Japanese works database(How to join/Help)
Top page: All/Only Reviews

Others
Site map

AllAnimeGameComicNovelDramaSp. effectJP movieMovie	Info:voice,machine..	Reviewer sorted by	Diary
Search / Outside DB:

Novel ranking in Japan: Rank 78/in 2,329 titles (Total 22.99/Deviation 60.97) Rank 77 <= => Rank 79
Novel average points ranking in Japan: Rank 21/in 130 titles (Average 2.09(Very good)/Deviation 59.54) Rank 20 <= => Rank 22 (more than 10 evaluatoin were posted)

Leader Behind The Scenes Ieyasu Tokugawa(Novel)

[Other version: RSS/Japanese version]

Other media
Comics:Kage Musha Tokugawa Ieyasu / Drama:KAGEMUSHA TOKUGAWA IEYASU

All
Reviews(Post)

Forum

Images

Information about this title

Shinchosha Keiichiro Ryu

Official sites
1. http://www.ikedakai.com/ (Translation)
2. http://www.mm-labo.com/culture/literature/review/kagemusya.html (Translation)
3. http://www2u.biglobe.ne.jp/~BIJIN-8/fsyohyo/kagetoku.html (Translation)

Statics of evaluation(The statics is updated once a day)

	Average	NovelRank	Deviation(Total)	Evaluation points(Total)	Best of the Best
Inside Japan	Very good(2.09)	78	60.97	22.99
Outside Japan	Good(1.00)	6	38.45	1.00

Statics of activity

	Total Views	Comment	Evaluation
Inside Japan	6,309	14	11
Outside Japan	872	1	1

How others evaluated in Japan

Best

Very Good

Good

Normal

Bad

Very Bad

Worst

People

Percentage

27.3%

54.5%

18.2%

0.0%

Added percentage

27.3%

81.8%

100%

Summary

100%

Views for recent 8 days
Total 5 4 3 2 1 30 29 28
2 0 0 0 0 1 0 1 0

Language Sorted by date Sorted by recommendation New!
English Good
(Only Evaluation) Normal
(Only Evaluation) Bad
(Only Evaluation) All
(Only Evaluation) None
Japanese Good
(Only Evaluation) Normal
(Only Evaluation) Bad
(Only Evaluation) All
(Only Evaluation) All
This reputation board

Language	Sorted by date	Sorted by recommendation New!
English	Good (Only Evaluation)	Normal (Only Evaluation)	Bad (Only Evaluation)	All (Only Evaluation)	None
Japanese	Good (Only Evaluation)	Normal (Only Evaluation)	Bad (Only Evaluation)	All (Only Evaluation)	All

2005/06/15 Good [Edit/Delete//Only this reviewer/Only this review/post sympathy comment/]
by TAKARAYA Review history[Good:78(58%) Normal:57(42%) Bad:0(0%)] / Provider: 25767 Host:25801 Browser: 3646
This is a historical fiction of Japan.
In this novel, by the fight of Sekigahara, Ieyasu Tokugawa is assassinated by the ninja of a very able enemy.
The hypothesis that Ieyasu Tokugawa was assassinated by the fight of Sekigahara is interesting.
I think that the original writer of this novel has mind-boggling ideas.
However, a very able ninja who was able to assassinate Ieyasu Tokugawa in the middle of the battle seems not to have actually existed.
Furthermore, it is being written that Ieyasu Tokugawa's third son is a crafty successor.
However, I do not think that Ieyasu Tokugawa's third son was crafty successor.
If anything, Ieyasu Tokugawa's third son was a second-rate person.
I like this novel though this historical fiction is only a slick fiction.

Post your review / Top page

Other media
Comics:Kage Musha Tokugawa Ieyasu / Drama:KAGEMUSHA TOKUGAWA IEYASU

The below reviews are translated automatically from Japanese ones. To post to English version, please click here.

2006/11/12 Good [Original Japanese review]
by Shuワrutsueneggaa Provider: 5782 Host:5880 Browser: 4184
I looked at the comics first.
Although it read when [ small ] writing being [ it / a schoolchild ]-still kana ?, he remembers having read interpreting for oneself, although it is called difficult contents and cooked, since he liked history from the first.
It is the reason regarded as three novels also being purchased in passing and the printing type version being called whole set そろった comics version about two years ago by ん.
Comment are って which "is a frightful secret strife", and こ.
Jiro 3 郎 penetrates entirely many plots which Hidetada lets out, and it trifles with Hidetada with the plan which goes a it top.
It is whether although it will be the まんま if there is no showy depiction like a battle, even Sekigahara of the opening part is finished in the twinkling of an eye and it says that that is unsatisfactory, while reading and advancing, as for Sekigahara, is the ceremony of the mere Ieyasu shift, and is main.
Was the plot game which starts after this the heart?
Even so, it is existence of Rokuro of worth that it was conspicuous.
Since the sequel of comics was such touch, surely, Sakon Shima thought that became 軍師 of Jiro 3 郎 and he played an active part, and he was surprised at きや, and Rokuro's hard fighting and 知略.
The leading role is like [ which was regarded as whether you are Rokuro ].
Or are you the leading role?

2006/06/03 Comment(good) [Original Japanese review]
by 宇宙刑事ジャンギャバン Provider: 33223 Host:33285 Browser: 6287
The scene of farewell from Jiro 3 郎 and Masanobu Honda is also a little painful.
although Jiro 3 郎 felt friendship for Masanobu -- to the last -- Masanobu -- the Tokugawa family -- since it is safe -- Jiro 3 郎 -- using -- I have you -- it was .
Although Jiro 3 郎 probably also understood the thing by reason, was it the touch which expected Masanobu 情 by somewhere too?
However, the production of a country of the ideal in which the people of bleaching can live in comfort finishes with a dream after all...
Since history is not changed, it is sad.
Even if it reads over how many times.

2006/05/18 Very good [Original Japanese review]
by 634 Provider: 20475 Host:20568 Browser: 5234
Ieyasu -- if his contribution and the influence which it had on history are taken into consideration, the non-deer for which the bold arrangement of 本作 also stops will not be found, either Even if once compared with Nobunaga and Hideyoshi who are other 英傑, Ieyasu will be unpopular and it will be because a bad man catches sight of Ieyasu who ruined Toyotomi and has also squeezed out the power of Ota if it sees considering the Japanese of sympathy for the weak.
本作 is the work which caught a person image called such Ieyasu from the unusual viewpoint.
generally Hidetada who were more affable than Ieyasu and is said for flexibility to have been effective (Iemitsu, the son fascinated with Ieyasu, abandoned this Hidetada's gentleness, and the orderly system, and it 創って(ed) and waited for the cause by which the Shimabara riot by Christian suppression happens to bolting by the daimyo, and pressure of government finances.) It can say, if it says that it is making a bold interpretation and a bold arrangement effective also in [ of drawing in little offense party ] that it excelled in intrigue 術作 of a coward contrastive with it.
I can think that it did not become by finding whether it can be said that it was better than that of "Keiji of a flower" who put in power absurdly, or meeting when there was no degree of research in the point which removes the viewpoint of being sweet to relatives with this work, does it to them although Ieyasu is a coldhearted man, and makes it the form near an authentic history by an interpretation and design of a 本作 no one but.
So much, 本作 may say that research was done at the viewpoint to a history person.
by such thing, supposing the person of Ieyasu did or, possibly he had received assistance from a person like Jiro 3 郎 continuously -- carrying out -- "the Mikuni mind" -- many -- a kudzu -- the image of having always put Jiro 3 郎 as a person like Kung-Ming on the hand also becomes strong Compared with Nobunaga, Ieyasu an idea and creativity were scarce and were [ Ieyasu ] a person like Hideyoshi who is not dexterous, either The good portions of Nobunaga and Hideyoshi are incorporated and there is a point of having made that Akechimitsuhide into the model although there was also an image called the person who made it the bad role model for young people.
Activity of Jiro 3 郎 of 本作, In respect of a subsequent political posture, Akechimitsuhide may have taught in many cases, and a portion called the real thrill of the neighborhood had told vassals "Make it reference", and も歴史 which sees like this and is interpreted may be reminded, therefore 本作 is made impressive.
In respect of calling it the historical possibility, 本作 will be made to be considered and it not only idealizes the person of Ieyasu, but it could say that it contributed to expanding historical 面白味 and the historical imaginative power to the truth, and interpretative width.
Although " is also made history and " is 禁句, " is also carried out, " is attached, and the fact also thrusts [ we / who are the human beings in future generations always ] a proposition as a thing, and it is how seeing in the condition of such works enjoys 本作.

2006/04/04 Best! [Original Japanese review]
by Boraare viia Provider: 31984 Host:31987 Browser: 4317
a leader behind the scenes is ぶっとん [ say / that Ieyasu Tokugawa was dead suddenly in Sekigahara ] -- wits were extracted by the scale Although there were the Yoshiwara diploma and contents of having moved the person who hid and has died also from さ and the life-of-ill-fame line on the historical fact, the touch different again carried out what or it.
Although it is alive with this work to having drawn Yoshiwara and living human being although it hid and had died from さ, I feel that the dead person was drawn.
Compared with Yoshiwara and other works, hardly, although there was no depiction of a sword fight, it came using the head that much, but the るい secret strife was thrilling.

2005/09/01 Comment(good) [Original Japanese review]
by 神賢一 Provider: 7706 Host:7387 Browser: 5234
& gt; Mr.
space detective Jean Gabin -- > A leader's behind the scenes real name is Jiro Serada 3 郎.
The Shiro Chaya following 郎 is the merchant who served Ieyasu.
あぁ and the shameful mistake were made completely.
.
.
orz and a mistake fatal one more point.
Does not "1 Account of 夢庵 elegant" but the "Yoshiwara diploma" share the view of the world?
.
.
Shameful mistakes were fired.
It had not read for a long time.
Reflection.
# A former sentence does not dare correct.
It bears.

2005/08/15 Very good [Original Japanese review]
by Yam. Provider: 31239 Host:31238 Browser: 6305
It was a pleasant talk.
Although the Ieyasu leader-behind-the-scenes theory itself is not original and there are some precedents well.
Having passed away is one of really regrettable writers.
って on which the unexpected person is drawn with the legal ability person is rather pleasant.
Although the point with advantageous ま and famous man will not have a method of comrades, either.

2005/08/14 Comment(good) [Original Japanese review]
by 宇宙刑事ジャンギャバン Provider: 25233 Host:25110 Browser: 4925
A leader's behind the scenes real name is Jiro Serada 3 郎.
The Shiro Chaya following 郎 is the merchant who served Ieyasu.
I thought that the argument of Takashi who mentioned the tolerant measure to Hidetada to whom Ieyasu's strange action in a field and evening Toshio rare [ that 3 generalissimo Iemitsu ignored Hidetada who is a father, and worshipped "grandfather" Ieyasu once although it was a fictitious talk, and Seki ] た我 were late for 溺愛 to a child, and Seki was late for the field etc.
to basis, and advanced the Ieyasu leader-behind-the-scenes theory was very interesting.
However, since a historical fact is not bent, is it sad to finish it as defeat of Jiro 3 郎 after all?

2005/08/14 Very good [Original Japanese review]
by 神賢一 Provider: 9396 Host:9580 Browser: 4925
In the 隆慶 Ichiro work, it is a typical work and has quite high completeness and adjustment as an amusement work of a time fighting scene.
Although Seki has the background that Ieyasu dies in a field and Shiro Chaya 3 郎 serves as instead of [ the ] as the "leader behind the scenes" as well as "1 Account of 夢庵 elegant" as a base of a work, it is the work which can be called this editing to it.
Since other works and back stories are shared, it consists of fully kneaded stories, and the tale is made dramatic when Ieyasu piles up the "fact" called preferential treatment of the legitimate children of Ieyasu of "it is fictitious" and 晩年 that Seki is shot in the field on it.
Although it is not a historical novel, a period adventure story is a work to recommend to the favorite one very much.

2005/04/07 Good [Original Japanese review]
by 宇宙刑事ジャンギャバン Provider: 33223 Host:33255 Browser: 5978
Is it drama-ized by Hideki Takahashi Mr.
starring several years ago?
Although it cannot be denied that the talk was progressing in a run considerably well by the number of times of televising with which ten talks are not filled ...
Although it was the tale of a bold setup referred to as that Ieyasu Tokugawa had died in fact in Sekigahara, and the leader behind the scenes moved subsequent history The place which it seemingly mentioned to the example, was reasonable and made it the basis of a leader-behind-the-scenes theory to have made late legitimate-child Hidetada's crime unquestioned, to have 溺愛(ed) [ the doubtful action (it cuts to 兵 which has thrown the horse) of Ieyasu in front of a battle start, ] the child born after Sekigahara, etc.
had given persuasive power to the tale.
the attachment to Hidetada's timidity and Munenori's power -- ち -- it draws deeply -- having -- a better seed This depiction thinks that it has affected the comics "finishing [ あ ]" of hill ゆう considerably.
However, since a historical fact is not bent, as for a secret strife of hero Serada [ Jiro ] 3 郎 and Hidetada Tokugawa, it is surely sad [ a historical fact ] that it had to be made to finish it as Hidetada's final victory.

2004/08/29 Best! [Original Japanese review]
by 毒 Provider: 45790 Host:45556 Browser: 5978
Even if it deducts that leading role class favor passes, it is the highest amusement novel.
The author of that "Keiji" becomes the work under the political water surface which has not flown plot monochrome, either and is so....
It is if it considers.
To be sure, it is surprising.
Boldly, it is unreasonable 苦茶.
Fake Ieyasu who continues preventing Hidetada's expectation and plot.
the 隆慶 taste which supports it on the reverse side -- a large -- Sakon [ 爆発 ], Rokuro, 風魔 and others Jiro 3 郎 which pierces through its way of life even if it loses a dream and loses a life.
It appears that it was merely worrisome for a while at the very beginning, and it is Rokuro of appearing in a succession and worth with in fact most turn to the very end.
Favor carries out and it pushes down, so that this makes it regard it as ?
in fact whether you are ups-and-downs life to the extent that Jiro 3 郎 is not lost, and the real leading role, and it is 。.
Jiro 3 郎 does not have Sakon in the last even in the direction of お梶, either, and smallness Taro or Masanobu Honda also permit only him the royalty of a key.
Is it favor of the free author without knowing why too?

2004/04/15 Best! [Original Japanese review]
by すととん帝王 Provider: 38156 Host:38082 Browser: 4483
It could be called the compilation of a 隆慶 Ichiro big river period adventure story.
By there being nothing, daring make him the incarnation of various evils by elated Yagyu, paying attention to the cruel nature which lurks in human being called Hidetada Tokugawa, and the cruel whole surface, and making it the anti thesis to the image to public Hidetada, if "historical fact is true, there is nothing!
It may be teaching ".
In fact, after reading this, the idea to my Hidetada changed 180 degrees.
Although there is [ this / Ichiro / 隆慶 ] probably that it is also disagreeable well in "those who will show if feigned ignorance is carried out and it is good human being." " -- being such -- attractive in both face and figure -- a Mister -- man who is exposed to love [ like ] has the coldness of the blood like mercilessness and reptiles mostly -- he is using abundantly the language to the effect, ", with various works Seemingly, "outside good human being" is not trusted.
it thinks that the half-raw as his scenarist has probably influenced -- the idea of "a fight of the social weak" which is flowing in his work, and "a fight of defeat persons" is flowing continuously Hero Serada [ Jiro ] 3 郎 is beaten without being able to go against the current of the times after all.
Although it can roll back if Hidetada is killed, the pride of "a person on the way" does not accept only it by any means.
It was not carried out although it was possible to have killed Hidetada always and to have forced to such a wind when thinking that it would persist in its convenience.
He lived and the position of "anti-power" was pierced.
[ like ] Even if its dream vanishes.
[ metaphor ] Also として [ a metaphor and himself are killed ].
In order to attain the purpose, while his attitude of having not broken down one's principle is splendid, a sense of the evanescence of life drifts.
Such the depth differs from a simple period adventure story.
Of course, although there is also fleshing called 15 years of struggle for power, such a "sense of the evanescence of life" may be the greatest theme of this work.
Therefore, if the definition of this novel is considered, it will be appropriate to consider as a "big river period adventure story." A novel with dozens of times more interesting than a poor popular writer's novel.
It thinks that it is the novel this "leader-behind-the-scenes Ieyasu Tokugawa."

2004/04/15 Very good [Original Japanese review]
by 宝家義頼 Provider: 5504 Host:5350 Browser: 3646
Although the author is drawing Hidetada Tokugawa as a cunning person who excelled in trickery, those who is called actual Hidetada Tokugawa do not seem to have been so clever and to have been the person around whom wisdom turns.
The novel is written fairly pleasantly.

2004/04/13 Very good [Original Japanese review]
by Morochi Provider: 7812 Host:7792 Browser: 3875
This work is the same as "Keiji of a flower".
The comics version interrupts for a form like the close at once whether it was unpopular in the middle of the talk by being caricatured by Mr.
field Tetsuo and being now peevish, and it is as "Sakon-SAKON -" behind.
It revived again.
Since leader-behind-the-scenes Ieyasu Tokugawa is also written as an entertainment novel (fiction), although remarkable production is carried out, a setup used as the core of the talk "Ieyasu Tokugawa's Seki was after the field a leader behind the scenes" is an interesting work very interesting also as a novel of a historical essay.
Since it is soft in it being unexpected and is an intelligible style, Mr.
隆慶 Ichiro's text is also this work.
It was a very readable novel.

Post your review / Top page

Other media
Comics:Kage Musha Tokugawa Ieyasu / Drama:KAGEMUSHA TOKUGAWA IEYASU