Japanese works database(How to join/Help)
Top page: All/Only Reviews

Others
Site map


Search / Outside DB:

Comics ranking: Rank 4,134/in 4,168 titles (Total -52.85/Deviation 36.55) Rank 4,133 <= => Rank 4,135
Comics average points ranking: Rank 626/in 673 titles (Average -1.51(Very bad)/Deviation 31.97) Rank 625 <= => Rank 627 (more than 10 evaluatoin)
Comics ranking of 2000: Rank 71/in 72 titles Rank 70 <= => Rank 72

Ikki Tosen(Comics)

[Other version: RSS/Japanese version]

Other media
Anime:Ikki Tosen

All
Reviews(Post)

Forum

Images

Goods
(DVD)

Latest DVD: 2007/06/12 ():

Ikki Tousen Complete Set $98

DVD(2hit) Sales/Latest
Rank:58087 Ikki Tousen - Fighting Fate (Vol. 4) Tag:$98 2005/03/01 () Eval.:***** 1."DON'T CALL ME STUPIIIIIIID!!!!"	Rank:60862 Ikki Tousen Complete Set Tag:$98 2007/06/12 () Eval.:***** 1.A great story...but.....

Information about this title

Yuzi Shiozaki
Comic GUM
WANI BOOKS CO., LTD

Released:2000 in Japan

Statics of evaluation(The statics is updated once a day)

	Average	ComicsRank	Deviation(Total)	Evaluation points(Total)	Best of the Best
Inside Japan	Very bad(-1.51)	4,134	36.55	-52.85

Statics of activity

	Total Views	Comment	Evaluation
Inside Japan	79,641	38	35
Outside Japan	1,270	0	0

How others evaluated in Japan

Best

Very Good

Good

Normal

Bad

Very Bad

Worst

People

Percentage

2.9%

5.7%

8.6%

5.7%

14.3%

22.9%

40.0%

Added percentage

2.9%

8.6%

17.2%

22.9%

37.2%

60.1%

100%

Summary

17.2%

5.7%

77.2%

Views for recent 8 days
Total 20 19 18 17 16 15 14 13
2 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 1

Language Sorted by date Sorted by recommendation New!
English Good
(Only Evaluation) Normal
(Only Evaluation) Bad
(Only Evaluation) All
(Only Evaluation) None
Japanese Good
(Only Evaluation) Normal
(Only Evaluation) Bad
(Only Evaluation) All
(Only Evaluation) All
This reputation board

Language	Sorted by date	Sorted by recommendation New!
English	Good (Only Evaluation)	Normal (Only Evaluation)	Bad (Only Evaluation)	All (Only Evaluation)	None
Japanese	Good (Only Evaluation)	Normal (Only Evaluation)	Bad (Only Evaluation)	All (Only Evaluation)	All

Post your review / Top page

Other media
Anime:Ikki Tosen

The below reviews are translated automatically from Japanese ones. To post to English version, please click here.

2008/07/06 Very bad [Original Japanese review]
by 三八式ほへーじゅー Provider: 17538 Host:17528 Browser: 9363

[Good point]
Although written also to animation, a hero thinks that a Sonsaku is the interesting way of thinking.

[a bad point]
-- for themselves, they are the contents of gakkuri くる very much -- although it hides and is not conspicuous in the Sonsaku (being too severe) or Syuuyu out of whom a sigh comes to severe [ of character composition ] like animation -- Mr.
楽就 -- ...
-- if it is a historical fact -- long ago -- dying -- ます -- ...
--
[comprehensive evaluation]
people's work -- not much -- strong -- denying -- た -- although there is nothing, if this is severe -- ...
[ of the Mikuni mind fan

2008/05/06 Best! [Original Japanese review]
by Buruuteikasu Provider: 2744 Host:2622 Browser: 3874

[A good point]
There are quite many parts where the previous work progressed.

[A bad point]
The scenario was inferior to the previous work.

[Comprehensive evaluation]
In consideration of the achievements of a previous work, it is made the highest.

2008/02/23 Worst [Original Japanese review]
by H&J Provider: 9273 Host:9404 Browser: 8090
It cannot be.
If you want to draw changing grapple comics, you should look for a more suitable subject matter.
Therefore, it is the Mikuni 志って also for depending it -- I do not want to also carry out imagination very, supposing a foreign cartoonist sprouts, makes Japanese all Warring States generals a character and draws changing grapple comics.
Therefore, dislike is felt very much to this work.
Evaluation: Worst

2008/02/14 Worst [Original Japanese review]
by 剣舞大使 Provider: 34156 Host:34138 Browser: 4749
Good 点絵 -- Well beautiful -- Point.
Carry out by therefore treating the Mikuni mind also depending the thing which covered the skin called bad point battle comics and for which sex appeal is only offered in fact.
kore is the monochrome which trampled down the Mikuni mind by the time it was brilliant, and pushed the true contrary of the real thrill of the private Mikuni mind of men's hot blood on.
It is not wonderful that there is a highlight tear [ in chirarizumu, kyonuu, and a battle / dress / in biribiri ] work, and it is independently good on today's comics community.
However, probably, the Mikuni mind may not be used.
As the name of a person was used as it was, they are sushi and the domain of already an insult.
Is a hero 孫策?
Probably, he remembered anger more, if it was 〓o〓
Or [ that this is only help ] (it is what help.) It is not a good point, either -- Although lent from the person who entered from the game and touched various Mikuni mind works after that, saying "this is an ant now", it gives up by one volume.
"- !
-- " -- having thrust back .
Evaluation is the "worst" on a system.
When there were が and the worst in the worst, the 1st place of buchigiri was gained in the comics section.
Even the worst is lukewarm.

2008/01/24 Very good [Original Japanese review]
by 赤い水性のシャア Provider: 12661 Host:12504 Browser: 3034(Mobile)
Unique 作 called a woman quantity student in the general of almost all the Mikuni minds.
May a battle also be powerful although it is sex appeal serious consideration completely?
Nakedness of dress is almost same to the degree of a battle at biribiri.
It is erotic [ which a (smile) does not become at all offensively, either / good ].
I think that a picture is very beautiful and it has had influence good for both sex appeal and a battle.
Advance being slower and a thing with an expensive comic are merely a fault.
Evaluation is "very good."

2007/10/15 Very bad [Original Japanese review]
by 八郎太 Provider: 18003 Host:17894 Browser: 4663
The Mikuni mind is evaluation from the position of non-見.
What would it be?
-- Wherever it may take, it is the impression of being halfway (rather than it saying low level).
Since the shortage of force but love elements are also clearly few even if it sees as a battle thing, pleasantly, the talk is performed here and there and it is hard to understand it.
Erotic depiction is clearly unnatural and does not have skillful く whose place at which collects displeasure and it can laugh is not a certain translation, either and which a picture also meets further.
There is also no element which the point worries from the above reason.
Although an idea may be interesting one, it is only it truly.
Since the Mikuni mind is non-見 as mentioned above, although the "worst" is not given --

2007/10/14 Comment(good) [Original Japanese review]
by Metako Provider: 39923 Host:39892 Browser: 3874
When it says at a word, it is baka Mikuni mind (it praises once).
These comics are the sex appeal action grapple comics led by a woman quantity student fundamentally, and I think that the Mikuni mind has only the spice-element.
Although the Mikuni matchless hodgepodge battle was expected when 孫策な in the hero, it seems to take pains to go ahead with the talk and plan what or adjustment so that a historical fact may be met unawares.
In a story, I think under those circumstances that setup of the Mikuni mind is fetters conversely.
On the contrary, a single combat of a general and a general gaily drawn also in the Mikuni mind and 妙 of the essence and combination think that they are fully utilizing a setup of the Mikuni mind.
For the time being, we recommend a single reading to 関羽 of dark-skinned loose socks, 典偉 of gosurori, doji っ娘劉備 of glasses, and those that do not pull by such a keyword.
At the time of this comment, it gets down into 真っ只 which goes to Akakabe's fighting.
visible [ come out to a slight degree and / a conclusion ] kana since Akakabe is likely to become a climax somehow Evaluation is after that.

2007/05/14 Good [Original Japanese review]
by 銀葵 Provider: 11396 Host:11637 Browser: 3874
Erotic flavor battle comics which sprinkled the Mikuni mind over the spice grade.
if it dares express figuratively -- aho -- it is pleasant If a volume progresses, it is interesting in it being unexpected.
It is delicate whether there is any value for a price.
However, we cannot recommend you at all the direction which has strong intensity to the Mikuni mind as the world of hot 漢.
even if the favorite general is a 巨乳 girl -- "-- obtaining -- be glad with wwwktkrwwww" -- the method of る -- pleasing .
Although it was incidentally erotic flavor, it was carrying out strangely blankly, and since it was healthy, excessive erotic did not feel.
In general as it is, the beauty girl and man kyara in which all woman kyara have a taste as it is are smart.

2007/05/13 Very good [Original Japanese review]
by 赤い水仙 Provider: 34156 Host:34070 Browser: 4916
The new work which is not in the old Mikuni mind system.
Although there is also touch which rode on the wave of girl system grapple comics, since this author is touch がこんな from the first, good is carried out, and it is 。.
Are good for expressing the grave character of human relations, although sex depiction increased and it became bold as it became in the second half.
The tear of the dress showing the violence of a battle is also skillful.
Above all, the dreadfulness of this work has finished the very difficult work of testing a work called the Mikuni mind by comparison in the present age.
Saying clearly, this very thing is unprecedented.
Although it is worthy of reading at least this but, suffering of a youth is projected further there.
And delicacy which only the human being of an authentic history takes out to characters since it is premised on the world of the Mikuni mind having existed perfectly.
The selection out of 数ある is perfectly carried out also to characters.
The balance feeling of being few too much which do not elapse and is not is reading, and is astonished.
Each people never wear.
Sense of incongruity is lost by making an original flow without riding the flow by force, though a story also carries out the flow of an authentic history.
The chemical reaction of korabo which does not depend a thought called the Mikuni mind and a school thing, either is greatest.
Ryosaku who can osusume also to the true Mikuni mind fan.

2007/04/08 Bad [Original Japanese review]
by Naooki Provider: 8516 Host:8589 Browser: 4928
Although a picture is a fairly favorite category, it is not an erotic くて excessive lover more vainly than animation.

2007/04/06 Worst [Original Japanese review]
by 矢口 Provider: 27679 Host:27547 Browser: 10961(Mobile)
All these works are denied.
The insult to the Mikuni mind is not got as his statement of you is carried out.
It threw away without reading all.

2006/11/19 Worst [Original Japanese review]
by Shuワrutsueneggaa Provider: 6813 Host:6537 Browser: 4184
It browsed by chance at the secondhand bookseller.
Although it was asking rumor, it read with how it is sure enough.
It struck after a long time and went out.
probably, it is not 青筋立ってたん at a frame -- I thought that it would tear kana -- HAHAHA [!?
] This is the first time that it met with the work which ridiculed my Mikuni mind to love so far.
陳寿 of 魏 (蜀) spells an authentic history and the inside of Akiyo's 羅貫 completes expansion Mikuni mind.
Henceforth, Mikuni mind with which it was continued by loving people and Mr.
Eiji reason and Yoshikawa, and Mr.
Yokoyama 光輝 revived the present age .......
Oh, Mikuni mind ...
Heroes' ideal and dream ...
An everlasting masterpiece.
Great human beings' inheritance.
Although it may be somewhat exaggerated, I think so and do not suspect.
The Mikuni mind was trampled down.
if you get angry too much and being commented more -- blood-pressure going up -- since that is right, it carries out so far Too merely regrettable very.
Probably, evaluation is not possible other than the worst.
It is too regrettable.

2006/08/27 Bad [Original Japanese review]
by SHUNIA Provider: 44781 Host:44718 Browser: 5540
[A good point] ......
[A bad point] contents: -- C -- it is ignorant, concerning the "Mikuni mind" first They are the contents which can be referred to as bad [ "very bad" ] even when it is ignorant.
It comes out and, as for a story, the hero of quarrel liking = violence fuechi moves into a certain school.
And although the party of a school is challenged to fighting the beginning, the strong fellow of a school is suited at being killed by he on whom him have been seeking revenge.
A setup resembles って "a heavens top world." Also after that, some school and a "quarrel convention" are unfolded, people die occasionally, and a hero runs wild ...
That a part of body is blown away or a hole opens たり ...
erotic -- an imitation -- this street fight -- an imitation -- I think whether to have opposed comics "a heavens top world" Of course, the meaning in which the place a "school" exists ignores.
The destroyed part is also disregarded.
The lawless area "do regardless although people will die, and I will become dying condition." - - -, or a setup to say are not utilized for the fate of a comma-shaped bead at all, either.
A battle is almost unimpressive.
Furthermore, there are many scenes on which only "clothes" split with sufficient convenience.
They are [ that split with trousers with a chest, among those a lower half of the body at first, and, as for the last, trousers also split ] "changing and a dogfight." If it carries out critical, it will all split with the first one blow.
It comes out, and charm is not felt for female kyara which fights, kills and suits even by being made nakedness.
The setup a "school" will also be for minisuka and panchira well.
It could be said that "heavens top worlds" are still good, since the level of a picture is also common.
price: -- C -- it is not good to take out contents of this level with one volume, 100 pages, and the wide version added dozens of pages generally The price is "900 yen" from the contents of only this.
Even if he buys it with medieval times, it is 400 - 500 yen.
He can buy a common comic new article.
Considering these price side and contents both, it must be made not common [ "not common" ] but bad [ "bad" ].
as a reason of a moreover which is not "very bad", it does not go until it is too severe, and it is not poor at a picture [Others] Or [ that there is a meaning which took in って or the "Mikuni mind" ] ...
It is very hard to memorize a name for ignorant human being.
For example, himself.
Only the hero still remembers.
Since this point does not read, although it is already independently good ......
[Remarks] Comics to which the Mikuni mind is not recommended by the favorite person, either.
the contents -- completely -- not caring -- in addition -- and "panchira" and a "beauty girl" -- the favorite one -- pleasing .

2006/06/28 Worst [Original Japanese review]
by 摩雲金翅 Provider: 54266 Host:54320 Browser: 6287
First comics of the minimum worst.
Undoubtedly the Mikuni mind is licked.
If it was to the parody of an eroticism or the Mikuni mind, it ended with "do freely." But it cannot allow having stolen the name of characters as it was just as it is.
Correct in a Japanese's style at least.
you -- one -- they are nani people -- ?
author's intellect -- like -- it is found And character of the characters which are not in agreement with an original and remainder.
Steam rose from the frame for 呂蒙 respected especially to have been made into the free DQN woman.
Even if it sees as a free school thing, it is commonplace and there is no freshness (as but as a setup flys away and only condition is too fresh).
Although a pattern is also pretty apparently only at eroi, every person is the same touch, and originality is not felt.
It is provoking to have given the misapprehension which is not needed for China because of this again.
Dislike is memorized even by such comics Japanese.
These comics soiled the Mikuni mind which people have inherited and blown up over the past 2000 years in China and Japan.
It is profanity to people who lived that time, or people who have developed it.
It is feeling to put [ to chop up, although it did not carry out, since it was bad to the man of the publication industry which clove time and a labor precious for this trivial monochrome, and ] into a drum.
He wishes out-of-print recovery.

2006/06/25 Very bad [Original Japanese review]
by 高麗 Provider: 26009 Host:25778 Browser: 3875
Even if it まぁ良しと a picture, it is.
It is, even if it carries out without erotic いと or a relation.
It is, though a woman is sufficient as kyara.
the difference [ kyara ] of treatment -- it is -- passing -- だろ [!?
] 関羽良しと and kyara, such as 甘寧 and 顔良, are severe -- elapsing ....
although 顔良 is a top-level general and was soon damaged in 袁紹軍, that treatment has severe kyara to the extent that it fights in single combat with 関羽 -- elapsing ..
って frankly damaged by 呂蒙 -- how a picture is also severe ....
甘寧 is also large activity in the Hefei じゃ surprise attack -- this -- 呂蒙 -- frankly .
Naturally the treatment of a picture is also severe.
Is it a disappointing work for the person who also writes a setup and name of the Mikuni mind, and a pigeon and who this is not only a Chinese and did the Mikuni mind and matchless?
I want not only heroes but the persons who became famous somewhat to often draw more.
(ていう or 甘寧 is famous ?) If there is a setup called the Mikuni mind, do I want you to carry out about [ which not only a famous general but a minor general takes out ]?
the author has actually read the Mikuni mind -- ?
って doubt -- ます .
If 王允 and 陳宮 came also out of the death scene of 董卓, did I want you to also take out chousen (Chinese character trouble)?
No.
1 wanted to see a single combat of 呂布 and 関羽.
Come out in っていう and carry out.
that ろ that it fought and came out and was the first flower -- the treatment of !?
~ ん and 華雄 is also severe -- elapsing -- taking out -- 。 Since 袁紹 and Taso Tsao are also the Allied Forces' tops, come out and carry out.
If the Mikuni mind profanity was still carried out, I wanted you to reappear, although it does not think that such large-scale 戦 is made in まぁ modern society.
Since the occurrence before the battle something is also reproducing the battle scene, "蒼天 route " is erotic くて guroi, and is completely the result different also for the same Mikuni mind system?
I want you to increase a battle scene more anyhow.
だろ in which the hero is not doing 孫策って(ing), ....
historical fact reappearance at it and which dies direct [ だった ].
Although it still understands with what when it is the right of a kana ?
grandchild of 捻じ曲げてん with sufficient convenience.
me -- although the way of comics has been read only to five volumes, how is it now?
Thank you for your consideration.
Please let me know someone.
In some cases, I want to still say.
natural, if 呂蒙 of that is strong -- this [ 黄蓋 or / South Korean ] must be strong -- if ?
呂蒙 was called school big four and the historical fact was met, I wanted the big four for 甘寧 or not 呂蒙 but 黄蓋- to do this [ 普 and / South Korean ] In short, it is that.
It was too early to have taken out 呂蒙 and 甘寧.
The thing I want you to make into the contents if 甘寧 is taken out, after turning against 孫策, to the extent that it is made 凌操ぶっ殺して, the son's 凌統, and a dangerous relation.
It is if it is a person describing the Mikuni mind.
Since 周喩 excels military power in intellectual one, although a battle level is conviction, it is not visible to the head meeting in merit.
It is 軍師 of Kure even for a time.
After intellect is also excellent to the extent that 呂蒙 also becomes 軍師, I want you to show also there more.
now -- now, Akakabe and becoming [ 周喩 ]-what kana although said it has noticed pressing also for one's death from 孫策 so and so -- by serving, if it is as a ぇ ?
historical fact, it dies immediately from the Akakabe 終わって -- ?
author really does what -- serving -- ぇ Although written for a long time, there are a lot of things [ things ] to still say.
It is new まぁ and to have got hot so far, and the author also wants to do his best.
Once, a picture is まぁまぁ and solved by making evaluation into "and bad ".

2006/03/31 Bad [Original Japanese review]
by ☆なんて見えねーよ Provider: 6892 Host:6581 Browser: 4184
Comics which do not understand wanting what to do well.
kyara which does the talk of making a selling point of 巨乳 and the Zillah 見せ, and quarreling with たいん and the Mikuni mind, is too odd and comes out the back in たいん -- in any way -- an impression -- it carries out in thin thing ばっ -- よな - each being alike or depending たり it is in the time of seeing at first -- it got tired of obtaining interest もったけど by ?
[ this ] って touch

2006/02/28 Very bad [Original Japanese review]
by 漫喫戦士 Provider: 6262 Host:6016 Browser: 4925
I think that it is famous and the point dealing with a thing which is called the Mikuni mind and which is easy to be familiar is interesting.
However, this work is the contents which are never hard to be referred to as harnessing it effectively.
It is the aim which extracted it, i.e., a target, which a woman quantity student's uniform is torn, and fights while it has been a short skirt infinite.
First of all, the point has the too bad affinity of having used the character name of the Mikuni mind.
Being carried out in many cases about the very point, it completely has the reputation of not only here but a world in it, and agrees with it on it.
Although just the idea using the Mikuni mind is good, by the comics of such a setup, it imagines easily that it cannot be harnessed.
It will be a natural result although strong 叩き is received from the Mikuni mind fan as expected.
Although it was easy to be calculation also including the subject nature in such meanings, probably, there is almost no it.
って事 which still continues will be って事 which is also in the fan there.
it sells in the sex appeal route -- because a work, the contents are thinner and it also seldom feels originality seemingly it deals with the Mikuni mind also in respect of the event, and if it is next completely it skillful い事考えた that it will be able to write if it arranges just for a moment based on the famous event of the Mikuni mind, although seemingly it is Akakabe, concern of it will have been carried out in another meaning A hero can also take 孫策って as it is possible to make it finish only with kyara which passed away early with the Mikuni mind also with this work 5.
it aimed by no means -- dividing -- coming out -- although it will not be

2005/11/13 Good [Original Japanese review]
by Girodoro Provider: 50835 Host:50871 Browser: 4924
the high school student quarrel battle which is not what was able to be read when there was no idea of entwining the Mikuni mind to a high school student battle, about a setup of the interesting Mikuni mind -- it sprouts, and since bakabaka too much, it is, it sprouts in addition to it and the beauty girl is giving the general of the Mikuni mind, I try to want to multiply minus and minus, if panchira etc.
remains as it is -- it can come out, can read somehow and can advance Although it was what was alike that one although the heavens top world was in similar comics, that was not able to be read from the middle of having had the comment that it probably did not receive other than those who fit into pinpoint.
Otherwise, the unexpected nature which traces the Mikuni mind is good, not being read in panchira comics etc.
is [ how is the main of the work of this hand that is said well and that probably is not but erotically, and shows it ] a highlight.
It is the existence which showed that there is the new possibility also in high school student battle comics with the already done admiration.

2005/10/23 Worst [Original Japanese review]
by ミルク&カフェラテ Provider: 12904 Host:12822 Browser: 5234
Is it the work which does not understand how should be carried out any?
Is the general who comes out in the Mikuni mind does not pass?
If it is けど and it which will be って奴, does business want without sprouting and taking out the name of kyara of the Mikuni mind?
Evaluation is peevish without being except the worst.

2005/09/08 Worst [Original Japanese review]
by Shou Provider: 12661 Host:12602 Browser: 2771(Mobile)
honest, although it read since he liked the Mikuni mind -- it carried out by not being interesting at all It can be called only the trash which spoils completely the material with the battle which does not have force in an incomprehensible story, a meaningless erotic scene, the sufficient Mikuni mind, and sufficient ゆう.

Next / Post your review / Top page

Other media
Anime:Ikki Tosen

ALERT: You cannot use open proxy or TOR for posting your review. If it is detected, your access to this site will be prohibited.

Rule for reviews

This site allows you to write reviews for each title, but we don't allow you to criticize others' comment. Too bad or meaningless words are also not allowed. The comment which doesn't follow the rule will be deleted. If you find any comment which doesn't follow the rule, please notify us by clicking Suggest to delete.

Example to be deleted frequently

Favorite side
You dislike this one, then don't see it or comment this title
- Please go to the fan site. Anyone has the right to say what they feel in this site.

Disliking side
Do you like this one? You are stupid.
- Your view is only your view. Please concentrate on only the content of the title, not on others' comment.

Please use only English. If not, the comment will be deleted.

Your Name(Required)

Password (Required. more than 4 characters)

Your comment about this anime(Required)

Your evaluation of this title(Required)
You can choose the evaluation only once. After you post your evaluation, please choose comment instead of evaluation from the options.

Evaluation of this title(You can choose this only once)

Best!!
Very good
Good
Normal
Bad
Very Bad
Worst

If you evaluated this title once, please choose comment instead of the evaluation.
Comment by the person who thinks this is good
Comment by the person who thinks this is normal
Comment by the person who thinks this is bad

Please choose appropriate option for readers.

Caution: Please post the evaluation which follows the rule.