[Anime]Umineko no Naku Koro ni

Other media
Comics:Umineko no Naku Koro ni

If this is not the work which you are looking for, please use above search box or various list or DB's top page.

Reviews' statics

Anime total pnts rank=Avg. x Eval. num	Rank 3,062/in 3,115 titles (Total -48.02)	Rank 3,061 <= => Rank 3,063
Anime avg pnts rank(minimum:10 evals)	Rank 1,593/in 1,709 titles (Average -0.98(Bad))	Rank 1,592 <= => Rank 1,594
Anime total pnts rank of 2009	Rank 152/in 154 titles	Rank 151 <= => Rank 153

All
Reviews(Post)

Fan forum

Image&Wallpaper

Goods
(DVD)

OP/ED/PV

Goods from Japan

Latest DVD: 2010/03/25 ():

TVアニメーション「うみねこのなく頃に」コレクターズエディシ... \8,190

DVD Sales/Latest							Books Sales/Latest	Toys Sales/Latest	Music Sales/Latest
Rank:1230 TVアニメーション「うみねこのなく頃に」コレクターズエディシ... Tag:\6,930 2010/03/25 ()	Rank:1394 Blu-ray:TVアニメーション「うみねこのなく頃に」コレクターズエディシ... Tag:\8,190 2010/03/25 ()	Rank:1467 Blu-ray:TVアニメ「うみねこのなく頃に」コレクターズエディション Blu-r...Tag:\8,190 2010/04/21 ()	Rank:2185 TVアニメ「うみねこのなく頃に」コレクターズエディション〈初回...Tag:\6,930 2010/04/21 ()	Rank:2770 AV版 TVアニメ「うみねこのなく頃に」Note.06 DVD特装限定版「ゴ...Tag:\9,975 2010/03/25 ()	Rank:5726 うみねこのなく頃に特装限定版ゴールドエディション Note.01 [D... Tag:\9,975 2009/10/23 () Eval.:*****	Rank:6018 うみねこのなく頃に特装限定版ゴールドエディション Note.02 [D... Tag:\9,975 2009/11/26 ()	Rank:8744 単行本（ソフトカバー）:うみねこのなく頃に　Episode3（上） (講談社BOX) Tag:\1,365 2010/03/02 ()	Rank:11977 おもちゃ＆ホビー:うみねこのなく頃に真里亞の魔除けブレスレット Tag:\840 2009/08/29 () Eval.:*****	Rank:1293 CD:うみねこのなく頃に Tag:\1,500 2008/08/29 () Eval.:*****

Story

Umineko no Naku Koro ni takes place primarily in the year 1986, during the time frame of October 4 and October 5 on a small, secluded island named Rokkenjima 10 km around owned and lived on by Kinzo, the head of the wealthy Ushiromiya family. Kinzo is near death, and eight of his family members arrive on the island for the annual family conference, where the adults plan to discuss how Kinzo's assets will be divided once he is dead. Also on the island are three family members who live there, five of Kinzo's servants, and his personal physician. After the eight family members arrive, a typhoon traps them on the island, and shortly after, strange things start to happen and people start dying.

The main character of the story is Battler Ushiromiya, son of Kinzo's second son Rudolf. Battler has not been to the annual Ushiromiya conference in six years due to living with his maternal grandparents ever since his mother Asumu died, and even took his mother's maiden name instead of Ushiromiya. When his grandparents died, he went back to living with his father, his second wife Kyrie, and their daughter Ange, his half-sister. Once on the island, Battler once again becomes acquainted with the legend of the golden witch Beatrice who supposedly lives in the naturally dense forest on Rokkenjima. A portrait of her lies in the entrance hall of the Ushiromiya family mansion, and a puzzling epitaph is written below the portrait. Rumor has it on the island that Beatrice gave ten tons of gold to Kinzo in the past to restart the Ushiromiya family after being crippled in the 1923 Great Kanto earthquake. It is said that whoever solves the riddle of the witch's epitaph will receive the gold and be the next successor to the Ushiromiya family.

Once the typhoon hits, a ghastly game begins, starting with the murder of six people on the island. If the witch's epitaph cannot be solved, people will continue to die in mysterious deaths, following the outline given by the epitaph itself, until the witch Beatrice ultimately revives. After this comes to pass, Battler is the only one left alive who does not believe in witches or magic, and as such the door to the "golden land" (as stipulated on the epitaph) cannot be opened. Beatrice takes Battler and herself to a parallel dimension, Purgatorio, which is able to oversee events on Rokkenjima. From this point on, Battler and Beatrice are locked in a game of twisted logic where Battler must attempt to explain all of the mysterious events on Rokkenjima from the standpoint that they are caused by a human, and Beatrice attempts to explain everything with witches and magic. One of the recurring motifs is use of the locked room mystery, and several logical arguments are presented to explain the mysteries including the devil's proof, the raven paradox, and Schredinger's cat. If Beatrice can get Battler to ultimately surrender and accept witches and magic, Beatrice wins.
This story has the part which was created by referencing Wikipedia, so the licence of GFDL is applied to this story.

Information about this title

Ryukishi 07
Chiaki Kon
Toshihumi Kawase
Yoko Kikuchi
Studio Deen
Daisuke Ono Marina Inoue Suzumura Kenichi Yui Horie
Rie Kugimiya Yu Kobayasi Sayaka Oohara
Mugihito Jurota Kosugi Emi Shinohara Miki Ito
Masashi Hirose Rikiya Koyama Atsuko Tanaka Ami Koshimizu
Masato Funaki Hitoshi Bifu Yasuko Hatori Akihiko Ishizumi

Japan Released:2009/07/02(Thu) 01:30- Chiba Television TV

Official sites
1. http://umineko.tv/web/ (Translation)

Opening movie (1)

Katayoku no Tori [Fan reg.]

Ending movie (1)

la divina tragedia - Makyoku - [Fan reg.]

Promotion video (2)

Statics of evaluation(The statics is updated once a day)

	Average	AnimeRank	Deviation(Total)	Evaluation points(Total)	Best of the Best
Inside Japan	Bad(-0.98)	3,062	40.35	-48.02
Outside Japan	Very good(2.00)	395	46.46	2.00

Statics of activity

	Total Views	Comment	Evaluation
Inside Japan	29,489	61	49
Outside Japan	982	1	1

How others evaluated in Japan

Best

Very Good

Good

Normal

Bad

Very Bad

Worst

People

Percentage

4.1%

14.3%

10.2%

8.2%

14.3%

12.2%

36.7%

Added percentage

4.1%

18.4%

28.6%

36.8%

51.1%

63.3%

100%

Summary

28.6%

8.2%

63.2%

Views for recent 8 days
Total 18 17 16 15 14 13 12 11
13 2 2 0 3 2 2 1 1

Forum for the special topic (Create topic)

Sorted by:Newness / Oldness
All including comments
Only Evaluation Good
Evaluation:Best/Very Good/Good Normal
Evaluation Bad
Evaluation:Bad/Very Bad/Worst
This reputation board

2009/09/21 Very good [Edit/Delete/Suggest to delete/Only this reviewer/Show only this review or post sympathy comment/(Everyone can)]
by L(&"_"&) (Send message) Review history[Good:31(84%) Normal:2(5%) Bad:4(11%)] / Provider: 22411 Host:22644 Browser: 3414
[What is good]
Unusuality of the story.

[What is bad]
I cannot understand why Batora doesn't believe the existence of the magic in front of the witch.

[Summary]
This is not the work which can be shown to the children but I feel the story is interesting.

The below reviews are translated automatically from Japanese ones. To post your review to English version, please click here.

2010/02/26 Good [Original Japanese review]
by ^-^v (Send message) Provider: 19583 Host:19608 Browser: 6009

[Comprehensive evaluation]
Future hardly touched about the essential portions in a witch, magic, veato main [ the introduction about the rough view of the world and the main man side character ], and important, 戦 people, or the witch side world, Since it thinks that it is the work which should carry out comprehensive evaluation to understanding them by having a veato viewpoint by the thinking to which 戦 people return a chessboard, and a story developing at last as the whole anticipation (として [ a number of years pass and a sequel comes out ]), expectation is put, and it is this evaluation.

2010/02/24 Worst [Original Japanese review]
by Muuma (Send message) Provider: 6545 Host:6515 Browser: 14667

[Good point]
OP.
It is perfectly.
The members of a gorgeous voice actor.

[Bad point]
Story at large There is no climax compared with ひぐらし.
Only always the name with which too many characters are and which they cannot learn a name easily, either.

[Comprehensive evaluation]
Although expected very well at first, a story has not already been well clear anymore.
Or [ that it is what for a while past / cramming ] ...
It is made "worst" evaluation.

2010/02/14 Very bad [Original Japanese review]
by こち葉 (Send message) Provider: 52165 Host:52323 Browser: 10222
It is the evaluation after playing an original to the middle after animation viewing and listening.

[Good point]
The point that the same singer as the thing original game whose -OP music was wonderful is employed deserves evaluation.
- It is arranged with balance sufficient [ a veteran ] from the gorgeous member youngman of a voice actor.

[Bad point]
I think that the tastes of this animation divide clearly at the time of - grotesque depiction まずこ.
it is said that it is killed if the diagnosis homicide which happens first is repeatedly revived in order to fill a witch's pleasure, although it is not new as a mystery work -- a feeling of dislike was memorized for going down Although it is not the degree called protection, I think that the impressions of the side thought that describing in written form and a picture describe also differ very much.
- hear also from the practical joke of a work about the feeling of dislike to a face performance pus cat -- る Actually, also in an original, although the character has committed homicide, laughing vulgarly, it has the maker of animation itself, and the paragraph which it becomes, and is aimed at and manufactured.
The expression of a girl called 真里亞 is typical.
Although it turns out that a picture is compared, it is witch mode (?).
As for 真里亞, the situations of ups and downs differ considerably by the original and animation.
Since the animation staff has bad timing to after an excessive issue but as reappearance of the impact of a previous work is aimed at, he cannot say that he has succeeded not much.
The badness of timing could say the same thing also about quotation of Original BGM.
(I regard [ that the original is just going to be excellent most and ] the production of initial episode as individual) - A story stage setup is that Christie's " and nobody stopped being", "the twisted house", and the result that added Chesterton's description trick to this.
In other words, it is "てんこ is [ the royal road of a mystery ] also り." Although diplomacy of a witch and a hero rose as an original element here, this was not so interesting individually.
In inverse proportion to the difficulty of a rule, inference of a hero is too childish first.
Only by viewing and listening at once, since it will not be a brains group if the hero of this work says which it is, although it becomes the character in which a backer with sufficient nature and the sufficient head is needed, and it is a witch or appears in the second half, since the talk swells rapidly each time, it does not know what was solved.
Moreover, the beauty girl character which appeared one after another as a top of the method of an enemy also could not but be the obstacle of a tale.
This animation has been considered to be the bad comedy which leaves from the second half.
- a character -- also at a どんな hachamecha view of the world, even a character is enjoyed, if attractive However, as point 述 was carried out, since the character of this animation increases with deployment of the talk, it is ひぐ made overall and the impression of a degree character is not deep [ animation ].
But although the witch of a hero and an enemy and heroine was able to focus, these two persons have already been unreasonable!
(It does not すいま) especially -- a hero -- it was -- the direction of the homicide more peaceful than cruel homicide which plays with an enemy (it is also followed and runs a race) makes a good 的な remark to have declared confrontation, in order to prove "a relative is "negative [ of a witch ]" and innocent" (it is considerably impossible at this time) at the beginning -- it was in the stray state from beginning to end A character's not being consistent for every episode is just subtracted, if unexpected nature is aimed at and a story will collapse.

[Comprehensive evaluation]
The animation and it which do not consider at all but are seen with vigor were also quite painful.
Although I hear that the original is not yet completed, I think that only an end will be checked, when manufactured temporarily at 2 terms.
Evaluation is bad [ worst slippage / "very bad" ].

2010/02/14 Worst [Original Japanese review]
by mae_narae (Send message) Provider: 3954 Host:3715 Browser: 8880
He dislikes the cruelty which continues killing people intently, and the proud attitude of Beatrice.
magic -- it is -- a mystery -- it is -- it seemed to be good anyhow and there were no �i�れる's after all Since it was killed, as it only increased, it is not felt, but characters were to the limit [ やたら ], and いなくって and an unpleasant and cruel scene are merely merely repeated also for the character which can carry out empathy.
Since charm is not felt for a character even if it has said that a feeling of tension is not born to a battle, but it is noble-minded since it thinks that it is practically equal with it being another and sees even if which wins, it will be felt shallow.
Evaluation is the worst.

2010/02/10 Bad [Original Japanese review]
by Koruchio (Send message) Provider: 27275 Host:27615 Browser: 7351

[Good point]
- music.
- As it is, a picture is beautiful.

[Bad point]
It is hard to understand - story.
I want to say that it is which about whether it is an inference thing and whether it is a magic thing.
- Production which a meaning does not understand.
- Be grotesquely and it is 。.
- Mosaic regulation which enters occasionally.
I want to say that the scene which cannot carry out and carry out なきゃ broadcast to there is drawn why.

[Comprehensive evaluation]
It is "bad" although it is severer.

2010/02/01 Worst [Original Japanese review]
by Revi (Send message) Provider: 32099 Host:31952 Browser: 3428(Mobile)
Mr.
Shikata's song and performance of the voice actor of an adult group were wonderful.
The trash which does not have anything but it.
If allowed to say the individual opinion of a 1 original fan - Why was it used for the scene which does not suit halfway, having used original music?
When becoming, all preferable thing music should have been made newly.
this -- all pus cat sound stores -- it is caught only with the insult which receives like - The affair of the deficit and 青字 of the last round.
Just by there being that exchange, the scene of the last beato is useful.
It was "my being だぁれ".
[ which does not so much remain in an impression for the reason ] (It was even EP2 to have thought that Mr.
Ohara's beato was good again.) It builds how to speak too much and is too pertinacious.
beato after 2 terms will not be turned to completely (if it is) - alteration of incomprehensible words especially -- the 戦 people in the room of 朱志香 of EP2 -- "criminal is Beatrice -- the meaning of ろ" was not understood - Production is past [ the lower part ].
Even if it removed the original flatly and completely saw as another entertainment work, he was not able to be enjoyed at all.
It cannot rise and cry.
this -- 金取っちゃ -- it is useless - the last talk of each EP -- stuff why Probably, how to do suited elsewhere.
Some changes at a tea party and a reverse side tea meeting are not necessarily, either, and it is unclear.
- Multiple use of the face performance of 真里亞.
It is not necessary to recommend like that.
- It is iraira to じまんぐ ED which cannot read air the second half although the inside of the beginning was good.
in addition, everything -- if it mentions, there will be no end Don't make Kawase and Gota now concerned with animation pus cat manufacture.
I cannot but think that what is referred to as being able to draw through and take down an original so far does not have the love to a work very much.
Moreover, this way of finishing was what cannot perform expectation to 2 terms at all.
When the work the "pus cat" which we love, infers and is enjoyed thinks that it will be perverted by animation and it will reach the direction of original un-playing, it is mortifying to be very sad [ the work ] and provoking.
Therefore, evaluation presupposed that it is the worst.

2010/01/28 Worst [Original Japanese review]
by w-tan (Send message) Provider: 8385 Host:8569 Browser: 10678

[Good point]
How to use BGM
[Bad point]
There is too much talk of a repetition repetition required as animation that all are almost insufficient and that a right course does not progress anyhow.
An element to tell is not known at all.
Probably, it was able to finish, when there was also 24 during the conversation 4 talk.
Grotesque animation free rather than being [ nothing ] suspense in the scene which only cruelty is conspicuous and becomes indeed using the head.
It was time fully useless [ two periods of treatment of degradation ], so that it depended on the impact by grotesque depiction too much and ひぐらし did not become a comparison as a tale.

[Comprehensive evaluation]
It was the worst.

2010/01/22 Bad [Original Japanese review]
by Eddie_the_Head (Send message) Provider: 14263 Host:14260 Browser: 3419

[Good point]
The members of - voice actor are gorgeous.

[Bad point]
There are too many - characters and they cannot grasp.
- There are many cruel scenes.
- A setup and a story are incomprehensible and cannot understand.

[Comprehensive evaluation]
Although EP1 was able to be enjoyed comparatively, after it, what was not found in the least somehow, but viewing and listening has been stopped on the way.
I think that the honesty of the result of animation is bad.

2010/01/11 Good [Original Japanese review]
by Kikkoro (Send message) Provider: 5107 Host:5227 Browser: 9670
The original is not doing.
Although seen from the beginning to the last, he completely has a story and it cannot be understood.
Although it cannot say not at all since the talk itself is not known well, unlike the inference thing of a normal, for looking for the secret passage of language (declared in red), a "mystery" is important thing kana.
The impression to say was received.
I was enjoying the face performance of the super-deployment itself and characters who cannot be understood as a kind of gag.
Although it thinks that it is not the work which adopts such [ originally ] how to enjoy itself, I hear that it was able to enjoy itself and see to the last, and it is this evaluation.
Finally, probably because original music did not have the necessity of considering so that it may not interfere with words, there is much good music which remains in an impression.

2010/01/10 Comment(good) [Original Japanese review]
by ya-ji (Send message) Provider: 2959 Host:2795 Browser: 10251

[Good point]
The completeness of OP is high.
A story is interesting.

[bad point]
急い -- coming out is obvious, it is known and there are ず cousins
[Comprehensive evaluation]
Although there was also an unclear place, he was able to be enjoyed enough.
Above all, stories are not other animation and were made to pleasure each time.
It is the most interesting by the animation seen individually recently.
Since it thinks that it is a sufficiently good work even if it includes it, although the bad point also wrote, it is the highest.
散 is also pleasure.
I think that an original will also be carried out.

2010/01/06 Bad [Original Japanese review]
by ZaCKTs (Send message) Provider: 16457 Host:16341 Browser: 7655
An original is un-playing.
It is the grade which used [ a little ] for there to be saying like this as the ear.

[Good point]
Character
[Bad point]
Story
[Comprehensive evaluation]
It has finished, while it has not transmitted and known from the beginning to the last what want to carry out.
Since it was simply differentiated with the work of cruel scene ON れた others, was the touch which is likely to be solved 8 received?
Since the depression deployment which sinks beyond that necessity was sale of this series, it was able to put into practice there.
Being [ it / the animation which it has like a previous work by sapuraizu of a certain kind of being in a miserable eye with a character uncanny by using every possible means, or doing a cruel thing ] kana.
But was it only it?
It gave only the impression which considered how any cruel scenes would be put in.
I think that they are these animation saw nonsense, without probably having great knowledge.
He was so.
not understanding even now -- だらけ The talk does not understand [ with which it was finished as the chunk ] suddenly that whether comes out will make it go away, but some following talks come out.
-- Repetition.
Individually, the grotesque potato was weak, and this was not pleasantly reflected, however the character might look nice on such a scene.
Was it the way of making which extracted the target clearly?
if it enjoys itself and excels -- an original and れ -- or see after studying so that he can be enjoyed -- is it --?
Although he wanted to see a work happily pleasantly, this work was the touch whose hurdle for it was too expensive.
But when it was view-of-the-world most serious consideration, there must have been けど打つ手 which will become like this.
To a fan, it is convinced (?).
でも -- delicate as for [ of a certain kind / public ] saying [ TV animation ] since -- evaluation -- this

2010/01/04 Bad [Original Japanese review]
by Orutafuoosu (Send message) Provider: 53824 Host:53807 Browser: 5941
The completion of the first term viewing and listening of animation.
OP is the category of a masterpiece also in anison for the past several years.
Most members of a voice actor are hama っていた.
illustrating -- し there was also no collapse However, it is a problem to pack even EP4 into two periods of treatment at a stretch as everybody says.
a and the witch who were "ざ, ~ ん念 by favor do in a reformation etc., and become precocious, in addition to 端折られ and it, the tempo of production also has ~ ん *", important, late words, etc.
one after another, and the tension of a tale does not have a climax, either.
Probably, the original was hot...
Power is put into the peculiarity and a ghastly scene.
blood -- astringent -- flying -- an everyday occurrence it is in the case of animation-izing -- most -- alike -- hubs -- れる -- と -- "the party of delicious food" (are of 11 talks) currently considered Always being clearly displayed, although it is an especially vulgar scene also in a pus cat "真里亞 is eaten and it is ♪." it is converted into a video signal with [ which is very said ] an addition, and is what -- this staff -- と -- I considered The character which increases from the next to the next although it is at least five or more main characters.
Only for the fantasy world, it is also.
already -- a reality side and a fantasy side -- it is -- it [ it ] 1 animation -- it can make -- well [ ちゃ ] -- the kana which is not じゃ Since an original is member software for this work's being criticized severely, only core fans stick.
Therefore, evaluation tends to become severe.
Having been animation-ized this time is a problem setting-section to the last.
If even reply section is animation-ized ...
Possibly evaluation changed.

2010/01/03 Bad [Original Japanese review]
by RF (Send message) Provider: 4811 Host:4531 Browser: 14119
Original un-playing.
although the composition of having dramatized by magic is still good, the talk progresses -- と -- the composition which is alike and is divided into two or more worlds -- honesty -- it was incomprehensible It is slightly regrettable although it expected because ひぐらし was interesting.

2009/12/30 Very good [Original Japanese review]
by 梨奈 (Send message) Provider: 19304 Host:19247 Browser: 4357
The place where the portrait changes thinks that it is good with the music of OP.
It is troubled a little that there are too many characters.
A name and memorizing are serious.
About me, the talk is somewhat said from しっている by comics etc., however those who are not so think that they can seldom follow the talk.
But I think gradually that the talk is interesting.
In the character, 縁寿 which came out of EP4 thought that it was good.
Putting the expectation for 散 edited by the answer, evaluation is "very better than "it is good"."

2009/12/30 Worst [Original Japanese review]
by Matsu (Send message) Provider: 4300 Host:4376 Browser: 7875

[Good point]
OP which changes for every - voice actor and EP
[a bad point]
- the cut of important depiction, explanation shortage and production, and useless useless face performance and cruel depiction are visible only to gag because of a mosaic
[comprehensive evaluation]
-- it is original 自体ま -- for the mystery to which it does not reply remaining, animation-izing is too early clearly -- a seed It was impossible to give from EP1 to EP4 by two periods of treatment.
After finishing seeing animation altogether from one talk to the last round, does the staff play the original truly?
I considered.
Can an original fan show the original degradation version and infer [ clear depiction explanation is insufficient and / what ] understand an animation group in a thing?
It does not know for what purpose it animation-ized.

2009/12/28 Normal [Original Japanese review]
by Mr.Burns (Send message) Provider: 8899 Host:8809 Browser: 7347

[Good point]
The character, especially the female character may be pressing down the jar.
It is and wonderful in a thing with such sufficient glue, although it is a lady in summer princess etc.
A voice actor or performance of the insanity-scene which becomes and is gorgeous and always comes out with a work had shone.
おっぱ ...
illustrating -- although there was no device called this -- good -- you may shake -- moving .
A face is also stable.

[Bad point]
It stuffs too much a story and variously [ view-of-the-world ], and what is not clear anymore somehow.
Prediction in a meaning with ton demonstration deployment bad in 紗音's taking out a barrier suddenly or a strange goat coming out is impossible.
since it cannot distinguish [ back illusion and / actual ] at all, who really considers what -- it does not understand well The cruel depiction of passing by the ground wave which a great thing does not have may also completely be a problem just for a moment.
謎解き -- mind that this makes a televiewer infer truth -- smoothly -- it will not be .
Solve, if it is もん to solve!
even if it says, what is a mystery primarily -- since it does not understand a thing, there is also no method of comrades Suddenly delay たり of の which is how [ 卑下 / to the beato point ] to laugh, and was abusing the partner, and what is aimed at?

[comprehensive evaluation]
-- the cause [ that there are many characters ], ひぐ et al.
-- carrying out -- の -- it seldom delves into the psychology of each character like Is a mistake made in whether first of all, how's making this game animation etc.
being primary ...?
those who are not making it not understand even if it is too thick, there is unreasonableness in conversion to signals too much and it is playing the game -- more -- being incomprehensible -- it is not -- or However, it is [ which the quality of animation itself regards as having not made a mistake with it being very good ] comment that a cliff is carried out and it cannot be called a success, either.

2009/12/28 Worst [Original Japanese review]
by アリス☆メイド (Send message) Provider: 26677 Host:26935 Browser: 8879

[Good point]
Music
[Bad point]
Story
[Comprehensive evaluation]
The original was also done.
Even EP5 played.
I want a hand for a maker to apply once again why severe criticism sticks so far to a breast, and to think.
ひぐ et al.
of a previous work -- carrying out -- it was a really interesting work It was shocking.
Therefore, there is no げせ without せ to do.
regrettable -- very .
It is truly disappointed.
The evaluation here is seen, and rarely, although there is writing said that the original was good etc., there is no it.
Directivity did not become settled but the original has also strayed.
The bad point is got.
If a fantasy is taken in, it writes clearly by EP1.
A light is applied to criminal consideration from the locked-up room.
Since it has mannerism-ized, just before total destruction or total destruction is avoided each time.
The feelings of a character are emasculated.
A fantasy route must not make a witch appear, either.
It focuss on a byroad in the red too much, and the essence of a tale is disregarded.
Magic depiction in order to substitute magic for illusion, to the extent that it is impossible.
Mystery negative is too strong.
The talk becomes large too much and inconsistency and an open seam are conspicuous too much.
The low level of the thinking capability of Butler is raising irritation of a reader.
There is no consideration referred to as that it will come to say that a reader will be subjected and it will entertain 1.
Although there is much grotesque や涙 depiction, there is no impression nature.
It does not suppose that a mystery will be solved but there is too much suspension.
If unsolvable, there will be no 討論い and others.
Although there will be as [ no ] if it raises, decide directivity for the time being.
Well sad kana.
I feel that the limit of a writer was seen.

2009/12/27 Worst [Original Japanese review]
by おかわり君 (Send message) Provider: 30644 Host:30481 Browser: 4467
Original non-読.
before starting -- ひぐ et al.
-- carrying out -- since he was enjoyed, although it expected considerably -- OP is music and a picture (the hit out of which my - comes in kakkoii けど and futomomo simply is delicate -- individually.).
Since [ both ] it is also the symbol of the portion which gakkari(ed), it is good.
As it is, next time worried episode 1, and harahara also carried out it.
However, it was the result to the extent that an eye is not covered after episode 2.
the important scene is considerably excluded from the original -- although that is right -- it -- ひぐ et al.
-- also carrying out -- the same It seems that this work has too many characters too, and influence with little feelings depiction has sounded Moro.
The name of a character is a lack [ the sense of a level which starts rejection ].
By the common name, since there is a possibility that the man of a same name may become unpleasant like the Ito sincerity, although it may be consideration (or meaning that it is the so heterogeneous and unusual world) for not becoming so, since advance of the talk is early as a result, empathy is difficult.
Even if a murder case occurs in such the state, it does not become sad and anger does not spring, either.
the murder scene which a translation does not understand -- the charm of a view of the world or a character -- 惹き -- the price -- although it was るべき, it pulled only by there being displeasure intently -- honest As an enemy who should push down, it is deficient in charm only by being visible to けど which the aim which advertizes a vulgar portion by the childishness of Beatrice would also have, and accessories.
It was also disappointment that Beatrice appears frankly individually.
Although the eeriness of a portrait was able to be emphasized by OP or this editing, し [ the veil of a mystery is bared simply and it is those accessories ] -- ぜ to which Butler will also begin the game of "さあ次 unawares although it was angry about beato which calls homicide a game!
" -- し it omits and shines furthermore -- if its footing is regained even if a scene which is summarizing inference in the head is also insufficient and has fallen -- berabera -- since it talks in high spirits, it is visible only to idea inference show Although there was a gap called the cruel scene performed from near it contrary to romantic deployment like the day zunii animation that magic exists also pleasantly when believing, and there was love.
Although it turns out that it does not solve, it is nothing less than the "worst" also including even so the last round having closed the curtain by " 暴論 ".
Even though there was solution section, was it with 1 term?
I will consider.
At the last Did the members of a voice actor do their best?
It is killed repeatedly and is death sorrow sadness of a relative -- Although it thought "it will perform the state where memory was reset repeatedly and be serious" in everyday life since there were many loop things recently, since it has seldom concentrated on this editing, this work was worried too many.

2009/12/27 Normal [Original Japanese review]
by UY.KE (Send message) Provider: 25270 Host:25209 Browser: 9831
Explanation is as insufficient as it turns out that collecting by two periods of treatment was impossible even if it is original non-played itself.
Although it was very expectable at the time of episode 1, it is regrettable for a conclusion not to take lessons from a tale finally, but to have become the touch formed into the incorrect evil spirit.
When making since the original was completed exactly although it thought that it had a level which can be somehow enjoyed with the charm of a character, possibly it had become the work of the different evaluation.

2009/12/27 Very good [Original Japanese review]
by raruku (Send message) Provider: 2386 Host:2396 Browser: 9641

[a good point]
- the deployment which the 1 talk point which happens one after another cannot predict [ illegal ] -- many .
- Structure as the multilayer nature which previous work ひぐ deer and also the polish required, and a meta-fiction.
Freshness of doing in Conan and detective monochrome like Kindaichi, if it glances at it.
- Talk of reversing the proof of the evil spirit which has not been seen until now.
- a regular member -- not only the younger age group but young-and-old-of-both-sexes 取り入れた -- it is the directions of various age - the heroine to Butler is one beato person -- saying -- it is -- the hit which is not a harem vainly is まぁま -- although it does not understand
[Bad point]
There are too many people to whom a face does not occur only by - name being said..
Kana which wanted production on which a face comes out only for a moment whenever it takes out a name.
If it does not have a person correlation diagram in mind, it is [ whether it is puzzling and ].
- Although it turns out that it is a required talk, the volume on 縁寿 was not good.

[comprehensive evaluation]
-- a dragon -- the usual deployment is made to regard as an orthodox sasupe thing and bizarre monochrome the knight's start, and come to be alike of deployment also by boss boss とん is interesting too yet -- the talk -- how -- since it is peevish without also attaching なっていく or anticipation, and it is the world [ be / true anything / structurally / it ] finishing [ himself who merely entered ひぐらし from Drama CD before / this / an original play ] as the animation version was criticized severely -- it is -- if -- this will also regard as the super digest version which does not change a front and be infallible - まぁ -- this was also said last time -- as -- 2 -- since it thinks that it is cool and is not the made talk, I think that it is guiltless in a supervisor or composition If the full voice perfect version of the consumer who comes out for after what year being comes out, although it will think that he buys it absolutely, isn't there any being [ they / bear before it, he tries to want to also ひぐ carry out a cat, and / three dramas CD, a five sheet release, or aho ] 8 てくれ?

Post your evaluation or comment.(Evaluation can be posted only once)

You need
1 other people's posts to post your evaluation or
30 other people's posts to post your comment
after you post your evaluation or comment.
Other media
Comics:Umineko no Naku Koro ni

Your Name(Required):

Password (Required. more than 4 characters) [If you want to create secure password: Online mkpasswd service]

Your comment about this anime(Required)

Your evaluation of this title(Required)
You can choose the evaluation only once. After you post your evaluation, please choose comment instead of evaluation from the options.

Evaluation of this title(You can choose this only once)
Your evaluation
If you evaluated this title once, please choose comment instead of the evaluation. Or you can use forum.
Comment by the person who thinks this is good
Comment by the person who thinks this is normal
Comment by the person who thinks this is bad

Please choose appropriate option for readers.

Pleaase confirm that your post is satisfing the following rules

Rule for reviews

This site allows you to write reviews for each title, but we don't allow you to criticize others' comment. Too bad or meaningless words are also not allowed. The comment which doesn't follow the rule will be deleted and access will be denied.

Caution: Please post the evaluation which follows the rule.

DB Top > Works > Anime > Umineko no Naku Koro ni:Review/Information[Anime]