[a bad point]
-- heroine: -- past [ rinarii appearance ] At a thing with few women, it is in a religious group.
Everybody, a religious group, loves rinarii too much and is unpleasant.
it can do too much by it being gentle, being dear, being strong, and coming out It cannot sympathize.
He likes Miranda the place.
It favors too much and is .
(Heart which is the key of the talk) I feel that rinarii is protected beyond necessity at the time of LV4.
The time [ volume / on 壕 ] of a headquarters attack was tight at such a thing.
although it was very good, it stuck out too far and came out, charm was felt at the time in early stages of rinarii, and became that there is nothing Picture: Change too much.
[Comprehensive evaluation]
Although the talk is extremely good, it drags the mystery for every character too much, and it is .
("That man" of Kanda, and a rabbi's eyepatch) It gets tired.
2010/01/06 Comment(good) [Original Japanese review]
by sumire (Send message) Provider: 17740 Host:17660 Browser: 6296
[a good point]
-- ｃ is also good at * picture -- it is -- it is -- !
, especially Allen
[Bad point]
Although it is *, especially what, 19 volumes and the talk per 17 volumes are not known well.
[Comprehensive evaluation]
* Since D gure was "suki" from the first, I will make evaluation into the highest (^0^)/
2010/01/04 Normal [Original Japanese review]
by Noerunoeru (Send message) Provider: 9600 Host:9335 Browser: 5697
[Good point]
Fineness, such as a pattern Individuality of character each of, such as a story Talk to five volumes Rapid change of a 14th Allen's existence
[bad point]
pattern The 3rd exorcist plan A feeling of tension called war is being lost recently.
The dead human being is not harnessed (-- battle scenes, such as anita, are unclear.).
[Comprehensive evaluation]
It was a talk interesting to the highest in the beginning.
It is an unclear talk gradually.
(He liked individually the red Mull neighborhood to the week.) The improvement in future is wished.
Evaluation should do its best by the "normal."
2010/01/04 Very bad [Original Japanese review]
by VICE (Send message) Provider: 18498 Host:18662 Browser: 6208
[Good point]
rinarii in early stages of [, such as the 14th mystery which the whole family's of existence of AKUMA and Noah's setting hero has, ] a double track, crossing, character nature of komui
[a bad point]
-- all good points -- the opening of the period like 荀 -- a style -- it is the typical pattern meaning royal road of the comics which become worse and worse as the amusingness
[comprehensive evaluation]
early stages of rinarii's and others speech and conduct come after the good part, in spite of illustrating changing and being a lot of pakuri doubt (to the extent that it is said whether to be trace) war [ like ]
2009/12/17 Best! [Original Japanese review]
by zhcn (Send message) Provider: 26090 Host:26268 Browser: 15683
[a good point]
-- obtaining -- one Allen -- a 帥 setup is good
[A bad point]
is delicate.
[Comprehensive evaluation]
It is the highest.
2009/12/15 Best! [Original Japanese review]
by muwlove (Send message) Review history[Good:2(100%) Normal:0(0%) Bad:0(0%)] / Provider: 32128 Host:32073 Browser: 11528
[Good point]
Flow of - character, and the high skill of drawing, high battle scene, and talk
[Bad point]
- stop of publishing
[Comprehensive evaluation]
It is extremely interesting.
Since he likes a pattern and a character, please do your best.
2009/12/06 Worst [Original Japanese review]
by Guraton (Send message) Provider: 18633 Host:18455 Browser: 2706
[Good point]
"The author's ability" which makes "material
[bad point]
" story which constitutes a story the place through which it looked in since the maximum new publication had come out -- an author comment -- "-- the direction which considered that it was closed by it, and I'm sorry The comment of having thought that he was also closed" was carried out.
This cannot be allowed as the author's attitude any longer.
They are other people's affairs too much.
Although it was written that it was sick, should not it apologize to a reader in space formally at once?
At least a reason should explain why the magazine which carries the article changed why edit was not carried until now, either.
If it thinks [ better than before ] whether to be being able to do once it rested so far - The purpose of action does not understand a - ally [ to which a flow cannot follow gudaguda and acceleration past 荅 because of the useless gag into which what has happened by gochagocha, or 1 top 1 top is from , and is inserted on - serious scene ], and enemy side.
and very poor contents.
since the magazine which carries the article changed moreover -- a comic price price increase -- it is It is it a mystery to make no less than 460 yen such a thing truly.
The face of a character has also changed considerably.
How to apply a color also changed.
If character description is not obtained, there are some persons who do not understand who it is.
At least in it, the pattern is changing.
How far does a fan say he can follow now?
Even if it takes endurance of the past into consideration, evaluation is taken as the "worst."
2009/12/01 Comment(normal) [Original Japanese review]
by Poroporo (Send message) Provider: 24985 Host:25081 Browser: 14203
[Good point]
A picture is polite and very nice.
The deployment with every individual and interesting (especially rabbi) character which is not thought of is developed.
A background is very nice.
[a bad point]
-- completely -- -- there is nothing, so that you may say
[Comprehensive evaluation]
With everybody's opinion, a picture is becoming more skillful and more skillful in things.
1 top 1 top of a picture is polite, and readable.
I am pleasant to read without considering anything.
The aura which has come out clearly as although it otherwise is not accepted is different.
(Touch kana which rises up.)
2009/11/28 Worst [Original Japanese review]
by (卒 鐔) (Send message) Provider: 25819 Host:25879 Browser: 7843
Although it is bad to fans, these comics cannot be allowed truly.
Since it is plagiarism comics.
In the character which appears, characters, such as a trip of kino, try cancer, and a code age, are plagiarized.
Moreover, a battle scene also exists in others to the offensive method and the defensive method to other comics and the portion which hardly changes.
It is not believable that such comics can be seen and enjoyed (the direction which does not know a plagiarism situation is another).
Although there are also many stops of publishing recently, it is a pa O sake by no means!?
It is looking, and it is unpleasant and cannot allow any longer.
Is it until it will also close a moment, if there is no neta made personally?
Evaluation is out of the question.
2009/11/23 Worst [Original Japanese review]
by Boruga (Send message) Provider: 26120 Host:26214 Browser: 7898
[Good point]
Allen's personal character.
A setup called an exorcist and akuma.
There are many people good for an ally.
[Bad point]
It gochagocha and is hard to see a battle scene.
On the whole, it is too heavy.
Unpleasant [ an enemy side is calm and confident to the ally shedding large tears by van van 罩祉, and ], since the gag face is announced.
An enemy is too strong and there is no margin in an ally too much.
An always heavy atmosphere flows, and looks and gets tired.
Gag is not interesting.
Since a serious scene is forcibly thrust in the talk based on [, such as a reckless run of komurin, and a phantom disturbance, ] gag, balance is bad.
It has been an atmosphere heavy after all.
The picture is poor rapidly.
Comical [, such as teiki Mick, ] feel sick on the contrary.
[Comprehensive evaluation]
It is limited although it is the theme of how much tragic contents.
It is merely too heavy.
Since only an enemy is comical and the is overwhelmingly strong, no hope can also be found out.
2009/11/14 Good [Original Japanese review]
by 藪@鴻 (Send message) Provider: 34156 Host:34039 Browser: 2054(Mobile)
[Good point]
Early skill of drawing.
An early story.
View of the world.
Title <-
[Bad point]
Although various fine things are thought of, it is "character collapse which is more wicked than anything."
[General comment]
Strange comics of falling rapidly whenever skill of drawing passes through a series.
in order [ the ] to "beat an earl for" 1000 years, when making a tale [ say / "collecting inosensu" ], although it is natural, the "purpose" is carrying out clearly -- applying and coming out, the principal axis of a story is solid A Gothic view of the world new in a jump.
Many attractive characters were also in the ally side also at the enemy side, and the "sense" of the authors, such as a design of the arms for AKUMA, was demonstrated more than enough.
The character of the attractive character is [ ...., however ] collapse feeling to a regrettable thing.
- it must have been Allen (gentlemanly, dupe, hypocrite) - Kanda (cool-headedness, hostile duty principle) - rabbi (person easily elated, to the last neutrality) - rinarii (friend thought with a strong belief) -- Allen must have had with "people the belief " which saves AKUMA -- the depiction which cut Noah and AKUMA merciless and has minced them is widely different from the thing of "saving" -- it should carry out and Kanda must be a serious character -- gag (?) Halfway rather than it calls it the neutrality which considers an ally and feels in any way that it passes for it although it came to be taken out mostly and a rabbi should be in the position of neutrality of Noah and an exorcist.
Now, she who suited the position which rinarii has the first problem child and the sturdy heart, and is not protected, but is kept is princess treatment.
The depiction which begins to shed tears one by one is already seen, and does not shine.
If it was at the time of the first stage, the "highest" evaluation was given rightly.
Though regrettable, I want to estimate "It is good" by the present stage based on it.
A work regrettable to 祉.
2009/11/11 Very bad [Original Japanese review]
by Mr.Burns (Send message) Provider: 22433 Host:22389 Browser: 7345
[Good point]
It is new for a view-of-the-world jump, and a fantasy color is [ Gothically ] deep.
New [ hear / seldom / a setup called an exorcist and ].
Although it was that, he was surprised the first stage recently [ skill-of-drawing ] to be written in carefully and finely.
That level is a taking-its-hat-off thing by weekly series.
[a bad point]
-- the heroine -- this -- the place where this work is the worst -- the heroine's girl -- raising -- passing -- coming out -- other characters -- air The heart Mr.
Hoshino of whose is the key of a work in the thing which this child likes very much, and omnipotent is [ her and other characters ] also a heroine favorite and deployment just like harem comics.
Although [ which has become disagreeable because of a self-satisfied favor of the author at first although it was the most favorite character ] it is dear, it is with much trouble ...
It was good at the character beginning.
but the above-mentioned heroine -- raising -- coming out -- charm -- a reduction by half No matter where Mr.
plagiarism problem crossing's gun and a partner's woman may see how from, there is much what has also seen try cancer and the background of a picture something by somewhere somehow.
Although it thinks that many persons who consider the same thing are also in the world, I can think only paku ｃ, even if it sees the utterance of the author's past etc.
For a stop-of-publishing magnate's cartoonist not being published, about her, this is a first series although it can still allow.
impolite, although it is also in those who are drawing, even if sent to hospital -- although it is an island sink in Jump SQ after all
[Comprehensive evaluation]
It is spoilt just because a special setup and a special view of the world push only one person's character.
Someone does not understand [ a hero ] any longer, either.
Even the sign of drawing is not felt although there are also many non-collected hints.
This is a commercial work to the last, and I want a reader's thing to think more.
If the heroine wants to draw so much, I want you to do by the member.
2009/11/11 Comment(normal) [Original Japanese review]
by 絮怨21 (Send message) Provider: 19847 Host:19733 Browser: 6794(Mobile)
It is a comment in the time of reading one volume.
[a good point]
--
[comprehensive evaluation]
without - force without the place which may be outstanding in addition to bad a
[point]
and with sufficient - picture and sufficient atmosphere -- to be sure, a picture and atmosphere are good However, if not alike other than this, a thing without the place from which you may escape is painful.
Although well compared with hagaren, I feel that it is impolite to be compared with a work whose masterpiece of an adventure fantasy sells well only with such a picture.
Since evaluation can be read, it is common.
| Post your evaluation or comment.(Evaluation can be posted only once) You need
| |
| Your Name(Required): | |
| Password (Required. more than 4 characters) [If you want to create secure password: Online mkpasswd service] | |
| Your comment about this anime(Required) | |
| |
Pleaase confirm that your post is satisfing the following rules
Caution: Please post the evaluation which follows the rule. |
DB Top > Works > Comics > D.Gray-man[Comics]:Review/Information
| All Reviews(Post) | Fan forum | Image&Wallpaper | Goods (Books) |
| Other media Anime:D.Gray-man |
Sales top 100
| Anime(EN) | 1. Ponyo TwoDisc / 2. Astro Boy / 3. Ponyo TwoDisc / 4-100 |
| Game(EN) | 1. God of / 2. Pokemon SoulSilver / 3. Wii / 4-100 |
| Comics(EN) | 1. Warriors / 2. Warriors / 3. Twelve Kingdoms, The - Hardcov / 4-100 |
| Figure(EN) | 1. Bakugan 7 / 2. ScoobyDoo Figure / 3. Avatar Navi / 4-100 |
| Sorted by alphabet | People[Voice / Actor / Supervisor / Story / Producer / Editor / Camera / Music / Singer / Writer / Drawer] Company[Anime / Game / Comics / Book / Drama / Movie / Music / Office / Tv] / Magazine / Group / Machine |
| Sorted by related works number | People[Voice / Actor / Supervisor / Story / Producer / Editor / Camera / Music / Singer / Writer / Drawer] Company[Anime / Game / Comics / Book / Drama / Movie / Music / Office / Tv] / Magazine / Group / Machine |
| Sorted by fan number | People[Voice / Actor / Supervisor / Story / Music / Singer / Writer / Drawer] Company[Anime / Game / Comics / Book / Drama / Movie / Music / Office / Tv] / Magazine / Group / Machine |