2009/12/05 Very bad [Original Japanese review]
by d404me (Send message) Provider: 11211 Host:11016 Browser: 11654
The old picture was better.
The face when carrying out reaction is strange.
The contents are also thin and do not have what is transmitted at all.
2009/12/03 Very good [Original Japanese review]
by 膣 (Send message) Provider: 15570 Host:15577 Browser: 11101
I think that it is a good work.
Moreover, is it the golden tag of Mr.
Obata and Mr.
Oba?
But although desunooto is the completely different work and it was surprised at first, it is rather interesting if it reads!
The individual characters [ interesting ] and reverse-side side of an editorial department etc.
is found, and it is also a little toribia book, and does not consider, but obtains to ", and is - ｃｃ＜障.
Moreover, it is also romantic to say so, although not sympathized with the method of the love of an azuki bean and saikoo at all at first, and it is kana.
I consider recently [ ｃ ].
it sees a cartoonist's boys of a normal, and the friend's every day, and deployment has rise and fall drawing [ a thing ], and Mr.
Obata who do up at the comics which a continuation worries and raised, and Mr.
Oba think that they are uncanny I think it really great that only that does not drop the manuscript and serializes it by high skill of drawing every week although it is a weekly comics magazine!
The close is not lost from now on but it is one of the jump works in which I want you to do my best.
2009/11/30 Good [Original Japanese review]
by jumper (Send message) Provider: 14397 Host:14498 Browser: 9699
[a good point]
- which - deployment does not bore quickly -- there are high skill of drawing, an individual character tenacious a little, and room to consider many things
[a bad point]
- to which time is in riaru ｃ純 with opportunism past if only - deployment is seen -- the first impression of almost all characters is going too far
[Comprehensive evaluation]
It is reappraisement.
It is consideration although it becomes a little long before writing evaluation of these comics About two - consideration (1) -- what stimulates a reader variously primarily because a subject matter [ draw / what / these comics / a subject matter ] -- it is .
but what -- it will be -- something -- a reader seems to dance too much in these comics For example, the word "fun absolutism." Is what it is thought that has tried the reader especially in this etc.
only itself?
Since it is only an individual index in fun etc.
It is for leaving the work regarded as more people of a questionnaire being interesting.
Mr.
Oba itself -- understand it and make a person in the work say the language -- I think that it shines This is questionnaire if it is recently [ here ].
I see and feel that it is comparatively common .
its head is not only only coming about a time -- 障 -- although -- Mr.
Oba has thought that do put any special meanings and he will use language in "fun absolutism" to the index of "fun" of the reader who takes out the questionnaire.
In some cases, I want to draw and to say some also to a hand.
For example, efforts depiction.
I -> [ "it insists anyhow" as it being as collecting data /, and ] "interesting comics can be drawn" want to see -- although it is alike and a little easy expression is carried out -- actual -- being such -- immediately -- easy -- yes, has not it suited?
/ studying variety show that it is appearance in the work / consulting with someone I draw also here and think that how as a hand to catch is asked.
Since these comics become a pro's cartoonist, they regard this having thought and considered [ not passing ] as the "textbook" for drawing interesting comics being the work which is completely different.
Since the language [ ] generally itself, a "textbook", is doubtful.
I think that the textbook for becoming a pro and drawing interesting comics etc.
does not exist even if there are some which teach "hetappi comics" the foundation which is alike and draws comics to see He who wrote it even if it existed is only the talk that it was applied.
the report which has considered practically why that sold rather than it called it a textbook although there was "ape 障" -- it is 帥 if -- a cartoonist wish person's position -- "-- a tapir -- a man -- " to something -- it is going to obtain -- receiving at least to reference book " for regazing at oneself, if it becomes -- being appropriate -- it is not .
[ " ] It may be large-injured if this is kept for the reference book, furthermore how to book for succeeding something.
If the present comics industry is seen, it seems that it draws in what and the hand and the reader are partial.
Especially a boy magazine is.
Mr.
Oba seems to sue some for these comics to this present condition of the comics industry.
while these comics probably put the author's opinion and irony in their anticipation -- the success story of saikoo and shoe gin -- ∝ -- it is drawing amusingly -- what is necessary is just to carry out like this for being such works probably and drawing interesting comics, it sees, and it is expected that there is almost no positive message nature [ / nature ] - Some the meanings and intentions of "drawing saikoo and shoe gin by fingers" which Mr.
consideration (2) Hattori had said may be unexpectedly deep here.
I thought that the youngman describing the comics [ like ] which have dashed in the form where it fights while two heroes who took a farsighted view consider an ideal and an actual gap calmly until it sees these words, without seeing before recent years might be mocked.
Mr.
Oba wants to say more nearly another thing, when carrying out by accident, if it sees having indicated that however, Mr.
Hattori is drawing the two persons by "fingers." Although saikoo and others thinks well to be sure, he seems to do only the thing of what or the range which thinks too much and they can do.
Although it is also important for itselves to consider what comics can be drawn, if it is only it, mind that the husks as their cartoonist are not torn will also be carried out.
I want to also see like this a motion which searches for itself and challenges.
[ as a cartoonist ] He thinks that the conflict and preparedness which come from there what to what is priority given for whether it goes steadily whether it challenges whether reality is taken for whether itself is taken, and is omitted produce originality as a taste of a work.
how which they do like this after those comics were doing like that, when it wrote more concretely that saikoo and others was doing, and " which was alike and considered only the idea side to see -- it just said that only pursuit of secondary originality " had been carried out it is not in such touch, saying "it is drawing by fingers" -- it is Never paid versatility was said with it being this week.
Although the comics also with this interesting to be sure think that they can draw, I feel that it is difficult for becoming the signboard writer who can live on [ comics ] throughout life which saikoo and others aims at for them.
Can't the latest youngman say this, either?
even if interesting comics are missing from a normal -- the author -- pointing out -- this -- there are few people who can draw the comics which can be called This is proof with much people who are drawing by fingers.
There are some persons who cannot carry out skillful even of the fingers, skillful 篋 is called newcomer of expectation and it also carries out mind been [ mind / it ] sufficient and carried out.
it is not difficult to merely take out one's taste too -- it is it also needed to have mind highly and it repeated failure and frustration repeatedly -- there is a success by the vector previously -- considering .
However, it is difficult now to experience the failure and frustration.
Since other fellows draw the comics suitably united with the time and review popularity, while meeting and shining.
since -- it is defeated by that fellows and the same comics as are drawn Then, the writer's inherent powers are inelastic.
a result -- " -- an appearance lever becomes that the great work house which can be called genuine article " does not have less increasingly I feel that it goes into the reduction tendency rapidly by the repetition of such vicious circles for the present comics industry.
Doesn't Mr.
Oba want to point out the lowness of the overall mind?
if the fellow who did his best anyhow can draw interesting comics now or Iwase and Ishizawa look at becoming a pro and making [ it is sufficient and ] it him (Iwase is a novelist) -- something -- it seems to mock that Although it will aim with doing now as it wrote to on three that it did not get used to a signboard writer if it says what meaning those words of Mr.
Hattori have for important saikoo and shoe gin, don't you want to say that balance is not likely to have skillful ?
- I think that they are these comics that have survived for years in the evaluation jump based on consideration (1)(2) hereafter and that have dignity just because two persons draw.
Since it is the present condition of a jump, and a series to this timing, can it take also with the comics for a newcomer excavation to be sure?
However, even if the number of wish persons increases, I think it another question whether a leading newcomer comes out.
Since it thinks that this is not a textbook something as written by consideration (1).
I think that it is a stimulus.
Clearly, since love something is this comics, you see it, and does it adopt the way [ / the way ] of being drawn?
Although it is the character of saikoo and shoe gin which has a terrible discussion, does he fairly like it?
It is gazing at the difference among itself firmly, and it is likable that the posture over comics is always humble.
[ who are a rival ] [ the ages and himselves ] Does he have a feeling which extracts the power of the shoulder very much compared with desunooto as an atmosphere of the whole comics, and is drawing comics?
But introduction development turn and conclusion of the talk may be drawn too much awfully frankly just for a moment.
A rupture with Mr.
Miura is whether to have made it a little deeper.
I feel that there are some aims also here.
that to which only this will stimulate a reader if it is Mr.
Oba's character which he imagines -- -- it is -- "-- it is how -- such comics 8 -- -- " -- I see and think that they are those last who you would say [ those ] only the thing [ a thing / / a thing ] to feel, and come out and say, and would make it finish [ the uncle of saikoo has said in the 1st talk that "man of desunooto --" and the masochistic thing were also a one-shot gambler ].
Considering it, the end of these comics may be daring show wretchedly by the easy happy end.
that is, -- so far -- irony and an aim -- although many things have been guessed, [ I ] -- the sermon stink which seems to be white like this, and I cancers -- 違帥 positive message nature can hardly be taken in too Although the word "irony" has been used by this evaluation, it is the touch it is advising moderately from the place pulled 1 step in practice.
Doesn't the thing which Mr.
Oba wants to say truly have the irony further previously?
Please remember the early stages of a series here just for a moment.
-- the word "gambling" has come out And they are the point said never paid versatility [ saikoo and others said to be talented ] and the point of having said the comics which a 羃 style draws that an age is interesting.
The message turned equally to all the readers that read real intention, object currently mocked, and these comics of Mr.
Oba who can guess from these hits, such as reality which exposure of the target of living on [ comics ] throughout life, the irony with which some parts of a work were loaded and an aim, and the back situation of a jump, and the author itself have seen in the jump Whether although that fellow will be an honor student, it will be genius and it will be a genuine article, it gets used to what is aimed at is = "gambling" which is not understood unless it does to the last.
Isn't [ saying and ] it?
if it thinks right [ that ] -- "-- a tapir -- the meaning of man" -- "-- a tapir -- the comics to which it is man painter", or saikoo and others draws it on a hint -- a luck man -- like -- "bet -- a tapir -- man" -- it will see and may be the title [ / a title ]
| Post your evaluation or comment.(Evaluation can be posted only once) You need | |
| Your Name(Required): | |
| Password (Required. more than 4 characters) [If you want to create secure password: Online mkpasswd service] | |
| Your comment about this anime(Required) | |
| |
Pleaase confirm that your post is satisfing the following rules
Caution: Please post the evaluation which follows the rule. |
DB Top > Works > Comics > BakuMan.[Comics]:Review/Information
| All Reviews(Post) | Fan forum | Image&Wallpaper | Goods (Books) |
Sales top 100
| Anime(EN) | 1. Ponyo TwoDisc / 2. Astro Boy / 3. Ponyo TwoDisc / 4-100 |
| Game(EN) | 1. God of / 2. Pokemon SoulSilver / 3. Wii / 4-100 |
| Comics(EN) | 1. Warriors / 2. Warriors / 3. Twelve Kingdoms, The - Hardcov / 4-100 |
| Figure(EN) | 1. Bakugan 7 / 2. ScoobyDoo Figure / 3. Avatar Navi / 4-100 |
| Sorted by alphabet | People[Voice / Actor / Supervisor / Story / Producer / Editor / Camera / Music / Singer / Writer / Drawer] Company[Anime / Game / Comics / Book / Drama / Movie / Music / Office / Tv] / Magazine / Group / Machine |
| Sorted by related works number | People[Voice / Actor / Supervisor / Story / Producer / Editor / Camera / Music / Singer / Writer / Drawer] Company[Anime / Game / Comics / Book / Drama / Movie / Music / Office / Tv] / Magazine / Group / Machine |
| Sorted by fan number | People[Voice / Actor / Supervisor / Story / Music / Singer / Writer / Drawer] Company[Anime / Game / Comics / Book / Drama / Movie / Music / Office / Tv] / Magazine / Group / Machine |