Japanese works database(How to join/Help)
Top page: All/Only Reviews

Others
Site map


Search / Outside DB:

Novel ranking: Rank 2,383/in 2,386 titles (Total -27.00/Deviation 31.64) Rank 2,382 <= => Rank 2,384
Novel average points ranking: Rank 133/in 135 titles (Average -1.80(Very bad)/Deviation 18.67) Rank 132 <= => Rank 134 (more than 10 evaluatoin)

Souryuden(Novel)

[Other version: RSS/Japanese version]

Other media
Anime:Soryuden / Comics:Souryuden

All
Reviews(Post)

Forum

Images

Information about this title

Yoshiki Tanaka
Yoshitaka Amano
CLAMP
Koudansha

Statics of evaluation(The statics is updated once a day)

	Average	NovelRank	Deviation(Total)	Evaluation points(Total)	Best of the Best
Inside Japan	Very bad(-1.80)	2,383	31.64	-27.00

Statics of activity

	Total Views	Comment	Evaluation
Inside Japan	5,819	17	15
Outside Japan	285	0	0

How others evaluated in Japan

Best

Very Good

Good

Normal

Bad

Very Bad

Worst

People

Percentage

0.0%

6.7%

0.0%

33.3%

20.0%

40.0%

Added percentage

6.7%

40%

60%

100%

Summary

6.7%

93.3%

Views for recent 8 days
Total 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 31
5 1 1 1 1 0 0 0 1

Language Sorted by date Sorted by recommendation
English Good
(Only Evaluation) Normal
(Only Evaluation) Bad
(Only Evaluation) All
(Only Evaluation) None
Japanese Good
(Only Evaluation) Normal
(Only Evaluation) Bad
(Only Evaluation) All
(Only Evaluation) All
This reputation board

Language	Sorted by date	Sorted by recommendation
English	Good (Only Evaluation)	Normal (Only Evaluation)	Bad (Only Evaluation)	All (Only Evaluation)	None
Japanese	Good (Only Evaluation)	Normal (Only Evaluation)	Bad (Only Evaluation)	All (Only Evaluation)	All

Post your review / Top page

Other media
Anime:Soryuden / Comics:Souryuden

The below reviews are translated automatically from Japanese ones. To post to English version, please click here.

2008/08/23 Bad [Original Japanese review]
by 634 Provider: 11268 Host:11346 Browser: 6342
Is it the work which lost steps 読む気 aside from the first uchi, as a story progresses?
Touch which has not done classification of whether it is an adventure thing in contents, and whether to be a fantasy comparatively which is called large activity of the brothers who become a dragon, either.
Although the author thinks too that the direction which the direction of the record-of-war thing in 銀英伝, the fictitious different world like arusuraan, and the future world wrote for whether being 遙 matches well, even if it is continuing only such works, he may drop the capability as a writer on the contrary, and he has the feeling ...
The author was touch that the contents had failed in the great fan rapidly similarly to Reiji Matsumoto with "space warfare warship Yamato" with which studio ぬえ dealt as well as 銀英伝.
Gradually, it was hard coming to read a sentence, it caused, and a thing like ranobe was also felt in the bad meaning.
Although it was able to think that there was a portion into which animation also rises as it is, the important animation is also the touch [ zeal / with which begins to feel and the author fills such works / of an ending-abruptly dragonfly ] in any way ...
If it becomes the hero thing which knocks down the enemy who pounces on the bottom of the name of justice, they are the ego of the major nation which the author was drawing by 銀英伝 etc., and touch that various debts have been progressed in the bad meaning.
at least, make it a real politician -- make it the bottom of the followers and hand -- think that it is not a partner like the third-rate villain, and mainly make it the villain with the author's works -- make it an incompetent person -- as [ extend / it / this / although hakkiri and classification had come out / in the bad form ] -- beginning to feel, this does not care for it It may be that the direction which abandoned the complexity of such initial works was found [ a certain meaning and ] by whether it was judged that it was thought that it is easy to carry out reader uke, or the influence of the latest ranobe is also contained, or the author is also referring such portions the style and is referring to ranobe.
Rather than other ranobe, if these are still continued for a long time and an incomplete work like other works is not finished although there may be a portion saved in respect of ...
since it is still Yoshiki Tanaka, I will think what thing it is.
Well, it may be able to be written to the present author, that is, he may be 酷, and it may be that this author also forgets that.

2008/07/22 Comment(good) [Original Japanese review]
by Erikusaa Provider: 51364 Host:51335 Browser: 4184
me -- this work -- he likes To be sure, recently, since there is an impression with superfluous gag and the incident for 15 or 6 years of the real world is stuffed with the novel in a little less than 1 (at the 13-volume end time) (the Fuyuki 涼平 series which was the starting point is a great difference), it is also a fact that unreasonableness has produced many things.
But it makes to see 竜堂 brothers with super-usual state capability, and the friends of those grind the unreasonable attack by persons with huge power into a very thrilling feeling.
It seems that there are not few people that a political utterance, history recognition, etc.
which are shown by borrowing the mouth of the inside of the text or a character (many are 始 and 続) are attached to a nose, about this work.
There is an indeed rather [ in quantity ] superfluous field, and it does not become precocious although there is no admiration which has turned into the author's "knowledge public presentation place." But there are also many points that it can 首肯 by the thing strange generally in contents having not said (the man that the contents are not pleased will be unable to do evaluation already friendly to this work).
Above all, if this is lost, I will think that the fun of this work becomes that by which considerable reduction was carried out.
Now, "completing-when kana" is worried about "創竜〓" too.
although it regards the author, Mr.
Yoshiki Tanaka, often studying and writing a novel as what should be admired -- on the other hand -- the lateness of the brush of this gentleman -- established reputation -- it is -- further -- suddenly -- 〓 -- it carries out and there is also bad habit of beginning to leave a work alone and interrupting it (for example, "7 city tale", "tie tania", etc.) They are honesty and remarkable worries.
"創竜〓" Although it is called 13 volumes, five volumes and 11 volumes will be extra editing with an unrelated right course, and if no less than 12 volumes consider that it is a volume on extra as a matter of fact except for several pages of the last, the number of substance will still be ten.
In order to complete with saw at the time, I think that four volumes are required the back 3 [ at least ].
I do not consider an already excessive thing but want it to dash towards the last decisive battle with 牛種.
If there is the "government pair government" first and 魔竜 of eight animals is not pushed down with "you" even if it runs the shortest distance, it is bad, and If whether it will live as "people" on the ground to the last on it [ bad ] if it says the Shitsuki, 天帝 is rescued (the "天帝" itself is moreover doubtful) and the boss of 牛種 is not confronted, or it returns to heavens do not determine, the bad thing which should be done is a pile.
It is interested in what Natsuko Kobayagawa is made the last.
the supporting player who has impact too much -- dramatization -- I am what was troubled the top and carry out [ mind as it is called what or the author is also brandished by this character ] It could be made to be already able to die and could not be made to leave.

2007/11/20 Worst [Original Japanese review]
by Rarugo Provider: 29109 Host:29026 Browser: 4925
Although it seemed to be grand biography action which those who change to 巨竜 play an active part, and is unfolded on a world-wide scale when only the contents were heard, when it actually let the eye pass, the mountain of the criticism about superfluous modern society was drawn just because it was not such biography actions etc.
Does Mr.
Yoshiki Tanaka who is the author continue having deep hatred burned to the organization engaged in the dark part of modern society, such as politics, a bureaucrat, and the police?

2007/11/08 Worst [Original Japanese review]
by KRR Provider: 24524 Host:24609 Browser: 6520
Today's world is useless.
The man of power who is moving the world is wrong anyhow.
A politician is also wrong.
A rich man is also wrong.
The military persons concerned are also wrong.
The police persons concerned are also wrong.
The United States is also wrong.
Is it the novel as which the fun [ like ] which is continuing drawing such a criticism intently is not felt?

2007/11/01 Very bad [Original Japanese review]
by H&J Provider: 25562 Host:25715 Browser: 8090
It is the work of left-wing side size explosion which cannot be regarded as the work of Mr.
Tanaka who was neutrality to democracy by 銀英伝 at despotism.
Since only "the present politics was not good" among students, although it was mind-like [ a wild rampage of a 竜堂 brother ] for taste, it is just amazed now for the first time in coercive selling of the author's simplicity, or ignorance and cheap ideology.
Although he does not plan to tell many, may not it be more strangely [ whether it is "た / a wrist watch / than digital one / as だ with a sufficient analog etc.
] scrupulous merely a word?" Evaluation: It is very bad.

2007/05/17 Bad [Original Japanese review]
by Enshi Provider: 12661 Host:12508 Browser: 2989(Mobile)
Since it is to four volumes that I read, it is evaluation to there.
I thought, "When the first volume is read for the first time, it was an interesting novel in " etc.!" an individual 竜堂 brother's kyara -- interesting -- the -- it rioted, and ぶり was invigorating and was felt refreshed The quite ironical social satire was also rather pleasant.
the inside which it continues reading with two volumes [ three ] although it is ....
former -- 面白 -- having felt it pleasant came to feel it as a petty provoking thing the author who was also showing the contents as the social satire above all does [ diversion ], and it is no longer moved only by the novel as the 竜堂 brother is also rioting just as he likes [ himselves ] Except that an enemy's purpose was aiming at a 竜堂 brother's power, the cause felt boring was not found well, either.
........
I merely thought it uncanny to have mocked a certain religion.
The direction seen only in the ironical direction in the direction which wants to read the novel around which angles and heroes riot to a rabbit and it turns to it, and a world is whether to be able to enjoy oneself.
A pro-American faction had better not read the one [ dislike / a satire ].
When saying so, the 竜堂 brother round-table talk of the end of a book was the most interesting (smile).

2006/12/01 Comment(bad) [Original Japanese review]
by Pachimon Provider: 13780 Host:13982 Browser: 4184
Although social criticism was attached to the nose when a 竜堂 brother's true character was unknown and it was comparatively interesting, neighborhood object beam atmosphere where the stage moved to overseas became less interesting [ drift and ].
As [ match / seldom / the technique of beginning to spin a tale with live feeling each time / while a writer called Yoshiki Tanaka writes / well ] Probably, this man should write a long piece, after kneading a plot exactly to an end too.

2005/12/29 Bad [Original Japanese review]
by 神楽坂葵 Provider: 13485 Host:13727 Browser: 5471
It has been lost from the middle to わ k っわ by something.
Not strangely quite satisfactory.
Although a brother is kyara ったっているん, an enemy divides him and he is んって touch from わ.
I thought even if it becomes simpleer deployment.

2005/12/11 Worst [Original Japanese review]
by HE-AT Provider: 54290 Host:54127 Browser: 4184
The novel written the anti-day and anti-Americanism, and 3 of anti-society anti-principle.
Feeling became bad although read only once.

2005/10/27 Very good [Original Japanese review]
by nozomu Provider: 40807 Host:40872 Browser: 3875
It is at the time of inside 1 that I read this work for the first time.
about ten years after that ...
"the Al game" -- since it will come out only once together in several, although it is reading from habit That they were Mr.
余 and this い年 have exceeded the year of 始兄さん.
(Smile) anyhow -- reading -- て -- it can read to the last, without suffering a setback, since it is interesting However, a social satire is said clearly and needed.
If there is that, since the tempo which becomes the obstacle of a tale and is read will be out of order.
He is likely to want to come out 13 new publications, and it is peevish, and is -.
It is likely to become first to read, since the library versions (CLANP illustration) are collected now for the time being.

2005/09/30 Worst [Original Japanese review]
by Reuentahl Provider: 24348 Host:24232 Browser: 5234
Although it was the work which has refused to read until now, it read at last.
が ...
that - and これって -- it is the work of Mr.
Yoshiki Tanaka who wrote that Galaxy epic theory truly ...
?
(<- comment) -- it is good, and although people use the epigram that it is what changing as an ear, they used to fall at best so far truly since the reason Mr.
Tanaka is confined in the "hiding place" in Karuizawa (fearing the fan who turned into the mob or the assassin probably), and he is writing has saved up homework indeed -- only -- it is not .
Please let people write just Mr.
Tanaka, how, and such a work, and concentrate on arusuraan etc.!
Now, if evaluation is an ordinary novelist's work, although "it will just be going to worsen it very much", the author is Mr.
Tanaka and carries out it to lower evaluation more.
[ "it being bad" or ]

2005/07/09 Very bad [Original Japanese review]
by 十兵衛改 Provider: 33768 Host:33839 Browser: 1038(Mobile)
Since 銀英伝 was interesting, although it read ...
読まなきゃ was good...
The belly is full only by one volume.
it is not got blocked -- although it also regards coming out of a word and tidying up as how it is, only such comment come out -- therefore, it is unavoidable Such a work of which it can repent violently if fun like 銀英伝 is expected.
Is evaluation such a place?

2005/07/09 Worst [Original Japanese review]
by Batou Provider: 39254 Host:39156 Browser: 5922
The leading trash in history which makes a question cherish in it being the same writer as that Galaxy epic theory.
Too much big 較差 which lies between hero kyara and the main enemy kyara says that it looks and 飽きs bored, and is called れる, or withers, or does not have a feeling of strain.
If it is only it and sees developing a bad social criticism which any context does not have kyara and can do it suddenly better, and breaking off the flow of a tale completely, there is no how to already save.
The author feels even pity for the China worship over which it passes enough to make it think that this will be written to the revenge whose China things of a series of did not sell well.
This is not the thing to read but is a thing to drink.

2005/06/23 Bad [Original Japanese review]
by Katoru Provider: 17395 Host:17456 Browser: 5234
the Mito Komon gokko -- a very well deplorable enemy -- all -- violence -- 捻じ伏せる "Right course "omake it must be -- it is uncanny that the direction of a column tells an author individual's complaint dissatisfaction like the general world's fair argument -- elapsing and being impressive -- big one chewing gum -- みたいな -- a novel ."" A brotherly cousin is perfect O 人っ su which an ideology 掛かった utterance is -- disagreeableness and always rarely exclaimed although the brother may be doing justice gokko so that he may like.

2005/06/22 Bad [Original Japanese review]
by 蒼麗 Provider: 31195 Host:31062 Browser: 4928
the thing which sells novel 創竜伝 at the illustration of CLAMP and which is not boiled too much -- I will take out -- it comes out, and is illustration guide, when a buyer is also most?
Although the 1st volume read "Although a fearful intelligible interpretation can also be performed in a certain meaning, there are no place contents of a 結 office." It is alike, and it settles down and most subsequent volumes have not attached the hand.
A hero with a strong initial value is a bakasuka victory まくる setup with a beauty form.
It tends to become the pinch occasionally or an "initial value" tends to turn into an "initial value" in the comment which -> substantial reading with weak persuasive power does not have in the place whose partner was strong.
Rather than a novel, the direction of Drama CD hears and responds, and a があった memory has it, and the media mix which became kyaradeza which is animation-ized more than it and is different from the CLAMP version completely, and which was widely different is also new.

2005/06/22 Worst [Original Japanese review]
by Morochi Provider: 7812 Host:7781 Browser: 3875
This is ?
and the trash of a doubtful like about whether it is the writing of the author who produced works, such as that Galaxy epic theory, truly.
however, series continues very well so that there may be popularity so so in why -- do you want to see?
The impression which he almost buys from habit although the mother is also reading the house.
It is one work of boring [ with a view of the world / do not feel charm at kyara, and / deployment / there is no novelty, and / are also reading story deployment and ] guarantee.

2005/06/22 Very bad [Original Japanese review]
by Rarirurero Provider: 24716 Host:24641 Browser: 6305
It repents of having bought it with this work and inertia.
Anyhow, it is not interesting at all.
A world setup is extremely random as Mr.
aesthetic appreciation じうむ's 仰る.
It is not the thing which was able to read although there was nothing very then, since the framework had not become at all.
Empathy cannot be carried out to 竜堂 4 brother at all.
Since it is drawn as 天敵 of efforts, I think that it is natural.
A feeling of dislike is felt also for the posture to which surrounding damage also riots regardless and makes damage expand.
it will be at least an illustration if it is called a good place -- it is

Post your review / Top page

Other media
Anime:Soryuden / Comics:Souryuden

ALERT: You cannot use open proxy or TOR for posting your review. If it is detected, your access to this site will be prohibited.

Rule for reviews

This site allows you to write reviews for each title, but we don't allow you to criticize others' comment. Too bad or meaningless words are also not allowed. The comment which doesn't follow the rule will be deleted. If you find any comment which doesn't follow the rule, please notify us by clicking Suggest to delete.

Example to be deleted frequently

Favorite side
You dislike this one, then don't see it or comment this title
- Please go to the fan site. Anyone has the right to say what they feel in this site.

Disliking side
Do you like this one? You are stupid.
- Your view is only your view. Please concentrate on only the content of the title, not on others' comment.

Please use only English. If not, the comment will be deleted.

Your Name(Required)

Password (Required. more than 4 characters)

Your comment about this anime(Required)

Your evaluation of this title(Required)
You can choose the evaluation only once. After you post your evaluation, please choose comment instead of evaluation from the options.

Evaluation of this title(You can choose this only once)

Best!!
Very good
Good
Normal
Bad
Very Bad
Worst

If you evaluated this title once, please choose comment instead of the evaluation.
Comment by the person who thinks this is good
Comment by the person who thinks this is normal
Comment by the person who thinks this is bad

Please choose appropriate option for readers.

Caution: Please post the evaluation which follows the rule.