Japanese works database(How to join/Help)
Top page: All/Only Reviews

Others
Site map

AllAnimeGameComicNovelDramaSp. effectJP movieMovie	Info:voice,game..	Reviewers	Diary
Search / Outside DB:

Comics ranking: Rank 27/in 4,125 titles (Total 210.00/Deviation 96.08) Rank 26 <= => Rank 28
Comics average points ranking: Rank 60/in 661 titles (Average 2.00(Very good)/Deviation 61.26) Rank 59 <= => Rank 61 (more than 10 evaluatoin)
Comics ranking of 1999: Rank 1/in 57 titles => Rank 2

Hikaru no Go(Comics)

[Other version: RSS/Japanese version]

Other media
Anime:Hikaru no Go / Game:Hikarunogo

All
Reviews(Post)

Forum

Images

Goods
(Books)

Latest Books: 2008/05/06 ():

Hikaru no Go, Vol. 12 (Hikaru No Go (Graphic Novels)) $95

Books(50hit) Sales/Latest						DVD(12hit) Sales/Latest	Music(11hit) Sales/Latest	VideoGames(2hit) Sales/Latest	Toys(3hit) Sales/Latest
Rank:109636 Paperback:Hikaru No Go, Volume 8 (Hikaru No Go (Graphic Novels)) Tag:$95 2006/11/07 () Eval.:***** 1.THE BEST -- non-violent manga!	Rank:255750 Paperback:Hikaru no Go, Vol. 12 (Hikaru No Go (Graphic Novels)) Tag:$95 2008/05/06 () Eval.:***** 1.Hikaru No Go #12 is delightful!	Rank:260083 Paperback:Hikaru No Go, Vol. 1 Tag:$95 2004/06/16 () Eval.:***** 1.A title that shouldn't be missed	Rank:270748 Paperback:Hikaru No Go, Volume 2 (Hikaru No Go (Graphic Novels)) Tag:$95 2004/10/12 () Eval.:***** 1.CUT DOWN TO SIZE	Rank:342368 Paperback:Hikaru No Go Vol. 10 (Hikaru No Go (Graphic Novels)) Tag:$95 2007/08/07 () Eval.:***** 1.Review of Hikaru No Go vol. 10	Rank:363782 Paperback:Hikaru No Go, Volume 9 (Hikaru No Go (Graphic Novels)) Tag:$95 2007/04/03 () Eval.:***** 1.A great series even if you can't play go which I can't!	Rank:14534 Prince of Tennis Box Set 4 Tag:$98 2008/01/15 () Eval.:***** 1.Ripped box	Rank:498962 Audio CD:Hikaru No Go Original Anime Soundtrack 2002 ()	Rank:182148 Toy:Hikaru No Go Playing Cards Poker Deck Tag:$95	Rank:667 Toy:Go Game with Wood Board Tag:$99 2007/07/01 () Eval.:***** 1.Excellent beginner's set

Information about this title

Yumi Hotta
Takeshi Obata
Yukari Umezawa
SHUEISHA
Weekly Boys Jump

Released:1999 in Japan End:2003 in Japan

Official sites
1. http://jump.shueisha.co.jp/hikaru/ (Translation)

Statics of evaluation(The statics is updated once a day)

	Average	ComicsRank	Deviation(Total)	Evaluation points(Total)	Best of the Best
Inside Japan	Very good(2.00)	27	96.08	210.00	2
Outside Japan	Very good(2.00)	40	50.51	2.00

Statics of activity

	Total Views	Comment	Evaluation
Inside Japan	34,739	99	93
Outside Japan	1,901	1	1

How others evaluated in Japan

Best

Very Good

Good

Normal

Bad

Very Bad

Worst

People

Percentage

38.7%

15.1%

4.3%

0.0%

1.1%

2.2%

Added percentage

38.7%

77.4%

92.5%

96.8%

97.9%

100%

Summary

92.5%

4.3%

3.3%

Views for recent 8 days
Total 19 18 17 16 15 14 13 12
7 0 0 2 2 0 0 1 2

Language Sorted by date Sorted by recommendation New!
English Good
(Only Evaluation) Normal
(Only Evaluation) Bad
(Only Evaluation) All
(Only Evaluation) None
Japanese Good
(Only Evaluation) Normal
(Only Evaluation) Bad
(Only Evaluation) All
(Only Evaluation) All
This reputation board

Language	Sorted by date	Sorted by recommendation New!
English	Good (Only Evaluation)	Normal (Only Evaluation)	Bad (Only Evaluation)	All (Only Evaluation)	None
Japanese	Good (Only Evaluation)	Normal (Only Evaluation)	Bad (Only Evaluation)	All (Only Evaluation)	All

2005/03/23 Very good [Edit/Delete//Only this reviewer/Only this review/post sympathy comment/]
by oe2ng Review history[Good:7(100%) Normal:0(0%) Bad:0(0%)] / Provider: 48820 Host:48723 Browser: 3875
anybody growing up with some lesson about fail

Post your review / Top page

Other media
Anime:Hikaru no Go / Game:Hikarunogo

The below reviews are translated automatically from Japanese ones. To post to English version, please click here.

2008/07/09 Very good [Original Japanese review]
by Nirama Provider: 13991 Host:13982 Browser: 2983(Mobile)
This work that even those who do not know at all drew as well as those who understand the game of go is uncanny.
Although he tried to want for go board 描く to be quite serious, it is true to also draw such a fine place exactly.
Can't you try to want to be able to refer to as Hokuto cup editing after 佐為 disappears not much reputable?
Although he likes individually.
Although it thinks that a 佐 sake is "the go of hikaru" of いてこそ to be sure, I think that it was good that growth " when requiring own "佐 sake of hikaru, growth " after "佐 sake stops being, and both were able to be seen.
Kana which wanted to also already see a future event just for a moment although it thinks how it is even if it becomes not much long.
A picture often changes and is a better seed.
Especially Mr.
伊角 (smile)

2008/06/22 Good [Original Japanese review]
by Pika Provider: 14300 Host:14213 Browser: 5234

[Good point]
Story which can be enjoyed very much even if there is no rule 知 and others of - game of go.
It is 惹き込 rare て行き better た rapidly.
To have contributed to game-of-go spread can also be assented.
- The locus of growth (he does not so like the hikaru itself) of hikaru.
- There are many attractive characters.
- Playful 佐 sake.
- Although the Hokuto cup was pros-and-cons あるみたい, it burned with the deployment which has sweaty palms individually.

[Bad point]
He dislikes - 塔矢 akira in the character of all the comics that he has read until now.
Although it turns out that it is the character "in which it is hot in the game of go, and the surroundings disappear", use Ochi politely, or I give the visitor of the game of go the worst humiliation of 4 person 持碁, or think that it will be disqualification also as man, of course as a pro of the game of go.
It is hard to be convinced also to the recognition to hikaru individually.
Although disillusioned at once, it was very unpleasant to have taken [ continue ] the speech and conduct which had ability far higher till then much than themselves, were consistent after that (their real intention how that), and were looked down on.
- It is not rare for "not only the matter of no concern" which the author was telling in the book but words to feel it old.
"-- obtaining -- once""-- although " etc.
will be used soon -- - The volume on extra did not seldom care for it.
- Go skill is sometimes mysterious.
"-- a pro -- an examination -- substance -- a complete victory -- having passed -- akira -- one - two -- order -- a primary -- loitering -- て -- Awara -- three -- a time -- one -- a degree -- しか -- it cannot win -- " -- "-- 伊角 which can win Kuwahara Hon'imbo in the face of a board -- " -- etc
[Comprehensive evaluation]
I think it serious only for this to have been able to draw wonderful comics by simple subject matter called the game of go, and to also have won popularity.
Probably, the work of until was not made this much, if the teacher whom the original carved, Mr.
Obata of comics, and either were also missing.
However, it is regrettable that charm was seldom able to be felt individual for a hero's hikaru and the rival's akira.
For that, evaluation is "highest with a minus point!
" is not given --

2008/06/12 Very good [Original Japanese review]
by NTK Provider: 2643 Host:2657 Browser: 4184

[Good point]
The place which can be enjoyed even if it does not know the rule of - game of go, since he liked sai individually, it was [ - picture ] shocking that sai stopped
[a bad point]
with the very sufficient method of growth of superior and a hero and being in the second half.

[Comprehensive evaluation]
It is the highest without a complaint!
Although he wants for it to be alike and to carry out, since sai stopped being from the middle too, it is very good.

2008/06/03 Good [Original Japanese review]
by pom Provider: 14177 Host:14340 Browser: 8090
The work enjoyed very much in its junior-and-senior-high-school-students days.
From the volume on Hokuto cup, it becomes a hips bud rapidly and there is no conclusion about a way of God after all, and the answer which hikaru found out for itself is not understood well.
Though regrettable, for a 佐 reason, even editing is the portion which can acquire popularity and it surely cannot but criticize severely after that.
But it is rather good till the place which hikaru regains its footing and also faces its go each other again the second half.
There is if a top rate is particularly uncanny, no if production is uncanny, place to say.
not much -- a professional -- it is the work which is not stinking Although this is in a good meaning, of course ...
Although skill of drawing was stable from beginning to end, it moved from the middle stage that it was a deformation type pattern at the time of the first stage very well to the real route.
Although some sense of incongruity will be felt if it improves, it can see for features and the looks of hikaru growing, and this has also become a taste.
The subject matter to treat is only best and makes existence like the ghost which is not visible then, attach out of hikaru mind with go.
As it was as a technique, in fact, there was nothing.
It is an interesting setup.
Although it osusume reading in detail since it finishes with a free story introduction even if it puts a story in order from the beginning in drops, there is only power which pulls the reader strongly.
If the interesting place was raised especially, how depending on which pro examination section rises was uncanny.
In the persons who were looking at that talk by the weekly magazine or the comic by real time, it is influenced and the man of having memorized go also thinks that he is not few, either.
Himself who writes and who says is also the one person w.
In fact, it viewed and listened also to the way of animation.
BGM was rather smart, and the feeling of strain of a game, vigor, etc.
were emphasized by no one but [ animation ], and were good.
That one is also osusume(ed) although the talk of animation should not be taken up here.
Moreover, the smile which is the contents which a 奈瀬 fan can also enjoy since 奈瀬 is finer than comics Although a theme called the game of go may be at the beginning also as for those who consider a stake, if vigor on that occasion and the heat of a game can be felt, I will think that it is satisfactory at all.
そりゃ bubble かれば -- furthermore, he could be enjoyed -- けど and 悪手 were made to change oneself into a good move Since it does not come with a pin at all even if it says, it is a smile.
Moreover, since the game is progressing, is also looking for an actual record of the moves and plays of a game of Go also one how to enjoy itself based on the record of the moves and plays of a game of Go which actually existed?
Although it became long, as comprehensive evaluation, it [ very good even in the volume on Hokuto cup ] or subsequent ones is worsened, and it is made evaluation of being good.

2008/05/27 Best! [Original Japanese review]
by 熱血スポーツゲーマー Provider: 24824 Host:24947 Browser: 2256
Since you have done evaluation of the talk, it is another viewpoint.
These comics are read and the size of skill of drawing and the power which a sense gives is too felt strong.
Of course, it is not only by it.
I think that it can read happily because makers have faced each other sincerely to the game of go, they got down and had paid respect even if it does not know the rule of the game of go.
Making it read that a reader does not have sense of incongruity needs to know the game, and it needs to understand deeply.
You have to make an effort to tell a partner fun and wonderfulness moreover.
just -- "-- it says -- it carries out by は易(ing) -- it は難 and is " Difficulties of a maker are not common.
I think it were very good to have put Mr.
Umezawa on editorial supervision.
moreover, sincerity and the result of efforts should hear also from being admired from the game-of-go association -- ます There is a difference like heavens and the ground with the tennis comics of どこぞ.
When dealing with a thing called the game of go by comics, I think that the posture of this work is what can carry out the maximum evaluation.

2008/05/27 Very good [Original Japanese review]
by Aaaaaaa Provider: 25897 Host:25645 Browser: 8570
[ -- the figure good point hikaru grows up to be thought that it was very good The talk per last was able to be read without 飽きing bored although read how many times.

[Bad point]
I wanted you to continue to a slight degree.
I think that the bandage game of go of 塔矢 is not needed.

[Comprehensive evaluation]
It is very interesting although those whom the game of go does not understand at all read.
Conversely, it may be dissatisfied when those who know the game of go read.

2008/05/21 Good [Original Japanese review]
by goodday0220 Provider: 40360 Host:40264 Browser: 6395
Although the rule of the game of go did not know, this work was read every week.
Since from boyhood to younger days were drawn and devices truly appropriate for boys' comics, such as growth of hikaru and a game with a rival, were taken out above all, there is also no strange mortal 技っぽい and he was able to be enjoyed as comics of the real game of go.
Although it divided into part I and part II and the tale was advanced, having finished halfway is sorry about the ability to have not obtained a little.
Since it is the comics which are still satisfying fully, I consider that it is better to read.

2008/04/27 Best! [Original Japanese review]
by 炎髪君 Provider: 41661 Host:41599 Browser: 9070
Although there is already nothing in a house now, I think that game-of-go comics will be collected by no means なぁ - .., and now.
However, it was absorbed so much.
I can think from the bottom of my heart that the hika go which only that made uncanny comics from the game of go, and had been set to one of the faces of a jump is really uncanny.
For itself, hika go is hama って better た fully to these comics during a series.
A personal computer is sufficient game-of-go 8, and there is influenced uncanny memory with it being as reading despite the newspaper game of go だり.
Was also the picture nice only to Mr.
Obata, and was also Ms.
Yukari Umezawa helpful, and are such Ryosaku comics born?
A character is also good and is the highest comics.
Evaluation is the highest in the reason for saying.

2008/04/20 Good [Original Japanese review]
by Hikku Provider: 34156 Host:34112 Browser: 4731
Although the rule of the game of go was not understood at all, it was very interesting.
First, that is wonderful.
Next, I think that the process of growth of hikaru was able to be drawn well.
The supporting player of existence of rival 塔矢, 伊角 and Ochi, and 和谷 was also conspicuous.
It was exciting in whether hikaru wins its way up especially to a pro examination every week.
Mr.
Obata's style of painting becomes good for こど which piles up a volume.
I think that it toned down from edited by Hokuto.
The last talk was also regrettable halfway.
If the rule of the game of go is memorized, I will think that it is the work to which it takes more.

2008/04/09 Best! [Original Japanese review]
by 天人 Provider: 1307 Host:1244 Browser: 5234
Say that they are comics which the talk understands also in those who do not know [ a setup and ] about go well.
Animation finishes on the way and is sad.
I think that they are good comics.

2008/04/08 Very good [Original Japanese review]
by Herukomandaa Provider: 8075 Host:8017 Browser: 4184

[Good point]
Picture.
Story.
Character.

[Bad point]
A record of the moves and plays of a game of Go is pakuri.

[Comprehensive evaluation]
It is the highest except a record of the moves and plays of a game of Go not being pakuri.
But since it is pakuri too, it is a demerit mark.

2008/04/01 Best! [Original Japanese review]
by Gyaroppu Provider: 25356 Host:25322 Browser: 3646
Since it overlapped with the time when he began the game of go and the series started, it is 惹かれ better た immediately.
First, a picture is very beautiful and legible.
Growth of hikaru was expressed the skillful く table and the story was also good.
It reads making it terrible excitedly and the match of a 塔矢 expert and 佐 sake is better た.
In the volume on Hokuto cup, it is likable at the place which drew the difference of the ability of present Japan, and South Korea and China as reality, and was not made into the Japanophile, expressing the growth of hikaru own after the 佐 sake stopped being.
Since the record of the moves and plays of a game of Go used by the yonha game was the thing of the game which he knows, having been very regrettable individually is that a result is known immediately at the beginning.
Although it is well unavoidable ...

2008/03/31 Best! [Original Japanese review]
by ZERELU Provider: 31681 Host:31706 Browser: 7395

[Good point]
It thought that human depiction was nice despite a simple subject matter called go, and growth of a 佐 sake and hikaru was drawn, and after a 佐 sake disappeared, the figure hikaru overcomes it and grows up to be was also good.

[Bad point]
I wanted you to continue more.

2008/03/18 Best! [Original Japanese review]
by Fuurin Provider: 18575 Host:18507 Browser: 5234

[a good point]
-- even if it does not know the game of go, it can read -- just -- a masterpiece A picture and a story are quite good!
There is value of enough to read!
It is interesting!
.

[Comprehensive evaluation]
Highest!

2008/01/20 Best! [Original Japanese review]
by Gyunei Provider: 43274 Host:43237 Browser: 6342
As for all also of the picture regarded as there being also no complications and it being a masterpiece, a story, and kyara, it is good that the growth process of quantity level hikaru is drawn.
It came to the words of "having seen the appearance I begin and man grows up to be ..." with じ, ~ ん.
[ of the uncle of a game-of-go salon ] Was it hot that hikaru VS koyonha fought?
...

2008/01/20 Very good [Original Japanese review]
by 赤い水性のシャア Provider: 12661 Host:12509 Browser: 3034(Mobile)
This was able to be enjoyed, although he is an honest shogi group and there was no game of go from a part for a deer just for a moment.
although it was apprehensive about the close at the first time of a series to a subject matter called the game of go -- the outside of mind -- unexpected It was ordinarily interesting.
Moreover, it is as Mr.
Obata of tesunooto is writing, and a picture is great.
Although I do not understand well even if it saw a thing with superior where へん, or 板面, it was interesting in why.
Evaluation is "very good."

2008/01/19 Best! [Original Japanese review]
by 時雨月 Provider: 28877 Host:29050 Browser: 6520
If allowed to say honestly, whenever the Obata 健先生 will deal with the painter of a work, is how Mr.
Yumi's carved original is wonderful made to realize , although it does not know whether to be what may write such things?
...
The same painter is also different so far ...
although I do not understand the rule of the game of go at all -- here -- と -- is it uncanny in the place to say that a feeling of strain is transmitted just?
Like baseball or a basket, although 点差 is easy to be the form which is a foregone conclusion, the situation is layman's appraisal what and shogi, the game of go, etc.
think it poor what to be 悪手 by the hand with what [ sufficient ].
I think that the arm of the original author and a painter can tell it too perfectly.
The back, if I borrow the language read by somewhere a long time ago, the thing "hero power" does not exist in these comics.
When it becomes the pinch or becomes that it is likely to lose, there is no depiction ...
which the power more than ability is demonstrated [ ...
] suddenly and reverses the situation.
When a stand is taken against the strong man more than itself, it surely loses, and if a way made to regard it as "this" is able to be struck, it will become the proof of saying [ that the inherent powers of hikaru were improved ].
Therefore, growth of hikaru is known visibly.
If it becomes soon too, it turns out that Mr.
ゆみ's scenario was the give-and-take good relation in which Mr.
Obata's production and 画力 employ Mr.
Yumi efficiently taking advantage of Mr.
Obata.
Although まぁ and writing brew what No.
and か is not understood, I think that it is a good work.
Of course, evaluation is the "highest." Isn't it the real comics which are said in the work which can hold a picture well?
...

2007/11/17 Very good [Original Japanese review]
by 馬王 Provider: 18453 Host:18387 Browser: 8964
The point of having made the subject matter which truly carries out a young-man receptacle and which is called game of go which is not likely to be received, and making the game of go into the social boom is a very wonderful work.
It is the work which wove in hot blood flavor fundamentally with polite story composition and simple liberal arts in pattern in addition to the 美男 beauty and the good hand of 画力, and drew growth of a hero carefully and which was able to improve on the whole very much.
First of all, although it was reluctantly made to associate from his interest basis and the regret to the game of go at the beginning because hikaru which is not interested in the game of go at all meets with the 佐 sake of Hon'imbo, the process which the attachment and aspiration over the game of go of hikaru bud gradually from encounter of 塔矢, and pushes on to the way to the world of the game of go truly is reading, and it is very interesting.
since only the contents of the "game of go" are not simply drawn on a picture and another human drama, another relation, etc.
are polite -- Durrell -- it can read without things since the focus is drawing not only two persons but growth of the good rivals who meet in the go association meeting place -- zureru -- don't fill the whole kyara with love without things - and the point which can be taken in -- a good feel I think that the scene on which especially the 佐 sake will not have disappeared is the noted scene where the hikaru itself was most grown up into the adult.
Henceforth, it was thought that it was how to be able to finish taking in the expectation for the future when the generation of 進, は若者 and others shines, turning its eyes to Japanese China and South Korea, such as the Hokuto cup, and the world.

2007/10/28 Best! [Original Japanese review]
by Sharu Provider: 1407 Host:1248 Browser: 5598
Since the animation version was very interesting, 今作 which hits the original was also read.
Illustrating was good, drama nature was felt and story deployment was also very interesting.
Although I did not know the rule of the game of go at all, he was able to be enjoyed very much.
The process which makes the ability of the game of go make progress in hikaru gradually in response to advice of a 佐 sake is described carefully, and it was likable.
Moreover, it was polite, signs that hikaru was growing also as a reasonable creature in addition to the ability of the game of go were felt, and depiction of bonds with various friends of hikaru was also a good impression.
Although the image of the game of go of a psychological warfare was strong and it gave the impression of the sport of a little simple touch, skillful く描写 of the mental diplomacy with a waging-war partner is carried out, it is reading, and there was a feeling of tension.
Moreover, there is no common depiction of the abnormal "mortal work" etc.
in the work dealing with a sport, and I think that it is Ryosaku who can also read in comfort those who do not know the game of go at all with a serious style.
Since comical depiction is occasionally inserted even if it calls it a serious style, is also the point which not much formal touch does not carry out a good impression?
Illustrating is good, and the psychological description of each appearance character also has it, and it regards very much the story deployment as which drama nature is felt as yes, it being a quality work all fields.
[ polite ] Since it thought that it was Ryosaku who can read happily from the beginning to the last even if the rule of the game of go was not found at all, evaluation is made into the "highest."

2007/10/21 Best! [Original Japanese review]
by 前田清貴 Provider: 9818 Host:10088 Browser: 6520
The work with which I who know only a few (really for a while) can also enjoy the game of go.
(My oyaji is -- although it is a game-of-go fan.) I thought that it was an interesting work obediently.
However, since it will consider if the rule of the game of go cannot expect unsatisfactory in the place which read this work, doing too is only -- When dealing with the game of go, as originality, it is the highest.
(It is -- although it was surprised when it saw at first) Is it an everlasting masterpiece?

Next / Post your review / Top page

Other media
Anime:Hikaru no Go / Game:Hikarunogo

ALERT: You cannot use open proxy or TOR for posting your review. If it is detected, your access to this site will be prohibited.

Rule for reviews

This site allows you to write reviews for each title, but we don't allow you to criticize others' comment. Too bad or meaningless words are also not allowed. The comment which doesn't follow the rule will be deleted. If you find any comment which doesn't follow the rule, please notify us by clicking Suggest to delete.

Example to be deleted frequently

Favorite side
You dislike this one, then don't see it or comment this title
- Please go to the fan site. Anyone has the right to say what they feel in this site.

Disliking side
Do you like this one? You are stupid.
- Your view is only your view. Please concentrate on only the content of the title, not on others' comment.

Please use only English. If not, the comment will be deleted.

Your Name(Required)

Password (Required. more than 4 characters)

Your comment about this anime(Required)

Your evaluation of this title(Required)
You can choose the evaluation only once. After you post your evaluation, please choose comment instead of evaluation from the options.

Evaluation of this title(You can choose this only once)

Best!!
Very good
Good
Normal
Bad
Very Bad
Worst

If you evaluated this title once, please choose comment instead of the evaluation.
Comment by the person who thinks this is good
Comment by the person who thinks this is normal
Comment by the person who thinks this is bad

Please choose appropriate option for readers.

Caution: Please post the evaluation which follows the rule.