Japanese works database(How to join/Help)
Top page: All/Only Reviews

Others
Site map


Search / Outside DB:

Comics ranking: Rank 4,018/in 4,169 titles (Total -10.03/Deviation 46.16) Rank 4,017 <= => Rank 4,019
Comics average points ranking: Rank 567/in 673 titles (Average -0.59(Bad)/Deviation 39.65) Rank 566 <= => Rank 568 (more than 10 evaluatoin)
Comics ranking of 2005: Rank 128/in 139 titles Rank 127 <= => Rank 129

KOMA-KOMA(Comics)

[Other version: RSS/Japanese version]

All
Reviews(Post)

Forum

Images

Goods
(Books)

Latest Books: 2007/09/28 ():

PassPorter's Open Mouse for Walt Disney World and the Disney Cruise Line: Easy Access Vaca... $95

Books(73hit) Sales/Latest								DVD(5hit) Sales/Latest	Music(48hit) Sales/Latest
Rank:213792 Paperback:PassPorter's Open Mouse for Walt Disney World and the Disney Cruise Line: Easy Access Vaca... Tag:$95 2007/09/28 () Eval.:***** 1.Best book for travel challenges!	Rank:510273 Paperback:PassPorter's Walt Disney World for Your Special Needs: The Take-Along Travel Guide and Pla... Tag:$95 2005/08/15 () Eval.:***** 1.New Edition has a different title	Rank:991800 Paperback:Busting Vegas 2005 ()	Rank:1407285 Paperback:Koma Kulshan: The Story of Mount Baker Tag:$95 1984/09 ()	Rank:5623751 Paperback:Legends of the Hawaiian waters 1998 ()	Comic:Final Fantasy XI 4koma Anthology Comic (Final Fantasy XI 4 koma Ansoroji Komikku) (in Japa... Tag:$50	Hardcover:Koma : Klyuch k probuzhdeniyu. Samostoyatel'naya rabota nad soboj 2005 ()	Hardcover:The Sikhs in Canada - from Koma Gata Maru to Parliament Hill 2007 ()	Rank:16136 Days of Glory (Indigenes) Tag:$95 2007/06/12 () Eval.:***** 1.French Colonial Troops from North Africa are due their pensions	Rank:320147 Audio CD:Shutterspeed Tag:$49 2003/11/03 () Eval.:***** 1.Solid selection with a moody stylish vibe

Information about this title

Weekly Boys Magazine Koudansha

Released:2005/08/03 in Japan

Statics of evaluation(The statics is updated once a day)

	Average	ComicsRank	Deviation(Total)	Evaluation points(Total)	Best of the Best
Inside Japan	Bad(-0.59)	4,018	46.16	-10.03

Statics of activity

	Total Views	Comment	Evaluation
Inside Japan	3,122	18	17
Outside Japan	156	0	0

How others evaluated in Japan

Best

Very Good

Good

Normal

Bad

Very Bad

Worst

People

Percentage

0.0%

17.6%

35.3%

29.4%

5.9%

11.8%

Added percentage

17.6%

52.9%

82.3%

88.2%

100%

Summary

17.6%

35.3%

47.1%

Language Sorted by date Sorted by recommendation New!
English Good
(Only Evaluation) Normal
(Only Evaluation) Bad
(Only Evaluation) All
(Only Evaluation) None
Japanese Good
(Only Evaluation) Normal
(Only Evaluation) Bad
(Only Evaluation) All
(Only Evaluation) All
This reputation board

Language	Sorted by date	Sorted by recommendation New!
English	Good (Only Evaluation)	Normal (Only Evaluation)	Bad (Only Evaluation)	All (Only Evaluation)	None
Japanese	Good (Only Evaluation)	Normal (Only Evaluation)	Bad (Only Evaluation)	All (Only Evaluation)	All

Post your review / Top page

The below reviews are translated automatically from Japanese ones. To post to English version, please click here.

2008/06/22 Bad [Original Japanese review]
by 剣舞大使 Provider: 11609 Host:11609 Browser: 6034
Although it was comics dealing with shogi, the pleasure of important shogi was the comics which can be taken in neither - piece nor 1 free% at all.
Want to write mainly, although shogi is the subject matter of the talk.
"they are a hero and 樹, and its teacher.
- The human dorama っぽい spectacle in which it rustled [ growth / Seiichi ] in suffering." I thought that there was such an atmosphere somehow.
With extraordinarily attractive or a work which attaches a subject matter and a theme to an explanation grade, and drew it on a character without the projected element, and its episode, it will be hard to come out of a bud.
Deployment of the talk was also early and was the work which looks at from me and is not made into patt.
It is "bad."

2007/11/08 Worst [Original Japanese review]
by Namekujikinoko Provider: 7033 Host:6705 Browser: 8090
[Good point] It praises that it is a new work on the theme of - shogi.
[a bad point] - it has finished, not clarified [ that a hero wants whom and what to carry out and ] after all - A hero with the early flow of the talk hardly had a close game.
I regard these two as useless.
- Unless it knows the rule of shogi, don't follow.
There should just have been consideration of those who do not know.
[comprehensive evaluation] - "if the comics treating the new thing are drawn, it will not necessarily surely become a hit." -- I think so The present time, and not only animation but comics also have many imaichi things.
The unreal world is the adventure thing of the stage, and a battle thing.
The trash which does not have contents only by the work with much beauty form kyara, and the surface vainly.
Since it says so, it is overflowing.

2006/08/22 Bad [Original Japanese review]
by Monburan Provider: 4540 Host:4719 Browser: 5533
A work with the admiration which was frightened of the close and fought with the close.
I carry out [ mind as made to draw rather than the author drew ].
an intention of an editor should hear also about resembling the go of hikaru -- る Popularity did not come out of whether did resembling the go of the hikaru backfire and a reader's antipathy was incurred, but since it was popular acquisition, it became the way and quick footwork which change deployment too much.
There were some which should be seen individually, and if it is doing thoroughly, I will think that it became the work of there there.
が -- bad, since it is たられば to the last and is not realized as a work -- coming out -- 。

2006/05/29 Good [Original Japanese review]
by 十傑集 Provider: 11221 Host:11074 Browser: 4483
It was a favorable impression that the hero who was the bad brat (notes: even that junior high school student) whom comrades ょう does not have, either received instruction, or was made into the boy of this generation who has already gained the experience as a professional go player for many years at kotenpan, and grew perfectly in shogi.
Since the exchange with Seiichi, a teacher, was pleasant and 画力 was also high, he has a feeling that that way of finishing is regrettable.
What was necessary was just to have investigated the last of Seiichi who has the number of talks to a slight degree as for the close, and was attacked with a disease in every day with the hagure professional go player in Osaka, or cancer.

2006/04/01 Very bad [Original Japanese review]
by Jannu Provider: 14319 Host:14274 Browser: 5234
The impression that it was when saying so.
It likes shogi, although the thing of the mere imitation is seldom read, and it reads for the time being every week, and is better た.
these comics -- how is thin ..
a hero -- good -- いそ - simple [ it is kyara, and ], if Seiichi also comes out of a word and says on the way -- the strong man of an encouragement meeting -- a hero -- Seiichi's revenge -- shogi problem っぽ disagreeable つ which came out at that time although it is みたいな scene あったん which felt, and came out and challenged ..
as it is -- shogi -- if it is a strong man and thinks just for a moment, it will not answer and come out -- serving -- ?
..
ってまぁ comics -- such kuso -- difficult -- although it was troubled even if problem appearance was carried out, it has slightly already wanted something An after hero's rapid growth was not pleased, either.
.
Since criticism ばっ loan writing better た does not read and did not necessarily feel a feeling of て嫌悪, it is not the worst.
however, since it is a problem that it is thin anyhow, evaluation is very bad -- coming out -- 。

2006/02/18 Normal [Original Japanese review]
by Supan Provider: 26048 Host:25873 Browser: 5234
It already carries out now [ 終わっちゃ ] and is たねぇ.
It is just super-speed conclusion って touch.
Even so, if even 樹 is won continuing though Seiichi cannot be so strong and wins the expert of a ?
battle eye by magure why, magure is the って touch "which is not continued twice" and cannot but think quite opportunism-deployment.
Seiichi thinks that he was kyara which adds Mr.
Tsutsui and Mr.
伊角 and was divided by 2 when saying with "go of hikaru" (is it such a thing also in ability?).
Since the figure which wins a 塔矢 expert though kyara of the ability of [Mr.
Tsutsui Mr.
+ 伊角] / 2 may win hikaru by magure cannot be imagined just for a moment I think that inflation-izing of this Seiichi's strength is quite amusing in the same meaning as it (since Seiichi is ability to the extent that [ which was the way of drawing which is never the pro of the upper one in / although it is a pro / ability ] it carries out, and it received and the expert was made to ponder the direction of 樹 in a shogi convention how much --) And if it resulted in the last talk, although a series period was not necessarily so long, it is on parade [ of a flashback ].
It seemed that the volume on 総 collection was seen.
Is the method of this depiction quite fresh at this short series (it is not a eulogy)?
The last talk was quite delicate at the reason for saying.
Which of this じゃあ樹 and Seiichi does not know whether you are a hero.
The deployment after it says or 樹 becomes a junior high school student (high school student ?) was delicate much.
Although it was probably also going to summarize the last finely, a dyspeptic portion can see here and there.
the difference which divided this work and "the go of hikaru" was where ...
Although aside from the second half "go of hikaru" will be so much conspicuous and will be regarded as it having never been the last picture which would not be so good when it compared with the time, since it did not necessarily cut, but it having been the talk that it was very promising as a schoolchild also as deployment of the talk, well, when a number of turns is the level of 1 figure, if it says about 画力 ...
and -- individual -- the direction of shogi -- the game of go -- Japanese people -- first -- being easy -- since he has a feeling, し it carries out even mind which was more advantageous than "go of hikaru" at the point ...
If it mentions by force, is it "the difference of the charm of a character"?
With this work, I feel that charm was not felt overall for an appearance character.
It may be are it and that were also large too as for the impression of the "mere imitation" having wiped and having not gone out.
Although it estimated before "It is good", as a result of reconsidering the contents of a work calmly with too early deployment and end, I think that evaluation is changed [ be / allowed to た / I ] into "it is common." But since it was the work in which the future possibility is impressed, did I like the author to surely do my best by 次回作?

2006/02/10 Normal [Original Japanese review]
by TCC Provider: 42212 Host:42137 Browser: 4184
naming agency neta of Hario 某, a teacher, -- reason Murayama -- 聖です -- it is .
Although the comics currently serialized by certain youth magazine had also been read, were difficulties of Mr.
Takeshi teacher and Morinobu who was having him who was invaded sick taken care of etc.
interesting?
(?) Although it thought it unavoidable to have become the structure which was conscious of certain も hika go, it says that a story is also safe, or there is bad and it also regarded the picture as だった as it is when it met, was it closed [ whether it was painful that there was no freshness which does not carry out a situation, and ] weakly half a year, and was kept?
[ no ] an "incident islands bull" bull of the golden age although a genre is different, it ended [ it was alike and ] and pushed and い was not thought, it is the thing which was not like [ which is called the trash which feels displeasure to see ], either and I carry out [ thing ] and want the author to do my best from now on

2006/01/29 Comment(good) [Original Japanese review]
by Supan Provider: 2176 Host:2125 Browser: 5234
It was rather interesting when the hero was a schoolchild.
Although there are "go of hikaru" and a field currently worn to be sure, since such works are regarded as there being no choice in deployment of the talk not much drawing pleasantly (a part especially for introduction is.) I strike in age setting ももろ and feel now that it is unavoidable for sushi some and the point to beat.
Since it was the form where it fought with genius from the beginning unlike 樹は hikaru, he likes that at that.
A rival and a teacher also think that they are safe touch.
Is it delicate in a rival's wording etc.?
However, it is regrettable very that deployment is too early in whether it was even on this 落線 of the close.
I wanted the amount of 2-3 after books to do the talk of my schoolchild days also at the lowest.
after a re-appearance -- 樹 -- surprising -- growing up -- てい -- for the first time in [ the / sudden / a change ] -- a field -- 喰らう -- it becomes touch [ like ] It is sushi without being still unsatisfactory, although some existence of the teacher who made 樹 so far is also told.
First of all, since the scene of encounter is not drawn first and told in sequel, the admiration which calls it imaichi climax or is weak cannot be denied.
It was good that Seiichi got used to the pro.
However, it is very worrisome with the game with a sick becoming [ clear ] -> expert that deployment is too early too.
Is deployment liable to stepping out of the ring unintentionally especially recently?
an expert -- usually and a game -- inside -- it is -- a gap -- it is -- passing -- it is .
although it will be tolerance level if it is called まぁ tolerance level -- a game -- how to draw inner character feels that it is somewhat delicate し [ it merely receives a cruel impression / only / rather than earnest mode ].
I think that it is the work which makes the reader leaving behind on the whole something.
し [ a smell / 原因 / an editorial department ] punpun rather than the author's it is also self-satisfied /.
If if it is made to draw with a margin to a slight degree is thought, it can be called a very regrettable work.

2006/01/28 Bad [Original Japanese review]
by 10.17 Provider: 22988 Host:22746 Browser: 6287
As it is, the pair of a hero and Seiichi also had it at the beginning when the series started.
[ pleasant to be rather beautiful / the picture ] however -- gradually -- gag -- decreasing -- most 今じゃ -- it is an earnest story deployment is also early -- it elapses and is [ it comes out and ] hard to understand After 樹 grew, it stopped feeling charm for these comics.

2005/12/14 Normal [Original Japanese review]
by 紀世 Provider: 18548 Host:18507 Browser: 6032
It grows that he is also surely conscious of "go of hikaru" at first, and, probably, there is no ょう.
I want to expect that the work with which this genre also exceeds the go of hikaru comes out.
Probably, with this work, it will be slightly severe.
By the way, it already passes over growth of a hero and cannot follow.
Compared with the first stage, the body and the heart are すかり another person.
Even if evaluation also puts future expectation, it is a little under "common."

2005/12/14 Good [Original Japanese review]
by Sonsen Provider: 26066 Host:25924 Browser: 5635
Individually, it is a favorite work.
Doesn't it go into a very readable category?
In contents, although the go and mind which has been beaten of hikaru are also carried out, kyara is full of life.
However, it is regrettable not to be told not much deeply about the shogi which must be main.
I cannot think that these comics are read and shogi becomes strong.
I am looking forward to future deployment (although it does not know whether to be being or not ...).

2005/12/07 Good [Original Japanese review]
by Jippo Provider: 36691 Host:36761 Browser: 5234
It was thought that it was reading at first and there never needed to be mind of hika go.
I did not think "けどさ don't be more nearly very alike." (A recent work has alike many therefore) まぁ -- make it any -- since it thought that it was future (in flow), I thought that it was a work with sufficient まぁ

2005/12/01 Normal [Original Japanese review]
by Eden Review history[Good:1(100%) Normal:0(0%) Bad:0(0%)] / Provider: 11120 Host:11111 Browser: 5234
He will read and will be conscious of て or a beam "go of hikaru." Although appearance is also so, I stand as Seiichi's kyara and a position carries out [ Tsutsui or mind as struck ] in any way.
If it says that Seiichi became a pro and it is different, although it is different well ...
It is not too bad except it.
although it thinks that a picture may be legible, it is touch only in it -- it is Growth is quite too early and that is not pleased for a while.
Evaluation is "common." Since he likes shogi individually, it is expectation at the future of these comics.
...
however, it is delicate - (bitter smile)

2005/10/29 Normal [Original Japanese review]
by 無線機 Provider: 20627 Host:20417 Browser: 4487
It has not noticed, when [ at which the author wrote ] it started, although it read and being read with as [ near at hand ] (magazine ワndaa printing).
it read and impact still had the way of an as -- the comics of the same shogi For the moment, it is an almost unattractive work.
Since it is a magazine, he has a feeling that it can be doing.

2005/09/09 Bad [Original Japanese review]
by somnia Provider: 13265 Host:13324 Browser: 3875
It will surely be thought that it is influenced of certain game-of-go comics currently serialized in the jump.
comics -- almost the same [ some ] -- being certain -- と -- I consider -- well -- this extent -- ゆるせる But a place [ that the author is going to make it laugh by carrying out unreasonableness considerably ] is visible to these comics.
This is painful.
The place the efforts can be considerably seen is quite painful.
Even if it new-serializes independently, it had by not carrying out and has been finished with the comics of touch as its evaluation.
Evaluation is bad.
It is saying.

2005/08/19 Normal [Original Japanese review]
by Esupaa Provider: 8276 Host:8301 Browser: 3646
It is the structure which was conscious of hika go.
Since the hero resembles what mind at hikaru, carry out.
If it is a game-of-go boom, does it expect that it is the work which can cause a ぬ将棋 boom?
Or [ the well more mashi one in these members of a new series ].

2005/08/18 Bad [Original Japanese review]
by gusuta Provider: 52905 Host:52886 Browser: 4184
About this work, this word is all of me.
"-- these comics ...
patt -- carrying out -- ねぇ"

2005/08/18 Worst [Original Japanese review]
by 武蔵 Provider: 7631 Host:7368 Browser: 5234
I feel that deployment is slightly too quick.
he compares with "go of hikaru" somehow -- swallowing of a hero is too early although like I wanted you to write a thing called difficulties like "go of hikaru."

Post your review / Top page

ALERT: You cannot use open proxy or TOR for posting your review. If it is detected, your access to this site will be prohibited.

Rule for reviews

This site allows you to write reviews for each title, but we don't allow you to criticize others' comment. Too bad or meaningless words are also not allowed. The comment which doesn't follow the rule will be deleted. If you find any comment which doesn't follow the rule, please notify us by clicking Suggest to delete.

Example to be deleted frequently

Favorite side
You dislike this one, then don't see it or comment this title
- Please go to the fan site. Anyone has the right to say what they feel in this site.

Disliking side
Do you like this one? You are stupid.
- Your view is only your view. Please concentrate on only the content of the title, not on others' comment.

Please use only English. If not, the comment will be deleted.

Your Name(Required)

Password (Required. more than 4 characters)

Your comment about this anime(Required)

Your evaluation of this title(Required)
You can choose the evaluation only once. After you post your evaluation, please choose comment instead of evaluation from the options.

Evaluation of this title(You can choose this only once)

Best!!
Very good
Good
Normal
Bad
Very Bad
Worst

If you evaluated this title once, please choose comment instead of the evaluation.
Comment by the person who thinks this is good
Comment by the person who thinks this is normal
Comment by the person who thinks this is bad

Please choose appropriate option for readers.

Caution: Please post the evaluation which follows the rule.