Japanese works database(How to join/Help)
Top page: All/Only Reviews 		Others
Site map
Search / Outside DB:
Novel ranking: Rank 2,366/in 2,368 titles (Total -38.16/Deviation 26.19) Rank 2,365 <= => Rank 2,367
Novel average points ranking: Rank 134/in 138 titles (Average -1.06(Bad)/Deviation 26.21) Rank 133 <= => Rank 135 (more than 10 evaluatoin)

Suzumiya Haruhi's a sigh(Novel)


[Other version: RSS/Japanese version]

All
Reviews(Post)		ForumImages

Information about this title

Nagaru Tanigawa
Ito Noiji
Kadokawa Shoten Publishing Co.,Ltd.

Statics of evaluation(The statics is updated once a day)
 AverageNovelRankDeviation(Total)Evaluation points(Total)Best of the Best
Inside JapanBad(-1.06)2,36626.19-38.16 

Statics of activity

Total ViewsCommentEvaluation
Inside Japan11,5863736
Outside Japan30300

How others evaluated in Japan

BestVery GoodGoodNormalBadVery BadWorst
People02210787
Percentage0.0%5.6%5.6%27.8%19.4%22.2%19.4%
Added percentage0%5.6%11.2%39%58.4%80.6%100%
Summary11.2%27.8%61%
                                                                                                 

Views for recent 8 days
Total109876543
7
0
0
2
1
0
2
2
0

LanguageSorted by dateSorted by recommendation
EnglishGood
(Only Evaluation)		Normal
(Only Evaluation)		Bad
(Only Evaluation)		All
(Only Evaluation)		None
JapaneseGood
(Only Evaluation)		Normal
(Only Evaluation)		 Bad
(Only Evaluation)		All
(Only Evaluation)		All
This reputation board

Post your review / Top page
The below reviews are translated automatically from Japanese ones. To post to English version, please click here.
2008/08/08 Very good [Original Japanese review]
by 梅本 Provider: 7456 Host:7408 Browser: 7493
a few -- the time -- a series -- skipping -- passing -- it is .
(として [ it is good well ]) a little [ on the whole, it sees and / an end ] -- と -- although it is the touch to say, I think that neta called movie photography is good Although I am expected to say that what is necessary is just to be able to laugh, is it fundamentally amusing as for it having not been a problem later to have fired the model gun at the Shinto priest of a shrine?
A cover is with whether it is such a thing well.
し [ the Asahina みくる is not encouraging in a sailor suit ].
evaluation is very good by saying -- coming out -- 。
2008/07/09 Very good [Original Japanese review]
by Baabarian Provider: 14213 Host:14110 Browser: 2907(Mobile)
Although it obtains and - and comics are read indiscriminately, since only the ranobe [ itself ] haruhi series has been read, although there is seldom a view which looks at a work, please give it こご了承 with そこん.

[Good point]
- shamisen.
The character of shamisen roared with laughter with the jar.
- in addition to this, narration of kyon was fairly interesting (" -- don't see) If it decreases, it will carry out what.
" - The post-closing space where kyon got angry with haruhi did not occur.
- The scene at which kyon is angry to Taniguchi.
kyon is having been on the 擁う side about haruhi, and is also it the place out of which Taniguchi's human stink had come?
It is sushi now [ なっちゃ ] to Taniguchi who will not be cheap and has carried out man if one of the grumbles is not said by are.

[a bad point]
- or [ that it is the character of haruhi too ] ...
but -- without it carries out the bad laver only of that by pleasant thing continuation -- character -- good -- becoming -- てい -- っちゃ -- well, じゃ and conversely unnatural mind are also carried out, and I care about are so much and do not become precocious - a cover (smile) -- it wavers in surely having in a register and going with whether he will buy some for a duck hula -- a seed But or [ that it is completely more honest than other placed ranobe ].
The
[whole]
Although there were many opinions that tempo is bad, I could read at a stretch and did now [ ちゃ ].
まぁ -- it was the talk as which a short story is sufficient to be sure -- it carried out and there was no merit of the tempo like "disappearance" He likes better than "tedium" which does not become medicine at まぁ毒, either.
2008/05/22 Worst [Original Japanese review]
by huwa Provider: 13340 Host:13200 Browser: 5533
A work with No.
1 disagreeable in series.
First, a cover inflames displeasure.
Oh, I want you to stop the cover as for which those who buy ゆう and its book become despised.
Next, haruhi passes a troublesome person but about a story, and it is uza い.
Although it is independently good, an SOS team and the surroundings apply too much annoyingly [ 人含 ], and the carrying-out-movie work situation is 。.
Especially movie photography in a shrine was severe.
Although it was also so to have shot a model gun toward a pigeon, it was surprised that it shot toward the Shinto priest of the shrine.
It is because it thought that what even haruhi shoots a model gun with toward people was not done.
It is a criminal act and I think it amusing that haruhi has no feeling to that however it may call it a novel.
And anger was memorized to have acted so that it was very natural if it says from a flow, and haruhi might be usual in it again although it was the scene by which kyon is enraged to haruhi.
Then, being reconciled is too early although haruhi and kyon are reconciled.
It is rare and, but, what kyon gets angry with is reconciliation at a night ...
Made it better to prolong the portion here more.
To a thing with many scenes been lazy by movie photography Naturally based on the above, evaluation is the worst.
2008/04/12 Normal [Original Japanese review]
by 炎髪君 Provider: 54981 Host:54989 Browser: 8090

[Good point]
It obtains and is ?.
...
It is not good for a normal.
Contents are not bad although the thing with the delicate end is known.

[Bad point]
Since haruhi wished, does hoihoi 出てくる have neither a って pigeon nor an all right cherry tree?
the actual idea of haruhi -- " -- such a thing should happen truly -- there is nothing Was it as melancholy as " and had not Koizumi said?
^^;
[Comprehensive evaluation]
Although the end was finally, it was able to read happily smoothly till then.
since -- it solves by making it from a position at least "the comment regarded as good"
2008/01/23 Bad [Original Japanese review]
by CTU Provider: 34156 Host:34214 Browser: 4613
Is it the most disreputable work in haruhi series?
It is the work of the impression which a trial-and-error method was applied in order to extend a setup for the work which "it is melancholy" has already completed alone, and has gone wrong.
Even himself of a haruhi lover of haruhi of this volume is kitsu い.
when "haruhi was jealous of seeing and coming and took such action which teases みくる as a result" in a network behind, after being scolded by kyon been and understood, haruhi which it is going to make into ponytail was dear Since it was the touch which daradara(ed) on the whole [ it is long and ] vainly, it is at "it is bad."
2008/01/23 Very bad [Original Japanese review]
by 海上 Provider: 19847 Host:19721 Browser: 7781(Mobile)
Tempo is very bad in a talk which extended the short story as you tell.
Talk [ like ] which especially a story does not necessarily rise, either and is only investigation of a character.
Since the investigation was also called only surface of kyara or it has delved into the bad point, it has become better [ it / the work which is not as a result ].
It is at least a punch line that was interesting.
If this punch line was also a short story, although he was probably able to be enjoyed purely, since it is the talk the contents talked comparatively for a long time, is it unsatisfactory?
There is no value which says clearly and is read purposely.
It was not killing time, either.
Why did the author take out such a work to the world?
Although it thinks that evaluation can enjoy the way which "very bad" haruhi series expects and is not read, it is unattractive, so that this work still does not have follow in おっつ.
2007/12/15 Worst [Original Japanese review]
by kuririn Provider: 33683 Host:33511 Browser: 6714
It is not interesting the previous work of 涼宮 haruhi "is melancholy." I think that there are also those [ no ] who feel displeasure rather few.
The character of the heroine and 涼宮 haruhi increases also to the whole set first, and it is kitsu くなっています.
Giving alcohol and intoxicating it, without, not throwing into the cold inside pond of winter, or saying in what drink, たり.
[ dressing the disliking upperclassman with clothes with the high degree of exposure forcibly ] And since the crisis of a world downfall will come this work if feelings of 涼宮 haruhi are hurt, nobody can say it strongly to haruhi.
Therefore, haruhi becomes doing and I think that many those who feel displeasure there are also.
I am also one person of them.
haruhi other than a "sigh" -- rapidly -- humane -- growing up -- others' thing -- with this work, it is terrible character growing up into the good child who can do a thought and ること Although the hero would swarm by making it the wind of solving it, the author makes haruhi start a problem again, and has not it probably, failed just for a moment?
2007/12/03 Worst [Original Japanese review]
by hiro Review history[Good:1(100%) Normal:0(0%) Bad:0(0%)] / Provider: 12661 Host:12632 Browser: 2909(Mobile)
Not a "sigh" but a title's "reckless run" is [ the direction of others ] more suitable as 仰る.
haruhi of this volume passes the inside of self, and is the minimum.
So that pain [ already reading it ].
Although he can understand in these series if called -- which the theme "mental growth of haruhi" will also have and which therefore needed to be made to riot within the first stage, they are not the contents which also need to use one volume very much.
Although only the scene with which haruhi which fell had bundled hair after the quarrel was good.
Evaluation is made to strain oneself by slight severity.
2007/09/25 Bad [Original Japanese review]
by 八郎太 Provider: 18003 Host:17891 Browser: 4663
It is whether it is having written, even by having used one volume of this talk purposely.
Importance was not felt so much in this series.
The contents are more delicate.
Tempo can be bad, the great climax cannot be found, either and how to attach a punch line is also disappointed.
Because the last of the first work was good, it was so felt excessive.
But since narration of kyon is living, evaluation is stopped for "it to be bad."
2007/09/02 Normal [Original Japanese review]
by Akanechan Provider: 18003 Host:17950 Browser: 4641
Although there are many ありゃりゃ and severe opinions, it is peevish and I also regard such a thing as an ant, probably, the title of 作 will not be suitable probably now.
if it does not read by "the adventure episode 00 of the Asahina mikuru" and set of a short story after the direction called reckless run instead of a sigh may say -- not much -- he cannot be enjoyed -- the "adventure episode 00 of the Asahina mikuru" complemented with a single article although it will become evaluation [ be / bad ] is added, and it is just going to call it ordinary evaluation
2007/09/02 Worst [Original Japanese review]
by 虚構の旅人 Provider: 19636 Host:19755 Browser: 6287
The second work of extremely popular series.
wanting, as for this work, to do what -- completely -- と, so that you may say -- not understanding .
After popularity comes out by the first work, the author's mistake has taken out such a made work.
first, the time -- a series -- suddenly -- putting it out of order -- a seed し [ the contents of "tedium" are supposed to have finished ].
I think that this work was [ honesty important point ] a work which is not.
It was just unnecessary addition.
It was the theme to say that haruhi makes indies as composition of a story.
However, depiction of this indies photography is gudaguda again.
Probably, this author did like this, and while it will be unconscious, he has extended the talk.
This work even with free [ petty ] is the deployment to which it considered as daradara further.
First, although there is much depiction of the Asahina みくる strangely (if it says that it is natural naturally), isn't a person with disagreeable Asahina borne probably?
Only she to whom I am also flustered is actually abhorred.
A thing to take out to a mouth and say, if disagreeable ...
Since it is such kyara setup, although a part is unavoidable well.
However, isn't there anything [ any ] that is called a highlight in this work even so?
Completely have and there is nothing.
Although it was good, if the second work is this, it is the husband many readers including me probably "regarded [ ...
] as what the first work will become after this." Can't this work be read freely in a light novel?
"heaviness" -- it is a novel There is no it in this work that it is usually attractive to the extent that it stops stopping the more, the more a thing called a light novel reads.
Not to mention, I want to come to stop reading on the way rather.
I am also reading only this work only once.
Is just it the work of the "black history" of haruhi series?
Stripes were disappointedly carried out as a reader.
anti-吐 completely appears in the abusive language of haruhi said "ちゃん which seen and comes is my toy" in this work Generally, it is not felt for it turning out later ", in fact, others' thing is considered" by haruhi of late.
Placed by making a remark which does not consider this human being to be man, and character has changed considerably behind why ...
けど which may be the author's having also forgotten supposing it carried out or, or having not only thought not much deeply.
I think that a yell of kyon in this scene was a point remarkable as positioning as a character of kyon in deployment and.
Is always it careful of others and do you think that the character in character with the human being of also considering one's self-preservation was emphasized?
Synthetic evaluation is inexcusable.
Is it the "worst"?
There is neither a highlight nor an interesting scene and it has only merely got bored with gudaguda, daradara, and the advancing story indifferently.
It may be OK if it is those who say that the everyday common story is better than unprecedented acceleration etc.
However, probably, there are also few people who take to this work in the present age with much people who ask for too sudden deployment.
2007/08/14 Bad [Original Japanese review]
by 濁流の魔手 Provider: 18250 Host:18321 Browser: 4184
It was not an excessive good work.
I think that there would be no necessity of writing the work which emphasizes the poison of haruhi to there not much.
I think that it will be the volume which does not not much have necessity.
A story does not necessarily have especially big many complications, either, and is linear.
It has 飽きed bored in the hit which approached in the second half just for a moment.
But the place where kyon and haruhi quarrel is not a disagreeable reason well.
If there is no process of reconciliation of it and after that, evaluation will be having taken a nosedive.
Evaluation is "bad."
2007/06/23 Comment(normal) [Original Japanese review]
by np Provider: 18083 Host:17883 Browser: 4184
Is it す which is not required for the work which writes the poison of haruhi as hard as possible?
Main [ it is selfish, and ], when it is also the concept of this series that the girl with surprising power whom the method of comrades does not have, either grows little by little.
Work kana ?w slightly hot to a まぁ haruhi fan and the fan of the 鶴 store who made Mr.
酒混ぜて Asahina drink
2007/03/20 Normal [Original Japanese review]
by 黒い翼の天使 Provider: 50477 Host:50429 Browser: 3875
It was the talk which has various discovery as me who entered from animation.
The first talk of animation was improved by swift attack after reading through 本作.
Merely, it was the talk which "is thin as for contents although it can read lightly" as a work, and if it entered from the novel, it may have become a dry taste opinion.
I consider that it was better to collect into honesty and a short story grade.
but it is what -- it bit -- since it came out and read and there was no impression that る最中 was so bad -- once -- evaluation -- "-- it is usually made "
2007/03/14 Worst [Original Japanese review]
by god Provider: 34156 Host:34187 Browser: 3023
Made such a work why...
For tempo, haruhi which bad progress of a tale does not have, either is uzai.
It is one of the reasons to which I became disagreeable about haruhi.
Mental-state [ when kyon flings up a fist ] -> "give up and do!
knock!
oh, shake off 古泉 Mr.
!?
kyon of my 麗し stopped why, and control!
I allow!" ...
It was って touch (sweat).
Although Mr.
Asahina is not at the reason for liking and he dislikes him rather ...
Is the inside of the self of ねぇ ?
haruhi the work which reached the maximum level ...
2007/03/12 Very bad [Original Japanese review]
by 月夜の兎 Provider: 51712 Host:51817 Browser: 6287
I think that it is the talk which is the least interesting in the haruhi series to this time.
事件 which is sensation called [ no one but / haruhi series ] arises -- also coming out -- there is nothing -- only merely making a movie Moreover, SF element almost concentrates only the portion that a setup of a movie is realized, during movie photography, and happens, and an aftereffect does not reach to the other general society.
If the situation where a setup of a movie became actual occurred, the world of a movie eroded even to the actual life of an except during photography, and a little SOS team panic and deployment to say were expected.
Since the portion which it has with other works of being dear has hardly come also out of haruhi, it is only a free ワgamama foolish supervisor.
It is whether it is neta as which the short story must have been enough in contents.
2007/03/11 Very bad [Original Japanese review]
by Morochi Provider: 6119 Host:6200 Browser: 4184
It is making a movie by the cultural festival shortly!
Although kana ?
which is mashi from last time a little by calling it ...
was also thought It is gakkuri to contents as usual.
けど which will receive the bad impression especially since it is individually disagreeable to call it a selfish and egocentric character like haruhi, Make it it, and earnestly, considering ?
composition, too thinly [ the contents ], it is poor, and also heaping up the main events last time and this time has gone wrong, and last time similarly a repetition of the now same thing ..., i.e., an alien and future people, -- familiar -- a repetition of situation explanation of so and so -- a page -- working -- でい -- merely -- even coming out -- thin contents are still severer ...., if って言ったって to which the heroine of a tsundere system is having a large custom how much is also obtained and the portion of grade delay is not increased for a while su けどねぇ which does not feel and twist the charm as the heroine ....
The head could regard in the thing that it was not only bad as ?, and was not simply able to feel charm rather than the capricious speech and conduct when shooting etc.
were referred to as selfish.
2007/03/06 Bad [Original Japanese review]
by Shinnen Provider: 46904 Host:46844 Browser: 5234
When it went to a clubroom individually in order that kyon may become reconciled with haruhi, haruhi was considering as the 毛縛 wax of hair, and although he liked the depiction left and said, while reading on the whole unlike the previous work, weariness which becomes sleepy was.
But probably, it should let an eye pass at once, since it is a work important as an element which enjoys the movie of the animation version.
2007/01/27 Worst [Original Japanese review]
by lalala Provider: 3180 Host:3189 Browser: 6342
Since "it was melancholy" was rather pleasant, although he bought it, expectation was betrayed splendidly.
The talk of movie manufacture is daradaradaradara to it having been exciting when what wonderful が起こる it was......
How many times did you think it would stop already reading?
After finishing reading enduringly, there was only a feeling of "having got tired." This is not attached any longer except the "worst." The novel regarded as what read being pain is at least this.
Although it thinks that it changed again in other series if it is evaluation as the whole "haruhi", since there was interesting one, this is the "worst" in evaluation っぽい's as a "sigh" simple substance.
2006/12/29 Very bad [Original Japanese review]
by LOVEN Provider: 53557 Host:53533 Browser: 3874
that pleasant tempo of a previous work has no gutaguta しっぱ from ?
beginning to the last to where -- is the impression ...
strong?
I think that the point that the goal of 本作 is defined firmly first was good.
In that there is it and the thing which is not, it is mentally [ a reader ] large and is different, and supposing there is no it, I will think that it had become gutaguta further.
However, he thinks that a light novel should be to go up like a rocket and come down like a stick.
Probably a novel of this sort has an important grip above all, and if it makes it read to some extent and carries out [ it is clear and ], unless the contents are very severe, it is mostly read to the last.
However, this work is 蛇頭竜尾...
Disagreeable 蛇頭蛇尾 is also a good place.
anyhow -- from the beginning up to the last -- ups and downs -- there is nothing -- characters ...
that which had finished when 行ったり here 行ったり(ing) and having noticed -- such touch although it was probably a "successful" って intention like the author of the last punch line -- as here -- a word of "being ?
at ..." -- 片付いちゃ -- well .
What, is "it is very bad" an appropriate place in could read and having carried out now [ ちゃ ] to the last, even if said, and kyara standing, and having bit [ that っぷり is also living from a previous work ] as for evaluation?
Was this volume saved by honto and kyara?
Next / Post your review / Top page
ALERT: You cannot use open proxy or TOR for posting your review. If it is detected, your access to this site will be prohibited.
Rule for reviews

This site allows you to write reviews for each title, but we don't allow you to criticize others' comment. Too bad or meaningless words are also not allowed. The comment which doesn't follow the rule will be deleted. If you find any comment which doesn't follow the rule, please notify us by clicking Suggest to delete.

Example to be deleted frequently

Favorite side
You dislike this one, then don't see it or comment this title
- Please go to the fan site. Anyone has the right to say what they feel in this site.

Disliking side
Do you like this one? You are stupid.
- Your view is only your view. Please concentrate on only the content of the title, not on others' comment.

Please use only English. If not, the comment will be deleted.

Please give your evaluation or comment.

You need two other people's comment to post your comment again after you post your evaluation or comment.

Your Name(Required)
Password (Required. more than 4 characters)
Your comment about this anime(Required)

Your evaluation of this title(Required)
You can choose the evaluation only once. After you post your evaluation, please choose comment instead of evaluation from the options.
Evaluation of this title(You can choose this only once)

Best!!
Very good
Good
Normal
Bad
Very Bad
Worst

If you evaluated this title once, please choose comment instead of the evaluation.
Comment by the person who thinks this is good
Comment by the person who thinks this is normal
Comment by the person who thinks this is bad

Please choose appropriate option for readers.

Caution: Please post the evaluation which follows the rule.

Top page of DB | Site map | Copyright(c) 1999- 1st Class All rights reserved