Japanese works database(How to join/Help)
Top page: All/Only Reviews

Others
Site map


Search / Outside DB:

Anime ranking: Rank 892/in 2,678 titles (Total 13.94/Deviation 48.96) Rank 891 <= => Rank 893
Anime average points ranking: Rank 935/in 1,390 titles (Average 0.41(Good)/Deviation 46.70) Rank 934 <= => Rank 936 (more than 10 evaluatoin)

Mobile Suit GUNDAM SEED C.E.73 - STARGAZER -(Anime)

[Other version: RSS/Japanese version]

All
Reviews(Post)

Forum

Images

Information about this title

Sunrise Hajime Yatate Yoshiyuki Tomino Susumu Nishizawa Shigeru Morita
Kenichi Ohnuki OKAWARA KUNIO Kimitoshi Yamane Ikedashigemi Sasayoshi Fujino Megumi Ohashi Victor Entertainment,Inc. BANDAI VISUAL CO., LTD. Satori Negishi Yasutaka Mizushima
Sayaka Oohara Daisuke Ono
Jun Fukuyama Jyoji Nakata
Rina Satou Hiroshi Kamiya
Shuichi Ikeda Kazuhiro Nakata

Official sites
1. http://www.seed-stargazer.net/ (Translation)

Statics of evaluation(The statics is updated once a day)

	Average	AnimeRank	Deviation(Total)	Evaluation points(Total)	Best of the Best
Inside Japan	Good(0.41)	892	48.96	13.94

Statics of activity

	Total Views	Comment	Evaluation
Inside Japan	28,065	51	34
Outside Japan	235	0	0

How others evaluated in Japan

Best

Very Good

Good

Normal

Bad

Very Bad

Worst

People

Percentage

2.9%

20.6%

38.2%

14.7%

5.9%

11.8%

5.9%

Added percentage

2.9%

23.5%

61.7%

76.4%

82.3%

94.1%

100%

Summary

61.7%

14.7%

23.6%

Views for recent 8 days
Total 20 19 18 17 16 15 14 13
7 0 0 0 6 0 1 0 0

Language Sorted by date Sorted by recommendation New!
English Good
(Only Evaluation) Normal
(Only Evaluation) Bad
(Only Evaluation) All
(Only Evaluation) None
Japanese Good
(Only Evaluation) Normal
(Only Evaluation) Bad
(Only Evaluation) All
(Only Evaluation) None
This reputation board

Language	Sorted by date	Sorted by recommendation New!
English	Good (Only Evaluation)	Normal (Only Evaluation)	Bad (Only Evaluation)	All (Only Evaluation)	None
Japanese	Good (Only Evaluation)	Normal (Only Evaluation)	Bad (Only Evaluation)	All (Only Evaluation)	None

Post your review / Top page

The below reviews are translated automatically from Japanese ones. To post to English version, please click here.

2008/05/09 Good [Original Japanese review]
by moon-moon Provider: 1657 Host:1741 Browser: 6395
The talk was good.
Although it does not know whether it needed to be a cancer dam -- It is too short the back.
It is past [ strength ] although it must be MS developed to it for the purpose of inquiry of solar system 宙域 of Mars orbital beyond, and development although it was star geizaa.

2008/04/22 Worst [Original Japanese review]
by Tamekichi Provider: 16925 Host:16820 Browser: 4184
nanikore.
zoido.
eva.
although seen and cooked for a mechanism action guide -- putting - it finishes frankly since it is animation like [ only for sales promotion ] -- stale daytime drama 8s て - more -- boss putty 8 -- てくれ .
尺 of 45 minutes is also too short, and it is 。.
Feeling lost also on the rental.

2008/01/04 Very bad [Original Japanese review]
by Kangaruu Provider: 10245 Host:10185 Browser: 6391
At OVA of all 3 talks, they are the contents of supplementary biography-of Seed Destiny.
" like this editing; although there is no random person setup [ characters / main / of all the members ] "about the same as schoolchild;, it is very short in volume and its scenario is also modest.
The natural private unit showed up in the neutral research institute, the small-scale skirmish was developed, and it has finished frankly.
Although star geizaa which is a leading role machine was able to play an active part so so, a full-scale appearance is from the last talk, and the depiction itself is short.
If it results in the sub character which hardens the side, as soon as it sorties at a battlefield, it lapses into the pinch immediately, and they are butter butter and れていく frankly.
too frank -- past -- or ...

2007/12/03 Comment(normal) [Original Japanese review]
by 富野派 Provider: 11867 Host:12178 Browser: 4184
[Good point] 監督よ of まぁ種 series is with whether it is mashi from the work of り.
[Bad point] Story short けぇ -!
It passes and is !.
[Comprehensive evaluation] It is too short and is 。.
There is neither kore じゃ evaluation nor kuso, and there is no appearance (don't carry out じゃあ evaluation!).
If only this is short, I will think that introduction of the fine character of characters would not be needed.
Since it finishes before analyzing for itself.
The back battle scene was spoiled standing upright [ an enemy ].
chokomaka 動いてる is ず more.
あん -- a salary also with a high what じゃ do amateur -- らえ -- that is right A burudeyueruba star's (bottom っけ?) pilot is sub く感じた.
It is common [ a "bad" side / "common" ].

2007/10/16 Comment(bad) [Original Japanese review]
by Kaniya Provider: 35635 Host:35369 Browser: 4926
The greatest dissatisfaction to 今作's.
It is the battle of strike noワーru and star geizaa.
being such -- being also alike -- it expected tricky fighting using the wire by smart noワーru by 惹かれてた's also at the final game The unsatisfying state also inferior to the small fish game of かあ which is what.
Is the direction of the volume on SEED book a top rightly about the production of a battle?
Good wealthy person ってますけど, a petty battle, and many useless episode regard this work as having pulled the leg.

2007/09/30 Good [Original Japanese review]
by airi Provider: 4237 Host:4057 Browser: 5234
If this work did not wear the name of "SEED", it must have become a surely better work.
I think so.
If it does not have the view of the world of "SEED", I think that it had become a good work.
Or [ that the work isolated more was sufficient ].
But I like the tendency of the work itself something.
Animation and comics are last filled with deep emotion.
I of overall evaluation am "good." If there are not a view of the world of "SEED" and shortness of 尺, it will be having become a better work.

2007/09/12 Comment(normal) [Original Japanese review]
by Chonmage Provider: 12477 Host:12477 Browser: 7590
[A good point] It was made seed and profit was a wasteful work.
Although it was short, it was very better than the volume on seed book.
MS was very drawn heavily and the battle scene was good.
It will be unimpressive if it says bad.
[A bad point] The volume on seed book has been dragged too.
[Comprehensive evaluation] This was completely a different thing with the volume on seed book.
Does it see and is there any profit value?

2007/08/15 Bad [Original Japanese review]
by Kaniya Provider: 35635 Host:35369 Browser: 4926
Is there more grotesque expression than the volume on SEED book as for what thing?
As Mu rocket deii was made into 生贄 for the hobby by the side of manufacture, it memorized displeasure.
A cancer dam also seldom plays an active part in having taken out the new body with much trouble.
And it is weak.
The battle had neither a feeling of tension, nor force, and was very tedious.
I think that "a strong cancer dam" was not.
Although it is not interesting since freedom and justice みたい are defeated without "a matchless cancer dam" having a close game, "a weak cancer dam" is eye 興ざ.
It is unclear in that the focus of the after talk has faded and it should observe where, and the presence of a setup or each kyara is also felt thin.
I will make it go away [ which has been closely involved with this editing / which does not come out ] -- opaque The talk of the battle with the first shuttle launch or gin is past [ merit ].
honest -- it is a mystery what he wanted to make only from this If SEED and SEED-DESTINY are this supervisor, can it merely, hold expectations of becoming interesting certainly?

2007/07/22 Good [Original Japanese review]
by 雨 Provider: 1959 Host:1633 Browser: 5234
the candidate for comparison -- " -- that "SEED book editing, therefore a work to come to evaluate But it must be told to cutting C.E.
deeply from the direction of another that 45 minutes was short -- Since it has progressed at the high pace while various portions have been ambiguous, it is clear that there was a portion which is not [ skillful く飲み込 ].
Against how depending on which the talk spreads, when it finishes, a 呆気 lack and the dyspeptic feeling have been felt a little.
If it is made about [ なら 90 minute ] OVA at any rate, while thinking --, this shortness also carries out mind of the taste.
Although it is short, I think that logging of a scene had attractive power of enough in skillful く and atmosphere.
Although there was no 科白 of each character so mostly, it felt it as skillful く盛り raising ていた by depiction each of.
Above all, it favors individually that there was "no kirei thing listing" of this editing specialty.
If difficulty was said for a while, it was good to have seen the battle scene of bulls like one talk to a slight degree.
the second half -- どうしても -- the battle of MS(s) -- since it is main -- unavoidable one -- but, since it expected too much, I regard that thing insufficient remains a little as that of the method of 〆 of ?
last being good at that as [ be / insipid / even if it clarifies an end too much by the flow of this talk ] The last which is connected from ED music and which leaves a reverberation is a skillful く纏め shelf, without breaking atmosphere.
However, I also see how and cannot think the side story edited by that book.
Air is already too different.

2007/07/03 Good [Original Japanese review]
by Tokyo16 Provider: 13951 Host:13771 Browser: 2463
If it contrasts with the volume on SEED book, it will be visible to a masterpiece also by そりゃ何.
It may be made the flag of Nishiki of anti and this may also be able to be called unhappy work in that it is hard to receive original evaluation.
If excessive bias is extracted and measured, it will just be going to call it the fine work of a "good" maximum.
It is a work with many places still told still very much more.
Although the shortness of 尺 is fatal to be sure, since it is short, it is the high density of こそ, and last-minute fun is secured in an odd distribution this 15 minute x3 saying form.
it should tell -- the portion which is told and it cannot still finish telling is left to a televiewer's imagination All characters came out of a word, and stood kyara perfectly, and the depth in which life is given was able to give them.
The learning which withered, the mathematician who sneers at himself, the instructor who was opposing brainwash education had the firmly realistic feeling of actual existence.
Moreover, having applied spot to the cancer dam where only the so-called "military" grammar was told from the viewpoint of "space development" wants to esteem.
In the long history of cancer dam series, although a close-up of front 2 persons was taken in many cases among the 3 pillars of the "robot" which was a composition element, "an army/war", and "the universe/space colony", the portion as SF was just buried in the background.
It was mainly pulled back by 本作.
It admired obediently whether there was still such any cut end also in cancer dam series with !.
It starts in the time of V2 rocket and a bloody dark side hangs around space advance of human beings, such as a military satellite which also glares at surface of the earth space development competition which made the U.S.-Soviet cold war the back, and now.
The climax to which star geizaa (the laser for promotion) which is human beings' dream became the strongest arms, and settled the tendency of a battlefield is the metaphor of such an ironical history.
It is also admirable to have given the necessity on a theme perfectly to the ghastly battle depiction in one to 2 talk by this.
regrettable one -- action -- imaichi -- it is the point which was not interesting With a peak of the desperate struggle of a linear cancer tank and gin, it has stopped at making do with the meal of the wire art of noワーru, or bakuu, and the hula hoop of star geizaa.
Since it was special OVA, I wanted to enjoy a more hade battle.
Finally, ending is described.
Although a screen top has main personal history of suuen, in fact, a motion of Selene's heart (controlled and drawn) is just the paragon of 本作.
Even by omitting Edmond with that sufficient parenthesis, she who tried to live for the dream asks for warmth of a man as "since it is lonely"!
When throwing away suuen and stopping the amount of oxygen consumption, the solitary feeling thrown up in the space which was probably gone up, and which is beyond in imagination did not make a possibility of being saved do so but (for egoist Selene to have not thought).
However man may have a longing, the universe only merely spreads out and does not respond to the thought.
Her figure which shares slight oxygen and slight temperature at the bottom of the coldhearted universe after [ universe ] it continued yearning is very painful.
It was the wonderful scene in which it gives the extensiveness of the universe, and very small [ of man ].
No, I had the good thing shown.

2007/06/11 Good [Original Japanese review]
by Nebusokunotaka Provider: 30646 Host:30847 Browser: 5234
It is made as firmly as SEED or ?
って by this honto.
From the first, although it thought whether this editing had utilized it thoroughly although a setup of a view of the world is good, 本作 was seen and the idea changed to firm belief.
having felt in the 1st talk -- the direction of this editing -- a mass-produced type mobiru suit -- as an ace pilot's setoff -- a beam -- chunchun -- 撃 -- if it sees completely with て and a saber from bassabassa 斬られ, and the zakomon star of RPG or those who does not have arms with a mass-produced type in 今作, either, although it was drawn only as a mere obstacle when worse, it will be a threat, and it is drawn as "arms " which is not a zakomon star, either and It was thought that "differed from [!?
] old SEED in あれっ ?
etc." in "weight" of the whole tale made into the start.
And hate 合い of a natural and a coordinator is drawn quite ghastly by many men's death after that.
an honest guroi scene -- many -- mind -- めいり -- it is drawn firmly that it is it action from hate that those who perform the ghastly act more than it although it becomes right [ that ] had - friend who had parents killed killed, and "human stink" is felt for kyara and others よなぁ which was deterministically insufficient for "human stink" って's.
[ this ] remembering the person who makes a mother the start and who was kind to himself until now it also in the life in which suuen looked at sereena last and was raised into it as murder as "-- which knows the person similar to you" had ku る's not at all It says and the face is carried out.
ups and downs of feeling can see -- not having -- a friend -- "-- always related -- since it thinks that "human stink" can surely be regained taking advantage of the encounter with sereena, two persons want to believe that it was saved, although it is suuen called "

2007/05/14 Normal [Original Japanese review]
by 下田の里 Provider: 23770 Host:23443 Browser: 4184
When it says simply, it is "a simple work without undue importance." the touch which all other points have fallen victim, and it is diffuse as works, such as character molding, and deployment, a battle scene, and shallow, and has already been completely seen also by "the volume on 総 collection", and the "preliminary announcement of a movie" since other controversialists "have short 尺" as 仰っている then -- while it is [ nothing ] and is simple until that is not right, either and it compares with this editing "the movement fighter cancer dam SEED DESTINY", as to the work itself is bad -- "惹き -- the price -- I think that there is る要素" Selene & of a setup about the flight of the portrait to the war fire of the opening part, the bull deyueru x Kerberos of the middle stage, and star geizaa of the final stage, or the last; although suuen etc.
is modest, it has an interesting point, and it is felt "This setup is swollen, and I want you to remake half a year and to broadcast." Moreover, not the object for a battle but being set up with "the object for planetary exploration" to the last also has an interesting leading role machine.
It is なぁ for this setup having 尺, and explanation being possible, and depth coming out for a view of the world -- It is whether suuen was drawn comparatively well about the character.
He who was yearning after [ the universe ] at the time of childhood is pleased very well in the setup -- brainwashed with the institution of blue cosmos at the time of parents' death.
The overall shortage of explanation by the point that the point of fun is modest entirely, and the shortness of 尺 does not have undue importance.
good, since the point of ↑ cannot be protected as "completed goods" although -- is thought, even if it attaches individually "it is good" -- alike -- near infinite "-- I am allowed to usually consider as "

2007/05/08 Good [Original Japanese review]
by Zura Provider: 2823 Host:2725 Browser: 5717
From evil "ho O depiction of seed series, a specific kyara favor, hero side flawlessness, and the thing incomprehensible", since it was unrelated, it is the good kana.
It was merely too short too.
Was deployment too early a little?
I had you make from the 作る budget of this editing edited by the 総 collection in the part here for what talk, and it swarmed.

2007/05/03 Comment(good) [Original Japanese review]
by 甘王 Provider: 18003 Host:17725 Browser: 4621
I think that it has improved most in SEED series.
However, whole-volume 45 minutes are too short よなぁ.

2007/05/03 Good [Original Japanese review]
by Pupupu Provider: 6351 Host:6192 Browser: 4184
This work made as a side story of "SEEDDESINY." With all 3 talks, although it is short, I think for 1 talk 15 minutes that it was more interesting than this editing.
However, it is the impression which shortness serves as an enmity and has become a very regrettable work too (it is [ following ] comment and with [ some ] neta ばれ.).
The first talk Talk currently drawn by the general public-notice line in fear of - war arms.
It says [ that MS of zako treatment may also serve as a threat enough within a play ].
It has been transmitted well.
My おっ who challenges that by tank was also smart.
The rest is a talk which Selene goes up to the universe.
It ends by the appearance of suuen + strike noワーru.
Although the mind which was not the talk done even by using 15 precious minutes, although it had improved as a talk has not carried out, either ...
It strikes and changes and the second talk and the before talk are cancer dam large activity!!
Was disagreeable - battle depiction good?
noワーru -- it is [!!
(puramo making-たくなった ^^) ] strong .
Although Mu rocket deii was damaged without 呆気 and carried out now [ ちゃ ], a reality that by that I think that you may be.
When carrying out cancer dam 乗ってたって inattention and it was damaged, it became teachings with sufficient ゆう.
shamusu which increases the anger by the enemy also enlivened the talk the future.
I think that the point of eye two talks is the dream of suuen.
His "yearning by the distant universe" is on the double track [ to a next story ].
I think ってた.
Is eye まぁ 2 talk a place called kyara introduction of suuen?
It is made eye the third talk and 3 talk, and already is the last round!
Star geizaa which came out at last!!
The first type cancer dam for un-battling which attracted attention The concepts were "the uninhabited arms for outside space search." It is 絵描く Selene about the dream to the future to this cancer dam.
suuen which has forgotten the dream and has turned into a battle machine.
These two heroes are involved at last.
A highlight is offense and defense involving DSSD and star geizaa of a phantom pane.
shamusu rioted as expected.
The last does not somewhat have 呆気.
About [ which adheres to an enemy and self-blasts in order that one person may also make it a fellow traveler mostly ] carries out, and only ほ is っ.
It is たかな.
Star geizaa said in "the type cancer dam for un-battling" is also fought ordinarily (fairly strong moreover).
How to fasten the last had the admiration which has finished halfway in ...
etc., although まぁ was good.
But hope Since it was the way of finishing felt, it was not bad.
The comment of all 話見終わって thought, "They finished with the place which a tale began to move." Impression receptacle better た that used 45 minutes and the prologue finished at last.
It is very wasteful because future is likely to become interesting.
in order for suuen which next deployment remembered "dream and reformed itself judging from the concept of star geizaa and the dream of suuen to escape from a phantom pane and to protect star geizaa with Selene -- fighting -- and the universe -- 旅つ ...
" -- it sees and becomes the deployment [ た / deployment ] -- it is expected as it being it finishes with 45 minutes -- making -- since the theme of a regrettable about is hidden, a sequel is wished to have in a certain form (it is one-period-of-treatment broadcast with the connector to the theater version SEED) Since this shortness was enjoyed comparatively, evaluation will presuppose "It is good."

2007/04/21 Very good [Original Japanese review]
by Ny-Jp Provider: 42836 Host:42876 Browser: 4984
The side story of the cancer dam SEED was heard, and it saw, thinking "don't say that it has not become like DESINY." It was the work which betrayed expectation in the good meaning.
I thought that the portrait in the inside of war and depiction of the atmosphere of the war [ itself ] had improved most in SEED series.
In SEED series, I think gandamu っぽい most.
Delicacy with the last valid scene is still worrisome.
Although it thought that SEED was already good since it did not think that DESTINY was so interesting, if made to such ふう, I wished to see a continuation also in SEED series.

2007/04/20 Very good [Original Japanese review]
by 市販用MS Provider: 52566 Host:52459 Browser: 6342
It is a wasteful work, when avoiding, if it is a seed.
し [ the way supporting player who has done how to stand kyara by being in the latest animation has also got kyara firmly ] Although MS design is also good and illustrating is also satisfactory at all Since it is OVA, the whole is short.
Although minus also felt MS battle short Since ending was very good, it is plus-or-minus zero.
The feeling whether it was better to do by this TV is put.
It appears in the highest that it is a little easy to be insufficient.

2007/03/15 Very good [Original Japanese review]
by Bari Provider: 49720 Host:49787 Browser: 4483
Now came and it saw at last.
It was drawn in a hard and serious atmosphere different from this editing at a stretch by like viewing-and-listening 3 minute.
They are that immediately after yuniusu seven fall was a large calamity to the extent that it is just convinced to the name of break zaワーrudo, and the thorough education "a coordinator is wrong" with unusual blue cosmos.
Or [ that this editing was also in the shortage of depiction clearly, and was a cousin when this was seen ] ...
even if it also turns out that it can do so far with composition for 1 talk 15 minutes and considers this -- this editing -- how (abbreviation) -- For the only dissatisfaction, you are also as 仰る the shooting-down scenes of bull deyueru.
To three bakuu, halfway, about a cockpit, it is Mu rocket deii which has carried out far painful death rash, rather than it is ordinarily shot down by the favor carried out for stabbing.
however -- since suuen and strike noワーru which make open just next anger (if it is said [ which ] whether be quiet anger) just because there was this, and 撃破 three bakuu are impressive, although it cannot generally declare that it was severe ....
Also shamusu which ran first of all the back.
(especially -- "-- it is what -- this -- !
-- a lie -- it is -- ろおい -- the words ") I want to think that he is alive although it is the last scene to worry.
Evaluation is "very good."

2007/02/18 Good [Original Japanese review]
by N2 Provider: 6824 Host:6927 Browser: 6342
I am allowed to comment that it may be total.
Too, it is large that it was not an end to see by this deployment.
When coming to there, the last which star geizaa which carried the wish of many victims and transcended man's discrimination and hate leaves for 星海 was good.
As the good scene Confusion immediately after yuniusu seven fall.
The depiction as spectacular was good.
Although the incorrect evil spirit was suitably formed in the song in desuteinii, even the influence of that it was an earth scale calamity and after that was drawn firmly.
Gin vs linear cancer tank.
The pile and battle production of depiction to there are Hideyasu.
Desperate fighting and the terrorists who were controlling gin who entrusted their thought, having applied all were a coordinator's children, and it is said that they are saved, and is a lack.
The scene to which named star geizaa recognizes its name, and rewrites all the code names of record to star geizaa.
Space development, new technology, and the exciting jar to そ - Say were pressed down.
Life in which suuen is not rewarded.
Flashback.
his own personal history -- considerable -- the scene of the training instructor of きっつい who eats and starts azuraeru in it but -- mind also made [ every human being ] - and that hopeless world each also in 色んなもん背負って生きてるん very (this editing -- enough -- such a thing -- it was also thrown into relief that there is nothing 考えて) Touch that whether it says [ what ] and CE world saved and a lack [ like ] was displayed also to this.
In such meaning, a supervisor's skill is clear.
Fukude & both 沢 were conscious of CE being such the world perfectly -- ろ or -- It is wasteful that a limit can be grasped in tsura くなってきて and three talks from the middle of 2 talks in quality.
I regard many things as yes, the place which potatoes' do together and is aimed at having been interesting with in material.
Already, probably, the better way of being collected has been adopted just for a moment, if there have already been gold and time just for a moment.
There is nothing undue importance.
-- Individually, it is also tight that natural wicked-woman っぷり of serene was attached to the nose.
By such meaning, appointment of the Ohara さ or か女史 is the super-Hamah り役 in じゃ which carries out by accident, and considers and twists only its thing.
[ that woman and ]

2007/02/17 Bad [Original Japanese review]
by Zero Provider: 2201 Host:1930 Browser: 3875
honesty -- short -- elapsing -- it is ..
I came out and was able to think only being [ it / what ]-after all ?.
Doesn't it battle in bull deyueru etc.
for 1 minute?
If short, it is short ..
wanted to also raise the quality of a battle for becoming.
I can seldom think a powerful battle.
Strike noワーru VS star geizaa especially Because the design of MS was fairly smart, it was a regrettable work.

Next / Post your review / Top page

ALERT: You cannot use open proxy or TOR for posting your review. If it is detected, your access to this site will be prohibited.

Rule for reviews

This site allows you to write reviews for each title, but we don't allow you to criticize others' comment. Too bad or meaningless words are also not allowed. The comment which doesn't follow the rule will be deleted. If you find any comment which doesn't follow the rule, please notify us by clicking Suggest to delete.

Example to be deleted frequently

Favorite side
You dislike this one, then don't see it or comment this title
- Please go to the fan site. Anyone has the right to say what they feel in this site.

Disliking side
Do you like this one? You are stupid.
- Your view is only your view. Please concentrate on only the content of the title, not on others' comment.

Please use only English. If not, the comment will be deleted.

Your Name(Required)

Password (Required. more than 4 characters)

Your comment about this anime(Required)

Your evaluation of this title(Required)
You can choose the evaluation only once. After you post your evaluation, please choose comment instead of evaluation from the options.

Evaluation of this title(You can choose this only once)

Best!!
Very good
Good
Normal
Bad
Very Bad
Worst

If you evaluated this title once, please choose comment instead of the evaluation.
Comment by the person who thinks this is good
Comment by the person who thinks this is normal
Comment by the person who thinks this is bad

Please choose appropriate option for readers.

Caution: Please post the evaluation which follows the rule.