Japanese works database(How to join/Help)
Top page: All/Only Reviews

Others
Site map

AllAnimeGameComicNovelDramaSp. effectJP movieMovie	Info:voice,game..	Reviewers	Diary
Search / Outside DB:

Anime ranking: Rank 2,638/in 2,640 titles (Total -623.48/Deviation -27.36) Rank 2,637 <= => Rank 2,639
Anime average points ranking: Rank 1,274/in 1,376 titles (Average -0.88(Bad)/Deviation 33.22) Rank 1,273 <= => Rank 1,275 (more than 10 evaluatoin)
Anime ranking of 2002: Rank 84/in 84 titles Rank 83 <=

Mobile Suit Gundam SEED(Anime)

[Other version: RSS/Japanese version]

Other media
Game:Mobile Suit Gundam SEED Federation vs. Z.A.F.T. / Comics:Mobile Suit Gundam SEED / Novel:Mobile Suit Gundam SEED

All
Reviews(Post)

Forum

Images

Goods
(DVD)

Latest DVD: 2008/03/04 ():

Mobile Suit GUNDAM SEED: Anime Legends Collection, Vol. 2 $98

DVD(37hit) Sales/Latest						Books(33hit) Sales/Latest	Toys(37hit) Sales/Latest	Music(18hit) Sales/Latest	VideoGames(4hit) Sales/Latest
Rank:4716 Mobile Suit Gundam Wing - Complete Collection 2 Tag:$98 2006/05/09 () Eval.:***** 1.Complete Collection 2	Rank:12979 Mobile Suit GUNDAM SEED: Anime Legends Collection, Vol. 2 Tag:$98 2008/03/04 () Eval.:***** 1.MSG Seed	Rank:13831 Mobile Suit Gundam SEED Anime Legends Collection 1 Tag:$98 2008/01/08 () Eval.:***** 1.Great series, but defective discs.	Rank:14400 Mobile Suit Gundam SEED Destiny V10 Tag:$98 2007/09/25 () Eval.:***** 1.Quality service guaranteed.	Rank:15728 Mobile Suit Gundam: Seed Destiny, Vol. 11 Tag:$98 2007/11/06 () Eval.:***** 1.manufacturing defect,buyers beware!	Rank:17059 Mobile Suit Gundam Seed Destiny, Vol. 4 Tag:$98 2006/09/26 () Eval.:***** 1.The Battle Rages On	Rank:93154 Paperback:Mobile Suit Gundam SEED (Novel) Volume 2 (Gundam (Tokyopop) (Graphic Novels)) Tag:$99 2006/01/10 () Eval.:***** 1.Certainly better than the first	Rank:23946 Toy:Gundam Seed Destiny MSIA Force Impulse Gundam Action Figure	Rank:185998 Audio CD:Mobile Suit Gundam Seed Destiny Theme Song, Insert Song & Character Song Collection Eval.:***** 1.Updated Title List with Artists	Rank:5947 Video Game:Mobile Suit Gundam Seed Never Ending Tomorrrow Tag:$99 2005/09/28 () Eval.:***** 1.Awesome if you are a Gundam fan!

Information about this title

MBS(Mainichi Broadcasting System) TBS
Sunrise Hajime Yatate Yoshiyuki Tomino
FUKUDA MITSUO MOROSAWA CHIAKI Hiroyuki Yoshino Mendeakemi Hiroshi Onogi Kogure Kyouko
Hirai hisashi OKAWARA KUNIO Kimitoshi Yamane
Mutumi inomata Kazutaka Miyatake
Ikedashigemi Yasuo Urakami Toshihiko Sahashi
AUDIO PLANNING U Victor Entertainment,Inc. Sony Music Entertainment(Japan)Inc. SUNRISE Music Publication
Seiji Takeda
SOTSU AGENCY ADK Daisuke Asakura T.M.Revolution Nami Tamaki Yuki Kaziura See-Saw
Tatsuya Ishii

[Detail]

Mika Nakashima Ken Shima Rie Tanaka FictionJunction YUUKA
Souichirou Hoshi Akira Ishida Naomi Shindo
Takehito Koyasu Toshihoko seki Tomokazu Seki Mami
Akira sasanuma Kotono Mitsuishi Houko Kuwashima
Megumi toyoguti Yasuhiro Takato Takayuki Inoue Tetsu Siratori
Ryotaro Okiayu Isshin Chiba Shigeru Shibuya
Katumi Toriumi Michiyo Yanagisawa Nobuyuki Hiyama Ryohei
Hiro Yuki Syuniti miyamoto Takanori NISHIKAWA Naoki Tatsuta

Released:2002/10/05 in Japan End:2003/09/27 in Japan

Official sites
1. GUNDAM SEED WEB (Translation)

Image gallery sites
1. Gundam Seed Net [v2] - Image Archives

Statics of evaluation(The statics is updated once a day)

	Average	AnimeRank	Deviation(Total)	Evaluation points(Total)	Best of the Best
Inside Japan	Bad(-0.88)	2,638	-27.36	-623.48	1
Outside Japan	Very good(2.00)	394	46.43	2.00

Statics of activity

	Total Views	Comment	Evaluation
Inside Japan	475,641	2,554	721
Outside Japan	7,324	2	1

How others evaluated in Japan

Best

Very Good

Good

Normal

Bad

Very Bad

Worst

People

106

103

220

Percentage

6.1%

9.2%

10.5%

14.7%

14.3%

30.5%

Added percentage

6.1%

15.3%

25.8%

40.5%

55.2%

69.5%

100%

Summary

25.8%

14.7%

59.5%

Views for recent 8 days
Total 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1
31 5 7 3 1 3 4 5 3

Language Sorted by date Sorted by recommendation New!
English Good
(Only Evaluation) Normal
(Only Evaluation) Bad
(Only Evaluation) All
(Only Evaluation) None
Japanese Good
(Only Evaluation) Normal
(Only Evaluation) Bad
(Only Evaluation) All
(Only Evaluation) All
This reputation board

Language	Sorted by date	Sorted by recommendation New!
English	Good (Only Evaluation)	Normal (Only Evaluation)	Bad (Only Evaluation)	All (Only Evaluation)	None
Japanese	Good (Only Evaluation)	Normal (Only Evaluation)	Bad (Only Evaluation)	All (Only Evaluation)	All

2005/02/21 Comment(good) [Edit/Delete//Only this reviewer/Only this review/post sympathy comment/]
by nonifel balaba Provider: 28822 Host:28667 Browser: 4983
fantastic...........

i really love all the characters, special kira yamato and lacus clyne

my day is not complete if i can't watch tv

hope to see all the episodes

mwah..........

2004/09/20 Very good [Edit/Delete//Only this reviewer/Only this review/post sympathy comment/]
by MOHD Review history[Good:1(100%) Normal:0(0%) Bad:0(0%)] / Provider: 50795 Host:50929 Browser: 8192
Very exciting and interesting story, the Characters look is pretty cool. I dont think "GUNDAM" fans will love it, since I hate gundam and I still do. It focuses more of the characters and their dreams. Kira is cute ^_^!

Post your review / Top page

Other media
Game:Mobile Suit Gundam SEED Federation vs. Z.A.F.T. / Comics:Mobile Suit Gundam SEED / Novel:Mobile Suit Gundam SEED

The below reviews are translated automatically from Japanese ones. To post to English version, please click here.

2008/07/08 Very bad [Original Japanese review]
by お暇なゲ〜セン Provider: 50310 Host:50276 Browser: 3875
I will change 8s ぱ評価.
It is "bad" when many things are recalled.
A grotesque scene and an erotic scene are too severe.
Is it what may pass such a scene at 6:00 on Saturday?
One period of treatment of the beginning was interesting.
It was more interesting than honesty and 1st.
It was just the remake of 1st.
But it is " after kira tells sai 嫌味.
Inconsistency became [ the portion or pakuri which are regarded as " ] severe.
It is contradictory to do with having said kira too much, and it is だった especially the second half.
It is full destruction, calling it non-殺 ...
When warring without killing people, the heart should have been made into the demon from the beginning, and the enemy should have been beaten, or it should have pierced through it desperately to 剣心みたい.
rakusu and kagari did not seldom care for it somehow the back, either.
し [ asuran is also likely to have only the thing of the thing of kira on the head ].
But the girls of muu, day akka, nataru, or M1 asutorei were able to take to it.
The scene from which especially muu and nataru die looked at "漢"!
.
It was not able to see, if he had no tear at maji!
MS of a strike, a buster, gin, geitsu, or M1 asutorei was also smart.
However, I put into the world of a cancer dam by the favor of SEED.
Illustrating uses and "manufacture staff is animation 作る気あん truly about a belt.
I think ".

2008/07/08 Good [Original Japanese review]
by Arutemakoa Provider: 17298 Host:17277 Browser: 3874
Although it thinks that it is the work with which the pros and cons are divided so that it ranks with G cancer dam in cancer dam series, I think that this SEED was good.
Although it sees synthetically although there was also a point that まぁ was bad, and it is then ...

[Good point]
A === battle scene === this work thinks that a big change is seen by it in a battle scene.
The field where it not only merely exchanges shots, but elements, such as attack arms, defense arms, and geographical feature, are taken in in the battle side was seen, and tactics were rather good this time.
However, although it does not know whether it is the cause, the point which did not have not much many battle scenes is a difficulty or ...
= == story deployment = == story deployment receives touch which has belonged to the story from the basic first to ZZ.
It is the flow that the first hero kira Yamato will get in a mobiru suit "a strike" by chance in a colony, will beat an enemy, and will become a formal pilot from what.
However, the point which is deterministically different by this work is a point of knowing from the beginning kira being special human being called a coordinator.
Although it was a flow of the hero currently considered for first series to be completely the human being of a normal at first knowing that it is a new type on the way, and making the talent bloom, kira knows from the beginning that it is a coordinator, and this work knows that a surrounding friend is also a coordinator further.
For this reason, isn't it a place with this portion have started well suffering of fighting on the battlefield, and the involved suffering, with people by the capability which he has, and sufficient [ SEED ]?
= ==MS design == = Is the design of MS the least good in these SEED series first?
So, it is smart.
If it expresses at a word, it will become such a thing.
Many smart cancer dams, such as a "strike", "iijisu", "freedom", and "justice", had gathered, and striker pack conversion of a strike etc.
was interesting.

[a bad point]
-- === -- in addition to this -- character === -- it is too deep The said impression is very strong.
asuran persists in kira too much and rakusu is not understood well.
Frei (probably such a name) is a wicked woman who merely feels sick.
For the first time in [ to the extent that it ranks with katejina of a movement fighter V cancer dam (*) / a wicked woman ] was demonstrated.
It will change considerably by whether it is thought bad whether the depth of this character thinks that it is good.
= The volume on == 総 collection = many 総 collection editing to which == this work summarized the flow of an old tale not at all was broadcast.
Therefore, very sorry for the talk not to progress not much previously but become the deployment which the last round ends in the state of a run.
Although it may say, I want those who are looking every week to do honto pardon for those who can seldom be seen.
= Depiction which does not suit in == time zone = be till fairly dangerous places, such as == guroi depiction and a rape scene of kira by Frei.
In that time zone, I think that I want you to be cautious.

[Note]
TV series 最終作 of the space century series photographed by Director * movement fighter V cancer dam Tomino.
the head the weight of the talk is the same level as Z cancer dam, and people die anyhow, and according to guillotine -- cutting off -- etc.
-- there was also many cruel depiction Since it confessed that the supervisor was a depression sick taste behind, is it of a style the cause?
Although まぁ drama nature was good, for the first time in [ of katejina / a wicked woman ] is severe...

[Comprehensive evaluation]
Although there were also many bad points, I want to evaluate the point of having challenged various new things in the cancer dam.
Therefore, I wish to attach good thing evaluation.

2008/07/06 Bad [Original Japanese review]
by Yakkuru Provider: 19860 Host:19673 Browser: 4661
Since it has succeeded commercially, I want to evaluate there.
However, the contents ...
In spite of carrying out the theme [ war ], the head of great さん [ やたら ] is tochi 狂ってます.
A word as a natural can be killed to an eye, だ and a coordinator can be killed, and it is だ.
It is drawing only as perfect wrong.
It is extensive slaughter to do, although it is convinced that they are justice if it results in hero vigor.
in any way -- like this -- being also alike -- the flow of the second half was able to consider only to such winds
[Good point]
It is a portion in the first half.
Although there was no showy deployment to there, as it is, it was good.
It said that it was as worrying considerably about fighting also about kira だり, and there was also a portion.
There is individuality and the cancer dam in early stages of MS (except for freedom justice) is a good impression, respectively.
I think that it is a design like [ MS / of zafuto ] the first's ridezain which is an everyday occurrence on a cancer dam at large, and was devised as it is although it was suitable.
Sub characters, such as sub kyaramuu and day akka, had shone.
It is quite better than the character of a leading role class at the character which calls a peculiar expression or cannot be hated somewhere.
When it is a female character, it is only millimeter aria.
I think that it is a female character with No.
1 humanity.
Day akka and 惹かれあう所 were the only help of the second half little by little in the position in which he is placed.

[a bad point]
-- the character of a leading role rank -- what -- idea てる, rakusu which is not understood well, selfish kagari, and kira -- favorite asuran Such impressions were very strong.
It is too strong rather than it says.
The impression of there being no big idea as the leading figure who is moving in order to change the world, if it results in kira, and a hero, and fighting according to rakusu is strong.
An inside is thin although it is the character of a leading role class in short.
If it is attractive の by the capability of SEED currently attached to freedom Shas tester itoru, it will not be come to feel MS of the capability projected so far that it is uncongenial.

[Comprehensive evaluation]
Although a sequel is also so, there is little charm as a cancer dam work the theme of the work itself, the feelings of a character, and that it is as たり after finishing seeing, so that it may not be made to think.
Moreover, although per kira makes it language quite mostly about non-殺, I wanted you to put into practice more also in respect of a battle.
(Or [ that charm seethed also with kira for a while when at least a certain 蒼き shooting star was put into practice ]) The impression that deployment of the second half is quite bad too.
Although it does not think the first half that it is bad with it being individual, since the impression that it is good after finishing seeing too is thin, it will worsen evaluation.

2008/07/03 Best! [Original Japanese review]
by Norinyanchu Provider: 28072 Host:28017 Browser: 6287

[Good point]
Music character story
[Bad point]
Especially nothing
[comprehensive evaluation]
-- individually unreasonable -- it was interesting Why there is much criticism and about [ which are not understood ].
The story was also able to become hot and a character and music were good.

2008/06/25 Comment(bad) [Original Japanese review]
by 観察者 Provider: 1867 Host:1616 Browser: 8090

[Good point]
Theme song
[Bad point]
Numerousness edited by the 総 collection
[Comprehensive evaluation]
kira, asuran, kagari, and rakusu did not care for it.
The flower of the paper got from the girl before getting down to the earth the back.
Even now, having remained also from が降りて is wonderful.

2008/06/14 Best! [Original Japanese review]
by Kikona Provider: 23597 Host:23360 Browser: 5234

[Good point]
It was interesting.
I think that it is for [ present / young ] people.

[Bad point]
Especially nothing.

[Comprehensive evaluation]
Highest

2008/06/03 Worst [Original Japanese review]
by OD Provider: 38670 Host:38708 Browser: 4926

[Good point]
Cancer plastic CM of the Kamito 彩.

[Bad point]
All.

[Comprehensive evaluation]
It is a fearful work that it still looks directly if compared with 死種 of this sequel.
Seeing cancer plastic CM after an end rather than this editing is the unique animation w which was pleasure.

2008/05/30 Bad [Original Japanese review]
by Batsu Provider: 674 Host:547 Browser: 6213
I think that the 1st period of treatment of this work is very Hideyasu.
It is called an end [ and ] and you call it a battle.
if the 1st period of treatment is seen to put it bluntly -- baddo -- don't you go into a higher rank in all the past cancer dams?
Especially activity of mebiusuzero was good.
the figure with which it trifles with Captain Fraga's operation technology had 惹かれる's very much, without fearing, even if it turned four cancer dams to the enemy What he cannot allow by this work is existence of 4-pair-of-shoes walk type MS which made bakuu first in a roll.
When it was zoido, the battle to which it can still be rationally convinced somehow by "fighting an animal and an animal" was never able to be allowed to be visible to the composition of "slaughter of the animal by man" in this work.
Considering the body on which it seems to use the dog as the motif fundamentally so that it may understand also from there being a variation machine called Kerberos bakuu etc., and the dog is fed, it was very unpleasant.
It is a 噴飯 thing that the work by which the name of a cancer dam which can be said also as the flag cypripedium of robot animation rather than anything is entitled brought such composition to the battle.
About deployment of the second half, it does not dare mention freedom, justice, and it.
However, it may be called going too far of metaphor animal protection.
A man type mechanism will beat an animal type mechanism, and he will surely start rejection to destroy.
Although it considered [ how it is and ] that an individual situation was formed previously, he was never still able to do giving popularity to this work.

2008/05/14 Very bad [Original Japanese review]
by Kurooshie Provider: 38219 Host:37981 Browser: 8374
With what that was not not much interesting and by which it is looking somehow and the opening came immediately does this work become so?
"it having been too much" without じゃ carrying out like this in that place -- why does it continue winning generally?
[ which saw and had a lot the scene / た / a scene ] moreover -- the performance and difference of such capability or the body -- it is -- passing -- it is -- freedom, and justice and a performance are good -- elapsing -- it is -- other bodies -- completely -- odds, or honesty and it which cannot win by any means and considers a performance more as it is better to increase the body more together -- something -- everybody -- alike and visible "with a face together -- the hairstyle of the same face -- 変え -- てい -- only -- it is visible -- "
[Good point]
The body is smart.

[Bad point]
The direction which made capability of a character more nearly average says.
I consider that it is better to lower capability and the difference of the performance of the body to a slight degree.
The way which used the contents as the firm thing more says.

[Comprehensive evaluation]
I consider comprehensive evaluation as it is more interesting firm to make a setup very bad more.

2008/05/11 Bad [Original Japanese review]
by Pakkun Provider: 9008 Host:8682 Browser: 8780

[Good point]
A part of MS(s), a character, music
[Bad point]
Although it is not related to the badness work of a formal setup, the rarity as human being of the fundamental breakdown heroes of this editing, and batsu, it is a lack [ some /, such as a supervisor, / staff's part elegance of a fan ].

[Comprehensive evaluation]
Although there is nothing so idly that anti says, it is not so interesting as a believer says.
I thought that it was at least the inner bottom.
real intention says that no [ true ] is regrettable -- it is

2008/05/11 Comment(bad) [Original Japanese review]
by Chonmage Provider: 10858 Host:10853 Browser: 7590

[Good point]
Since it was a cancer dam after a long time before broadcast, it was glad.
The time zone of the ground 6.
A cancer dam sprouts and a parody can be seen.
Commercially, it wins a great success.

[Bad point]
しょ - does not have the design of a mobiru suit first, either.
It is fatal.
Large warship huge gun principle.
The misapprehension of a maker called strong = justice.
The battle scene which uses about and is lazy.
There is no structure こみ of a character.
The countenance and dress of a nerd aim.
A useless erotic scene.
The design of the past cancer dam, and pakuri of words.
A thin story and theatrical elocution.
The excessive issue edited by 総集.

[Comprehensive evaluation]
It was the minimum work without the completely seen value.
The cancer dam is insulted.
It is the animation for nerds.

2008/05/08 Comment(bad) [Original Japanese review]
by オリオン座 Provider: 12883 Host:12953 Browser: 2909(Mobile)
I abhor kagari.
the roughness of that temperament, and himself -- a selfish place Also the sense of justice of it and conceit.
It does not never care for it.
It abhors.
rather than -- a fellow -- being right -- if -- doing -- てい -- things -- a bad result -- starting -- since -- more -- Tati -- being bad .
し [ it will not be disclosed that it is worried although a supervisor's kisaka has also killed people by guerrilla activity of kagari if kagari is the daughter of the sovereign of Aube, or it is only it ].
し [ it helps / he / by 薦ん / murder rather and is foolish ].
し [ a scientist's erica also built the cancer dam for kagari and has killed many people again ].
The nerve of the human being of neutral nation Aube is suspected.
It acts as what everybody, and a small daughter's ワgamama is used and homicide activities are carried out.
It becomes an international problem.
asuran put together forcibly -- her -- a political thing -- all -- his brains -- only depending -- it is -- し .
such inside carried out -- kagari -- one person -- it has become between those who cannot do じゃ何, either Autonomy has been lost while asuran is also pulled by her.
The crime of asuran and the persons concerned of Aube made kagari such deplorable human being.

2008/05/08 Bad [Original Japanese review]
by ロケット花火改 Provider: 21953 Host:21979 Browser: 3875
It went into the merit of too much [ at the beginning ] laver from which this work began immediately at mind.
The talk carried out tempo and smart places, such as production of action of a loan MS, etc.
had many highlights.
Whenever the talk progressed, it was all covered gradually at the place where the good place is bad.
He has considered the reason earnestly during these several years.
Then, only the following reasons came to mind.
You also think that you are the language loans of companion mind.
- There is no collision of the ideas and principles whose too (other characters usually pass if it forces) strong series of - former - kira whose MS is too (it shows too much well) beautiful suited.
- <- which cannot feel charm for MS -- the most fatal - Since words are omitted beyond necessity, it is looking, and an ambiguous scene thinks that many (there is little amount of information although he can understand if it says that he can understand) etc.
is mentioned by it.
In cancer dam series, it is all fatal.
I cannot be pleasant to merely show fighting [ which neither strategy nature nor excrement has in it ].
Although it is interesting, it will not be so good too somewhere.

2008/05/08 Bad [Original Japanese review]
by 才也電卓 Provider: 4446 Host:4243 Browser: 5234
Although I hear that the first cancer dam is imitated and it is making and a frightful criticism is received, except the Tomino cancer dam, it is looking most, and as pleasantly, I think that it is individual.
a debt of kira and asuran and Frei (below っけ.) a character -- it was interesting I think that it was also good that there were a number of nil impression scenes in the founder fundamentally.
...
Although っ thinks that it is interesting, however it may model the contents, it is not the fun of a cancer dam.
Does kira do?
..
I see and think whether the touch [ た / touch ] is close to the direction of the laver of a dragon ball By asuranpapa, a change of a giren chief is not 務まりま(ed) the back.
The place it was thought weak as a character that was unexpected had that first.
Although it is "normal" - "it is good" when probably completely seeing as another work, since it is the result using the name of a cancer dam, it is "bad."

2008/05/08 Comment(bad) [Original Japanese review]
by オリオン座 Provider: 12883 Host:12949 Browser: 2909(Mobile)
If the opinion of the Celt is seen to the Celt, I will think that asuran and kagari are the relations which must not be connected.
It is also the problem of time to know to shelter the representative of a country for the son of war criminal Patrick zara, if it acts as a manager to whom kagari takes the thing of asuran into pieces, to be criticized by people since kagari had hidden kira and rakusu which spread war too many in the end, to lose the reliance as a representative, and to start a coup d'etat.
Distrust is borne even against other countries and I think that it becomes the isolated country where no country does export of a substance and import.
The ringleader was sheltering asuran and others by the individual feeling of kagari, and all are the cause of a lack [ a dramatist's arm which did not consider to such a thing but was merely put together ].

2008/05/07 Good [Original Japanese review]
by moon-moon Provider: 1657 Host:1741 Browser: 6395
For itself, it is a saw cancer dam for the first time.
At the time of a high school, it rises with this subject with a friend, and is a better seed.
The parenthesis of a mobiru suit is also good and I regard it as good.
I hear that he came to look at other cancer dams after looking at this.
-- A title called a cancer dam is great anyhow.

2008/05/07 Very bad [Original Japanese review]
by pom Provider: 14055 Host:14209 Browser: 11343

[Good point]
Not much nothing, even if it retraces memory.
He somewhat liked music.

[a bad point]
-- it is truly foolish to be moved by all the members' characters which come out -- him -- it is untidy ...
っていう -- things Empathy was not able to be carried out at all in what.
Was it monotonous in a battle being unexpected somehow ...
Character dithering is weak above all ...
although it was a pattern (probably -- illustrating -- charge is together) similar to sukuraido and was somewhat tight also at sukuraido, since it sprouts further compared with sukuraido and the ingredient increased too much, it was very hot

2008/05/07 Best! [Original Japanese review]
by Abonrii Provider: 28257 Host:28094 Browser: 7395

[A good point]
A picture is beautiful.
Smartness of MS.
Battle scene.

[A bad point]
The place whose story is too complicated.

[Comprehensive evaluation]
this work -- it is unpopular at all -- it is .
It is thought that criticism is concentrating about kira of a story and a hero.
Although I feel that surely it understands, but I have a feeling that it is not having restricted to this.
gandamu by which other works have a heavy theme, its story is complicated, and the hero is always irritated to the adult or the world -- I think that it is a ってこんな work Probably the child was also looking at this work, thinking that he could not understand.
Those for which he asks a cancer dam are the smartness of MS, and a showy battle scene.
I say clearly and think that it is good anyhow except it.
In such meaning, I think that this work was successful.
The freedom of overwhelming strength is smart.
He is merely large satisfaction only in it.
Impressiveness suited also fighting with the freedom of the last, and Providence, and it was the highest.

2008/05/04 Worst [Original Japanese review]
by Fuaamaa Provider: 39435 Host:39364 Browser: 4483

[Good point]
まぁあえて言えば絵 is beautiful.

[Bad point]
It persists in a first cancer dam too much.
If the work which is not understood whether be a parody or be omaaju is made, I will feel that the direction completely done on another body which is not a "cancer dam" received.
Furthermore, if it says, past [ cancer dam 増え ], a name, and the body are not in agreement.
And treating other bodies as zako is not pleased.
It is fastidious in a battle scene too much, and a theme called change and the drama of the mental state of the human being in war is too light.
Since it is んん which only the greenhorns who know neither the still fought reason nor then the thing to lose so much are riding and fighting on the arms which the name attached [ "freedom" ] in "justice", it is a laughingstock.
A gimmick and scene 出す to take only several characters are also unsightly.

[comprehensive evaluation]
-- the 2-3rd -- cool -- the three-way race (?) of Aube, earth union, and zafuto it is -- although -- where constructs with where and does not hakkiri る asuran and day akka is also calm, and it defects, and shines and hits, and the consciousness as a military man is not seen.
Nothings that can be learned from this animation are twisted and, therefore, evaluation is the worst.

2008/05/03 Good [Original Japanese review]
by Kurashi Provider: 28916 Host:28755 Browser: 2876
- The SEED character looked at them who were announced by the animation magazine in summer of - 2002 which is not a beauty form character, and I at least felt so.
Therefore, I thought that it was not the work which aimed at "such a route." Although it was being able to say later, it was short circuit thinking.
However, the point that it is not a beauty form is still considered so.
If it says more correctly, in a beauty form, it is "there was nothing." Isn't that everyone probably remained [ which watched the result of SEED ] in the impression strongly (although it is not made language) "change of a pattern"?
When the touch of Hirai who was dragging sukuraido still more also passed televising half a year, it had become the peculiar looks which carried matsuge like that rotation nokogiri.
much illustrating -- a character designer's pattern to which the staff has to refer -- under one work manufacture -- like this -- until -- the example which changed dramatically does not have so many histories of animation of Japan, either If it mentions by force, the Miki book character in super-space-time fort MACROSS (the 1st work of TV) will be close to this example.
Was the change of the Hirai character an unexpected occurrence?
usually -- if come out and it is -- a character designer -- if his pattern changes remarkably, therefore, the surrounding staff will not allow [ that the spot only gets confused ] it for self, either However, unlike usual, the work attitude of saying [ that it was possible ], i.e., SEED, can surmise that it was avaricious making better contents.
Although reference was made about a character design and illustrating as an intelligible example here, this is applied also to a scenario also at production.
The thing with epoch-making SEED is in the point which made qualitative change of such a staff work the selling point (to inside of silence) above all.
Is it exaggerated if it is called - into which the staff's kind was also broken to the same timing as kira carried out the seed crack within a play?
(In SEED, there is nothing that should be especially mentioned about a voice actor, or a singer and music rather.) Since they were in the state completed from the beginning, supposing they mean and assemble the staff into whom a seed was not broken more than it and who is likely to bud at any moment, they are very rare producing capability!
I do not have the courage to omit it with "a lucky hit." - - and - which become little by little good - to which -, -, and the hero who become more interesting and more interesting take -- such meaning which, so to speak, used the methodology (at the time especially -- a newcomer cartoonist's debut 作 --) of a weekly boy magazine by television animation is large Although it is large therefore, it has become difficult to take in "the further growth" at a sequel and DESTINY.
But, it may also be able to be called boys' comics-result.
Already, although the dub ruoo series of a view of the world with a new cancer dam serves as a core, SEED-related new work puramo or a game are yet unlikely to stop.
Moreover, by the so-called CM of "ground 6 animation" konpi CD, for the first time in [ of kira and asuran (Ed) / nature ] is clever, and can realize deep-rooted [ of this work / popular ].

Next / Post your review / Top page

Other media
Game:Mobile Suit Gundam SEED Federation vs. Z.A.F.T. / Comics:Mobile Suit Gundam SEED / Novel:Mobile Suit Gundam SEED

ALERT: You cannot use open proxy or TOR for posting your review. If it is detected, your access to this site will be prohibited.

Rule for reviews

This site allows you to write reviews for each title, but we don't allow you to criticize others' comment. Too bad or meaningless words are also not allowed. The comment which doesn't follow the rule will be deleted. If you find any comment which doesn't follow the rule, please notify us by clicking Suggest to delete.

Example to be deleted frequently

Favorite side
You dislike this one, then don't see it or comment this title
- Please go to the fan site. Anyone has the right to say what they feel in this site.

Disliking side
Do you like this one? You are stupid.
- Your view is only your view. Please concentrate on only the content of the title, not on others' comment.

Please use only English. If not, the comment will be deleted.

Your Name(Required)

Password (Required. more than 4 characters)

Your comment about this anime(Required)

Your evaluation of this title(Required)
You can choose the evaluation only once. After you post your evaluation, please choose comment instead of evaluation from the options.

Evaluation of this title(You can choose this only once)

Best!!
Very good
Good
Normal
Bad
Very Bad
Worst

If you evaluated this title once, please choose comment instead of the evaluation.
Comment by the person who thinks this is good
Comment by the person who thinks this is normal
Comment by the person who thinks this is bad

Please choose appropriate option for readers.

Caution: Please post the evaluation which follows the rule.