Japanese works database(How to join/Help)
Top page: All/Only Reviews

Others
Site map


Search / Outside DB:

Comics ranking: Rank 4,087/in 4,212 titles (Total -13.05/Deviation 45.57) Rank 4,086 <= => Rank 4,088
Comics average points ranking: Rank 604/in 693 titles (Average -0.87(Bad)/Deviation 37.27) Rank 603 <= => Rank 605 (more than 10 evaluatoin)
Comics ranking of 1999: Rank 55/in 59 titles Rank 54 <= => Rank 56

Ginga Densetsu WEED(Comics)

[Other version: RSS/Japanese version]

Other media
Anime:Ginga Legend Weed (Ginga Densetsu Weed)

All
Reviews(Post)

Forum

Images

Goods
(DVD)

Latest DVD: 2006/09/26 ():

Wolf's Rain: Complete Collection II $98

DVD(8hit) Sales/Latest								Music(1hit) Sales/Latest
Rank:9615 Wolf's Rain: Complete Collection II Tag:$98 2006/09/26 () Eval.:***** 1.An End To The Journey And A Heart-Wrenching Cost	Rank:30040 Wolf's Rain - Limited Complete Collection Tag:$98 2005/11/22 () Eval.:***** 1.For the Anime Obsessed ...	Vol. 6-Ginga Densetsu Weed Tag:$99 2006/05/29 ()	Vol. 7-Ginga Densetsu Weed Tag:$99 2006/05/29 () Eval.:***** 1.Best Show EVER!!!!!	Vol. 10-Ginga Densetsu Weed Tag:$49 2006/07/31 ()	Vol. 11-Ginga Densetsu Weed Tag:$49 2006/07/31 ()	Vol. 12-Ginga Densetsu Weed Tag:$99 2006/08/28 ()	Vol. 13-Ginga Densetsu Weed Tag:$99 2006/08/28 ()	Rank:150829 Audio CD:Ginga Densetsu Weed Op Thema Tag:$99 2005/12/13 ()

Information about this title

Yoshihiro Takahashi
Weekly Manga Goraku
Nihon Bungei sha

Released:1999 in Japan

Statics of evaluation(The statics is updated once a day)

	Average	ComicsRank	Deviation(Total)	Evaluation points(Total)	Best of the Best
Inside Japan	Bad(-0.87)	4,087	45.57	-13.05

Statics of activity

	Total Views	Comment	Evaluation
Inside Japan	9,873	19	15
Outside Japan	731	0	0

How others evaluated in Japan

Best

Very Good

Good

Normal

Bad

Very Bad

Worst

People

Percentage

6.7%

13.3%

0.0%

6.7%

33.3%

20.0%

Added percentage

6.7%

20%

26.7%

60%

80%

100%

Summary

20%

6.7%

73.3%

Views for recent 8 days
Total 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3
13 1 4 1 3 1 1 1 1

Language Sorted by date Sorted by recommendation
English Good
(Only Evaluation) Normal
(Only Evaluation) Bad
(Only Evaluation) All
(Only Evaluation) None
Japanese Good
(Only Evaluation) Normal
(Only Evaluation) Bad
(Only Evaluation) All
(Only Evaluation) All
This reputation board

Language	Sorted by date	Sorted by recommendation
English	Good (Only Evaluation)	Normal (Only Evaluation)	Bad (Only Evaluation)	All (Only Evaluation)	None
Japanese	Good (Only Evaluation)	Normal (Only Evaluation)	Bad (Only Evaluation)	All (Only Evaluation)	All

Post your review / Top page

Other media
Anime:Ginga Legend Weed (Ginga Densetsu Weed)

The below reviews are translated automatically from Japanese ones. To post to English version, please click here.

2008/08/24 Best! [Original Japanese review]
by 在原健太郎 Provider: 54175 Host:53964 Browser: 8934
Serializing [ in a weekly jump ]-by Mr.
Takahashi means ひろ's dog comics currently serialized by weekly comics goraku from 99 years sequel.
the subordinate's of Nero's of the North Alps's setter GB -- a certain day -- it meets with 幼犬 of 虎毛 which lives with a weak mother 母犬 which was just before death asks take a son to the basis of the captain and silver of Ou, and is 息絶える.
GB names him "Weed " and is left for both Ou.
the ground which changed there for the monster-ized rabid dog P4, and was ruined although it was Weed and GB which overcame gotagota of a destination many and arrived at Ou -- it was carrying out Then, Weed who met with Ben, the son and sword of 黒虎, and 影虎 collects them, and challenges to fighting bold to the ringleader P4 of paradise collapse.
Smith's sacrifice -- it is -- P4 -- pushing down -- paradisiac peace -- recovery -- although it was Weed and others the bottom, it knows that the father and silver which was crossing each other were caught by search in wife and children at 暴 Mr.
` method 玄' of the Alps, and leaves again with the friend to help a father The new adventure drama which inherited the masterpiece "銀牙 -shooting star silver -" which drew the dog with the trial of fighting as a hero.
It begins from the place left in quest of the father whom the son of the silver to which got separate [ this-work article ] at a certain crossing, and it gave birth although it was the story which makes a friend and goes while the partner (red helmet) who fights by carrying out while a previous work is produced was decided, and it fights each other for the overthrow and emulating each other does not look at yet.
but 犬界 which the paradise in Ou which arrived also lapsed into the collapse state in response to false misapprehension from man for the monster dog P4, and the crack of paradise collapse toppled and built the red helmet 13 years ago further, was alike also in 権野, and was unified is also collapsed -- making -- ` method 玄' and `kamakiri' -- it will turn into the world which was in disorder to Warring-States みたい in which it sees and the cruel and cunning ambitious person [ た / an ambitious person ] appears Silver son and Weed fight how in such a situation, and it grows up, studying in it what justice is with friendship, and the fun of this-work article is in the place referred to as whether to regain peace.
And in a previous work, the adventure and drama which were not made on the setup are here, and the dogs of various kinds more than a previous work including a former generation's sons appear.
For the moment, II world is not simply in carrying out activity in which like [ exceeding a father ] was conspicuous other than Weed and 哲心.
Compared with the speedy flow of a previous work, deployment of a story is very slow.
Probably, the tale is made so much thoroughly.
Moreover, the thing of being peaceful may be teaching it being what is realized by overcoming many trials.
At such a point, I think that it may be blessed from the previous work because there is a place of activity of well so various characters.
And death of the old generation having impression of Smith John muslin, white wolf, etc.
Although that is right, since [ which was not able to do it by the intention of a jump of those days ] Mr.
Takahashi wanted to draw the death which attached the one-animal one-animal story in fighting with the red helmet army corps of a previous work with ほん, probably it will do it in this-work article.
The place made into the brilliant figure very movingly is very good by taking the form where show the brave figure of himself's last in fighting [ which pierced through justice ], and it is told to the next generation.
However, did the sniper, alias maadaaS, greet the last, without the ability reforming himself to the last last at last?
Although it fell to 寿沢, the trusted hyena intervened and all three animals must have been understood with Ben in the previous work on the river, only why or Ben was saved, and although two animals were still missing, the truth was told in this-work article.
since the lower half of the body changed into the state of a wheelchair and the sniper has tasted a hell on earth in the figure of that humiliation for 13 years -- more than a previous work -- the heart -- becoming perverse -- that -- じゃあ will also be obtained and there is no room of a reformation -- けど It is ` highest also at "銀牙"!
Although 'was attached, since the feeling which values a life for the heart which the contents of the hot force and impression ある story deployment lose and are not inferior to a previous work in this-work article, but it is wonderful, and pierces through justice in fighting, and a friend is taught, evaluation is [highest!
It is ].
if the gallant thing which taught 今じゃこういう humanity and justice is drawn by people, since it will become a worthless thing -- ます with resistance Therefore, it is very nice to compare to a dog and to teach it.
If it is this, し [ anyone can read without resistance ].
such humanity and justice and justice -- future -- the point -- however a time may change, I think that I am what must always be succeeded

2008/02/20 Bad [Original Japanese review]
by TCC Provider: 10414 Host:10694 Browser: 4184
Is this the sequel of shooting star silver seemingly?
ます with my having also heard the voice (smile) by which the Galaxy 10,000 length of the role of riki was imitated to a certain site, when calling it silver .........

[A good point]
- "Dog" The investigation which leaves is it.
if viido and the big brother in character with a hero think that they exchanged reunion of joy and .........
will be said bad, although it may be a little common one, viido is not the character of a type which holds a feeling of dislike at least -- carrying out -- the relation of appearance [ them ] dogs -- it may be worrisome
[A bad point]
- 所詮 is the "dog" version worthless comics.
but -- if it is called a dog, although it will be carefully treated by the human being and will temporarily cook from him in some countries -- others -- his statement れていた -- like -- "-- if dog Mr." and others is not a subject matter, is it the melon and the impressive style which becomes still weaker of this comics no one but?
- Also picture ...........
Isn't hakkiri 言ってこれ so good, either?
The character which distinction seldom attaches, and how many animals are seen.

[Comprehensive evaluation]
if it says right [ that ], this author will also be a jump system writer -- as ..........
since it does not have having read, although original also has generational gap, and it cannot be said not at all, while it is regrettable -- reading -- a てあ ball -- I do not think that it is interesting Are there much jump system writer って and direction which is leaning on the glory of such the past truly?
the members of edit which were not able to understand well that it was not only them but "the magazine of writer あって" -- being also alike -- although it thinks that there is a big cause .........
a large object can read the point and evaluation also "will worsen" the talk

2008/01/07 Comment(good) [Original Japanese review]
by 次元龍 Provider: 36780 Host:36545 Browser: 5234
[Good point] The individuality of a character is rich.
[Bad point] Only an episode rate enemy comes out from a beet.
[Comprehensive evaluation] Is it good?
They are 96 points anyhow synthetically.

2006/06/06 Comment(bad) [Original Japanese review]
by 宇宙刑事ジャンギャバン Provider: 33223 Host:33285 Browser: 4314
Smith, John, and white wolf ....
the dogs which played an active part in the previous work rapidly kill -- having -- a sad thing Is the author going to kill silver by fighting with the military dog to which it came from Russia?
Probably, it will kill.
Therefore, it is since it is made to go to fight in a small number.
A father is desperate and Weed, a son, is falling in love easy to って's which takes a stand against the pro of a battle.
It is ....
gradually.
As [ arose / 軋轢 / between the son of the marshal whose Russia army corps is also not a monolith but a boss, and other young management / however, ] Is そこい and others eye the price!?
However, the Russia army corps is unjust.
although there is no sense of incongruity to there even if they slaughter dogs, since the red helmet and Gaia of a previous work are different-species fellows to the last -- dogs -- why -- oh, if a until massacre is not ventured, doesn't it become?
It is more unreasonable than 法玄.

2006/05/28 Worst [Original Japanese review]
by 634 Provider: 20897 Host:21004 Browser: 5234
It seems that 本作 also leaned on the past glory and daradara and the introductory notes which continue have only been imitated after all.
It was called "kin meat man Nisei" and said, "Apply to a ring!", and each story of the second generation large activity of a remake of a jump work finished with the misfire, and became the style which got worse, so that it did not become as compared with the previous work, and 本作 also only entered into it.
Although even the previous work personified the dog in the bad meaning, was made into a jump customer's group strife monochrome and did not have such a degree of favorable impression, 本作 has fallen more than it.
To where, the impression which has hung on to the past budget was stronger, the author itself became old too much, it seems that the neta piece is also exposed, even if it considered such fields, evaluation called Ryosaku was not given to a compliment, either, and the image of the young day when the young generation advocated a theme called 創っていく in a new time was only forgotten to the badness of the work method.
Animal comics are not that what is necessary is just to personify nothing.
And by exterminating a stray dog by the label of doing damage to a wild animal with the hanger-on who brings about rabies if it is original, although it is appropriate existence, it is harnessing in the bad meaning at 本作.
Regulation of the health center in this world is fairly loose, and is surely ぶっ壊(ing) nature beyond a certain meaning and our world.
Although it will be made into the form of a strife of a motorcycle gang and my yatt, a worthless や Yankee is smart only in a movie or comics, and the neighborhood which makes dear dogs the hoodlum 愚連隊 group of a nose knob, and the author cannot but say that they have given the perverted perverted love to an animal.
Although such an image of the previous work was strong, 本作 has increased further.
The work which leans on the glory of such past turned every day, and the neighborhood and 本作 which the situation of betraying the conventional fan follows were expressed only in the form of the daradara 食い crushing work of the author's neta piece.
The responsibility which broke such readers' dream is large, the humbleness which listens to a reader's complaint is not very seen, either, and neither the author nor Shueisha has yet applied the brakes to leaning on the past glory and getting worse.
This is the subject thrust [ company / work / bookstores other than Shueisha, many publishing companies, or ].

2006/05/28 Bad [Original Japanese review]
by Ebodainohiraki Provider: 5898 Host:6011 Browser: 7395
Are they the comics in which the "dog" is performing the strife of shima argument of Mr.
yaku O, a poor student, and a motorcycle gang?
If it is not a dog, novelty will think that it is the work a decade ago which one does not have.
me -- Mr.
"like-this [ a man ]" って云う Hiroshi Motomiya's work -- the same smell is felt for 本作 although a みたいな style is disagreeable Or [ it is also related to have acted Mr.
Motomiya's assistant as the author before ] ...
牡犬 is ambitious to the last, it will be full of vitality, and 雌犬 will be satiated too much with the type for which it is moderate generally and is waiting with a usage pattern.
Although it was still able to read as it is when Weed was still young, if it becomes brawnier and brawnier mentally, deployment can already be read and it will have become strangely.
Although it was so thought also at the time of shooting star silver, the stray dog which appears has too many pure blood kinds!
The Tosa dogfight and gray toden surely carry out the multi-member appearance also of it.
If it is a hunting dog, although it may be left on a mountain (it is a deplorable fact) It is said physically that gray toden with few the Tosa dogfights of the peak and the registered members in Japan forms a multi-member stray dog with a pure blood kind...
Although it may be the dog species which the author tends to draw actually, since the foot and the stray dog which is alike and lives of Fuji have many dogs mixed-breed-ized halfway, this is also the portion which feels No.
1 lie stink as me, and is felt strangely White fighter Yamato was the "dog" which Yamato carried out perfectly, and it carried out the bottom, and since it was a pet dog also in serious character, there were some which face the faithful portion shown to the violence shown at the time of fighting and an owner, and it was also a good impression conversely.
Moreover, in the case of shooting star silver, it is a thing new still in idea, it was carried out the bottom, and, as it is, slight pleasure carried out.
It was difficult to continue reading in any way for the sequel which does not have も変わり映え like this.
Although it is not having restricted to this author, is it that there are very many the veteran cartoonists who can do only as it leans on the "name" of an old masterpiece?
Because the author's heyday is known, is seeing the reality which has lowered evaluation rapidly very sad?
there are still many numbers of turns -- although it will be evaluated as it is therefore -- supporters -- one -- which neighborhood -- it will be -- although it considers so that the person who felt and read ?
郷愁 may be made to surely feel the mere imitation and a quality down ...
I think that it is a wonderful work as a certain meaning

2006/03/31 Worst [Original Japanese review]
by ☆なんて見えねーよ Provider: 6892 Host:6581 Browser: 4184
The sequel of dog comics.
the thing which would つ - get tired of biting and which it is doing after all -- together っぽい -- carrying out -- the dog of the second generation, and an impression -- thin -- it comes out by carrying out and says, and there is no image if it is sequel やん at any rate -- decisively -- garatt -- changing -- ちゃ -- useless -- something -- ?
-- I considered -- it is not got blocked

2006/01/26 Normal [Original Japanese review]
by Supan Provider: 2176 Host:2125 Browser: 5234
the "volume on 法玄 -- anyhow -- 長った -- it is -- the time -- it shines [ ...
] daradara 8 till" when -- although considered, the deployment after the volume on monkey is rather interesting Although edited by Hokkaido (?) has still started just since it is reading only by the comic, it is the touch which is also likely to be expectable for the moment this time.
Isn't not much attractive kyara in appearance kyara?
I feel that charm has, on the whole, also reduced previous work appearance kyara by half.
It is with John and Smith to have carried out the charm rise.
Especially Smith changes and it is a surprise like.
Isn't as honest one as jieromu in new kyara in Weed?
Evaluation is at least まぁ "common."

2005/09/27 Comment(bad) [Original Japanese review]
by 宇宙刑事ジャンギャバン Provider: 33021 Host:33021 Browser: 5978
Did you rush into new series and did the new enemy appear in the direction in Hokkaido this time?
jieromu performed to the greeting at white wolf is attacked by the group of a doubtful dog.
Weed whom the means which come out and know the plight of such jieromu do not have, either is merry with a first love.
immediately after [ however, / telling about the tameness start with the cherry tree which is a mother from a father's silver ] -- 見目 -- helping a beautiful pet dog and falling to love ....
not much -- と -- if it says, it will be deployment too much going too well

2005/09/16 Very bad [Original Japanese review]
by betch Provider: 36378 Host:36320 Browser: 4184
Does being treated like that favorably only by a hero merely calling it a captain's son get angry?
although it thought that it was childlike at first and was dear, whenever the talk progresses also in the hero -- a heavens top world -- it ran self-righteous and it has been thought that the hero and kyara of certain pirate comics are wearing the end -- silver -- 法玄 -- と -- the settlement stopped when it is going to stab with eye ど As for then having blown away the silver Weed is also 鑑 of dogs and is [ silver ] his father, the mukatt belly stood truly.
In 法玄 etc., it says clearly and is the kyui level of a dragon ball.
Why does it protect such accessories that also feel no charm and strength?
There is also a reason which such a hero can do in empathy etc., or no preparations.
even if it says た [ silver / "exceeded / as for you / the heart or the body / me /" see to Weed and ] -- persuasive power zero Though he is able to understand the feeling which yields 100 step temporarily and is referred to as "being unable to kill any accessories", such a story is said clearly, and 胸くそ of completeness is bad.
[ of Weed ] When these comics were read at first, dogs merely talked, and I looked at not knowing and fighting and did the "銀牙 shooting star silver" of this previous work now [ hama って ].
So, I carried out [ mind as he had started hypnotism temporarily ], and feeling became bad very much.
Dogs looked at talking or fighting.
Were they the Hamah るべき with "銀牙 shooting star silver"?

2005/04/24 Comment(good) [Original Japanese review]
by Nanatsuman Provider: 36462 Host:36531 Browser: 3875
Although 猿種 of this enemy's general seems to be galley dahihi, does it have about about 5m of lengths?
...
(the average length of galley dahihi is 1m from 70cm) Is it mutation like [ a general ] a red helmet?

2005/04/20 Very good [Original Japanese review]
by Nanatsuman Provider: 8630 Host:8356 Browser: 3875
Weed thought that it could have the device of recent work although there was no impact like a previous work.
It was able to have sympathy in doing one's best in him in the 佐助は銀牙 world, for the Weed friends, although it is inferior to other stray dogs as military power by 柴犬種 which is unique existence since it is 柴犬 to which the physique is inferior in him sharply, and a leg is sometimes pulled plentifully, and helping Weed and others especially, greatly.
(ますし helped several times with the artifice of 佐助) 佐助みたいな existence was very fresh to it in the 銀牙 world of large-sized practical use dog-species serious consideration.
As for the sublime last, the breast got hot although the death of Smith or John was sad.
Smith was significant about the point that the warrior who was not looked at by the 銀牙 time was seen.
There are many a part of 犬ばっ or dogs which are carrying out fade-out not to mention activity is possible and there is nothing although it plays an active part and there is ability like Ron, 遺蔵, or a shower the back.
Since Ron and 遺蔵 are pleased, I want them to give an opportunity individually.

2005/03/11 Very good [Original Japanese review]
by Itsuki Provider: 22857 Host:22773 Browser: 4789
Or [ that a previous work can enjoy itself if it is a really favorite person ].
Isn't there any enemy who exceeds a red helmet as people of ↓ have merely said?
But activity of the fighters of a previous work etc.
is seen and it is interesting.

2005/02/04 Very bad [Original Japanese review]
by Hippiihiyoko Provider: 7936 Host:7849 Browser: 5237
"Inflation-izing of strength" to which the ally also becomes strong rapidly as the enemy becomes strong.
If it is the favorite one of battle comics, I think that it is the spectacle seen repeatedly.
-- This work is a new work with which "deflation-ization of strength" of an enemy and an ally has taken place.
Whenever an enemy piles up a time, he becomes accessories.
The villain's part of a previous work "shooting star silver" is the reconstruction dog -> wild dog (Doberman pinscher) -> monkey of laboratory animals at 今作, although it was Okuma which grew large, so that it was fearful.
It is - dejectedly.
An ally is also reduced to the day to a hero's "Weed"'s setoff who joined the hero army.
kyara which carried out uncanny activity at the time of an enemy, and kyara whose uncanny name was able to resound in the neighborhood are everybody.
the cause of the age which the men who showed wonderful activity by the previous work also depend, or みー -- し dementia has started in んな weakening -- Ben etc.
John and Smith 死んじゃった and are 。.
A previous work fan considers that it is better not to see.
Yes.

2004/09/29 Very bad [Original Japanese review]
by 若鶏カレー Provider: 16575 Host:16531 Browser: 3875
銀牙 -- と -- although いぇ was also interesting and was expected -- Also as for a story, compared with the red helmet of a previous work, 法玄 will look too like accessories.
Even if it makes it silver, because it was strong like a demon, in a previous work, it is very regrettable to catch a sight which aged.
Even if it makes it Weed, there is no impact like the silver of a previous work, and kyara is weak somehow.
し [ silver friend John has also been killed ] -- Because he liked, having been damaged by 法玄 something is very regrettable.
And treatment is severe even if it makes it the member who came out newly this time.
Isn't he forgotten lightly in the big four's child etc.?
し [ the member of a previous work is also halfway ].
And it lives long too much and is 。.
How old it will really be in muslin, Ben, etc.
I wanted you to finish it as the previous work too.

2004/08/05 Worst [Original Japanese review]
by 毒 Provider: 45790 Host:45579 Browser: 5978
Although it is not called one talk, it 飽きs bored at once.
justice justice and smallness -- the place which I want to elaborate on the talk to a slight degree before advertizing poetic justice noisily Is it useless as it expects that I want you to show the thing mashi to a slight degree as which production is sufficient, if a story is mannerism?
The beginning to it is shortly main, without learning a lesson from having done from the silver time of eye friends' collection in the fight of dogs etc.
Did not think of a design in order for the child of a red helmet to have survived, and to also do the second confrontation or to protect friends, to the extent that it cannot but stop fighting with man and is agonized, either.

2004/07/19 Bad [Original Japanese review]
by 雲丹烏賊の介 Provider: 23537 Host:23438 Browser: 3875
As an impression, the drama of a Warring States thing or a gang strife thing is used as a motif, kyara is reset to a dog, and they are たっぽい comics.
The impression of all in the ability of fun to be felt there, although a dog develops a gallant conversation which is not like a dog at all while the necessity why it transposed to the dog has seldom been felt by it.
For me, they are the thin comics of an impression.

2004/07/19 Bad [Original Japanese review]
by Morochi Provider: 6119 Host:6194 Browser: 3875
す notices [ liked shooting star silver and / the 3 or 4 somethings neighborhood to advance ] the thing which were impressed by nostalgia when these comics were read first and which nothing is so pleasantly when it reads anew, after the prejudice of mannerism-ized nostalgia is lost by rubbing and is aghast.
since there was a long thing charge period, I obtained the composition of the talk and wanted you to do my best just for a moment

Post your review / Top page

Other media
Anime:Ginga Legend Weed (Ginga Densetsu Weed)

ALERT: You cannot use open proxy or TOR for posting your review. If it is detected, your access to this site will be prohibited.

Rule for reviews

This site allows you to write reviews for each title, but we don't allow you to criticize others' comment. Too bad or meaningless words are also not allowed. The comment which doesn't follow the rule will be deleted. If you find any comment which doesn't follow the rule, please notify us by clicking Suggest to delete.

Example to be deleted frequently

Favorite side
You dislike this one, then don't see it or comment this title
- Please go to the fan site. Anyone has the right to say what they feel in this site.

Disliking side
Do you like this one? You are stupid.
- Your view is only your view. Please concentrate on only the content of the title, not on others' comment.

Please use only English. If not, the comment will be deleted.

Your Name(Required)

Password (Required. more than 4 characters)

Your comment about this anime(Required)

Your evaluation of this title(Required)
You can choose the evaluation only once. After you post your evaluation, please choose comment instead of evaluation from the options.

Evaluation of this title(You can choose this only once)

Best!!
Very good
Good
Normal
Bad
Very Bad
Worst

If you evaluated this title once, please choose comment instead of the evaluation.
Comment by the person who thinks this is good
Comment by the person who thinks this is normal
Comment by the person who thinks this is bad

Please choose appropriate option for readers.

Caution: Please post the evaluation which follows the rule.