MOON GUARDIAN (Mamotte Shugogetten!)[Anime]

Limit and sort reviews by your preference

Sort by

Sorted by:Newness	Oldness

Include comments

All including comments	Good	Normal	Bad

Limit evaluation

All evaluation	Good evaluation	Bad evaluation	Best	Very Good	Good	Normal	Bad	Very Bad	Worst

Reviews(Post)

2004/07/23 Bad(-1 pnt) [Edit/Delete/Suggest to delete/Show only this review or post sympathy comment/]
by Carlos Ross (Skip) Review history[Good:80(52%) Normal:18(12%) Bad:55(36%)] / Provider: 23289 Host:23435 Browser: 3873
Shichiri Tasuke is a hapless nebbish. Shaorin and Ruuan are two goddesses who compete to grant his every wish, and invariably cause "hijinks" that often leave Tasuke in mortal danger (largely because they apparently share one rather small brain).

No, this isn't Oh My Goddess -- no, this simplistic melange of slapstick is something far less qualified to be labeled as "comedy" or even "entertainment". Especially not when the pinnacle of humor is having a large cartoony wooden cutout of Mount Fuji yell out "Fuji! Fuji!" as if it's the world's largest Pokemon. Ha. Funny indeed.

About the only things good about Mamotte Shugogetten are the opening song and the lovably cute Rishu, who really deserves a better show.

As for the rest, one word sums it all up succinctly:

<i>Tasukete!</i>

1999/12/29 Best(+3 pnt) [Unable to delete by yourself/Suggest to delete/Show only this review or post sympathy comment/]
by Kuma (Skip)
One of my favorite anime and manga series! The manga illustrations by Sakurano Minene-sensei are beautiful and haunting. The story is a very funny romance. At first the story may seem like a re-telling of Aa, Megamisama! but the story really is quite different.

Post to this review list

Fan forum(Post)

Forum for the special topic (Create topic)

Review by poll(Poll)

Post your evaluation or comment.

Difference of evaluation and comment
Comment You can post as many times as you wish but other people have to post twice before you post again. And if you want to post negative comment, you need 20 posts before you post again.
Evaluation You can post evaluation just once and it affects the evaluation points of the work. If it is not your final evaluation, it is better for you to write this is temporary evaluation.

Other media: Comics:Mamotte Shugogetten

Your Name(Required):

Password (Required. more than 4 characters) [If you want to create secure password: Online mkpasswd service]

Your review or comment for this work(Required/Please write politely)

[Comment(?)]
Comment by the person who thinks this is good
Comment by the person who thinks this is normal
Comment by the person who thinks this is bad

Caution: Please post the evaluation which follows the above rule.

Anime total pnts rank=Avg x Eval	Rank 455/in 3,702 titles(Total 55/Deviation 54.80)	Rank 454<= => Rank 456
Anime avg pnts(minimum:10 evals)	Rank 1,159/in 2,044 titles(Average 0.64=Good/86 reviews)	Rank 1,158<= => Rank 1,160
Anime total pnts rank of 1998	Rank 18/in 108 titles	Rank 17<= => Rank 19

[Anime]MOON GUARDIAN (Mamotte Shugogetten!)