Japanese works database(How to join/Help)
Top page: All/Only Reviews

Others
Site map

AllAnimeGameComicNovelDramaSp. effectJP movieMovie	Info:voice,game..	Reviewers	Diary
Search / Outside DB:

Comics ranking: Rank 20/in 4,124 titles (Total 240.76/Deviation 103.05) Rank 19 <= => Rank 21
Comics average points ranking: Rank 458/in 661 titles (Average 0.16(Good)/Deviation 45.94) Rank 457 <= => Rank 459 (more than 10 evaluatoin)
Comics ranking of 2004: Rank 2/in 84 titles Rank 1 <= => Rank 3

D.Gray-man(Comics)

[Other version: RSS/Japanese version]

Other media
Anime:D.Gray-man

All
Reviews(Post)

Forum

Images

Goods
(Books)

Latest Books: 2008/08/05 ():

D.Gray-man, Volume 10 $99

Books(59hit) Sales/Latest						DVD(5hit) Sales/Latest	Music(11hit) Sales/Latest	VideoGames(1hit) Sales/Latest	Toys(4hit) Sales/Latest
Rank:48161 Comic:D.Gray-man, Volume 9 Tag:$99 2008/05/06 ()	Rank:64046 Comic:D.Gray-man, Volume 4 Tag:$99 2007/02/06 ()	Rank:69537 Comic:D.Gray-man, Volume 3 Tag:$99 2006/11/21 () Eval.:***** 1.A review of D. Gray-man, vol. 3	Rank:71035 Comic:D.Gray-man, Volume 2 Tag:$99 2006/08/01 () Eval.:***** 1.A review of D. Gray-man, vol. 2	Rank:78648 Comic:D.Gray-man, Volume 8 Tag:$99 2008/02/05 ()	Rank:240728 Comic:D.Gray-man, Volume 5 Tag:$99 2007/05/01 ()	Rank:38134 Buso Renkin Box Set 1 Tag:$98 2008/04/29 () Eval.:***** 1.Not Classic But Good	Rank:7017 Audio CD:Precious Moments: Wedding Collection 2000/01/01 ()	Rank:2747 CD-ROM:Temple of Elemental Evil: A Classic Greyhawk Adventure Tag:$99 2003/09/16 () Eval.:***** 1.Not bad but I've had better.	Rank:44674 Toy:Shrek the Third Plush Set with Shrek, Donkey, Puss N Boots, Gingy, Pink Dronkey, Gray Dron... Eval.:***** 1.Shrek Plush

Information about this title

Katsura Hoshino
Weekly Boys Jump
SHUEISHA

Released:2004 in Japan

Official sites
1. http://jump.shueisha.co.jp/dgrayman/index.html (Translation)

Statics of evaluation(The statics is updated once a day)

	Average	ComicsRank	Deviation(Total)	Evaluation points(Total)	Best of the Best
Inside Japan	Good(0.16)	20	103.05	240.76	9
Outside Japan	Good(0.00)	97	41.48	0.00

Statics of activity

	Total Views	Comment	Evaluation
Inside Japan	476,696	652	436
Outside Japan	1,942	1	1

How others evaluated in Japan

Best

Very Good

Good

Normal

Bad

Very Bad

Worst

People

Percentage

14.7%

15.8%

16.1%

14.4%

15.1%

10.8%

13.1%

Added percentage

14.7%

30.5%

46.6%

61%

76.1%

86.9%

100%

Summary

46.6%

14.4%

39%

Views for recent 8 days
Total 18 17 16 15 14 13 12 11
45 4 5 3 3 5 9 9 7

Language Sorted by date Sorted by recommendation New!
English Good
(Only Evaluation) Normal
(Only Evaluation) Bad
(Only Evaluation) All
(Only Evaluation) None
Japanese Good
(Only Evaluation) Normal
(Only Evaluation) Bad
(Only Evaluation) All
(Only Evaluation) All
This reputation board

Language	Sorted by date	Sorted by recommendation New!
English	Good (Only Evaluation)	Normal (Only Evaluation)	Bad (Only Evaluation)	All (Only Evaluation)	None
Japanese	Good (Only Evaluation)	Normal (Only Evaluation)	Bad (Only Evaluation)	All (Only Evaluation)	All

2008/04/30 Normal [Edit/Delete//Only this reviewer/Only this review/post sympathy comment/]
by Love and peace Review history[Good:15(83%) Normal:3(17%) Bad:0(0%)] / Provider: 15264 Host:15441 Browser: 3008
[What is good]
I like the story and the drawing style of the beginning of the comic.

[What is bad]
I don't like the drawig style and the groomy story of this in these days.
And sometimes the comic is drawn roughly on boys weekly Jump.
I know the work of the comic writer is hard, but I hope he finish his work by making use of assistents.

[Summary]
This is the comic which I have kept reading.
In that meaning, the comic is not so bad.
But compared to the beginning of the comic, I cannot feel that the comic gets better.

Post your review / Top page

Other media
Anime:D.Gray-man

The below reviews are translated automatically from Japanese ones. To post to English version, please click here.

2008/07/18 Good [Original Japanese review]
by 努力家その一 Provider: 11601 Host:11787 Browser: 4184

[Good point]
The - religious group side and Noah side is also smart.
- 土翁 - editing, and edited by Miranda (I think that it is interesting)
[A bad point]
- A place [ there are many battles fundamentally ] - Gag does not seem to be interesting.
- The place where a battle is hard to see
[Comprehensive evaluation]
These comics are slightly delicate in themselves.
Although he liked the beginning, it does not seem to be especially interesting after edited by Edo.
Although many points worse than a good point were mentioned, since it was a honto lover at first, evaluation is good!

2008/07/11 Comment(bad) [Original Japanese review]
by Aiu Provider: 25769 Host:25829 Browser: 6520
Although said repeatedly, has this work already finished?
The latest deployment method of this work If it limits, ↓ which performs target depiction in which ↓ from which the thing which do not seethe with the body of ↓ ally which decoys a reader (a beauty form character and rinarii do not die, of course) well [ something ], and which nothing is is broken out and rescued in apparent depression deployment also truly lost something, then the gag which breaks a still good thing will be put in.
Is it の繰り返し?
first, if depression deployment is done, make it more intense -- if it becomes, although it will be a disagreeable way of speaking, it is saying [ "kill without a division partition" ] by the case of this A feeling of urgency does not come [ the leading figure ] out of one person to a death 7 きゃ tale.
Since such depiction is carried out rather, I think that a valid character shines.
And it is about the incomprehensible phenomenon which happens to the body of a view.
Such so-called convenience says and a lucky pattern is conspicuous for what the hot pattern was piled up upwards repeatedly and set.
(The hunter and it of the newest talk) It is unavoidable to be predicted at a reader, if it repeats repeatedly.
At and the last About the gag of this work a sense -- or it put in and has changed time -- carrying out -- hakkiri 言って -- it is obstructive, not to mention unnecessary 。 which should be erased immediately now Not to mention that gag provokes laughter, it rubs a reader's heart the wrong way.
Long-letter I am sorry.

2008/07/09 Comment(bad) [Original Japanese review]
by 水夏 Provider: 55977 Host:56001 Browser: 6287
When the evaluation to this work is attached before here, it attaches [ made / have you / it ] once "it is good." The time passed from that and evaluation in me also changed.
Supposing there is evaluation which present I attach to this work, it is not exactly the "worst." honest -- I think that they are the comics of a trash which come out of a word and are finished rinarii Lee, the heroine, is endless.
Although it does not know that what is necessary is just to somewhere point out, there is a problem too much, and is uza い individual the most unpleasant anyhow?
this child -- although it was not very disagreeable at the time of the first stage I thought that it was the heroine made to the normal till the time of the town of rolling [ of three volumes ] back.
The time of dragging discord with Allen in the town of rolling back by four volumes began to be caught.
"-- that -- did still angry?
Isn't it slightly vindictive?
つ -- I made it do in the neighborhood which Allen is made to notice purposely without saying clearly that it is angry, and thought いな." In five volumes, it was begun to think that a close-up of a tearful face should not be taken awfully, and gakkari(ed) to only be confused at six volumes with suuman near at hand which carried out 咎落ち.
extraordinary judgment also only kneads emotional argument 喚き handbill て駄々 to komui referred to as not being a bush umbrella -- もん .
"Don't also only blaming what alternative plan nothing and saying have too good mushi?
You call it ".
Did you come to cook?
and her who has been shocked, so that Allen does battle line secession and becomes unconscious -- seeing -- "-- it will be in a battlefield in what year -- this child thought " How much, although it is the girl of teens, there is this [ no ] at the character of battle comics.
Whenever the friend has got damaged one by one, it may be in such a state, and it can be alive until now, and is a shelf.
since it began to have done its best when only -- would conquer itself by eight volumes from しまぁ and seven volumes, although it was regarded as it growing up bordering on this [ such ] it is after nine volume -- ありゃ there is also no piece of 欠 of calmness only by appearing in a battle line in the state where there is nothing inosensu 使え, and crying cumbersome, when important, なっ, るわ, and -- unhappy appeal -- it is annoying -- じゃ to which the weakness of the head also applies a ring further and whenever [ spoiled-child ] is getting worse - or www For example, although such a combatant that has not become is just going to 瞬殺 by the enemy 50 times if this is the HxH world, it does not become such a thing by any means, but is helped by the ally after all by どまり made into a hostage at most.
even if that is not right -- being such -- only crying -- morale -- 削ぐ -- the rabbi who did it by seven volumes at once [ -- ] although the character which a friend [ like ] preaches some comes out has the precedent which said, "rinarii was able to be made to cry" and was used as the target on the other hand at the bad fellow Although a character called ruberie appears in others by the auditor of the Vatican, depiction called cruel human being is made with やたら only by saying [ carrying out that it is dangerous with the situation whether religious group headquarters is made to destroy completely by the enemy or it is carried out to rinarii in spite of having said the fair argument, however it may see ].
In short, it is "the character which does not indulge rinarii is wrong generally" in this world.
As for the spectacle which has applied total energy to characters all indulging the heroine it being the situation that butter butter 殺 of the ally is carried out, only 失笑 leaks.
And it divides and it was disgusted that the sad shout of the death of anita and the ghostly girl who fell victim in the human body experiment of a past religious group was made into dashi of rinariimansee depiction.
なぁぁ -- "-- dear -- it cannot elapse and refuse -- it is " -- "-- I will say -- it says -- I will stop -- it is " Judging from these things, the author seems to be interested only in already drawing "tragic heroine rinarii." し [ the treatment of other characters is neglectful in using mind for the conformity of the talk just because it is occupied with her ].
The situation that even a hero's activity is recently pushed on the heroine's psychological description.
It is teema って何 of this work and is っけ the bottom.
Tragedy of "war.
", "relief." Isn't that the author wants to draw in "the tragedy of rinarii, and relief"?
Isn't [ that this author only wants to say or to only carry out tragic drunkenness to put it bluntly and ] it?
I want to pray what because my heart is wild cannot consider so.
It is anger of a reason although it is all kinds of insult and abuse somehow, and it was a work favorite at first.
Please allow.

2008/06/27 Comment(bad) [Original Japanese review]
by 夏野 Provider: 4899 Host:4992 Browser: 3875

[A bad point]
The talk carries out for a long time, and is, zatsui and ugly - talk dislike [ - picture ], and it is
[comprehensive evaluation]
.
On the whole, it is the work which is not interesting.
Although a picture often hears about zatsui that the picture of Mr.
Hoshino is beautiful, I do not so like it.
It was very ugly at the time of saw, and stopped looking at it not much in jump our journal first.
Although the voice actor likes the animation, he does not so like a character.

2008/06/23 Best! [Original Japanese review]
by Rizu Provider: 3260 Host:3358 Browser: 7282
The picture of Mr.
Hoshino which a picture regards as skillful い is very delicate, for example, its character regarded as a real feeling being in the rose crossing and building which are attached to team dress very is also individual.
D.
Although it may say and Gray-man may be also in the one more じゃな [ not much liking ] to say, I like it.
It is aiding from now on.

2008/06/22 Worst [Original Japanese review]
by Rokishii Provider: 9785 Host:9743 Browser: 6034
honest, although evaluation that there is atmosphere, interesting at with personality [ a character ] and the beginning is often heard -- it cannot sympathize at all It is boring from the beginning.
It is the opinion of an I individual to まぁ bitter taste.
Does he like all people of coupling 厨?
It is troubled with an understanding.

2008/06/16 Very bad [Original Japanese review]
by Kanchi Provider: 46001 Host:46080 Browser: 6342
There was atmosphere, it was good also at the picture, the character also stood, and the first direction also regarded the cover as their being good and great comics (about the 3rd talk).
However, as the talk progressed gradually, and boro had come out, it failed rapidly.
it is suuman dark のく that especially it became remarkable -- it is り and he stopped subscription at the time What do you want do make the character which the reader who is not even if it comes out suddenly until now does not know run recklessly, and to carry out?
If you want to pull sympathy, you should take out from before more.
Although having elaborated on the talk before the series is good, it ぜ - sees and the busyness of the series to which neta goes out and which will be rich shows た [ a thing / thinking in the talk etc.
and not shining ] well.
It changes constantly, so that a pattern also becomes irritated, and in quest of seriousness, it has become a dark talk vainly violently.
Do you want to come again?

2008/06/14 Comment(normal) [Original Japanese review]
by k林 Provider: 26612 Host:26715 Browser: 6520

[Good point]
Every exorcist's individuality is characteristic and thinks that it is interesting.

[a bad point]
-- or [ that who is merely where at the time of fighting ] -- a few -- understanding ずらい -- かなぁ - Considering very たり ...

[Comprehensive evaluation]
A picture is also nice and the talk is also interesting.

2008/06/09 Very bad [Original Japanese review]
by goodday0220 Provider: 40360 Host:40264 Browser: 6395
Anew so to speak, I regard this work as the wasteful work.
Although it thinks that neither a story nor a character is bad, a picture is too soft too, the first stage carries out peculiar, and さ cannot obtain 失くしてしまう.
For example, although what was necessary was just to have been the work which individuality comes out, and a picture finally becomes peculiar, and is drawn quite pleasantly as the talk progressed, although it was soft at first to the comics みたい "king dorobou JING", after not carrying this work, the picture soft-elapsed, peculiar [ of it ] was carried out and さ has lost it.
Now, it is so severe that it can say that it was not clear anymore whether the place of where of a battle is interesting.
Although this work was expected when it read at first, the mind which will be read if the latest jump is read has faded away.
It is a very regrettable work.

2008/06/09 Comment(good) [Original Japanese review]
by Toro Provider: 16466 Host:16326 Browser: 4855

[Good point]
- picture is the width of the individuality, charm, and nationality of the psychological description and each character of beautiful and a character.

[Bad point]
The touch of the gag insertion and the picture in - battle scene changes (especially per ten volumes is).

[Comprehensive evaluation]
He likes deployment of an overall story individually [ it is interesting and ].
I consider [ that the talk which shifted somewhat whether he would forget a setup of the purpose and the original character which fight with AKUMA at the time of the beginning from the contents is increasing, and ].
In Mr.
Hoshino, I think that I want fresh spirit on the contrary to remember the contents of this tale, and the deployment which should progress.
But it thinks that these comics are the appearance of a character, individuality, and the charm that the width of nationality does not have in others, either, and since the gag into which it is put was also interesting as it is, although it was called the bad point, I at least am not worried.
Rather, the direction of a serious ばっ loan reads and it is て飽きる -- However, since I want you to go ahead with the talk after reading the tempo of comics, and air (is it called atmosphere?) on that occasion to a slight degree and thinking thoroughly, I consider [ that that is just going to improve and ].
it is what although many things were carried out now [ word ] -- it bit -- it comes out and D gure is a favorite work Therefore, improving more and wanting to make an interesting work is.
Mr.
Hoshino support is given and it is ますっ!

2008/06/08 Comment(good) [Original Japanese review]
by Natsume Provider: 24938 Host:24751 Browser: 4317
D gure is said in pakuri of hagaren etc.
-- it got to know for the first time the opinion in the direction of ↓ -- I think that it is reasonable truly, where is alike -- it is Since I like it D gure, although it continues reading still more, only some pictures have a worrisome portion.
gocha ついてる気 takes [ a picture ] recently somehow.
I write finely and think that it is crowded too much.
I like the picture per 7 or 8 volumes.
Since it has settled down and has applied carefully.
Although it read over recently and being considered, the first stage of a story is more interesting.
Mr.
Hoshino who made that world is sugoi.
The beginning and something have changed now.
Is the story brighter?
Well, the place of Lvr4 is different for a while again.
Future carries out comfort to it and there is also a point wholly.
Is mainly it the secret of a character?
It is [ when and ] pleasure about whether you explain.
I think that you may see on the whole.
Story deployment is loading future with expectation.
Do you continue wanting to read still more?

2008/06/08 Very good [Original Japanese review]
by kana=Clownlord Provider: 12867 Host:12635 Browser: 4184

[Good point]
I think that - picture is beautiful.
- He likes a character individually.

[Bad point]
Dark さ in early stages of - should be lost.

[Comprehensive evaluation]
About the problem of the pattern struck variously, I think that mind outside is good the place which has changed suddenly.
I think that it has changed in the direction for every cartoonist to change in a pattern etc.
and see from sushi and me.
it is called dark さ -- it is -- to be sure, it is regrettable that the early view of the world is lost However, since we cannot do [ writing a day gray man etc.
and ] and the method of comrades cannot be done, either, it needs to be enduringly given by Mr.
Hoshino.
Although it seems that there are many opinions that it is pakuri of hagaren, it does not know where is pakuri.
in whole set 読ん, ます sees in the similar point etc.
and does not hit Please do not say such opinion before being able to say where へん are pakuri perfectly.
Probably almost all men will have heard and struck rumor.
...
It is [ or / possibly a hagaren hero's hairstyle is resembling Allen ].
Does it know in which the comics character which is carrying out the hairstyle of a middle reason is?
the person whom a day gray man likes anyhow -- 毛頭 -- it is sufficient [ how ] Although it was favorite, for the first time in [ latest / inactivation ] was considered, and one evaluation was lowered.
Mr.
Hoshino -- please do your best It is aiding.

2008/06/07 Worst [Original Japanese review]
by 鼠 Provider: 34156 Host:34024 Browser: 2067

[Good point]
Story by which it can be impressed to - six volume [ about ]
[Bad point]
It has deviated from the theme called - war which - picture with which the character of a character carries gag into upheaval and a serious scene compared with the early stages of - when the dissolution of - hint is not obtained seldom looks at.

[Comprehensive evaluation]
Although impression was carried out at the time of the first stage in the talk of rara, or Miranda and suuman, I feel recently that there is much deployment which tilts a head.
Is the next deployment gag saying that the religious group was attacked and many friends died?
Isn't important character mind outside said anyhow?
and, and hair growing or becoming a vampire たり -- honestly -- a boss -- it is deployment [ becoming small / pull ] [ becoming 猫語 ] First of all, he can understand [ why was the earl beaten, and was the world saved, or has it said, and such medicine is developed and ].
It says and plays.
overtime work -- is it る?
Although it is lying idle, using "war" as a mouth would like you, as for this, to stop it once, although it seems that "war" is a theme.
It draws too much and is unpleasant so that he may like the author.
Since I want you to be closed early, evaluation is the worst.

2008/06/03 Worst [Original Japanese review]
by カジキマグロ2世 Provider: 55727 Host:55758 Browser: 7931

[Good point]
Nothing.

[Bad point]
After-mentioned.

[Comprehensive evaluation]
It is serialized by the boy magazine.
That is a problem.
They are gay comics however it may see.
Although it came to see the comics which boys make friends with by the boy magazine recently, it will be in one.
Although the picture was nice, it is coarse in the steps lower part the first stage.
A battle scene something does not understand at all what is carried out.
Are there any setup and design which often exist to the extent that it is unavoidable to tell it pakuri and plagiarism?
Does it seem that there are many fans without character although it is one sorry to after fans?
"D.
The fellow who does gure criticism has the memory called " in 氏.
Although don't read is said if disagreeable, if you buy the jump, it will surely go into an eye.
It prays ending at an early stage.
And it expects that hot new boys' comics are serialized.

2008/05/30 Very good [Original Japanese review]
by Kikona Provider: 23597 Host:23360 Browser: 5718

[Good point]
A picture is beautiful.
Characters are attractive.

[Bad point]
Deployment of the talk felt a few early.
I think that I wanted you to consider deployment of the talk calmly.

[Comprehensive evaluation]
Since it is a favorite work fundamentally, they are "and good ".

2008/05/27 Comment(bad) [Original Japanese review]
by 韋駄天 Provider: 26499 Host:26335 Browser: 5234
it is more alike and, therefore, characters are [ long hair, or うさ耳, child-izing or words ] all biohazards "nyaa" and the end in our journal -- it is ...
Doesn't it carry out selfish too much rather?
Please give such a thing even to the end of a book of a comic as fan service liking.
Since there is no opportunity to meet independently if it is it, and the complaint beginning cannot be found.
Now, it is a bad nature member.
if it sees from whether only どん will be aimed at and the concept of a boy magazine -- yet -- と -- the direction of らぶる -- a little -- or -- it is mashi (although evaluation is the worst) They are not the contents which should be done in our journal at least.
(A jump is not the author's free book individually.) It is very unpleasant.
Evaluation is the worst.
It is it if the worst in the worst is given.

2008/05/24 Good [Original Japanese review]
by 夜純 Provider: 27927 Host:28109 Browser: 4926

[Good point]
- feeling expression in which - picture is well and which has performed a setup of the individuality of - character (words, expression)
[Bad point]
gyagu っぽい絵 in - battle scene which does not have stability in - picture
[Comprehensive evaluation]
I regard the picture of Mr.
Hoshino as skillful い.
It is not necessarily too macho and is not a stick.
I think that designs, such as team dress, may also be elaborate.
However, if it often sees, it is slightly regrettable that the place which is different compared with omission or last week may come out.
It was surprised that the picture has changed extremely, and I like after, before changing.

2008/05/22 Good [Original Japanese review]
by huwa Provider: 13340 Host:13200 Browser: 5533
Although per [ eight volumes to ] ten volumes was good, I feel that skill of drawing has fallen recently.
After and an enemy become strong too much at an increasing tempo, and it is だ.
I consider that it is [ to say ] better to have exceeded and to strengthen gradually with growth of a friend's character.
In a character, it is shocking for the hair of rinarii to have been burned and to have become a crop.
He liked the individually longer one.
And past [ crossing marshal strength ].
Although it is a marshal, when a level is too different from Allen and others too much how much, there is a possibility that it may become impossible to play an active part.
But D gure is one of the worried works.
A story is becoming interesting recently.
It expects at future.
Evaluation is good at the reason for saying.

2008/05/15 Good [Original Japanese review]
by 露蝶 Provider: 50846 Host:51035 Browser: 5234

[Good point]
A picture is beautiful!
A character setup is superior!

[a bad point]
-- not carrying out -- うしーん -- in a jumble -- flood い

2008/05/14 Best! [Original Japanese review]
by Natsume Provider: 24938 Host:24751 Browser: 4317

[Good point]
A picture is nice.
A character is smart.
The place where the design of dress is elaborate is also good.

[Bad point]
A story progresses and it has become free battle comics.
Although the character of rinarii itself is not kirai, it has made a mistake in how to use a character.

[comprehensive evaluation]
-- it is -- it bit -- although said -- me -- D gure 大っ -- he likes So, it is very regrettable that the talk is gotagota.
It aids from now on and is the "highest."

Next / Post your review / Top page

Other media
Anime:D.Gray-man

ALERT: You cannot use open proxy or TOR for posting your review. If it is detected, your access to this site will be prohibited.

Rule for reviews

This site allows you to write reviews for each title, but we don't allow you to criticize others' comment. Too bad or meaningless words are also not allowed. The comment which doesn't follow the rule will be deleted. If you find any comment which doesn't follow the rule, please notify us by clicking Suggest to delete.

Example to be deleted frequently

Favorite side
You dislike this one, then don't see it or comment this title
- Please go to the fan site. Anyone has the right to say what they feel in this site.

Disliking side
Do you like this one? You are stupid.
- Your view is only your view. Please concentrate on only the content of the title, not on others' comment.

Please use only English. If not, the comment will be deleted.

Your Name(Required)

Password (Required. more than 4 characters)

Your comment about this anime(Required)

Your evaluation of this title(Required)
You can choose the evaluation only once. After you post your evaluation, please choose comment instead of evaluation from the options.

Evaluation of this title(You can choose this only once)

Best!!
Very good
Good
Normal
Bad
Very Bad
Worst

If you evaluated this title once, please choose comment instead of the evaluation.
Comment by the person who thinks this is good
Comment by the person who thinks this is normal
Comment by the person who thinks this is bad

Please choose appropriate option for readers.

Caution: Please post the evaluation which follows the rule.