set

Tag:$98
2007/09/18
()
Eval.:*****
1.Excellent series, nice production, but...		 Rank:3929
Fullmetal Alchemist: Season 1, Part 2 Box Set

Tag:$98
2007/11/20
()
Eval.:*****
1.Continuing the series, this is a GREAT set to buy- pros and cons here		 Rank:7692
Fullmetal Alchemist, Volume 13: Brotherhood (Episodes 49-51)

Tag:$98
2006/09/12
()
Eval.:*****
1.A roll of the dice		 Rank:31059
Comic:Fullmetal Alchemist, Volume 16

Tag:$99
2008/03/18
()
Eval.:*****
1.Beyond the Dream		 Rank:4027
Toy:Fullmetal Alchemist snake necklace + Pin

Tag:$99
Eval.:*****
1.fma necklace		 Rank:11369
Audio CD:Fullmetal Alchemist Complete Best

Tag:$98
2006/05/30
()
Eval.:*****
1.full version of the ending themes		 Rank:3347
Video Game:Fullmetal Alchemist 2 Curse of the Crimson Elixir

Tag:$99
2005/07/12
()
Eval.:*****
1.Pretty lame actually
Original-Plan:Hiromu Arakawa Director:Seiji Mizushima Story-Editor:Sho Aikawa
Character-Designer:Yoshiyuki Ito Main-Animator:Koji Sugiura Mechanic-Designer:Jun-ya Ishigaki Chimera-Designer:Hideki Fukushima
Art-Director:Kazuyuki Hashimoto Norifumi Nakamura Color-Stylist:Shihoko Nakayama Photography-Director:Kyo Fukushi
Music:Michiru Ohshima Audio Director:Masafumi Mima Produced-by:MBS ANIPLEX BONES
Released:2003/10/03 in Japan End:2004/10/02 in Japan
Official sites
1. http://www.aniplex.co.jp/hagaren/ (Translation)
2. http://mbs.jp/hagaren/index2.html (Translation)
3. http://gangan.square-enix.co.jp/hagaren/ (Translation)
Statics of evaluation(The statics is updated once a day)
 AverageAnimeRankDeviation(Total)Evaluation points(Total)Best of the Best
Inside JapanGood(0.49)7169.21183.252
Outside JapanVery good(1.67)22047.465.01 

Statics of activity

Total ViewsCommentEvaluation
Inside Japan144,928985325
Outside Japan6,45833

How others evaluated in Japan

BestVery GoodGoodNormalBadVery BadWorst
People57567243381940
Percentage17.5%17.2%22.2%13.2%11.7%5.8%12.3%
Added percentage17.5%34.7%56.9%70.1%81.8%87.6%100%
Summary56.9%13.2%29.8%
                                                                                                 

Views for recent 8 days
Total432130292827
5
0
2
0
1
0
2
0
0

LanguageSorted by dateSorted by recommendation New!
EnglishGood
(Only Evaluation)		Normal
(Only Evaluation)		Bad
(Only Evaluation)		All
(Only Evaluation)		None
JapaneseGood
(Only Evaluation)		Normal
(Only Evaluation)		 Bad
(Only Evaluation)		All
(Only Evaluation)		All
This reputation board

2006/10/26 Best! [Edit/Delete//Only this reviewer/Only this review/post sympathy comment/]
by susan sullivan Review history[Good:1(100%) Normal:0(0%) Bad:0(0%)] / Provider: 7024 Host:6895 Browser: 7973
I've had every emotion pulled from me because of this saga of two brothers in FullMetal. If I'm not screaming in righteous anger for them, then I'm in sackcloth and ashes, that's a biblical term, because we've just lost a character, whether it be the good guy, or bad. It's too bad that the Award shows in the U.S. don't have included a foreign tv animation category.Maybe if we all get together, and sign a petition to include this category, the committee in California for the Emmy Awards would listen to us.This saga is laced with a soundtrack that's melancoly and stunning. I have a full life; never been hooked on things. But FullMetal, you are the exception. You are dear to my heart, and now a part of it. Susan
2005/08/24 Normal [Edit/Delete//Only this reviewer/Only this review/post sympathy comment/]
by TAKARAYA Review history[Good:78(58%) Normal:57(42%) Bad:0(0%)] / Provider: 20996 Host:20931 Browser: 3646
This animated cartoon is roughly popular in Japan.
However, I do not somewhat like this animated cartoon.
Because there are a lot of bloodshed scenes and cruel scenes in this animated cartoon.
Therefore, this animated cartoon is not for the infant.
There is a gag scene in this animated cartoon, too.
However, I did not feel the gag of this animated cartoon pleasant.
This animated cartoon's first theme song was the best.
However, the theme song of this animated cartoon was often changed to other songs.
I do not feel it to be pleasant.
2004/07/19 Very good [Edit/Delete//Only this reviewer/Only this review/post sympathy comment/]
by Carlos Ross Review history[Good:74(51%) Normal:17(12%) Bad:54(37%)] / Provider: 13289 Host:13321 Browser: 3874
A well-animated, cleverly written show with excellent characters and an occasional macabre storyline that isn't afraid to kill off regular characters? I honestly haven't been so excited about a mainstream action anime series in a very long time.
Post your review / Top page
Other media
Game:FullMetal Alchemist and the Broken Angel / Comics:Fullmetal Alchemist / Novel:Fullmetal Alchemist
The below reviews are translated automatically from Japanese ones. To post to English version, please click here.
2008/06/24 Best! [Original Japanese review]
by Nakata Provider: 22343 Host:22617 Browser: 5234

[Good point]
When it says previously, they are the comment of those who are not original 読ん.
It says clearly and is て better た in slight 錬金術師な of steel.
although comics じゃい which carried out all, "hagaren [ hagaren and ]" said and has come out of a magazine of what for a start was thought -- what -- that Super-Hamah る.
carry out a point [ contradictory ] for having been in some places -- since it is comics there -- placing .
A character and a favorable impression shine and a story is also good.
There is a talk of being moved to tears, and there is a talk that it can become hot.
It was obediently interesting.

[Bad point]
Especially place to worry -- If it dares say, the mind over which it passed frankly [ the death of a fuse ] [ ...
I have slightly already wanted the damage to each character.
] No, since it was an army, it is unavoidable one, and I said or wanted the normal to feel sad more.
Since its intensity was the strong character, it is kana.

[Comprehensive evaluation]
He likes.
hagaren.
OP-ED was also good!
2008/05/16 Very good [Original Japanese review]
by H.B Provider: 22433 Host:22134 Browser: 4184

[Good point]
The role of justice and the villain have a very high charm of a character.
The members of a voice actor are too gorgeous.
(Mr.
Boku who played the leading role is ほん and God!) OP is quite good.
Individually, Melissa is good.

[Bad point]
There is a portion which cannot be understood the final stage.

[comprehensive evaluation]
-- "-- although it was grotesquely and the opinion " was seen plentifully, I say so -- it was calm I think that I want you to make it the merely a little more intelligible talk.
2008/04/25 Very good [Original Japanese review]
by moon-moon Provider: 1657 Host:1741 Browser: 6395
Original non-読.
It was able to see very much interestingly.
How (end-like thing) to treat each character also had the place which thinks how it is also including the theater version.
however, "human body in the opening part and the middle stage -- training -- about ", a "homun cross", and an "equivalent exchange"-related thing, it is said that it had drawn to the last somehow -- it felt, and I came out and thought that it was good If 話し of fairly shocking Neenah in the first half can be shown as itself, since such contents (theme) will talk and it will be judged as だ.
[ of original non-読 ] In such meaning, I think that it had not finished halfway.
I think that the theater version was unnecessary addition in itself.
2008/04/09 Normal [Original Japanese review]
by goodday0220 Provider: 24221 Host:24340 Browser: 3491
Although the original story was also a little contained the first half based on the original, I think that it was not able to be tried that it has anything sense of incongruity.
however -- the story of the second half had the touch hurried a little -- considering -- it passes suddenly, and it is looking and there are many incomprehensible parts I think that many places which do not clarify about 錬金術 [ say / being / it / what structure / kana ] or this world were seen as especially the last round is approached.
However, is that progressing in front is severe for them who have lost many things by war, such as a thought, 錬金術, etc.
by a erurikku brother's bonds and military men thought, and do you think that it is a work to see and aid?
2008/03/23 Best! [Original Japanese review]
by PIRO Provider: 274 Host:150 Browser: 7395

[Good point]
The picture was beautiful.
I think that especially Ed suited voice actors.
The music of OP and ED was also very good.
The rewrite of the horse mackerel can used as especially the last OP was caused quite exactly, and the drawing which gets off the elevator of the beginning of OP thought to the last that it was deep at the time of saw.
guroi was also individually good slightly.
Although the character of Ed with comics was different, the animation was individually more serious and he liked.

[Bad point]
This is whether to have given in the dead of night.

[Comprehensive evaluation]
Highest!
It comes out and is 。.
2008/03/22 Comment(normal) [Original Japanese review]
by Annasan Provider: 46421 Host:46629 Browser: 6386

[Good point]
I think that OP and ED were very good.
I think that it was easy to see since the gyaku scene etc.
entered even if Mr.
voice actor さ of colorful performance etc.
was good and he became んじ in serious.

[Bad point]
Although the picture something was also good, is it guroi a little to be sure?
I was also unpleasant in the place which opens the door of the psychology of the beginning of eye one talk of 鋼錬, when small (7 or 8 years old), and I have not seen the direction of animation since then.
the direction of animation -- dividing -- 3 and 4 -- since a year (12 years old) is carried out -- the comics -- あつめ -- DVD was seen anew
[Comprehensive evaluation]
Since it was also at the time with guroi, I wanted you to increase a gag scene to a slight degree.
Was very it a ぃぃ work in respect of [ which can permeate the body in たいせつさ of a life among stories ] the?
2008/03/18 Best! [Original Japanese review]
by Kumakichi Provider: 54041 Host:53982 Browser: 5234
Illustrating is kirei and OP and ED also have no place it is good and gorgeous [ a voice actor ] and bad!
There is no feeling of gudaguda in that there were four periods of treatment, the story is crazier and it has been seen.
grotesque -- it is -- 鋼錬 was fairly calm although it was weak Merely, since only are of human body training was unpleasant, persons weak are cautions.
for the first time -- saw's -- this animation (except [ for children ]) -- anime って -- since interesting って事 was made to notice, it is animation favorite [ even now ] for itself, and important I think that I also want those who have not seen to see.
Evaluation is the "highest."
2008/02/20 Very bad [Original Japanese review]
by 哭鳴 Provider: 48622 Host:48438 Browser: 8090

[Good point]
- theme song was good.
Especially "Motherland" is the Divine Comedy.
- I think that the voice actor could be gorgeous.

[Bad point]
A different original story from - original, and its end (especially second half).
- Vainly grotesque.
- Collapse of the character in comparison with an original
[comprehensive evaluation]
-- honest -- this original story cannot but call it not good Although he did not plan to have said to there when only まぁ original became, while only that met the original the opening part, it was the touch --, and it was difficult to think it original that it is interesting.
Furthermore, the homun cross was very unpleasant.
It came in the end somehow, carried out now [ considerable character 壊れて ], and was swinging considerably.
Especially Lars did not understand wanting what to already carry out.
It said clearly and was very annoying.
Moreover, it was truly amazed at the end which that meaning does not understand.
then -- the end -- seen country んじ A general comment is "very bad."
2008/02/13 Comment(good) [Original Japanese review]
by Pokkairo Provider: 928 Host:859 Browser: 3674
I think that this animation is a God work with it being private.
There is an often [ whenever it plays with a friend ] seen memory.
It thinks that the importance of a life was studied and the last round is まじ泣け better た.
of course, the theater version was also seen!
It is the highest.
2007/12/29 Comment(bad) [Original Japanese review]
by kkss Provider: 34599 Host:34620 Browser: 5234
[Bad point] I think that I am the now most interesting book in.
[ who buys it whenever it is by original 読ん and a book also comes out ] Although it knew when the friend is looking at animation, then animation differed from the original, and seen by video, when the original which has not finished was made into animation as overall comment, stripes were disappointedly carried out to becoming in the style of ゆう like this for a few.
Couldn't those in whom only a few has appeared be used for a long time, and can't having been disappointed most be convinced to the place where the portion I wanted you to use in an original is hardly used in the original?
the mother's of what has me beyond having had a feeling that it goes into a hand immediately because grief た had an image with it difficult [ to get, so that the stone of that mass tangu killed the parents of uinrii and a su 賢 person is endless in an original ], and a door, and a erurikku brother's thing -- I wanted you to treat more delicately if it says by the umbrella and characters on the scale's regarded as my wanting 1 it was thought that was interesting by animation to also look at an original -- mass tangu and a subordinate -- I think that the episode made to be considered very much more than the interesting deployment of the thing of the miserable past of a close relation or a ishuvaaru 殲滅 game and a homun cross etc.
by what is full Although it may be more grotesque than comics
2007/12/28 Best! [Original Japanese review]
by ハガレン大好き Provider: 18475 Host:18351 Browser: 6641
[a good point] -- a colonel and Ed -- super-かっ -- deep -- it is, and it carries out and the contents are also interesting [Bad point] Or [ that it is grotesquely just for a moment, and is however ] -- [Comprehensive evaluation] Highest!
2007/12/08 Normal [Original Japanese review]
by Sennuki Provider: 38066 Host:38222 Browser: 4203
Compared with the comics version, the touch which talks dark heavily by force carries out a few.
本作 will get [ whether it is looking anyhow and the shoulder grows stiff and ] tired although the comics version becomes heavy by "it progresses in front, extracting the power of the shoulder in the still made range although it is variously"'s too much.
(A theme [ Length being quite short.
] beta and kana although it is sufficient it talks [ heavy dozens of talks ] ...) Although performance of an action scene and a voice actor is smart and the song of OP or ending is also concentration 入って (or [ for / especially young / children ]) (especially two leading roles), when it sees synthetically, is it the good above with a grinding sound?
It does not understand well what the animation staff wants to show.
"-- a front ...
progress!!
-- although " was good by the straight message A thought serious [ the situation of straining one's voice which cannot be uttered ] with beta, and mad may be transmitted.
It is discontinuous, and since it was seeing, whether it is impossible why for the rose to talk does not understand.
2007/12/03 Comment(bad) [Original Japanese review]
by Edei Provider: 13471 Host:13285 Browser: 5234
I think that it is a work without what is transmitted after all because it will seemingly only be [ be / if / it is a price for obtaining something, ] reasonable.
Although it was existence of a setup "the world there" which he was conscious of a thing called especially the concept of death, and Mr.
TSI wore with 仰る事, just this felt thin most with this work that inclined only toward the parenthesis merit and violence of only appearance.
although each other is stabbed by the last round with 天狐 whose trauma of a hero is the strongest supernatural creature and a life is dropped on "the supernatural creature settlement people truck and 貧" which is the sequel of a "supernatural creature settlement people trauma" -- a trauma -- as for him, after death chose the way which protects the dead good from 魔物 as settlement people in the next world The dead who were able to do only the life of the average were also to say like it that the large object is leading the time of having reached neither Heaven nor hell and having been alive, and the life which does not change so while in life.
The admiration allowed such a setup just because it is a gag work dealing with a supernatural creature was strong, and the hint was stretched not a little also from 火車 which the trauma eradicated to the lifetime, and 目比べ虫 having hinted, "The soul which can be drawn into hell decreased." Since a close-up of the figure of the mother who zombie-ized [ unlike it ] in the case of this work is made to take or the character cruelly killed including the woman and the unrelated human being of a homun cross is made to the production which stimulates intentionally the nerve of the televiewer who asks for the やたら reality by the sermon which enumeration of the cruel treatment or the violence scene to a rose and a meaning do not understand further, or an original fan, it is ill-natured all the more.
When making the theme of a tale, it does not deny that it is necessary to draw the ugliness of the person who carried sad fate on the back, or human being.
I cannot think it good to merely put in order the badness and the cruel talk of the feeling that only ...
[ necessarily ] not to be referred to as remove depiction of bloodshed or death, however displeasure which scoops out the heart to tell the sadness and message which are full of a world remain at all.
Even if it does not carry out expression or the grotesque scene which wound those who are in this work, there is a work which appeals for a message to tell someone's hearts without limit.
After finishing seeing such works, isn't something new born to the heart of the person who looked at it?
...
I think that expression which is in this work for telling something is not all.
And I think that a really good work is immediately in a side unexpectedly only by being hidden by the boom or the hit.
My something to say is above.
It apologizes for having continued writing the poor writing of only this for a long time.
2007/11/17 Good [Original Japanese review]
by 陣兵 Provider: 18696 Host:18447 Browser: 3875
[Good point] A story is interesting.
[Bad point] Especially nothing.
[Comprehensive evaluation] Although the comics of 錬金術師 of steel were collected, it carried out now [ 売っちゃ ].
It does not know what now (comics) it has become.
Animation was seen occasionally.
2007/11/17 Worst [Original Japanese review]
by Tamekichi Provider: 19906 Host:19808 Browser: 10759
Past [ a grotesque comb ].
it is what although cage strike ON れる does not think that it is bad with it being another on account of an original stock -- that punch line Last, suddenly, a strained meaning was given actually and it withered.
し [ explanation was insufficient ].
Kana of 人っている which has understood that deployment of the final stage, without [ a related book or ] reading.
2007/11/04 Worst [Original Japanese review]
by 小野 Provider: 6619 Host:6542 Browser: 8964
[Good point] Thinking that an original setup was reconstructed well, the merit of illustrating is more than an original.
(It says or the degradation condition of illustrating of the latest original is severe ^^;) [Bad point] It does not seem to be the animation broadcast very much in the ground 6.
there are many guroi scenes -- elapsing -- it is -- it carried out, and the scene which raped the rose which is the heroine was seen and it felt nauseated When the child who looked at this regarded as なっ what you would think, stripes were carried out shudderingly.
When it could do, I had midnight broadcast such animation and it was extorted.
Although Ed finally helped the younger brother and it was flown in the world over there, I consider [ having made it better / to die ordinarily / and ].
Since it thinks that it is an equivalent exchange.
it and an original -- if it sees considering favorite me -- the character of kyara -- too different -- it is .
Well, if this considers an original and another work, there is especially no problem.
2007/09/23 Good [Original Japanese review]
by Kemu Provider: 12661 Host:12507 Browser: 3004(Mobile)
Although an original is also so, since a hero's past and purpose are dark, even if they show others brightly, as for this animation, they always forget neither sadness nor sadness among brothers thoroughly.
Don't do neither the past nor the purpose in 錬金術 after all.
It does not know what if it goes in quest of it, he will become, and is sushi -- Therefore, the figure which still progresses moves bravely not at all.
And although the work itself is the translation made confused as an important part is approached, since the margin has been lost by わ to which the thing of わ敵 which decreases since it was concerned with the country concerning [ this ] the purpose increases, is it unavoidable?
If it collects, he likes a scenario individually anyhow.
since -- evaluation is good -- it is [ make / have you / it ] alike
2007/09/17 Normal [Original Japanese review]
by CRQ Provider: 18183 Host:18109 Browser: 3875
[Good point] Illustrating was very beautiful through all talks.
Performance of the voice actor was wonderful.
The singer who sings a theme song was only a famous person.
The story of the first half is [ bright talks, such as gag, ] and was good although there was also a little dark talk.
[Bad point] If it becomes in the second half, there will be no almost bright talk and it will be a serious and heavy talk.
Moreover, in "importance of a life", and the story, although it has said and being cooked, murder's scene felt [ many ] inconsistency さ recklessly.
It did not understand in the least that the last round also wanted what to transmit.
[comprehensive evaluation] -- the second half very good the first half is bad -- it comes out and comprehensive evaluation is common
2007/08/25 Good [Original Japanese review]
by あり団子 Provider: 1114 Host:1207 Browser: 6306
I think that it was interesting with it being gentle.
Although whose child was [ eye one talk ] the simple deployment to which a bad fellow is subjugated in the hero, it is unexpected that subsequent deployment progresses seriously, and at it, it thinks that it was conversely good.
What is a mystery, or the focus had clarified, I myself to whom "they are whom [ this ]" is similarly viewing and listening [ which heroes consider ] felt, it was interesting and the sharable place was good.
although there is especially no place to watch in charm, depiction and illustrating, and a motion of characters (music was good) -- overall -- as it is -- being alike -- I think that it is finished As it is, I hear that evaluation was interesting and it presupposes "It is good."
2007/08/13 Normal [Original Japanese review]
by SQUARE Provider: 40935 Host:41033 Browser: 8090
[Good point] It was beautiful, and the scene of fighting also had the real picture and it was smart.
The contents were also interesting and it is the highest as me.
[Bad point] I feel that a favorite person and a disagreeable person separate for this animation.
There is too cruel depiction.
I think that it is [ to say ] reasonable.
Well, there is also no method of comrades there.
Since the character of kyara has also changed, it is regrettable.
The time made animation-ization is too early and thinks だ.
I am boring for the level of animation to fall, if too early even if there is much popularity.
[Comprehensive evaluation] The picture is the highest privately as contents real [ the scene of beauty and fighting ] and smart also drew it also on the interesting top.
Since it is cruel, it is useless.
Doesn't a ばっ [ this ] loan have a method of comrades, either?
But I think that it is indispensable to this animation.
since the way of the last has become original in itself, I want you to make an animation 2 term along an original - Considering very たり.
It is the dream not suiting.
Probably, this was finished in the better work, if it was made firmly along with the original, since the character of a character had also changed.
Since animation is good, evaluation is ordinarily.
Next / Post your review / Top page
Other media
Game:FullMetal Alchemist and the Broken Angel / Comics:Fullmetal Alchemist / Novel:Fullmetal Alchemist
Top page of DB | Site map | Copyright(c) 1999- 1st Class All rights reserved