Japanese works database(How to join/Help)
Top page: All/Only Reviews 		Others
Site map
AllAnimeGameComicNovelDramaSp. effectJP movieMovieInfo:voice,machine..Reviewer sorted byDiary
Search / Outside DB:
Comics ranking in Japan: Rank 17/in 4,101 titles (Total 259.41/Deviation 107.40) Rank 16 <= => Rank 18
Comics average points ranking in Japan: Rank 218/in 655 titles (Average 1.33(Good)/Deviation 55.72) Rank 217 <= => Rank 219 (more than 10 evaluatoin were posted)
Comics ranking of 2001 in Japan: Rank 1/in 73 titles => Rank 2

Fullmetal Alchemist(Comics)


[Other version: RSS/Japanese version]


Other media
Anime:Fullmetal Alchemist (Hagane no Renkinjyutsu shi: TV series) / Game:FullMetal Alchemist and the Broken Angel / Novel:Fullmetal Alchemist
All
Reviews(Post)		ForumImagesGoods
(Books)
Latest Books: 2008/10/21 ():Fullmetal Alchemist, Volume 17 (Fullmetal Alchemist (Graphic Novels)) $99
Books(100hit)
Sales/Latest		DVD(38hit)
Sales/Latest		Music(23hit)
Sales/Latest		VideoGames(9hit)
Sales/Latest		Toys(152hit)
Sales/Latest
Rank:31059
Comic:Fullmetal Alchemist, Volume 16

Tag:$99
2008/03/18
()
Eval.:*****
1.Beyond the Dream		 Rank:32337
Paperback:Fullmetal Alchemist, Volume 15

Tag:$99
2007/12/18
()
Eval.:*****
1.The Hero of Ishbal		 Rank:38773
Paperback:Fullmetal Alchemist, Volume 7

Tag:$99
2006/05/16
()
Eval.:*****
1.A journey into the past.		 Rank:43390
Comic:Fullmetal Alchemist, Volume 6

Tag:$99
2006/03/21
()
Eval.:*****
1.FLASHBACK CONTINUED		 Rank:46169
Comic:Fullmetal Alchemist, Volume 11

Tag:$99
2007/01/16
()
Eval.:*****
1.Ah, Hohenheim, we knew you'd be back.		 Rank:50433
Comic:Fullmetal Alchemist, Volume 14

Tag:$99
2007/08/21
()
Eval.:*****
1.Frickin' Shweet		 Rank:2910
Fullmetal Alchemist The Movie - The Conqueror of Shamballa

Tag:$98
2006/09/12
()
Eval.:*****
1.Interesting continuation		 Rank:11369
Audio CD:Fullmetal Alchemist Complete Best

Tag:$98
2006/05/30
()
Eval.:*****
1.full version of the ending themes		 Rank:3347
Video Game:Fullmetal Alchemist 2 Curse of the Crimson Elixir

Tag:$99
2005/07/12
()
Eval.:*****
1.Pretty lame actually		 Rank:4027
Toy:Fullmetal Alchemist snake necklace + Pin

Tag:$99
Eval.:*****
1.fma necklace
Information about this title

Hiromu Arakawa
BOYS GANGAN
SQUARE ENIX
Romi Park Junko Minagawa Rie Kugimiya Kusaka Chihiro
Toru Ohkawa Michiko Neya Kenji Utsumi
Megumi toyoguti Keiji Fujiwara
Yasunori Matsumoto Hiroaki Hirata Tsugumi Higasayama Atsuko Tanaka Kazuhiro Nakata Masako Katsuki Yukana Aya Hisakawa Shinichiro Miki Reiko Kiuchi
Masaaki Tsukada Sintarou Oohata

Released:2001/07/12 in Japan
Official sites
1. http://gangan.square-enix.co.jp/hagaren/ (Translation)
Image gallery sites
1. http://silver-fox.vis.ne.jp/book-data-first.htm
Statics of evaluation(The statics is updated once a day)
 AverageComicsRankDeviation(Total)Evaluation points(Total)Best of the Best
Inside JapanGood(1.33)17107.40259.412
Outside JapanVery good(2.00)5750.462.00 

Statics of activity

Total ViewsCommentEvaluation
Inside Japan102,239296177
Outside Japan1,55711

How others evaluated in Japan

BestVery GoodGoodNormalBadVery BadWorst
People504632251464
Percentage28.2%26.0%18.1%14.1%7.9%3.4%2.3%
Added percentage28.2%54.2%72.3%86.4%94.3%97.7%100%
Summary72.3%14.1%13.6%
                                                                                                  

Views for recent 8 days
Total432130292827
10
1
1
1
0
3
1
2
1

LanguageSorted by dateSorted by recommendation New!
EnglishGood
(Only Evaluation)		Normal
(Only Evaluation)		Bad
(Only Evaluation)		All
(Only Evaluation)		None
JapaneseGood
(Only Evaluation)		Normal
(Only Evaluation)		 Bad
(Only Evaluation)		All
(Only Evaluation)		All
This reputation board

2007/02/28 Very good [Edit/Delete//Only this reviewer/Only this review/post sympathy comment/]
by Love and peace Review history[Good:14(82%) Normal:3(18%) Bad:0(0%)] / Provider: 15264 Host:15441 Browser: 3008
The drawing style is very clear and I like it.
There are many characters but the story is going well with good balance.
Creating unresolved mistery while solving some mistery, it keeps catching reader's attention.
It is great thing to keep high reputation for a long term.
I think this is one of the current representative of Japanese comics.
Post your review / Top page
Other media
Anime:Fullmetal Alchemist (Hagane no Renkinjyutsu shi: TV series) / Game:FullMetal Alchemist and the Broken Angel / Novel:Fullmetal Alchemist
The below reviews are translated automatically from Japanese ones. To post to English version, please click here.
2008/06/29 Best! [Original Japanese review]
by Natsume Provider: 24938 Host:24751 Browser: 4317
It borrowed from the friend and read.
Is saw's beginning about TV broadcast at the time like the third grader in an elementary school?
Since "the animation which it may be dark and is not understood" was memorized those days, it reread by comics.
Is it uncanny if it そ?
That story composition The mystery which deepens as a story progresses, truth explained.
The back becomes deep rapidly.
I am hips better た about cancer cancer at the favor of hagaren.
And the range of the comics to read spread very well.
(It is GF besides cancer cancer) Comics are collected personally now.
Then, although 19 volumes were read, was this preparation みたいなかんじ for next fighting?
20 volumes are expected.
I think that it becomes deployment new future again.
Is evaluation the "highest", of course?
2008/06/09 Very good [Original Japanese review]
by another^z Provider: 42231 Host:42295 Browser: 4730
He likes, and it is peevish and is this work.
I also had the past of hoe enhaimu made to cry.
If it reads 2 or 3 times, it is in a neglect state as it is.
It would not carry out what.
(Smile) What the hero was being killed by kinburii for was made to harahara.
if it says at a bad point -- the love of Ed and WIN Lee -- was rice cold?
evaluation is very good -- coming out -- 。
2008/05/22 Bad [Original Japanese review]
by 知久作 Provider: 304 Host:274 Browser: 7282
Since evaluation was high in various places, although it was at least three-year before, it read collectively.
As me, it was fairly delicate...
Although three years have passed since it read for the time being, already forget most of the stories.
A younger brother's name does not remember even the name of ろ and a hero.
Although many things were read by comics tea drinking those days, there may also be no talk which he forgets clearly so far.
.
I think that the impression was very thin.
2008/05/15 Very good [Original Japanese review]
by RAH Provider: 29382 Host:29397 Browser: 7793(Mobile)
From cancer cancer this month, it is likely to become interesting.
guriido (Lynn) became a friend and there was a motion.
Is future a highlight?
2008/04/25 Good [Original Japanese review]
by Agato Provider: 29382 Host:29389 Browser: 7797(Mobile)
These comics were the causes for me to fit into the Square ENIX system.
How to assemble a story is good!
However, is it it lazy recently [ -- ]?
Since it was likely to become interesting in the maximum new publication again, expectation is put and evaluation is good.
2008/04/21 Normal [Original Japanese review]
by Ingurandokarakonnichiha Provider: 24292 Host:24035 Browser: 5234
It is like an author reason and a B film...
You are the very passage.
Can you enjoy yourself very much?
The touch battle which comparatively likes the picture regarded as a story being good tedium and is honest.
After foundations are kana for children - just for a moment.
2008/04/17 Best! [Original Japanese review]
by 創世記 Provider: 3624 Host:3849 Browser: 5234
hagaren -- a normal -- hamari ます Skillful く and the story are also substantial for the picture.
A bad place is only being a monthly.
It is strangely late that a comic comes out because it is a monthly.
However, I think that hagaren is comics with the value for which it has waited for a long time.
2008/04/13 Comment(good) [Original Japanese review]
by 十傑集 Provider: 11009 Host:11078 Browser: 5234
if 13 volumes are reread -- the different community of the inside of the body of guratonii -- the fraud of reto 教 of one volume -- there was the founder's of a religion bleached-bones body An art is fine --
2008/04/11 Best! [Original Japanese review]
by 竜也23 Provider: 14339 Host:14316 Browser: 8090

[Good point]
Comics currently read from a schoolchild's time.
It is one of the works which it is waiting from that time and are still observed.
Although there was much depiction which a theme may be somewhat difficult and is not understood when said honestly, if it rereads now, I will feel that he could understand many things and the interest increased at that time.
It was crazy at time to the battle scene and the attractive character of まぁそ.
As mentioned now, the character of this work is liked anyhow.
ど 5 and this are wholly full of individuality, and the empathy of them can be carried out truly.
I did not think that it could take to a hero so far.
I take a story to advance of a tale and carry out [ mind as it is gradually daaku deployment ] it.
Since まぁ himself likes such daaku deployment, what is said like this is a large welcome.
since depiction of such a scene of the author is in it well, it is more interesting
[Bad point]
There is nothing especially.
if it says by force -- this -- a weekly series -- じゃな -- saying -- things -- kana A continuation is worrisome and unavoidable.
Since it is late too when it is monthly publication, it is さ ....

[Comprehensive evaluation]
Comics regarded as the most interesting from cancer cancer.
Evaluation "it is the highest!
It is ".
2008/04/06 Best! [Original Japanese review]
by Azuna Provider: 4705 Host:4429 Browser: 5234
They are the comics which a continuation worries in the highest now!
(Smile) I think that it is uncanny to honto that the comics (picture) in which only this has force by the woman can be drawn!
It is ♪♪ which is a frame frame from now on when a hint will also be explained gradually, I will cause and the last will become honto what.
Although there is a portion heavy of course since it is a dark fantasy, I think that it is tightening the whole work.
It drops off and is peevish to finish with a shady feeling in which it swelled very much, and the expectation for subsequent deployment was also interesting and ♪, besides gag also read it one book, and it is *.
It is ♪ currently had [ this does not have having said so, and ] a feeling which has done one route just from the beginning to the last and (although it becomes empty without being still the last (smile)) read in comfort although the serial comic strips with story nature have the acceleration something which neither an post-installation setup nor a meaning understands very well.
In the reason for saying, evaluation is the highest without a complaint!
*
2008/03/29 Very bad [Original Japanese review]
by SSP Provider: 17842 Host:17915 Browser: 5234
Since the series is not completed, although it cannot declare, a dark past story is dark...
That there is gag in ワri by which people are killed recklessly たり.
It never takes to it.
A pattern is fond, and comes out because sets aside...
2008/03/29 Best! [Original Japanese review]
by 韋駄天 Provider: 26499 Host:26340 Browser: 5234

[Good point]
Effective use of the new idea hint of 錬金術.
detailed explanation should do -- the psychological description of a persuasive (here -- important) hero etc.

[Comprehensive evaluation]
While a work full of inconsistencys 跋扈, this work is impressed by the posture currently considered and made to the future thing.
What was a mystery was solved little by little, and I have just been going to approach the important part of a tale still more, or am continue to look forward to it.
Evaluation is the highest.
2008/03/29 Best! [Original Japanese review]
by 原田 Provider: 18003 Host:17740 Browser: 4632
It is very pleasure about whether how is an old hint developed and to be collected.
the inside of the tale to complicate -- rationality -- I would like you to warn against lacking positive and persuasive power
2008/03/26 Best! [Original Japanese review]
by Korian Provider: 2010 Host:2111 Browser: 7395
The point merely worries uncanny interesting comics and this very simply.
However, I want you to already leave the way of 獣神.
2008/03/25 Best! [Original Japanese review]
by Chiichi Provider: 36632 Host:36784 Browser: 8090

[Good point]
I think that the tempo of a story is good exactly.
Although a 賢 person's stone, a homun cross, etc.
were felt as difficult contents kana at first, it is drawn in a very readable and peculiar view of the world.

[Bad point]
There is nothing especially.

[Comprehensive evaluation]
Although 飽きed bored the middle, in 19 volumes, it is pleasure about what are various mysteries also known and it will become now from now on.
omake in the last of a book is also one of the charm.
2008/03/07 Comment(good) [Original Japanese review]
by Afumau Provider: 26561 Host:26676 Browser: 8593

[Good point]
It is こ when the way to which it should go is found in conflict and suffering.
It was interesting positively the first stage.

[Bad point]
It is boring recently.

[Comprehensive evaluation]
Deployment and tempo are too bad although he has bought the book without missing.
However, it is even if time progress is written ...
He will not buy it soon.
2008/03/01 Best! [Original Japanese review]
by Kagura Provider: 3645 Host:3723 Browser: 5234

[Good point]
He has [ - character regarded as the contents of - being interesting ] individuality and likes.

[Bad point]
Kana which is not especially
[Comprehensive evaluation]
He likes animation in the different talk, and comics are also favorite.
2008/02/28 Very good [Original Japanese review]
by 朱鷺 Provider: 6462 Host:6715 Browser: 4317
individual -- these comics -- "-- it is favorite He so likes that you may call it ".
the role which thinks that is the talk which is pulling skillful く読者 although late mind is also somewhat carried out about story deployment, and each character has rich individuality and cannot do it vainly -- I think that words are carried out Since how to draw a picture above all looked simple and was it monthly publication that it was as being fine in fact たり, I thought that the picture and talk of こそ were used.
However, is the point which still was not made to the highest the length of a series too?
A series will be started from 2001 and it is already seven years by this year.
Continuing still more, since it still says, "It is the turning point at last" is expected.
If story deployment is slow, even if it carries out early to a slight degree, can't a reader follow?
Although it has not necessarily said that the present present condition is by no means interesting, not only May but Lynn and a run fan take out Singh's persons soon, and I think that you may heap up with the vigor which involves in the whole country.
When it is not the author but is the intention of sukueni, I want you to merely carry out somehow.
Although it is individual at the end, and love deployment of Ed and uinrii is are nowadays, can't even an adult enjoy it by daring take in in present-day popular comics by it?
In the now said for the law it becomes impossible to read comics to come out, I think that importance can be attached very much to it.
It is [ much ]
[highest that even a child can read from an adult at the point of appealing against something although it is!
Kana which may take out]
.
Can you consider?
2008/02/11 Good [Original Japanese review]
by yamabuki Provider: 26232 Host:26151 Browser: 6386
in fact -- words 回しが and や -- it is weak It is because words with as sufficient a parenthesis as it is in characters with a birthmark and words to make it saying "kyara stands although it is a supporting player" is made to say and it is a ばっ loan.
A hero also with comparatively strong turn and presence is the portion of these comics which is also help comparatively in happy Ed.
Activity Roy and like making per riza play an active part more, and making it say "There is presence from the leading role" should also be carried out.
Help of the author is felt around there.
Only the words that it is the hypocrisy to do" think that they are by it being speech and conduct which should be recorded in the history of a fiction from ...
however " which the characters of these comics emitted, or the good which is not.
If such language criticizes the act which easy nihilism or easy himself does no good behavior of characters when holding out a hand as "since it is because the direction of it is the man", but holds out a hand, only the distinguished services which made the words which how to carry out a counterattack to the party who is going to make it a bundle with the word "hypocrisy", with the narcissism that a parenthesis is good does not have, either tell a 2-dimensional character will be what should be mentioned especially.
Based on the latter words, evaluation is made "good."
2008/02/08 Comment(bad) [Original Japanese review]
by 電波ゆんゆん Provider: 15732 Host:15980 Browser: 3793
[a good point] -- the place which looks interesting apparently -- pulling -- skillful -- it is -- 。 It was good the first stage.
[Bad point] There is too much 出し after a setup.
I want it to stop to protect the hero who is not what was praised morally.
Love deployment is too cold and it is 。.
[comprehensive evaluation] -- although before was evaluated, it does not load -- there is nothing -- it passed and was made uninteresting apparently -- grand -- it is -- an endless and relatives story -- well, it is ざり The animation version's was interesting much.
It is because a setup within a brain of only the author is discharged [ which it does not load like this why ] for whether there is not nothing and interest springs for a long time by ?
reader leaving behind.
hero -- (the relatives) convenience of the rest is truly good - koitsu and others The reason which will be stopped if relatives also うと murder with 武器持 to せ which seems to be unavoidable, and which goes away a value view.
Carry out a cold sermon.
For the rest, a character is haribote truly.
Feeling is not in sight only by setup.
~ which made the past which seems to be smart for the time being -- is it only kyara like a ってな junior high school student's illusion diary?
It is especially Hawkeye.
since it is the contents which such anyhow good persons mutual-boil and preach mutually, however you can carry out empathy to nobody and you may become, be and be -- make it selfish と -- しか -- I cannot consider It stopped result and reading.
It abandoned, although it was going to find it until now the place in which it may do its best.
After he understood that various persons were in a world, the author gained social experience more, was employed to somewhere, could come and should draw?
The head is past [ 固 ] to gachigachi.
Next / Post your review / Top page
Other media
Anime:Fullmetal Alchemist (Hagane no Renkinjyutsu shi: TV series) / Game:FullMetal Alchemist and the Broken Angel / Novel:Fullmetal Alchemist
Top page of DB | Site map | Copyright(c) 1999- 1st Class All rights reserved