Japanese works database(How to join/Help)
Top page: All/Only Reviews

Others
Site map

AllAnimeGameComicNovelDramaSp. effectJP movieMovie	Info:voice,machine..	Reviewer sorted by	Diary
Search / Outside DB:

Comics ranking in Japan: Rank 65/in 4,101 titles (Total 92.90/Deviation 69.58) Rank 64 <= => Rank 66
Comics average points ranking in Japan: Rank 501/in 655 titles (Average -0.15(Good)/Deviation 43.37) Rank 500 <= => Rank 502 (more than 10 evaluatoin were posted)
Comics ranking of 2003 in Japan: Rank 5/in 88 titles Rank 4 <= => Rank 6

Magister Negi Magi (Mahou Sensei Negima)(Comics)

[Other version: RSS/Japanese version]

Other media
Anime:Magister Negi Magi (Mahou Sensei Negima) / Special effects:MAGISTER NEGI MAGI

All
Reviews(Post)

Diary
2008/02/01

Forum

Images

Goods
(Books)

Latest Books: 2008/06/03 ():

Negima!: Magister Negi Magi, Volume 18 $95

Books(73hit) Sales/Latest							DVD(9hit) Sales/Latest	Music(5hit) Sales/Latest	Toys(4hit) Sales/Latest
Rank:14163 Comic:Negima!: Magister Negi Magi, Volume 18 Tag:$95 2008/06/03 () Eval.:***** 1.Until we meet again!	Rank:52954 Comic:Negima!: Magister Negi Magi, Volume 17 Tag:$95 2008/03/04 () Eval.:***** 1.The Great, Heated, Close Combat!	Rank:68121 Paperback:Negima!: Magister Negi Magi, Volume 16 Tag:$95 2007/12/18 () Eval.:***** 1.Friendship! Victory! Reunion	Rank:89925 Comic:Negima!: Magister Negi Magi, Volume 6 Tag:$95 2005/06/28 () Eval.:***** 1.the beginning of the end... of the School Trip arc	Rank:91441 Comic:Negima!: Magister Negi Magi, Volume 15 Tag:$95 2007/08/28 () Eval.:***** 1.Negi, time is of essence.	Rank:192452 Comic:Negima!: Magister Negi Magi, Volume 1 Tag:$95 2004/04/27 () Eval.:***** 1.The Negima Series	Rank:227994 Comic:Negima!: Magister Negi Magi, Volume 19 Tag:$95 2008/09/09 ()	Vol. 1-Magister Negi Magi 2005/06/27 ()	Rank:932540 Audio CD:Magister Negi Magi: 2 Gakki Shuryo Shiki Tag:$99 2004/09/06 ()	Rank:122570 Toy:Mahou Sensei Negima Figumate Gashapon School Vol.2 Box

Information about this title

Ken Akamatsu
Koudansha
Weekly Boys Magazine

Released:2003 in Japan

Official sites
1. AI Love Network (Translation)

Statics of evaluation(The statics is updated once a day)

	Average	ComicsRank	Deviation(Total)	Evaluation points(Total)	Best of the Best
Inside Japan	Good(-0.15)	65	69.58	92.90	7
Outside Japan	Good(0.00)	87	41.41	0.00

Statics of activity

	Total Views	Comment	Evaluation
Inside Japan	93,373	238	174
Outside Japan	3,430	1	1

How others evaluated in Japan

Best

Very Good

Good

Normal

Bad

Very Bad

Worst

People

Percentage

20.1%

10.3%

9.8%

10.3%

15.5%

11.5%

22.4%

Added percentage

20.1%

30.4%

40.2%

50.5%

66%

77.5%

100%

Summary

40.2%

10.3%

49.4%

Views for recent 8 days
Total 4 3 2 1 30 29 28 27
5 0 1 2 0 1 0 1 0

Language Sorted by date Sorted by recommendation New!
English Good
(Only Evaluation) Normal
(Only Evaluation) Bad
(Only Evaluation) All
(Only Evaluation) None
Japanese Good
(Only Evaluation) Normal
(Only Evaluation) Bad
(Only Evaluation) All
(Only Evaluation) All
This reputation board

Language	Sorted by date	Sorted by recommendation New!
English	Good (Only Evaluation)	Normal (Only Evaluation)	Bad (Only Evaluation)	All (Only Evaluation)	None
Japanese	Good (Only Evaluation)	Normal (Only Evaluation)	Bad (Only Evaluation)	All (Only Evaluation)	All

2005/05/31 Normal [Edit/Delete//Only this reviewer/Only this review/post sympathy comment/]
by TAKARAYA Review history[Good:78(58%) Normal:57(42%) Bad:0(0%)] / Provider: 7483 Host:7332 Browser: 3646
The author of this cartoon seems to have received the influence by "Harry Potter".
This cartoon seems to have imitated "Harry Potter".
I do not feel the originality in this cartoon.
In this cartoon, there are the main 31 schoolgirls.
However, it is difficult to memorize all their names.
Attractive heroines are few though there are a lot of heroines.
In this cartoon, there are scenes to whom schoolgirls' clothes tear.
However, I think that such scenes are unnecessary.
I do not think such scenes to be pleasant.
Recently, in this cartoon, the action scene has increased.
Therefore, this cartoon seems to be a sport-combative cartoon rather than to be the Love comedy now.
I thought that this cartoon would become an animated cartoon in the future.
As expected, this cartoon became an animated cartoon.
However, I did not think the animated cartoon to be broadcast this year.
Therefore, I was surprised.
I do not feel that this cartoon is a masterpieces.
However, I think that this cartoon is comparatively good compared with other cartoons serialized by "Weekly boy magazine" now.
Therefore, I do not think this cartoon to be trash.

Post your review / Top page

Other media
Anime:Magister Negi Magi (Mahou Sensei Negima) / Special effects:MAGISTER NEGI MAGI

The below reviews are translated automatically from Japanese ones. To post to English version, please click here.

2008/06/15 Bad [Original Japanese review]
by お暇なゲ〜セン Provider: 18003 Host:17834 Browser: 2143
School festival (?) Although it was interesting till time, it became impossible to gutaguta and enjoy deployment after it with a fighting convention.
a character -- eva and 1000 rain -- although he liked However, the work to which the name of "magic" is attached has many similar titles.
"-- magic O woman riO -- karu O -- "

2008/05/27 Best! [Original Japanese review]
by Kikona Provider: 23597 Host:23360 Browser: 5234
A girl is dearer than girls' comics.
The tale is also considered exactly and is interesting.
It is the highest!

2008/05/26 Best! [Original Japanese review]
by Nonono Provider: 12281 Host:12259 Browser: 8090
it should project -- it is beauty さ of a background or a character too I think that this has improved the view of the world of Welsh onion ま.
Although a student is a work with very many characters of 31 persons, the story is elaborated perfectly one by one and a sub story is also considerably impressive.
Is the problem chirachira 出てくる panchira?
...
Although the love chicken of a previous work was also so, if it has a bad influence on a child, there is much criticism.
Regardless of it, I think that this work is the highest class as beauty girls' comics.

2008/05/17 Good [Original Japanese review]
by high_sclool Provider: 50712 Host:50607 Browser: 8090
a love -- although there are those who say does not need to understand whether they are rice or a battle, I think that the merit of this work is there I think that I will get bored with considering if it is only either.
Taking advantage of a setup called magic, I think it good to develop the talk in the various directions.
Although I feel that it is delicate at first, I consider [ that the valiance of a Welsh onion looks nice gradually in skillful く, and ] a picture little by little.
Every person's setup is also fine and the character which can be regarded as unpleasant is not in it, either.
I think that they are the comics which should just lose a useless exposure scene.

2008/04/27 Best! [Original Japanese review]
by CTU Provider: 18003 Host:17802 Browser: 4613
なが Hamah り better た is interesting now.
That's right in which the story proposal existed at the time of two volumes which are regarded as it being uncanny to have made a setup of no less than 31 students to a fine place, and in which Hasegawa 1000 rain under activity also first appeared recently, for example He quite likes individually [ Hasegawa 1000 rain which also regards a character as individuality being strong respectively, and the Ayase 夕映 ] two persons.
moreover, "-- I think it good that it sprouts and the two elements " and a "battle" can be enjoyed It is thought that there will be somewhat many tsundere characters after [ delicate honestly / a character ] a vegetable Kagurazaka tomorrow which is merely the main heroine (tomorrow a vegetable, eva, 1000 rain, four persons of aanya).
Evaluation is the "highest."

2008/04/26 Very bad [Original Japanese review]
by 眠い Provider: 1472 Host:1509 Browser: 4184

[a good point]
- battle simple substance and a love -- rice -- if it is a simple substance, as it is, it is interesting
[Bad point]
There are too many 31 - classmates too, therefore hint is too complicated.
- wanting to do a battle -- a love -- halfway in wanting whether to give rice - There are too many erotic scenes and how to draw 女体 on a compliment, either is not the praised level.

[Comprehensive evaluation]
The magic school which 夕映 becomes amnesia and does not know is reached, and a translation is not known by that the bookstore is a training jar hunter たり.
and classmates will be scattered all over the world and meeting again with [ with all the members ] will take in what year the back" -- well, it is ざり Is there only any impression of having missed the timing with which these comics are made finishing finely?

2008/04/06 Normal [Original Japanese review]
by Gasugano Provider: 24907 Host:24926 Browser: 5234
An once warm-heart mood disappears by having changed the story into the magic world forcibly.
They are serial comic strips over a long period of time which is groping for the style which mixed a battle and 萌え forcibly.
"The completeness as comics was almost perfect even in about ten volumes." The strong point which should be observed is the good hand of "character 立て" and "recovery of a hint." In a character, every person's character setup is solid and has individuality very much.
To be sure, the appearance of a character is almost the same, and a group exception is somewhat difficult for the man of only saw.
However, what is resembled is only appearance and the internal thing is set as the character which is different firmly.
I think it uncanny that it can be injured by the character with character writing about 30 persons' character.
If the details of comics are often looked at, the character of a character has come out perfectly.
when it often sees, the socks of hakase are one of the two -- it deletes, it falls, and it is sufficient, and at the time of the phantom talk, while a 鳴滝 sister cries, it is running about It is really wonderful as comics to have written exactly, without extracting a hand till such fine places.
When free, it is also interesting to extract to one person and to reread comics once again.
It is because あっ and character 立て which is surprised are set in some places.
And uncanny one is the method of "recovery of a hint." The hint of the talk is [ that it is reasonable and there is no futility ] recoverable exactly.
Doubting what that talk became is also exactly solved on the talk after all.
龍宮 which handgun usage made clear as an example in the 49th hour of six volumes is observed.
I think that it is an post-installation setup about whether it was the character which can also fight this.
but signs that it has inspected not entering dodge ball but talking together with a moment should hear about 龍宮 in the fifth hour of one volume -- る That is, as for 龍宮, it already turns out [ which will be involved these days ] that the hint as a battle character was stretched.
If it focuss on ghostly Aisaka who began and appeared by Asakura of the report part which is pursuing the scoop as other examples, and nine volumes, this and the interesting hint are stuck.
from [ which is called / persons / two / these ] next doors in a seat at the seating list of one volume / -- since -- it seems that the hint was already stuck Aisaka and Asakura come to have Aisaka visible only to Asakura who became good in relations and was not seen until now on deployment of a story.
And it is said that this is because it is [ that seats were next doors all the time for two years ] reasonable.
That is, it means that Asakura had got the strongest stealth reconnaissance plane which people do not catch sight of and which does not receive magic, either at this time.
Aisaka is got and it can imagine that Asakura which became the chairman of a grapple convention is rightly involved in a story in a certain form after this.
It is a surprising hint supposing it is carrying out Aisaka's seat next to the seat in Asakura from one volume supposing this.
Although many [ like it cannot finish writing here ] hints are stuck on Welsh onion ま, the back is all only a deep interesting hint.
It could also be called one of the how to enjoy Welsh onion ま to read comics only in search of a hint.
It is said that they were decided as the character by which the character located on the left by the Welsh onion except for the time of a battle is located on inferiority in strength and the right being superior although there may be few people who have noticed.
The composition is known well in the 14th hour of two volumes.
Seemingly, it will become readable at the side read when not understanding well carries out like this, since it is a difficult talk.
since it is taken into consideration to such visual things, the passion applied to the author's comics should hear -- る "House theoretical" of "log emphasized やたら after becoming after ten volume, and pushy 似非 philosophy" Although it became long, if a word is finally said, I like this "air" that Mr.
Akamatsu draws.
This warm atmosphere that feels relieved is reading and it becomes pleasant comfort.

2008/03/29 Very good [Original Japanese review]
by Kootaroo Provider: 29545 Host:29753 Browser: 6342

[Good point]
Individuality of a character.

[Bad point]
It exposes too much and is 。.
Those with a pakuri element.

[Comprehensive evaluation]
Although it began to read recently, it is the Hamah り better た immediately.
The individuality of a character is uncanny.
However, doesn't having exposed vainly accept?

2008/03/28 Bad [Original Japanese review]
by ppphhh Provider: 13170 Host:13359 Browser: 2461

[Good point]
For a picture, the lines of the beautiful talk are boys' comics.

[Bad point]
It wears nakedness, and [ of the woman character which comes out whenever something is ] the bottom, and is - costume play etc.

[Comprehensive evaluation]
Also often and bad, a right course is boys' comics っぽい.
Merely superfluous service (?) A scene is mostly annoying.
a love with many previous work on such a scene -- the skin was not suited, although it may be for bringing the fan at that time as it is, since it was rice -- Incidentally, since the previous work has not read, it is guessed.
the foundations of the talk -- beta っぽいけど -- a work regrettable as oneself because he likes

2008/03/25 Comment(bad) [Original Japanese review]
by Namekujikinoko Provider: 3968 Host:3956 Browser: 8090
The badness of tempo and the numerousness of stops of publishing felt the premonition to which it is not hardly published and the talk is likely to begin to move greatly recently, although BLEACH of the jump I want you to make into honto somehow of the flow of the talk was also late only about a battle.
But Welsh onion ま does not feel such a sign at all.
Although it is a personal opinion, after a return match with fueito of 21 volumes finishes, I think that what was necessary was to have returned to Japan quickly and just to have returned to school life.
It was not an overstatement, although he bought the magazine, since Welsh onion ま serialized a long time ago.
I did not think that it was ruined at that time so far, either.
It may stop when or reading, if this stray continues forever.
But I think that a situation will already be seen for a while.

2008/03/22 Best! [Original Japanese review]
by 生徒 Provider: 2258 Host:2108 Browser: 3876
I think that this work has improved very much.
A picture is beautiful and 31 persons' individuality is made use of well.
A story is also interesting, and since a battle scene is also powerful, I want you to continue from now on.
A place [ speaking of the point which is not needed, there are many useless sex appeal scenes ].
If it loses even there, I will think that it is the highest work.
If their comment are said, they will be the comics with which I do not want you to finish.

2008/03/21 Very good [Original Japanese review]
by Sabukichi Provider: 39067 Host:38861 Browser: 8090
It is the work which dabbled the animation version also in the original after saw.
some people will not receive plentifully -- I think that けど私 is fairly interesting -- a seed I am a setup which surely cannot exist or also regard それっぽい depiction quite as many.
But it is the kana which the hero is a principal axis to the last, and is still stopped since sushi and such things are a setup called the age which cannot be considered.
more than it considered the back -- a battle -- was the comics element deep?
That it appears that it is best friend [ a rival and ] みたい in a new character in to become a pupil たりたり -- A setup of it and each character thought that it had twined quite well.
Since there is much number, although the character currently seldom touched is also, each way of twining is uncanny.
I also worry future deployment and think to honto that it is an interesting work.
If it is called a disagreeable place, it will be the main heroine (?).
it is -- is only it only seldom not caring for asuna?

2008/02/28 Best! [Original Japanese review]
by 天上天下 Provider: 29131 Host:29094 Browser: 5234
Akamatsu -- "the authority" a がおくる unexplored love -- rice -- they are a work and advent the shock which was terrible as for the shock which met with this work to the extent that 天裂け地 does not just break -- it was -- disagreeable - although the "love chicken" was more famous till then -- now -- the direction of "Welsh onion ま" -- famous -- なっちゃ now -- carrying out -- a seed

2008/02/19 Very good [Original Japanese review]
by 夜茶丸 Provider: 7108 Host:7067 Browser: 6520

[a good point]
- the point (although it seemingly began by groping to tame which did not have such a work mostly at the beginning of a - Akamatsu Mr.
reason "fusion of 燃えと萌え" series which thinks that Mr.
Akamatsu is God when writing by hand and carrying out the weekly series of the institution of only are etc.
to put it bluntly) that illustrating is beautiful and CG is also used well me ---like -- strangely -- fitting -- て -- individual -- " -- It burns.
" is a favorite reader -- I think that there are many - characters, a series is continued and the individuality of a character can be efficiently employed firmly although the inside of the beginning had a feeling of ちゃ混ぜ
[Bad point]
The character which has too many - characters and is unpopular is a point (although he seemingly plans to carry through a short story by one まぁ person [ one ], - tastes tend (this is Welsh onion ま, although it is being able to say all works!) to be divided clearly) out of which it is hard to come to a work.
Or [ that it is extreme if it is alike and says ] ...

[Comprehensive evaluation]
It is one of the very favorite works.
Entering is early animation "magic teacher Welsh onion ま!
It is " んっ for a while to the hero Welsh onion who is " (fellow who is not broadcast recently).
Although it is also at the time with " って思う, I think that the Welsh onion therefore also has 10 years old also of っていう面 as for it.
Although I conclude that the Welsh onion looks at the process which grows up from 10 useless, useless years old through future various things by まぁ and such touch (', omega, and `)

2008/02/18 Good [Original Japanese review]
by Bosutonia Provider: 51955 Host:52050 Browser: 5521
This comes out for the first time.
is Mr.
Akamatsu's work a very much troublesome work?
To then, evaluation
[Good point]
- picture be beautiful.
I think that the level more than fixed is always maintained.
- Individuality of a character.
Although it is an unreasonable setup called the 31 heroines, each draws and I think that the division is possible.
- View of the world.
A magic community etc.
has a fine setup and is drawing the building, the dress, etc.
finely.
- School festival.
When there was such a thing actually, the atmosphere of the festival made to regard it as pleasant was felt.

[Bad point]
Although it was said that - picture is beautiful, it will be visible to a-less individuality somehow picture.
(although that is not actually right, either) There are many - sex appeal scenes.
you word crack ている -- many [ in things / too ] Do say [ the trousers shown as the degree whose aanya is a kick, and / whether it is ugly something and ] that it is dirty, speaking concretely?
Although it will be glad to a delightful person, since a character may collapse.
- A surrounding adult is too sweet on a Welsh onion.
部活 approval of school length etc.
is inexcusable.
I think it amusing that nothing copes with it even if it will be known, if magic is disclosed to the student.
- The force of a battle is missing.
Since theory past る構図 is taken, although it is intelligible, I think that it is surely unimpressive.
- The dress of a character.
Although a kind is abundant and it is good, I think that there is too much dress which is easy to take out sex appeal in any way.
し [ there are even those who have on the dress which appears from the beginning ].
- A Welsh onion is also past [ て ].
There is too much love feeling 持っている human being (+ robo).
Although it is a hero's fate, I consider taking to it simply wholly in any way, as passed.
- Good person past る, such as a classmate.
For the first time in [ although the character which is not applied is also in this a little, to the extent that it is surprised wholly / a fake Saint ].
Admiration for children cannot be denied.
Evaluation is "good" although many bad points were written after all.
it is what -- is himself who bit the touch currently enjoyed that it can ride as it is, if it carries out and does not think deeply?
He does not so like individually asuna whose himself is the main heroine at the end.
Such character will be weak.
し [ it also has capability in magic cancellation etc.
].
Because it is not described, し [ it is not visible to the touch which suffered troubles by practice ].
Receiving, a favorite character is the "Evan jierin." He sprouts and likes her grand past and overwhelming strength, and the calm touch more.
however, it -- recently and a silly joke -- it was red when the thing of a Welsh onion was pointed out by the circle -- after it carries out and gosurori-ization of a dress becomes superfluous, the image has broken for a while It is that I want her to be that I want you to touch a Welsh onion as an adult in an adult figure all the time too.
It expects at future.

2008/02/17 Comment(normal) [Original Japanese review]
by 十傑集 Provider: 11009 Host:11078 Browser: 5234
This talk was the most interesting within limits which he read -- The shota hero which it was [ only being loved by the older elder sister and ] is loved by the older ossan (爆).
but -- since it is touch that it flattered the reader that the female students of the bloomers of the first half have ridden on houki -- "-- usually --" どまり

2008/02/04 Bad [Original Japanese review]
by 剣舞大使 Provider: 18003 Host:17735 Browser: 4749
Although the work of a week boy magazine is checked, in finding out fun, 本作 is read and is delicate.
the author says that the point is good as a cartoonist, or is informed [ secrets of success in life ], and so -- しか -- I do not consider the scuffle to which it pulls the until talk like that only by cultural festival ?, a setup excellent in extendibility, especially the point that there is much heroine since it is the student of a school -- if there is also no unnaturalness and it is likely to be choi-appearance-popular in others centering on the main -- turn -- increasing -- a case -- the main class -- promotion Isn't it kyara which is very useful now for the authors, such as per 1000 rain?
However, only for this reason, there is mainly a setup called a school, and I can think that there is no necessity that a Welsh onion is a teacher, anywhere.
if a Welsh onion is not likable as a man as a teacher and it sees as a teacher -- O -- unpleasant to eight or more teachers the heroines are brainwashed with the Welsh onion, so that it suspects for it being -- up to [ there ] -- people -- 惹き -- the price -- probably there is no る〓o〓What was necessary was just to have become okojo.
Although it will probably be better than the work which makes a reader desertion and runs recklessly, neither a view of the world nor a battle nor kyara can be enjoyed more.
Evaluation is "bad" by the point which also carries out a question mark and comfort to neither the humanity of a Welsh onion, nor the treatment of the heroine.
The pakuteioo card which is a term was set by QOA.
A friend's look was painful, although it read and thought that て was good --

2008/01/31 Normal [Original Japanese review]
by Benpa Provider: 18003 Host:17759 Browser: 4671
a love -- it does not understand well wanting whether to have in a battle whether it is rice recently Although there is no point which thinks is not much bad, drawing a girl too much, and the man being also an inner side of the thigh, or 女っぽくなっていたり(ing) worries this man.

2008/01/29 Best! [Original Japanese review]
by ポンコツ2008 Provider: 5361 Host:5349 Browser: 3646
It is fine one by one [ character ], and it is set up and is interesting.
Since the numerousness of kyara is also well moved as a group, there is also no unnaturalness.
A story is also pleasant, is read and does not 飽き bored.
I think that all the members just return from the magic world.

2008/01/17 Worst [Original Japanese review]
by Mata Provider: 33413 Host:33396 Browser: 2989(Mobile)
It was visible only to trivial sermon comics.
If only a school festival is considered -- A setup is limited of a setup.

Next / Post your review / Top page

Other media
Anime:Magister Negi Magi (Mahou Sensei Negima) / Special effects:MAGISTER NEGI MAGI