[Comics]Fullmetal Alchemist

Other media
Anime:Fullmetal Alchemist (Hagane no Renkinjyutsu shi: TV series) / Game:FullMetal Alchemist and the Broken Angel / Literature:Fullmetal Alchemist

If this is not the work which you are looking for, please use above search box or various list or DB's top page.

Reviews' statics

Comics total pnts rank=Avg. x Eval. num	Rank 6/in 4,773 titles (Total 411.64)	Rank 5 <= => Rank 7
Comics avg pnts rank(minimum:10 evals)	Rank 186/in 896 titles (Average 1.64(Very good))	Rank 185 <= => Rank 187
Comics total pnts rank of 2001	Rank 1/in 106 titles	=> Rank 2

All
Reviews(Post)

Fan forum

Image&Wallpaper

Goods
(Books)

Goods from USA

Goods from Japan

Latest Books: 2010/01/19 ():
Fullmetal Alchemist Volume 22 (Fullmetal Alchemist (Graphic ... $9.99

Books Sales/Latest		DVD Sales/Latest	Music Sales/Latest	VideoGames Sales/Latest
Rank:36584 Paperback:Fullmetal Alchemist Volume 22 (Fullmetal Alchemist (Graphic ... Tag:$9.99 2010/01/19 () Eval.:***** 1.Entertaining Continuance to the FullMetal Saga	Rank:38211 Paperback:Fullmetal Alchemist, Vol. 21 (Fullmetal Alchemist (Graphic N... Tag:$9.99 2009/11/17 () Eval.:***** 1.Strategy at its best!	Rank:3578 Fullmetal Alchemist: The Complete Second Season Tag:$69.98 2009/03/10 () Eval.:***** 1.Best anime of the decade	Rank:108727 Audio CD:Fullmetal Alchemist Complete Best Tag:$17.98 2006/05/30 () Eval.:***** 1.MUSIC FOR THE FMA FAN	Rank:4002 Video Game:Fullmetal Alchemist: Dual Sympathy Tag:$19.99 2006/12/12 () Eval.:***** 1.Relatively Short

Latest Books: 2010/03/27 ():

ガンガンアートコレクション2010 鋼の錬金術師 Vol.12 \7,500

Books(77hit) Sales/Latest			DVD(30hit) Sales/Latest	Music(7hit) Sales/Latest
Rank:27785 ペーパーバック:荒川弘イラスト集「FULLMETAL ALCHEMIST」 Tag:\1,500 2004/02/27 () Eval.:*****	Rank:93373 単行本:ハガレン研究所DX Tag:\800 2004/09/30 () Eval.:*****	Rank:108747 新書:小説・鋼の錬金術師―砂礫の大地 (Comic novels) Tag:\900 2003/02 () Eval.:*****	Rank:3592 Blu-ray:鋼の錬金術師 FULLMETAL ALCHEMIST 4 [Blu-ray] Tag:\7,140 2009/11/25 () Eval.:*****	Rank:119789 CD:TVアニメ「獣神演武」キャラクターソング(語り部Ver.) Vol.2 劉... Tag:\1,890 2008/01/30 ()

Information about this title

Hiromu Arakawa
SQUARE ENIX
Romi Park Junko Minagawa Rie Kugimiya Kusaka Chihiro
Toru Ohkawa Michiko Neya Kenji Utsumi
Megumi toyoguti Keiji Fujiwara
Yasunori Matsumoto Hiroaki Hirata Tsugumi Higasayama Atsuko Tanaka Kazuhiro Nakata Masako Katsuki Yukana Aya Hisakawa Shinichiro Miki Reiko Kiuchi
Masaaki Tsukada Sintarou Oohata

Japan Released:2001/07/12(Thu) BOYS GANGAN

Official sites
1. http://gangan.square-enix.co.jp/hagaren/ (Translation)

Statics of evaluation(The statics is updated once a day)

	Average	ComicsRank	Deviation(Total)	Evaluation points(Total)	Best of the Best
Inside Japan	Very good(1.64)	6	160.47	411.64	6
Outside Japan	Very good(2.00)	78	49.82	2.00

Statics of activity

	Total Views	Comment	Evaluation
Inside Japan	177,282	375	251
Outside Japan	3,366	1	1

How others evaluated in Japan

Best

Very Good

Good

Normal

Bad

Very Bad

Worst

People

Percentage

37.1%

27.9%

13.5%

11.2%

5.6%

3.2%

1.6%

Added percentage

37.1%

65%

78.5%

89.7%

95.3%

98.5%

100%

Summary

78.5%

11.2%

10.4%

Views for recent 8 days
Total 20 19 18 17 16 15 14 13
6 0 1 1 0 0 2 1 1

Forum for the special topic (Create topic)

Sorted by:Newness / Oldness
All including comments
Only Evaluation Good
Evaluation:Best/Very Good/Good Normal
Evaluation Bad
Evaluation:Bad/Very Bad/Worst
This reputation board

2007/02/28 Very good [Edit/Delete/Suggest to delete/Only this reviewer/Show only this review or post sympathy comment/(Everyone can)]
by Love and peace (Send message) Review history[Good:16(80%) Normal:4(20%) Bad:0(0%)] / Provider: 15264 Host:15441 Browser: 3008
The drawing style is very clear and I like it.
There are many characters but the story is going well with good balance.
Creating unresolved mistery while solving some mistery, it keeps catching reader's attention.
It is great thing to keep high reputation for a long term.
I think this is one of the current representative of Japanese comics.

The below reviews are translated automatically from Japanese ones. To post your review to English version, please click here.

2010/03/21 Comment(good) [Original Japanese review]
by 水夏 (Send message) Provider: 33802 Host:33659 Browser: 7942
the work which the world is already permitted enough -- it is -- sushi and you -- w regarded as at least a comment being carried out since it is a too favorite work although it thought whether he needed to evaluate now, since good evaluation was attached and it came Truly, it is perfect, and is peevish and these comics are ぇ.
Skill of drawing is stabilized from beginning to end, and shines, and only anyhow deep and attractive people are [ a character ].
Although many comics in which no and a character can utilize it thoroughly only by being attractive, and are not exist, do these comics have the brilliant arrangement to putting the right man in the right place of a character?
Although there is like this much number, the character which each companion is arranged and is not playing an active part, and the character which does not have necessity in a story are absent.
Is it uncanny that it throws away until it results in mobu, and a character is not?
For a story, in being heavy たり, grotesquely, the positive portion which a theme is consistent and man has though す draws man's negative side by cut たり is praised, and sushi and a character are もんじゃ- of an everybody "misfortune or difficult mystery なんぼ fundamentally!
Since it is only 」っていう people, it is looking, and does not become 欝 but a feeling is good.
There is nothing, and the publication pace of a comic of most stops of publishing is also favorable, and they are sushi and the comics which feel easy awfully truly and are being seen.
There is nothing [ saw ] about a thing called the cartoonist who does not have a weak point as Mr.
Arakawa.
Although the conclusion of the tale can be seen still more, a yell will be sent if it does its best at a tune with this by all means.
I will take evaluation formal for the time being until it reads the last round.

2010/02/21 Good [Original Japanese review]
by Goto (Send message) Provider: 3138 Host:2936 Browser: 9109
a story -- every talk -- always -- dare -- ず -- a に -- 飽きing bored -- not making -- a device -- feeling -- し -- the depiction with grotesque depiction and war depiction far tighter than this -- although comics are in others without limit and neither impact nor ghastliness was felt so, within the limits last-minute as boys' comics is maintained to the last A character never does not make it obtrusive at worst, although what is likely to be made to carry out activity to the extent that the leading role is defeated, and is likely to have a drawer like らせる can see many persons, and it does not start a power inflation to the change which does not make from a battle the character in which a leading role supporting player only shows the strength and activity which imposed something and restriction mostly and excelled, and is, either.
theatrical elocution -- anyhow -- almost -- a 毎度熱 right [ that ] and smartness -- if it says conversely but only in about the thing of げな touch -- this character -- such words 言わせれば -- it is hot It is smart!
It was moved by the 的な uke aim, became more nearly surfeited and more nearly surfeited [ enough ], and has cooled down on the contrary.
the balance of anyhow composition -- being skillful -- it is alike and carries out

2010/02/14 Best! [Original Japanese review]
by 赤ちゃんと少林寺黒帯 (Send message) Provider: 2202 Host:2306 Browser: 10413
skill-of-drawing: -- also saying [ O monthly publication ] -- it is -- it is written till the place where a picture is fine, and is legible Story; I carry out [ mind / like a double track / whose each of words is ] whether it thought from the start of O to the last.
A じゃこんな work is not made as it merely writes off the top of its head.
Composition power: It is good for the ひけが emergency for making O continuation read.
However, since the character which has not appeared for a long time may come out, it may not understand.
Character: Every O character is conspicuous and almost all characters are good characters for themselves.
Although it is sad when a character dies (differing from part II of those ninja comics), it is good that there is nothing at futility death.
Although mind mass tangu is too unyielding is also carried out ...
Although it is a digression, he likes especially hoe enhaimu.

2010/02/07 Best! [Original Japanese review]
by Piipiieido (Send message) Provider: 7763 Host:7450 Browser: 8735
ちょい a mystery is [ ちょい ] a work and interesting and which change of a situation is sharp, gets tired and does not carry out again -- although it is grotesque -- evaluation -- "the highest"

2010/02/07 Good [Original Japanese review]
by Monyu (Send message) Provider: 26345 Host:26547 Browser: 11275

[Comprehensive evaluation]
Isn't it in the comics which made 錬金術 major language suddenly?
Although an interpretation thinks that it differs from the so-called 錬金術 in a fantasy, I think that this will be interesting now.
Although it does not know what it becomes by the last round, the talk is slight basic darkness.
Although a pattern does not look grotesque to there by comics っぽい's, there is also expression which can be referred to as grotesque in man and an animal uniting (composition) etc.
A place [ it said that a pattern was not too bad ].
Does it say that it is thick on the whole, or is there any individuality just for a moment?
Many girls to the woman writer of a pattern who a male writer catches sight of apparently think that they are also keeping their promise are not dear, although a style is a beauty girl well.
Evaluation is good.
Although mind as which the highest is sufficient is also carried out since it is individual fairly favorite comics, whenever it buys and reads from the middle, possibly one volume is omitted in between, and it reads, and is る.
In order for considering to start plentifully, it is evaluation lowering better た for a while.
Although the number of turns is connected, some talks have not run out.
It has not flown.
...
this may be the problem of my head well

2010/02/03 Best! [Original Japanese review]
by Enegori (Send message) Provider: 3957 Host:3909 Browser: 8759

[Good point]
They are already all!
Deployment of the story drawn especially!
Gag which is contained in the individuality of a character in some places!
He likes very much that laughter is also in serious inside.

[Bad point]
Nothing!

[comprehensive evaluation]
-- this work -- favorite っ It can be moved to tears and can laugh...
It is the highest!
A continuation is worrisome and unavoidable.
Although there is a place which regards a few as whether it is also guroi and it being, that thinks that there is touch which backs up the story.
♪ in which I want the following volume to appear early

2010/02/02 Comment(good) [Original Japanese review]
by 一七夜月 (Send message) Provider: 23234 Host:23295 Browser: 10225

[Good point]
It has considered by - picture superior till the fine place, and is stable.
- The foundation of setting 錬金術 is fresh.
- The story point is worrisome and unavoidable.
A hint is also plotted and it is interesting.
- The character of character ど is also individual and likable.
For the moment, a disagreeable character is not.
If Ed, Al, and uinrii are removed among main characters, し [ uncle (smile) Al will also almost be armor ].
- Gag 笑えます.
entering in a serious scene たり -- although -- atmosphere does not necessarily collapse -- it carries out, and gag 入りま is not carried out when maji -- it carries out and I am not worried so much If the relief agent for not carrying out strain tiredness is thought.

[Bad point]
Nothing (for some men, it is grotesquely.) .
.
?

[Comprehensive evaluation]
They are the most favorite comics.
Even if it takes anything, it is �zu� without a complaint.
Since it already goes into the last chapter, it cannot look aside.
After daring complete, I want to attach evaluation, although he wants to make evaluation into the "highest."

2010/01/27 Best! [Original Japanese review]
by Miayuki (Send message) Provider: 34710 Host:34590 Browser: 3428(Mobile)
It is the highest!
Even if it takes composition, a picture, a story, and anything, they are first class goods!
Composition is overwhelming other comics especially.
I thought that も鳥肌 left like this only depending on how to show a scene as for the method of a change of a scene, the scene which utters a thought.
as まぁ巻 is piled up -- 錬金術 -- " -- although the admiration which is way" of an ant anything cannot be denied -- there -- まぁ and charms -- (smile)

2010/01/25 Very bad [Original Japanese review]
by nanjyakoreha (Send message) Provider: 16029 Host:15909 Browser: 12366
Comics which it stopped looking at in why on the way.
a cause -- it is unknown The woman was surprised that it is the author.
The equivalent exchange of money and fun is not materialized for me.

2010/01/20 Best! [Original Japanese review]
by 儀初 (Send message) Provider: 10008 Host:9730 Browser: 5740

[a good point]
-- a view-of-the-world double-tracked character
[a bad point]
-- nothing --
[comprehensive evaluation]
-- it is wonderful Meet so.
Isn't there any talk firm so far?
A point [ contradictory ] hardly comes out to a power relationship, the position of a character, etc.
As for the talk of such battles and fantasy systems, it is fairly uncanny about two one or not to completely be found, although it comes out!
It is the highest without a complaint!

2010/01/19 Best! [Original Japanese review]
by モンキー D タカトシ (Send message) Provider: 5872 Host:5822 Browser: 4483

[Good point]
All.
Since it is aloof when writing, skill of drawing is the contents of complaint-less double-tracked tension まくり an especially good place.
[ -- the death of bad point kinburii is severe

2010/01/18 Comment(good) [Original Japanese review]
by Hiroshige (Send message) Provider: 17997 Host:17896 Browser: 10770
Although evaluation carried out clearly is carried out after a series end, I think for the time being that it is completeness wonderful as comics.
It is hardly damping until now.
Deployment whose mystery calls a mystery.
With the composition of the talk, and no hint complaint.
With [ even if the character also stands ] no んく.
If it gives in total with the last gutt, it is certain to become the monumental work of a dark fantasy, and an everlasting masterpiece.
Although subsequent cancer cancer is anxious.

2010/01/18 Best! [Original Japanese review]
by きなこ牛乳 (Send message) Provider: 29046 Host:29393 Browser: 5872

[a good point]
-- picture a principle battle scene called the way view-of-the-world equivalent exchange to which a story progresses -- fine gag
[Bad point]
Especially nothing
[Comprehensive evaluation]
It is interesting when it says at a word.
It is exhausted to it.
It is the work which was able to be most enjoyed by the comics read until now.
all -- 巻全て -- although read, the work collected this much does not have a saw thing Although it is the last chapter still more, it is pleasure about what end is greeted.

2010/01/18 Very good [Original Japanese review]
by Pengingorira (Send message) Provider: 14609 Host:14410 Browser: 7940

[Good point]
A character is individual and it is good.
A view of the world is good.
The story is often kneaded.
A battle scene is smart.
The place which is not dark すぎ is also good.

[Bad point]
Those with grotesque depiction.

[Comprehensive evaluation]
It is under series now, deployment carries out comfort most, and they are comics wholly.
I think that it reads absolutely and there is no loss.

2010/01/17 Best! [Original Japanese review]
by 了泉庵漠 (Send message) Provider: 516 Host:484 Browser: 10187

[Good point]
A story is deep and can understand automatically still quickly.
Skill of drawing <- there is not a person of the same face.
By the theme thinking that it is said [ which ] whether to be, although it is a style, interesting gag is contained also into it.

[Bad point]
There is nothing especially.

[Comprehensive evaluation]
While the relation and the past of complicated characters are involved [ that it is various and ], the place where the story continues, without a seed shifting thinks that it is good.
It goes into the favorite comics higher rank individually.

2010/01/17 Best! [Original Japanese review]
by クー2 (Send message) Provider: 18003 Host:17730 Browser: 1968(Mobile)
Are these comics the highest?
He does not forget comical gag into serious deployment or the heavy talk.
Moreover, a battle is also violently impressive.
It is ぬ Mr.
Lee is [ ぬ ] a favorite as himself.
Is the heart which never forsakes the feeling, the strong people, and the strong friend of becoming a king good?
I also want the present politician to follow example.
I think that this tale is the highest work made to consider a life deeply.

2010/01/15 Best! [Original Japanese review]
by Puraisu (Send message) Provider: 20315 Host:20349 Browser: 5533
The contents are also new and very readable interesting works.
It is easy to carry out empathy to a character sociably.
It can laugh also at the gag which comes out to the heavy talk, and a character is good.

2010/01/08 Best! [Original Japanese review]
by mおkお (Send message) Provider: 2307 Host:2143 Browser: 11465

[Good point]
The intelligible top 割絵 story is firmly made to the last.
The principle of an equivalent exchange
[Bad point]
There is nothing especially.

[Comprehensive evaluation]
Are these comics uncanny?
A story is also deep and a picture is also legible.
It is [ how it finishes and ] pleasure.
since -- evaluation -- "the highest"

2010/01/04 Best! [Original Japanese review]
by Namekobanana (Send message) Provider: 4626 Host:4665 Browser: 5389
growth of people is a theme -- it is * also with an interesting story which it carries out, is beautiful also as for a picture, and is impressed -- gag is on strike of serious touch now and then, and balance is maintained Individuality is in a character and I want to come to aid, respectively.
Are they よ-く考える and deep comics?
From now on, a climax enjoys itself and it is !.
"Highest!
It is" evaluation!

2010/01/03 Best! [Original Japanese review]
by Babuu (Send message) Provider: 21933 Host:21964 Browser: 11168

[Good point]
Deployment of the idea character and tale of - capability
[a bad point]
- there is nothing especially It is つまらなそ- until it reads.
Although said, if it actually reads, it is smart and is interesting, and it is painful, and is already saikoo ってかんじ.
kechi attaches to this and there is no れ in it.

Post your evaluation or comment.(Evaluation can be posted only once)

You need
1 other people's posts to post your evaluation or
30 other people's posts to post your comment
after you post your evaluation or comment.
Other media
Anime:Fullmetal Alchemist (Hagane no Renkinjyutsu shi: TV series) / Game:FullMetal Alchemist and the Broken Angel / Literature:Fullmetal Alchemist

Your Name(Required):

Password (Required. more than 4 characters) [If you want to create secure password: Online mkpasswd service]

Your comment about this anime(Required)

Your evaluation of this title(Required)
You can choose the evaluation only once. After you post your evaluation, please choose comment instead of evaluation from the options.

Evaluation of this title(You can choose this only once)
Your evaluation
If you evaluated this title once, please choose comment instead of the evaluation. Or you can use forum.
Comment by the person who thinks this is good
Comment by the person who thinks this is normal
Comment by the person who thinks this is bad

Please choose appropriate option for readers.

Pleaase confirm that your post is satisfing the following rules

Rule for reviews

This site allows you to write reviews for each title, but we don't allow you to criticize others' comment. Too bad or meaningless words are also not allowed. The comment which doesn't follow the rule will be deleted and access will be denied.

Caution: Please post the evaluation which follows the rule.

DB Top > Works > Comics > Fullmetal Alchemist[Comics]:Review/Information

All
Reviews(Post)

Fan forum

Image&Wallpaper

Goods
(Books)

Other media
Anime:Fullmetal Alchemist (Hagane no Renkinjyutsu shi: TV series) / Game:FullMetal Alchemist and the Broken Angel / Literature:Fullmetal Alchemist

Sales top 100

Anime(EN)	1. Ponyo TwoDisc / 2. Astro Boy / 3. Ponyo TwoDisc / 4-100
Game(EN)	1. God of / 2. Pokemon SoulSilver / 3. Wii / 4-100
Comics(EN)	1. Warriors / 2. Scott Pilgrim, Vol. 3 / 3. xxxHOLiC 15 / 4-100
Figure(EN)	1. Bakugan 7 / 2. Bakugan Launcher / 3. Avatar Navi / 4-100

Other: Anime(JP) / Game(JP) / Game machine(JP) / Comics(JP) / Movie(JP) / JP movie(JP) / Figure(JP) / Anime/Game Music(JP) / SF/Fantasy(JP) / Mistery(JP) / History(JP) / Romance(JP)

Sorted by alphabet	People[Voice / Actor / Supervisor / Story / Producer / Editor / Camera / Music / Singer / Writer / Drawer] Company[Anime / Game / Comics / Book / Drama / Movie / Music / Office / Tv] / Magazine / Group / Machine
Sorted by related works number	People[Voice / Actor / Supervisor / Story / Producer / Editor / Camera / Music / Singer / Writer / Drawer] Company[Anime / Game / Comics / Book / Drama / Movie / Music / Office / Tv] / Magazine / Group / Machine
Sorted by fan number	People[Voice / Actor / Supervisor / Story / Music / Singer / Writer / Drawer] Company[Anime / Game / Comics / Book / Drama / Movie / Music / Office / Tv] / Magazine / Group / Machine

Sorted by:Newness / Oldness
All including comments Only Evaluation	Good Evaluation:Best/Very Good/Good	Normal Evaluation	Bad Evaluation:Bad/Very Bad/Worst