Japanese works database(How to join/Help)
Top page: All/Only Reviews

Others
Site map


Search / Outside DB:

Comics ranking: Rank 66/in 4,176 titles (Total 95.04/Deviation 69.87) Rank 65 <= => Rank 67
Comics average points ranking: Rank 82/in 675 titles (Average 1.92(Very good)/Deviation 60.65) Rank 81 <= => Rank 83 (more than 10 evaluatoin)
Comics ranking of 2000: Rank 3/in 74 titles Rank 2 <= => Rank 4

Dorabase Doraemon Super-baseball Anecdote(Comics)

[Other version: RSS/Japanese version]

All
Reviews(Post)

Forum

Images

Information about this title

Shintaro Mugiwara
SHOGAKUKAN
Monthly Corocoro

Released:2000/09 in Japan

Statics of evaluation(The statics is updated once a day)

	Average	ComicsRank	Deviation(Total)	Evaluation points(Total)	Best of the Best
Inside Japan	Very good(1.92)	66	69.87	95.04	2

Statics of activity

	Total Views	Comment	Evaluation
Inside Japan	27,906	38	37
Outside Japan	581	0	0

How others evaluated in Japan

Best

Very Good

Good

Normal

Bad

Very Bad

Worst

People

Percentage

35.1%

45.9%

8.1%

5.4%

0.0%

2.7%

Added percentage

35.1%

81%

89.1%

94.5%

97.2%

100%

Summary

89.1%

5.4%

Views for recent 8 days
Total 28 27 26 25 24 23 22 21
11 2 1 1 1 1 0 2 3

Language Sorted by date Sorted by recommendation New!
English Good
(Only Evaluation) Normal
(Only Evaluation) Bad
(Only Evaluation) All
(Only Evaluation) None
Japanese Good
(Only Evaluation) Normal
(Only Evaluation) Bad
(Only Evaluation) All
(Only Evaluation) All
This reputation board

Language	Sorted by date	Sorted by recommendation New!
English	Good (Only Evaluation)	Normal (Only Evaluation)	Bad (Only Evaluation)	All (Only Evaluation)	None
Japanese	Good (Only Evaluation)	Normal (Only Evaluation)	Bad (Only Evaluation)	All (Only Evaluation)	All

Post your review / Top page

The below reviews are translated automatically from Japanese ones. To post to English version, please click here.

2008/05/29 Good [Original Japanese review]
by Torakichi Provider: 2100 Host:2241 Browser: 5234

[a good point]
-- a character is dear -- legible It is intelligible.

[Comprehensive evaluation]
The place referred to as being able to use ひ 3 tool is interesting.
By setup which is not in other baseball comics, I think that it is interesting.
Although it seems to be for children, doesn't it close age 問わず楽?
A picture is legible, and the scene of a game is powerful and thinks that it is smart.
He has a feeling called baseball comics also with a readable woman.
The past episode etc.
is in every character, and the thought to everybody's baseball was transmitted and impressed.

2008/05/28 Best! [Original Japanese review]
by Kimutake Provider: 16046 Host:16076 Browser: 6395
In korokoro, I think that it is the highest result.
It is good that the interesting portion is also contained in some places.
魔球 of W ball was good.
(Kana whose Q ball was slightly delicate) merely -- yet -- whom -- man -- must killing -- since there are not people with the 技みたいな thing -- one someone -- a grade thinks kana - which must not be (The work which carried out the human detached building is disagreeable) I am also animation-ized hope.
It is waging war with shiro at least...

2008/05/08 Very good [Original Japanese review]
by ちょなすSP Provider: 24194 Host:24076 Browser: 4184

[Good point]
A character has rich individuality respectively and is interesting.
the scene greatly using the top with a sufficient parenthesis of the scene struck or given up -- a thing -- it is dear that tora which is very powerful is always smiling (It also becomes a occasionally hen face) Cheevy is dear at a natural character.
It is quite bibitt た when a ton ball is hit!
The shadow of tin is thin somehow.
But that is good again.
so much -- a shadow -- although it thinks that it is not thin ..
The kime てて parenthesis of eemondo is always good for a period of treatment!?
kuro is always nature 見せていて ii.
hyoro is always positive and paku which is always doing its best is dear at 太っちょ.
HR in a emoru game is too great, and it is 。.
It is interesting that the head is always being blown away by pyoko.
It is extended ひろしが and he likes the character of たっぽい shiro.
Although it is cool, there is also easy toko.

[Bad point]
A game will always be decided in HR of kuro.
Any characters other than kuro and eemondo can seldom be struck.
If it takes out at any rate, I will want you to appear in Doraemon more.
Early shiro is fearful ...

[Comprehensive evaluation]
It is "very good." In てん and a う虫 comic, I think that they are quite good comics.

2008/05/04 Very good [Original Japanese review]
by Agato Provider: 29382 Host:29389 Browser: 7797(Mobile)
(Good point) Game deployment is hot!
kuro えもん and shiro えもん fighting is interesting.
There are many attractive characters.
(Bad point) The place which the conclusion of a game always finishes as a home run.
World 大会偏 is mannerism just for a moment.
The deployment after world 大会偏 is expected.
It is as good as evaluation.

2007/11/26 Normal [Original Japanese review]
by Medaru Provider: 7316 Host:7541 Browser: 4184
Although that is right, it is touch with many popular systems that it is not too bad as me.
In the latest korokoro, I think that it is quite good also by まぁ.
It is a nostalgic work, when he reads quite to a front and remembers たころ.
(It does not read and become precocious now) To be sure, the situation of a game was also good.
し [ passionate one was also in the character ].
However, a genre is delicate whether it is a sport.
The ball to throw is visible only to action work.
It is likely to swerve, when hitting the ball.
since -- "perfect baseball comics" is good -- not becoming precocious .
Even if it does not carry out derivation of Doraemon to one more ......
however -- a while ago -- も言った -- in korokoro, it is the quite better one like However, there is that [ no ] and I regard that it is action 技みたい to a slight degree as realistic as it is better to reduce.
Since he likes the baseball comics already carried out perfectly just for a moment, it may be that this work did not suit itself.
Evaluation is "common." Incidentally I like baseball.
I am sorry to be a poor writing.

2007/08/06 Very good [Original Japanese review]
by Dorimaa Provider: 11920 Host:11849 Browser: 4184
In korokoro, it is outstanding.
The contents are royal road supo solutions.
Illustrating is also stable.
Although 魔球 which cannot exist also comes out, since it is the view of the world which cannot exist from the first, I think that a certain grade can allow.
It is the work which can be constantly enjoyed to only purity then.
But since it is not like [ which is called the highest ], either, evaluation is "very good."

2007/08/02 Very good [Original Japanese review]
by 濁流の魔手 Provider: 18500 Host:18655 Browser: 4184
the well-known trash said constantly -- the inside of a group play -- it is -- only -- an honest work About illustrating There is especially no complaint.
Probably, there is no skillful いといって inconvenience in korokoro.
Since the fine place is not neglected upwards and the tone is also used seriously, there is a difference of heavens and the ground in a "miracle ball" etc.
Be related with kyara.
Especially a complaint does not have this, either.
I think that attractive kyara is equal also to the enemy also at the view.
While a design has not broken down a view of the world, either, there is width, and since it is interesting, I think that it is very very well.
Be related with a story.
I think in korokoro that it is the result of the highest peak.
Although an unreal scene is conspicuous using ひ 3 tool etc.
as supo solution comics, since the world is the world, it can see leniently.
It is drawn very attractively [ growth or efforts ].
[ in / the baseball of a useless robot, Hiroshi and others / in contents ] a time -- a たま appearance -- I also regard 魔球 to carry out as there being many interesting things However, since he has a feeling with slightly one-track how to finish a game, it very regrets there.
Even if it sees a Mister element, in korokoro, it is an excellent work.
It is based on the above thing and evaluation is "very good."

2007/07/30 Good [Original Japanese review]
by 虚構の旅人 Provider: 19636 Host:19755 Browser: 6287
Signboard comics of korokoro.
Are these comics interesting to runaway one in a comic constantly?
To the last, the inside of korokoro Is the way of thinking that a secret tool can be used the way of thinking of the baseball no one but of the future?
Thereby, pleasure which is different from free baseball comics for a while was completed.
Are the deployment and the breaking pitch which cannot exist also tidied up at a word of since it is the world of Doraemon also in ""?
A zigzag breaking pitch called W (white) ball has been considered at once also by whom.
Furthermore, Hiroshi who is one of heroes also has a fastball in the muscular power which there is nothing and was cultivated by daily work in genius.
Is almost no "genius" in these comics?
Are most kyara "geniuses" so to speak having come to be called "genius" by efforts from the surroundings?
It was a useless robot and a hero's kuro えもん was [ a rival's shiro えもん ] also a useless robot a long time ago.
It was impressed by the scene describing efforts of shiro えもん from it.
Is the rest the robot and emoru which are called "genius" by not getting drunk with the talent which has also here, but trying hard every day?
From a master's ganie, "If the victory cannot be won, stop baseball" is said, a hand cowardly by the way is also used by one mind to give baseball, and the scene which is going to win the victory sounds the heart.
After all, a home run is hit to mike えもん which respected itself.
However, it is a seed that endurance can be accepted and baseball can be continued now.
魔球 "a red ton ball" was the good way of thinking.
The only difficulty of this work is that almost all games are decided by the come-from-behind home run.
When winning at the time of a lead, Hiroshi ends the last for a strikeout.
It hardly beats.
Furthermore, the game of soccer and baseball was also useless.
Conversely, is it spoiled?
However, it is a good impression to have written the feelings of tora uniquely.
although tin was not playing an active part until now, either, recently came out constantly and turn came Are they American secret arms and pleasure?
Synthetic evaluation is "good" based on a good place and a bad place.
How it heaps up after this carries out comfort.
Is also it a work wholly?

2007/07/23 Very good [Original Japanese review]
by Meteo Provider: 19923 Host:20019 Browser: 3162
A man's romance and friendship are the masterpieces fully got blocked!!
Although I do not have experience of a baseball team, since it is the person experienced in a band, the pleasure and difficulty which progress to the purpose in a team are known.
It is a work with those with laughter, and a tear.
In order to win, contrastive characters, such as Cheevy who very likes frantic hot kuro and baseball, regard a team as being realized together.
the poco which it carried out, and the process which was good, and which one kuro person supports all mutually rather than plays an active part, and is led to a victory said and carried out even if it made it the game of baseball, and was a disagreeable fellow (disagreeable fellow in an unavoidable top) -- emon kept company with kuro for practice, and was impressed by encouraging strongly Above all, the scene which a friend leaves was found, so that the feeling of aiding each other way was painful.
Since the friend had withdrawn also from himself in the band a long time ago, it was doubled with the feeling at that time, and has cried.
It is は明言 which shows the nature of hetakuso of kuro.
An energyful [ that Cheevy is bright and ] of a figure enjoyed earnestly is very agreeable.
Moreover, it was able to smile at it being extended with Doraemon at the beginning and 太 carrying out a friendship performance.
it was made the highest -- very good, since it becomes atrocity from the middle stage, although it goes -- coming out -- 。 dorabeesu banzai!!

2007/07/08 Very good [Original Japanese review]
by 過去の栄光 Provider: 40756 Host:40736 Browser: 5234
A masterpiece, comics which made Doraemon nice in baseball comics.
For the time being, it is thought that the top can be taken in a juvenile section only by saying [ force ] to depiction of a game at each time.
Mostly, although a picture has the portion which seldom puts in power in a juvenile magazine, as for this work, power is considerably contained also in a picture.
I think that it is the point which should be evaluated considerably there.
Next, it is a kyara setup.
This is also brilliant!
It is brilliant that air kyara is not in one person, either.
It is also likable that there is follow of making not to be conspicuous into neta.
I think that it is simply interesting and is made not to make displeasure take out with a game to the ball with which W ball etc.
cannot have a setup of using a secret tool coming out to there.
I also regard using as arms ordinarily depiction which cannot exist as very much brilliant.
Evaluation is very good.
It is work No.1 I want you to animation-ize.

2007/05/13 Very bad [Original Japanese review]
by サラダ丸 Provider: 34275 Host:34017 Browser: 3875
For the talk, cat type robots' kyara is [ individual and ] as the ten pre of the worn-out hot blood baseball story which the dame っ子 team does its best and wins.
Although the hit which was also the charm of a work and which shines skillful く使いこ nothing in an "it is by a unit of 1 time about three kinds of ひ 3 tools chosen at random" game was good, when it is brandished by setup of a game and a tool can also be used only one out of three kinds now, the rule itself changes and putting the cart before the horse is also excessive.
-- which some enemies surely trouble doraazu for unhappy 持ち using a hand dirty by the way of excuse, and passes the past thing in water with the victory of doraazu after all is a repetition except shiro えもん.
the first enemy and poco -- although えもん and guri えもん currently threatened by emoru could be allowed and was cooked, it allowed shiro えもん serious injury 負わせた doranpu -- since it hit, it deteriorated Since it becomes impossible to play baseball again on a promise with a master (president of a large company) when emoru loses, it makes it deceive and lose in shiro えもん by the fake letter.
Will threaten, if it catches the pet of spy sending 込むわ and guri えもん to doraazu, it goes into a partner team and it beats doraazu.
although blocked, its 魔球 was only broken [ terrible / dampish ] in the final -- will to fight -- loss -- carrying out -- a game throw -- reverse gire is carried out after like -- there is also no charm as a villain and it does not let the line as a captain pass, either -- losing -- dog nature -- exposed けど which will probably be good only as for itself, and shiro えもん, guri えもん and mike えもん which were made a steppingstone -- full disregard [ who reformed himself since the master allowed saying "those without defeat っぱ are Mr.
Kyo as it is" even if it lost the thing, and became reconciled with baseball 続けます and doraazu freshly ] [ … って ] The next retsu also attracts customers by flier out of which shiro えもん comes to a game, saying "shiro comes out" since bassen of a house is poor business performance, and it starts in the seko い詐欺 act of the human pitcher of whether it is platinum in practice or to be Hakusan.
It uses for reconstruction of the upgrade of its robopicchaa by 盗ん.
all the parts of the body of pyoko えもん completely collided and damaged during the game -- kuzu of 守銭奴 which has also extracted the head to the seko い銭 profit today without he doing also apologizing to it having been bad at doraazu, even if it aids with lunch sale, it shines on a seat for audience for 銭儲け and it loses, not to mention the father also scolds the son who did the part thief in the face of large spectators.
although the game finished and it was reconciled once, both these persons have not re-appeared without reproof with what -- thing ?
-- Doraemon of the head family -- a tune -- the morals of the author who has managed friend ごっこ although it is made to finish it as deep た suicidal explosions or punishment are suspected

2007/03/14 Best! [Original Japanese review]
by god Provider: 34156 Host:34054 Browser: 3023
Although it does not read very constantly unless ?
まぁ which will be what constantly, and this work are in why ...
I regard a hero as it having been the correct answer which was carried out to kuro.
The match with shiro can be enjoyed truly.
I take [ mind / quite like the strongest team / whose Japan is ] this time.
Does emoru often bear?
the moment of being made baka if it was the pitcher of certain famous comics -- 155km -- I think that it takes out (smile) I want you to progress a remarkable masterpiece and with this.

2007/02/18 Best! [Original Japanese review]
by Rein Provider: 24060 Host:23818 Browser: 5234
By comics, it is reading constantly at the very beginning.
If it says that it is new with it being the Doraemon + baseball, it will be a new idea, in addition to the invigoration of sushi "sport comics", the tool and the feature of "Doraemon" will also be added, and I will think that it is very much interesting.
By ordinary baseball comics, the tactics using the secret tool which cannot be seen and which can be used to three during a game are also interesting.
kyara is also very individual and very full of life.
It is so high that it is likely to be called thing ?
in which 画力 does not have じゃあ undue importance constantly, either, and can it be read happily?
First of all, since it is ワke which is using "Doraemon" as the foundation, "魔球" and a "secret tool" have "no displeasure to unreal depiction" which he has in sport comics by Koto called an ant.
He is also animation-ized hope secretly.
Since evaluation did not have the fault which was conspicuous especially although attaching the "highest" to the comics of the present korokoro had resistance in age, it is carried out to this evaluation.

2007/02/18 Best! [Original Japanese review]
by 金 Provider: 52019 Host:52079 Browser: 5234
Even if it compares with an old work rather than interesting for comics which move aside now, there is interesting 画力 and it has broken neither a story nor a view of the world original with interesting Doraemon.
As [ be / better / it / to carry out the animation-ization here instead of renewing Doraemon ] ...
Since he likes better than drama an original, it is the highest without a complaint.

2007/02/02 Normal [Original Japanese review]
by fukuyama Provider: 41781 Host:41969 Browser: 5234
Although it thinks that it is interesting, it is disagreeable that there is nothing conclusion ついて only with a home run each time.
the back and except kuro えもん -- the member of doraazu -- massage -- it is also disagreeable not to play an active part Common, when putting in a ゆう portion so, although it is interesting.

2007/01/09 Very good [Original Japanese review]
by 劉備 Provider: 53114 Host:53223 Browser: 4184
That I read these comics and considered first was "?
which will be what constantly why." This is good for honto.
It is very more interesting than the jump of the neighborhood about there, the comics of Sunday, etc.
The comics which were mistaken in the magazine carried this much have not seen.
However, since it cannot now perform changing a magazine etc., a wheat straw teacher wishes not mistaking the magazine to carry next time.

2006/08/24 Very good [Original Japanese review]
by 山口 Provider: 29615 Host:29732 Browser: 6287
It is the merit of the quality which cannot be considered constantly.
mannerism is not carried out so much -- carrying out -- the combination of the Doraemon + baseball -- skillful く描 -- he てます it comes out constantly and there is no undue importance in a series etc.

2006/08/23 Best! [Original Japanese review]
by Su Provider: 9836 Host:10025 Browser: 6396
It is the highest!
Touch that it says very or several step level is different from a jump, Sunday, or the fellow that is doing で今.
I think zuba omission てる also in の constantly.
Do I want you to surely animation-ize?

2006/08/15 Very good [Original Japanese review]
by 堕天使 Provider: 18939 Host:18793 Browser: 4483
Constantly, it is comic and I think that it is the work regarded as it is uncanny as me and interesting.
Pictures are [ story composition or a character ] also top class in successive generation and present age korokoro comics.
I think that it is inside 々食い and a せる story that Doraemon does baseball for the schoolchild who looked at Doraemon and has grown up when young.
honest -- I dislike the baseball comics which carry out 魔球 which cannot exist, and a batting style, and supo soul comics There are saying [ since it is まぁ korokoro ] and that production is uncanny and it is hot.
However, although the 魔球 and batting style appear in these comics in bowl さ, has popularity come out?
As me, it is a 惹かれ better seed to the latter.
Especially the last round that is full of the feeling of strain of whether it finally arrives at a home at the not a game but last of a home run ばっ loan unlike "MAJOR" or to be made out is the fun of the about which does not have undue importance comically constantly.
It was uncanny that shiro えもん threw W ball by the pick-off throw in the game with shiro えもん of when.
Although touch that I was good at first was not carried out to others, the production of the comeback using the secret tool is also good.
Since the known tool is most, foundations are the impression things which are carried out in different usage, and reverse and win and which will be rich.
As a character, it is wholly attractive.
that a hero is not talent absolutism should hear about that it was a dropbehind at first having stepped up efforts, and finally the member of doraazu having become 憧られる existence from the surroundings -- て -- it is very good Is it good as for kuro えもん that it is a No.
3 third base?
These comics were usually contrary to the hero of baseball becoming a pitcher at it.
I felt freshness uncanny for it, it made still more pleasantly, and I was sure that this author's ability is zuba omission ている here.
shiro えもん is my favorite.
I have the broken shoulder cured in doranpu editing of the following which is the greatest rival of kuro えもん at first, and was pushed down -- it is a role, and it is damaged in the talk of emoru, a role is done [ it is saved, and ], and it is it a character with wide width that it is as giving the greatest rival after that again たり at a role honest -- I consider that it is better to have closed present Doraemon and to do this dorabeesu Evaluation is made "very good."

2006/08/02 Best! [Original Japanese review]
by 時の風来人 Provider: 40320 Host:40211 Browser: 5234
now, since there is also no mannerism and it is reading, while coming out constantly and being serialized by new hot blood baseball comics, and it is satisfied, the "highest" is attached [ make / have you / it ] Although many directions are described, he also desires animation-ization.
However, don't I want TV Asahi where only goods are seeing Doraemon to broadcast?

Next / Post your review / Top page

ALERT: You cannot use open proxy or TOR for posting your review. If it is detected, your access to this site will be prohibited.

Rule for reviews

This site allows you to write reviews for each title, but we don't allow you to criticize others' comment. Too bad or meaningless words are also not allowed. The comment which doesn't follow the rule will be deleted. If you find any comment which doesn't follow the rule, please notify us by clicking Suggest to delete.

Example to be deleted frequently

Favorite side
You dislike this one, then don't see it or comment this title
- Please go to the fan site. Anyone has the right to say what they feel in this site.

Disliking side
Do you like this one? You are stupid.
- Your view is only your view. Please concentrate on only the content of the title, not on others' comment.

Please use only English. If not, the comment will be deleted.

Your Name(Required)

Password (Required. more than 4 characters)

Your comment about this anime(Required)

Your evaluation of this title(Required)
You can choose the evaluation only once. After you post your evaluation, please choose comment instead of evaluation from the options.

Evaluation of this title(You can choose this only once)

Best!!
Very good
Good
Normal
Bad
Very Bad
Worst

If you evaluated this title once, please choose comment instead of the evaluation.
Comment by the person who thinks this is good
Comment by the person who thinks this is normal
Comment by the person who thinks this is bad

Please choose appropriate option for readers.

Caution: Please post the evaluation which follows the rule.