| The below reviews are translated automatically from Japanese ones. To post your review to English version, please click here. |
2010/07/04 Normal [Original Japanese review]
by Rryuuzu (Send message) Review history / Provider: 17500 Host:17507 Browser: 4891
Is [ what is said and ] it a halfway work?
First, the badness of illustrating is conspicuous.
It is not good that there is a time in which especially the face of a character collapses severely.
There are too many portions currently explained to be them in narration.
If it is not made to understand neither in situation depiction nor words more perfectly.
Isn't it good that an enemy does not clarify, either?
And, and the scene looked for while saying that a migration place is looked for fought with garumangamirasu, and was vagueness.
[ that there is nothing not much ] [ fighting with boraa ]
Is it the scene of Yamato as a good point?
This scene of 3 is the most beautiful.
Although that is right, 峨 which was illustrated based on the picture which photoed the model with the fish-eye lens and for which it presses is very powerful.
It was the work which says that there are also many scenes by which an enemy does not clarify upwards and Yamato is damaged, and does not feel them refreshed in any way, or cannot be enjoyed.
As evaluation, it is common.
2009/10/17 Very Bad [Original Japanese review]
by TTTE-307G (Send message) Review history / Provider: 49745 Host:49922 Browser: 6415
Even if it deducted the point of old animation, it carried out by not being interesting.
First of all, it is a problem that any relation to the last purpose of Yamato does not have the battle of Yamato.
However it may battle as it is fighting helplessly, since an enemy comes, the talk progresses and it does not become 羂.
Although the interest was still in the battle the first half, when it became boraa of the second half, and a battle, it was merely gudaguda.
It is a cause that the boraa itself is also too weak.
Moreover, incoherent action of the ancient times caught in others.
Contrast of the pacifism sharubaato's and De Dis Ra's imperialism is left after all.
How to save the earth found suddenly.
The unnatural last decisive battle.
etc.
had many fields discouraged.
It does not understand having wanted honesty and what to do.
2009/05/05 Good [Original Japanese review]
by KCC (Send message) Review history / Provider: 11399 Host:11367 Browser: 7049
Although the series of space warfare warship Yamato is never a bad work and is a masterpiece rather a saw case independently, this "III" should be said to have been an especially unhappy work also in it.
"": Everybody 罩祉ｃ, impressed !
"2": The second half and an end can be changed and impression of the theater version is spoilt!
"New departure": .
if it must have died wholly
"-- if when really [":] comes forever, it will finish
If "" which large-took a break was not made for there to have been nothing, it was in the state which cannot be enjoyed at all after "2", and it was a work used as the start from the image of the minus of "being [ or ] again."
Moreover, "it is one more year to human-beings extinction".
"it will do this time for one year.
[ that the position was already taken on the cancer dam, or ] [ of the beginning ] It is a point also with regrettable after all the story having also been running rapidly [ in half a year ] from shortening and the middle, carrying out the expectation ".
Furthermore, the end of Domon who is the leading role of "III", and 臂 is carelessness.
On the setup, although the new member heard that it was to die from the principle beginning, however these two persons might think, they did not die.
This death of two persons is one of the not being yet satisfactory in the history of saw animation individually.
However, even if it deducted the minus point of only this, it was the work which can fully be enjoyed the first half.
"" It is the work regarded as your being evaluated more supposing it continuing for one year if there is no flow of -> "2."
2008/08/16 Very Bad [Original Japanese review]
by Baadakku (Send message) Review history / Provider: 6794 Host:6761 Browser: 8090
severe one -- a word is boiled and it is exhausted
It is severer than the first work and illustrating is one more year to a downfall -- Make it random --
Past [ of De Dis Ra / 荅怨 ].
The second half by favor --
-- of bemuraaze by which the large-sized movement fort also betrayed expectation splendidly, and was overly damaged immediately.
High paade slur gun -- Did not think that it would use from the beginning --
Domon and 臂's existence value ....
such --
which might say that the cancer dam appeared well --
Although it is the trash of the evaluation highest class, since the period until the worst does not go, it is "it is also near the worst and bad."
2008/02/11 Normal [Original Japanese review]
by (Send message) Review history / Provider: 11009 Host:11078 Browser: 5234
It does not memorize and become precocious most middle stages.
The sun will ュぇ enlarged and it will go to search of a migration place (however, -- [ because / one Yamato ].).
Having considered time, expense, etc.
concerning migration, this new kyara was filled up as a crew before the start of the opening part, and saying "to the Yamato sortie --" explanation entered, The nantoka gun which presses down expansion of the sun at having been captured in the new empire which it was made zutaboro in the middle stage and De Dis Ra built, and the final stage was discharged, and that De Dis Ra was doing the quite delicious part has memorized by the conclusion also at this time.
Since popularity came out, De Dis Ra is the same as Godzilla etc., and is he the type of a good turn?
the feeling to the man who drove in the earth just before the downfall although it was probably an ant, if desperate persons' sympathizer G etc.
was the soldiers of an end like a cancer dam -- several small years -- the earth whole -- improving -- it is not being usually (Weak point of Yamato which is [ the hereabouts neighborhood ] too weak)
2008/02/11 Very Bad [Original Japanese review]
by H&J (Send message) Review history / Provider: 909 Host:758 Browser: 8090
罸綺 -- familiar one-year countdown -- "-- again -- or -- having built the Great country by one battleship which" De Dis Ra survived by "it is new" -- "-- it is going too well -- --"
He got angry in the thought of the party of a sharubaato star above all.
While holding up an ideal with a honeyed words "it is good if they are peace.
There is no responsibility 羂 at all to the thing of the believer of other stars.
"
Evaluation: It is very bad.
2006/11/26 Normal [Original Japanese review]
by ゅ御款 (Send message) Review history / Provider: 40935 Host:41100 Browser: 3650
Although it thinks that it is never a petty work, it will become the comment "this deployment has already 蕋純ed bored."
Although the story of 3 is beginning of "leaving for the second search for the earth in order to escape from the crisis of the solar system", saying clearly and doing hardly changes with the 1st work.
Although there are that De Dis Ra is cooperative, there being a talk Yamato being captured by the enemy, and a difference in some, since the rough flow of "leaving for the universe in order to save the earth, receiving the item which saves the earth in the star which arrived many stars at the last the surroundings, and coming back to the earth" is completely the same, touch called a mere rehash carries out them.
I think that new kyara newly added by 3 was also seldom able to say that it was attractive.
Although two persons become main [ 臂 and Domon ] in new kyara of 3, about Domon, I give special treatment and feel that it passes.
although there is a scene where Domon acts as the substitute captain of a warship instead of injured ancient times, not Domon that is the newcomer crew of a life group when thinking ordinarily but the vice-captain's of a warship Sanada should enact a captain-of-a-warship substitute -- if -- I carry out and admiration which also killed --?
last forcibly feels that it had become the thing which was being carried out vividly and in which Domon's existence itself floated
Honestly, 臂 and Domon consider that it was better not to kill.
And it is also minus that the last same sermon stink as 2 is drifting.
It is thought that it would not be able to do those days as soon as it directed even so already slightly nonchalantly although it may be that such messages are contained since present constitutional amendment argument was the time of prohibition.
The conversation of Princess sharubaato of the last talk is the feeling itself which it lets hear about a sermon of an old man.
Independently, he wants to hear a sermon, and it is not an animation 荀 reason, and can seldom welcome saying like this.
although what was made being conscious of the 1st work which is a masterpiece is felt -- so -- or -- I have finished it as the mere imitation of the 1st work, and feel that there was nothing for the place superior to the 1st work
2006/06/04 Good [Original Japanese review]
by Tarako (Send message) Review history / Provider: 31975 Host:32071 Browser: 3874
as me who am the Yamato fan -- obtaining -- ~ -- it and is difficult But they are comment soon.
Although the last program of a series does not think that it is severe.
1.
It is one more year to an earth downfall.
"-- again -- or -- I thought honest with -" Probably it comes to consider and the direction will be impossible.
2.
It was interesting in it being unexpected till the first half - the middle stage.
The rajiendora number, the "Yamato" VS "garumangamirasu" new reflective satellite gun, etc.
appeared, and he was able to be enjoyed very well.
It has got used also to a new crew.
However, Yamato, past [ kosumotaigaa ゃ ].
It seemed to carry about 100 sets (seriously).
3.
Middle-stage middle.
Confrontation with a boraa federation.
The villain of Yamato is intelligible (smile).
However, a mechanism is past [ chachi ].
Below the destroyer of a gamirasu empire ....
Reunion with De Dis Ra was also individually good.
4.
-- already -- the speed of a run of the final stage ?
last -- surprise
It merely came for the shift of the queen of sharubaato with Jean.
The law that it is not as one human being and must live as people's symbol as a queen.
Music also matched.
Although 罕臂 is good for 5.2 persons' death, Domon is ....
just for a moment.
Even if it kills nothing by force.
A setup called in war has only lived to sharubaato 帥 well, if having-from "Article 9 of the constitution" kana ?
Article 9 of the constitution is protected strictly.
Behind, this is inherited by the "perfect peace" thought of the cancer dam W (didn't it necessarily inherit?).
It is the work which a comment cannot carry out easily as a Yamato fan generally.
Incidentally he likes here better than "Yamato 2."
To those who are not looking, if there is "time, it will see, and is it at least !"?
2006/03/29 Very Bad [Original Japanese review]
by Marin (Send message) Review history / Provider: 30606 Host:30421 Browser: 3846
Random sociability reached the earth which is on the verge of a downfall every year.
well which will call friendship with De Dis Ra, or will be rubbed to collusion --
the enemy who is a war thing and is attractive can take out -- saying -- mere neta piece
2006/03/26 Very Good [Original Japanese review]
by amane (Send message) Review history / Provider: 45319 Host:45167 Browser: 3646
Setup, such as the simple the 2nd search for the earth and not an enemy but Mikuni mind-deployment, and newcomer crew who are doing kyara 腴, is wonderful.
and the contents were the poor things which have not employed this great setup efficiently at all.
Then, this evaluation wants to buy the volition which showed a glimpse of Yamato which sweet kana ?
does not have as a fan until now, either.
2005/10/23 Bad [Original Japanese review]
by 鴻9 (Send message) Review history / Provider: 2804 Host:2495 Browser: 5623
Depending on a view, it may be an unhappy work.
The work which has not held the current of the times, and change of a televiewer but hung on to the past glory.
To the wax which became somehow or other in the plan stage when carrying out market research calmly
Time as which re-broadcast and ganpura captured the spotlight and cinematization was announced at the end of the year although the audience rating of the cancer dam was dull and it became the close when calling it the second half of 1980.
Moreover, it is made 閩俄 of Director Tomino who inherits a cancer dam, and masterpiece ideon is the time which this and the audience rating were dull, closed, and was determined.
That is, it can be said that the flow of a world was completely after the cancer dam the difficult time which the close will overrun if still more inattentive but.
although there is a portion which shines to a setting side -- on the other hand -- as usual -- 紊援 -- there was a thing thing -- carrying out -- the first work, the climax, and Yamato 2 -- new -- it made that it was permanent, and it continued being made and we are already disgusted Above all, it is after the unexpected happening where the animation of degree number one of attention "the thing without the front" of climax-Yamato 2 bewilders all Japanese (there was necessarily nothing with a joke).
The world has completely already been in a "Yamato is 胼" state.
When it was before the cancer dam when it was before the climax and there was no climax or, possibly evaluation also changed more.
2005/10/23 Good [Original Japanese review]
by Sukekaku (Send message) Review history / Provider: 29253 Host:29265 Browser: 5234
Although it was the generation who has seen space warfare warship Yamato directly, the unexpected thought was carried out to the reputation of series being bad fairly to this site in the second half of; Yamato.
It accepts that there was an impossible setup sure second half especially by the last program of a series.
although it is a situation by the side of it and a producer -- every time -- illustrating -- the supervisor was different and the pattern has been greatly different -- a minus image -- it was (especially 3714 times) .
An original picture is 5101115202324 times.
There was a pitiable thing in this series that hits part V (as what "" did not have).
According to the setting document of this series, the story was set up by broadcast 51 times and many Sakamaki and Bando new crew were made to appear at the beginning.
By having taken care of Princess ruda, De Dis Ra became an enemy again and it was prepared at the beginning abundantly [ three-way fighting with both a garumangamirasu empire and a boraa federation, the talks that each newcomer crew is main, etc.
].
However, since broadcast has contracted to 25 times by the stage for which it pressed considerably, reunion (the 15th time) with De Dis Ra of the second half or the encounter (the 21.22nd time) or later with Princess ruda becomes a run story, and new crew have also had turn crushed.
Although surely there was also a problem when the conclusion was said previously, even if it deducts it, I think that Yamato was the masterpiece of the passing mark.
If there is no it, of course, I will think that it was still better.
It is [ the / big / two ] reasonable.
First, Yamato is having finished with supatt.
For the first time in [ by the neta piece and low-quality-izing of the recent years of an once masterpiece "Doraemon" and "the third rupan" which continues from the period to present / stray / degeneration and ] will be as your opinion having come out on each page.
Although "President De Dis Ra fights"'s planned after the Yamato last program of a series, seemingly it did not result in realization, and I think rather that it was good.
If at least one year is continued like "the third rupan" till present, doesn't it know what became?
Next, also about the contents, if compared with the last round, such as super squadron series for the past several years, I will think that it is far good.
Also in others, in the super squadron, laughter is indiscriminately put in in an earnest scene, or how to finish the last round has become poor as is also said in each column.
It is as incidentally the poor way of "the police box in front of the Kameari, Katsushika-ku here park" also being struck by borokuso to this site by such points.
Although it could say that surely he was contented overly with the Yamato popularity and an impossible setup was carried out including story deployment, if it says conversely, I will think that it can be said that Yamato was the masterpiece allowed even if it does the thing of only that.
However, only the thought of sharubaato does not get so that the lower one may also be said.
At least, although he wants to abandon "war, since it is actually impossible, if it is " which confined the star in different dimension space, it understands.
the Nishizaki producer -- interrogative " to "Gandhi-pacifism -- singing -- I have you -- an unexpected thought is also carried out
since only wish-pacifism does not have not being pleased and Yamato-likeness -- the evaluation to other series -- 1 rank lowering 障
2005/10/19 Very Bad [Original Japanese review]
by 634 (Send message) Review history / Provider: 13427 Host:13156 Browser: 5234
"-- the 3rd cartridge of television series after dropping a stock to " forever
As there were various criticism and dissatisfaction from that time, there is a memory which the answer to those televiewers was not able to say was good also for a compliment, either.
Although a setup that the earth will be ruined one more year after was not bad, unnecessary time was spent by reunion with De Dis Ra of the middle stage, and for the first time in [ of the second half / a run drama ] was unconvincing at starting point 絽.
if a setup of a sharu bird star cannot say that it is good, either but it can throw away "fighting -- space ｃ -- fighting -- being lost -- [!!
] -- the star which is contradictory in " -- it was .
There is a star of the symbol of the peace which omitted such baka also well while the Galle Mann gamirasu and the boraa federation had pushed themselves forward.
it is made to read also in the biography of the person who was a leader with great India of "earth -- being nonviolent for the peace of honto -- a --thing -- what [!!
] -- " -- after -- becoming -- having considered .
Ryusuke etc.
Domon who is the hero (they are not ancient times even if it makes a mistake!!) of 篏 had lost Hirata 1 which is the senior who respects by fighting with the Galle Mann gamirasu, and I considered this seriously [ half ] at 篁篏 by it having been better to ruin as Domon said to thinking that it was the scene which is uniquely moved to tears, since the last arrival ground of a trip was such a star.
I want to carry out voice to "To persuade, if it is mon which can be persuaded!!
the peace without arms is not ruined nonresistant!!" at size, and to say to the party of the sharu bird against a --fellow etc.
since the boraa federation was a gathering of the party whom - does not have more than a dark star cluster empire, either, Yamato was lost and conceit was folded also in De Dis Ra.
Since sharu bird faith etc.
is the instruction "for being ruined".
[ which is fundamentally / the peace citizen meeting of the street in a town etc.
/ different ]
|
Yamato3 op
