DB Top > Works > Comics >

[Comics]Medaka Box

[Other version: RSS/Japanese version]
If this is not the work which you are looking for, please use above search box or various list or DB's top page.

Reviews' statics

Comics total pnts rank=Avg. x Eval. num	Rank 4,687/in 4,775 titles (Total -29.24)	Rank 4,686 <= => Rank 4,688
Comics avg pnts rank(minimum:10 evals)	Rank 712/in 896 titles (Average -0.34(Good))	Rank 711 <= => Rank 713
Comics total pnts rank of 2009	Rank 87/in 91 titles	Rank 86 <= => Rank 88

All
Reviews(Post)

Fan forum

Image&Wallpaper

Goods
(Books)

Goods from Japan

Latest Books: 2010/04/02 ():

めだかボックス 4 (ジャンプコミックス) \420

Books(4hit) Sales/Latest
コミック:めだかボックス 4 (ジャンプコミックス)Tag:\420 2010/04/02 ()	コミック:めだかボックス 1 (ジャンプコミックス)Tag:\420 2009/10/02 () Eval.:*****	コミック:めだかボックス 2 (ジャンプコミックス) Tag:\420 2009/12/04 () Eval.:*****	コミック:めだかボックス 3 (ジャンプコミックス) Tag:\420 2010/02/04 () Eval.:*****

Story

Medaka and Zenkichi make the ultimate student council!! Bring in your problems!!

Information about this title

Ishin Nishio Akira Akatsuki
SHUEISHA

Japan Released:2009/05/11(Mon) Weekly Boys Jump

Official sites
1. http://www.shonenjump.com/j/rensai/medakabox/index.html (Translation)

Statics of evaluation(The statics is updated once a day)

	Average	ComicsRank	Deviation(Total)	Evaluation points(Total)	Best of the Best
Inside Japan	Good(-0.34)	4,687	40.46	-29.24	2
Outside Japan	Best(3.00)	47	54.66	3.00

Statics of activity

	Total Views	Comment	Evaluation
Inside Japan	81,520	109	87
Outside Japan	1,134	1	1

How others evaluated in Japan

Best

Very Good

Good

Normal

Bad

Very Bad

Worst

People

Percentage

17.2%

6.9%

9.2%

13.8%

20.7%

18.4%

Added percentage

17.2%

24.1%

33.3%

47.1%

60.9%

81.6%

100%

Summary

33.3%

13.8%

52.9%

Views for recent 8 days
Total 21 20 19 18 17 16 15 14
11 1 2 1 0 4 0 2 1

Forum for the special topic (Create topic)

Sorted by:Newness / Oldness
All including comments
Only Evaluation Good
Evaluation:Best/Very Good/Good Normal
Evaluation Bad
Evaluation:Bad/Very Bad/Worst
This reputation board

2009/09/15 Best! [Edit/Delete/Suggest to delete/Only this reviewer/Show only this review or post sympathy comment/(Everyone can)]
by muwlove (Send message) Review history[Good:2(100%) Normal:0(0%) Bad:0(0%)] / Provider: 32128 Host:32069 Browser: 11525
[What is good]
It is a good picture.
Medaka and Shiranui's characteristics.

[What is bad]
Too much focus on Medaka.

[Summary]
Overall, it is very well made work. I hope it serialized long.

The below reviews are translated automatically from Japanese ones. To post your review to English version, please click here.

2010/03/22 Very bad [Original Japanese review]
by 愛希羅 (Send message) Provider: 22941 Host:23157 Browser: 11169

[Good point]
Early story corresponding to the request to a skill-of-drawing student council
[a bad point]
-- the character suddenly said for a battle route to be unusual -- being hard -- or [ that a student council with many (certain hunter comics of a jump -- similarly) explanatory notes is eye " / why or / although it carries out and is the comics (13 sets of 13 persons are explained to be an unusual person's height -- pushed down comparatively immediately) which are not unusual ] -- fan club" -- it has turned Hitoyoshi [ -- the comics which applaud [ whether it is eye comprehensive evaluation] and ] I want to come to put in an inquiry.
Only for the skill of "animal よけ", the fault only by perfect human being is.
If a fault has extraordinariness more, it will think that it was able to balance abnormalities as it is perfect.
If you do not like the Nishio Restoration describing the original, I will think that these comics do not care for it.
Evaluation will presuppose that it is very bad.

2010/03/19 Normal [Original Japanese review]
by TEN (Send message) Provider: 10211 Host:10516 Browser: 9466
Although it becomes battle comics and is a long this-work article There was a place which changed also except the battle.
It is that the monologue increased unusually.
Although it thinks that the scene describing an enemy and the past of an ally is required, and its timing to take out is also good, it says that it is surely romantic, or does not come to have an explanatory feeling.
Since it is special comics, I want you to make it more the form to see instead of the form where a situation is read by words or depiction, taking advantage of a picture or a character.
an original -- Nishio -- although a text is also enough because the Restoration, now, I think that it does not change with the illustration always being attached to the novel with much trouble -- drawing -- since the powerful person is drawing, I want to read this work in the form which pulls out a text from a picture more Or is the ability of illustrating which is not skillful く描け about an original insufficient?
I thought that I wanted you to draw as "comics" more because the famous original was equal to the picture kirei anyhow with much trouble.

2010/03/16 Very good [Original Japanese review]
by Razuberii (Send message) Provider: 34156 Host:34070 Browser: 1968(Mobile)
Although it became battle comics recently, I think that it is a "あり" (there was also opinion are not good, plentifully).
I think that a trouble of an unusual reason something may also suit an enemy.
He mixes feelings and likes the battle of つつ.
it is eye a free one -- it cannot drain off from per three in small 5- that tsundere or because of [ which were removed ] a scene something -- it is likely to be carried out (another -- there -- the main -- even when -- there is nothing anything) The problems are whether is a man strong against underground 1 and 2 brought, and a thing strong against others is, and what to carry out, if fastidious [ finish ].
Since it is most solid in the battle of the present jump, I want you to do my best.

2010/03/10 Bad [Original Japanese review]
by Kamino (Send message) Provider: 38998 Host:38982 Browser: 11002

[Good point]
- skill of drawing
[bad point]
- a favorite character is not - A battle is not so interesting, either.

[Comprehensive evaluation]
Early one was still good (although the hero was disagreeable).
A battle is past [ a normal ].
Do you try to want to have gone up popularity for a while recently?

2010/03/03 Bad [Original Japanese review]
by H&J (Send message) Provider: 6838 Host:6757 Browser: 10688
Although the subjectivity of the ethical-doctrine-that-human-being's-inborn-nature-is-good base of whether to be eye perfect human being of the opening part which inclined intently was interesting, it is thin and the eccentric person eccentric person total attack deployment is sorry about being [ which appears from the battle-ized latest next to the next ] idling.
Although the enemy side characters who come out in this work are truly only the man who exceeds a place and do not say that there is no persuasive power of existence, they are considered to be a quite thin thing.
However the battle full of eccentric persons in the world without a touch of reality may theorize, since it is not thought that it is not much interesting Evaluation: It is bad.

2010/03/02 Worst [Original Japanese review]
by Serumin (Send message) Provider: 3196 Host:3180 Browser: 5698

[Good point]
Excuse me, it is not.
--
[a bad point]
-- (1) picture >> -- although it is not poor, somehow, for oneself, it is suitable and does not become precocious (2) >> with erotic depiction; I consider in a thing with many [ indiscriminately ] scenes which expose the skin.
in one talk, the heroine was calm and had changed her clothes in public -- carrying out -- the talk of moreover swimming -- women -- it obtains and cannot say in ~ んここ (3) Thing >> from which the talk became a battle route suddenly; Although it worries at first, it is consultation and the fellow who says and it thought that they were the comics which solve a trouble with a standard box, is battle cartooning carried out suddenly?
That thinks that it is not good.
Although the dragon ball also changed from comics full of gags to battle comics, since a Gokuu is learning the martial art from the time of comics full of gags and was using the martial art, that was good.
In short, that it seems that you may become battle comics any time, it is set up and a dragon ball shines.
However, it is め, or that it seems that you may become battle comics like a dragon ball any time, it is set up and a box does not become precocious.
If such a setup is set at least, considering the beginning, I will think that it was made evaluation good to a slight degree.
(4) Do and is the depiction [ pass ] to depiction >> Visualize the scene which whether it is た exploded the school building by argument of a student council and a school committee for discipline, and was destroyed?
how much -- it is also -- doing -- passing -- it is -- !
such a thing -- if it does by reality, it will be regarded as terrorism (5) It is Eye 黒神 or except Has No Individuality.
(6) Style is not Fit for Boy Jump.

[Comprehensive evaluation]
As me, the worst and other controversialists of the too (although it does not those[ with explanation ]-ま in the favorite one --) who are not found think somehow that it was unsavory to have carried out from the middle at battle comics in this work as 仰る.
Evaluation is taken as the "worst."

2010/02/24 Comment(bad) [Original Japanese review]
by Machomen (Send message) Provider: 5000 Host:5067 Browser: 8759

[Good point]
The contents of the skill-of-drawing beginning
[Bad point]
There may be neta of the system which cannot exist, and there is too nothing and it is painful.
It battle-izes too much and is 。.
a hero is perfect -- past .
The standard box of initial setting is not used at all.

[Comprehensive evaluation]
Although skill of drawing was high so so, and the first contents were good, and battle-ized, it has self-blasted.
when it is writing that it may be truly that it cannot be, こ smashes -- it is painful

2010/02/15 Comment(normal) [Original Japanese review]
by 宮田さんの隣人 (Send message) Provider: 382 Host:391 Browser: 10260

[Good point]
A character may be individual and illustrating's may be stable.

[Bad point]
Although he wants to draw the collision-thing of ego and ego in work, the ego thinks that forcing contents past て読者 cannot be following.

[comprehensive evaluation]
for which I feel that the rest is favorably treated for a while compared with other comics -- because it is common, there is [ ordinary well bad ] also that it can read in comfort

2010/02/09 Good [Original Japanese review]
by 最後 (Send message) Provider: 7161 Host:7182 Browser: 14895

[Good point]
話絵 to battle-izing is beautiful.

[Bad point]
It is [ whether it is a little too perfect め whether it is eye battle-izing and ] the talk of mansee.

[comprehensive evaluation]
-- although it was a foregone conclusion that a neta piece is carried out immediately, if it is still before a battle -- good - very good -- about -- they were the comics which can be attached enough (Well, popularity is ..., although it seems that there was nothing) The characters beautiful [ a picture ] and main were drawn very attractively.
I am め, although it carries out, and it is drawn [ which gag and the place it can be laughed that are kusuri had ] too much perfectly whether it is め a little, and it is め or is only deployment of mansee -- biting -- the meeting [ た / a meeting ] -- the part which the favorite thing of the character which seems to be long was also helped and was not a battle thing in the jump -- it was reading pleasantly However, it has battle-ized like other comics whether it is the sad sex of a jump work.
Since it was good at a picture, I wanted it to have stopped it in the least and to write a work new again, if it still battle-izes, although possibly it was unavoidable since it was unpopular.

2010/02/07 Best! [Original Japanese review]
by DASH (Send message) Provider: 699 Host:483 Browser: 8652

[Good point]
A picture is beautiful.
Gag is interesting.
Zenkichi is too smart.

[Bad point]
mure of battle-izing which remains for a while
[Comprehensive evaluation]
Although it was surprised at battle-ization, I also regard it as it being natural.
He likes individually and evaluation is the highest in sushi and the meaning of wanting you to do one's best from now on.

2010/02/04 Good [Original Japanese review]
by Moyogi (Send message) Provider: 23899 Host:23884 Browser: 11169

[a good point]
-- 1 -- a by [ talks ] boss boss -- it becomes nice and the drawing weariness which goes does not come -- carry out story deployment main -- a character
[Bad point]
Especially nothing
[Comprehensive evaluation]
Although it had skill of drawing high from the first, it is surprised that it becomes still nicer.
In a jump, I think that it is the skill of drawing which fights for 12.
Although it was surprised at sudden battle-ization, this is interesting now.
He also likes certain comics under series battle-ized from comics full of gags, and it is sushi.
This work has an interesting character anyhow.
Every person has a thing like each opinion, and although it is wild, seemingly it will be very dear and can consider whether it is thing touch like childlikeness of somewhere year suitability.

2010/01/30 Worst [Original Japanese review]
by 海驢 (Send message) Provider: 14213 Host:14238 Browser: 2982(Mobile)
Although illustrating is how to be well very well, its talk is incoherent and it memorizes the hit displeasure which has carried lie knowledge there are many characters and clear in the weekly boy jump dignifiedly.
The first kind deed -'s of the setup [ whether to make a fool of a reader after becoming a battle route strangely ] which was still good increased.

2010/01/25 Good [Original Japanese review]
by porta (Send message) Provider: 7921 Host:7682 Browser: 2256

[Good point]
Till before the early stages of - - a battle, although liking is likely to be divided, it is rather interesting.
- Skill of drawing has sufficient thing and characters are the contents which can enjoy individuality abundance, exorbitant deployment, etc.
as already raised.

[Bad point]
It is the place which cannot deny touch impossible in any way after becoming a battle thing ...

[Comprehensive evaluation]
It becomes battle route change of jump comics custom (or it could not but carry out.).
from -- the admiration it became impossible to enjoy one now is large It does not go to collapse but touch [ forcibly / too / と ] is the touch which cannot be denied.
Till before a battle, it puts in that he was able to be enjoyed enough and is "good."

2010/01/25 Worst [Original Japanese review]
by KAMIKAZE (Send message) Provider: 53383 Host:53386 Browser: 6770

[Good point]
Is skill of drawing a still good grade?
Other than this, it is not found.

[Bad point]
Deployment becomes a battle recently and the story "has self-blasted." It is the fault which can be said that this is fatal.

[comprehensive evaluation]
-- although activity of the student council centering on whether it is eye 黒神 is a main talk ...
if it is trouble consultations (trouble consultation of the model of the picture of the honor student of a fine-arts system etc.) of in the university [ original ], although it is の which was still good ....
if the contents which had come out recently are looked at, they will be the battle comics using arms to the end why or in the end -- coming out -- isn't it?
the every day of a student council must be the main works -- why -- a battle Honestly, now, the comics itself "have self-blasted." making the same mistake as a certain private teacher comics of the same magazine -- if ...
already, the contents have failed in this, so that correction is not effective -- しか -- it cannot consider .
I think that the fundamental thing should have been done honestly.
Since the above-mentioned thing is fatal, evaluation is the "worst."

2010/01/23 Very bad [Original Japanese review]
by sAGi (Send message) Provider: 19847 Host:19718 Browser: 7774(Mobile)
About the place which says that a good point has beautiful illustrating.
I want you to stop the battle deployment which the latest translation does not understand.
Although it thinks that it is not so late to carry out a まぁ neta piece and being cooked, this deployment does not exist.
By a character sprouting, although it may be an aim, it does not sprout at all.
If it finishes when a complication with an honest student in charge of discipline is solved, I will think that it was still good.
The present deployment does not understand wanting what to carry out at all.
Evaluation is very bad.

2010/01/16 Comment(bad) [Original Japanese review]
by nyaoyamano (Send message) Provider: 21640 Host:21711 Browser: 13902

[a good point]
- there is nothing
[Bad point]
How to use deployment and the character of - story
[comprehensive evaluation]
-- original: -- only saying [ the Nishio Restoration ] -- it is -- the thickness and deepness of the contents -- although it hoped that there might be nothing が hanpa -- too -- a jump there needs to be no unreasonableness in doing biweekly - and ...
an eccentric person superman -- it is also -- the times where now the work of such a technique is overflowing although the view of the world which the characters of ざれ weave is splendid -- this work -- not much -- charm -- feeling -- ないっす The way when being posted by the standard box in oneself at which it worried and which did things indifferently was pleasant...

2010/01/09 Very bad [Original Japanese review]
by Kagerou (Send message) Provider: 34156 Host:34041 Browser: 2027(Mobile)
if interesting as neta -- しか -- the work which cannot be taken It is not so interesting if it sees seriously.
It is not awfully got blocked.
Although it is the impression that this man's comics are full of eccentric persons ....
They are whether it says [ what ] and a thoughtless eccentric person.
an eccentric person -- even when だらけ, although kicked, only the surface top of the eccentric person who may be interesting and whom this author writes is an eccentric person, and contents are thin It is poor at investigation.
Since the character of a character is forcibly told in a text tone, there is no depth which does not carry out a situation.
It is not an abnormal as it is settled in the region of て or an eccentric person.
That is, it is the eccentric person of anticipation within the limits.
A "professional killer" and "目線 from a top" Setup whose character only tends to be strange when thinking well.
Other jump comics, for example, hisoka of a "hunter hunter".
Since it is the abnormal on a precise assembly, eeriness comes out.
I am eye " or -" does not get used to a not-good lover.
It is because it is the setting tone comics of eccentric person きどり by which contents are not accompanied only by appearance.
A real eccentric person is an eccentric person more.

2010/01/09 Normal [Original Japanese review]
by 無線機 (Send message) Provider: 27699 Host:27749 Browser: 2914(Mobile)
Although it is practically equal to fun after changing before route change, I think that there was no mura in fun as trouble solution section after becoming a volume on battle, and it became the deployment which can draw only the talk as expected.
since -- change -- the front -- some -- the good kana If it has appeared, great comment cannot be found by the comics of the grade to read, either.

2010/01/02 Very good [Original Japanese review]
by 裏 (Send message) Provider: 42910 Host:42758 Browser: 10720

[a good point]
-- an individual character -- the play on words told to a high skill-of-drawing way of the world
[Bad point]
Place which it passes forcibly
[Comprehensive evaluation]
This is touch of the about "oh, makes a route change" when it was the work with which tastes are divided as hard as possible and changes to a battle thing from an early setup, and there was no resistance independently.
But some 「it is ん.
although kicked, it is the level with the place which thinks " which can still be passed, and early deployment also likes the present deployment Nishio -- し it will think the kana which is not in the text peculiar to kana which is not regarded as these comics being interesting, or those who consider as iratt, either if you do not like the style of the Nishio Restoration, although it is my believer opinion (I like it) The Nishio Restoration has come out well, and genius, abnormalities, and the deployment to say also like it, and it regards them as "interesting" to a normal.

2009/12/29 Very bad [Original Japanese review]
by 山口21号 (Send message) Provider: 19847 Host:19730 Browser: 6794(Mobile)
Further evaluation is revised downward.

[Good point]
Although it was observed at first by calling it the
[comprehensive evaluation]
Nishio Restoration original which does not sound the heart even if it said expected
[the bad point]
, unnatural battle cartooning, and the however uncanny thing at the - beginning with high - skill of drawing, it is the work which now continues barely by his charisma nature.
Although it was expectable at first, battle cartooning has been carried out by unnatural deployment.
Since the heart is not sounded at all even if it says a however uncanny thing, although it is good if the talk is interesting even if it carries out battle cartooning then, there is also no method of comrades.
(Although neuro was in the same hero strongest comics as whether it is め, persuasive power was in words there) it is alike and evaluation is made into the very bad thing to lower

Post your evaluation or comment.(Evaluation can be posted only once)

You need
1 other people's posts to post your evaluation or
30 other people's posts to post your comment
after you post your evaluation or comment.

Your Name(Required):

Password (Required. more than 4 characters) [If you want to create secure password: Online mkpasswd service]

Your comment about this anime(Required)

Your evaluation of this title(Required)
You can choose the evaluation only once. After you post your evaluation, please choose comment instead of evaluation from the options.

Evaluation of this title(You can choose this only once)
Your evaluation
If you evaluated this title once, please choose comment instead of the evaluation. Or you can use forum.
Comment by the person who thinks this is good
Comment by the person who thinks this is normal
Comment by the person who thinks this is bad

Please choose appropriate option for readers.

Pleaase confirm that your post is satisfing the following rules

Rule for reviews

This site allows you to write reviews for each title, but we don't allow you to criticize others' comment. Too bad or meaningless words are also not allowed. The comment which doesn't follow the rule will be deleted and access will be denied.

Caution: Please post the evaluation which follows the rule.

DB Top > Works > Comics > Medaka Box[Comics]:Review/Information

All
Reviews(Post)

Fan forum

Image&Wallpaper

Goods
(Books)

Sales top 100

Anime(EN)	1. Ponyo TwoDisc / 2. Astro Boy / 3. Ponyo TwoDisc / 4-100
Game(EN)	1. God of / 2. Pokemon SoulSilver / 3. Wii / 4-100
Comics(EN)	1. Warriors / 2. Twelve Kingdoms, The - Hardcov / 3. Warriors / 4-100
Figure(EN)	1. Bakugan 7 / 2. Transformers / 3. ScoobyDoo Figure / 4-100

Other: Anime(JP) / Game(JP) / Game machine(JP) / Comics(JP) / Movie(JP) / JP movie(JP) / Figure(JP) / Anime/Game Music(JP) / SF/Fantasy(JP) / Mistery(JP) / History(JP) / Romance(JP)

Sorted by alphabet	People[Voice / Actor / Supervisor / Story / Producer / Editor / Camera / Music / Singer / Writer / Drawer] Company[Anime / Game / Comics / Book / Drama / Movie / Music / Office / Tv] / Magazine / Group / Machine
Sorted by related works number	People[Voice / Actor / Supervisor / Story / Producer / Editor / Camera / Music / Singer / Writer / Drawer] Company[Anime / Game / Comics / Book / Drama / Movie / Music / Office / Tv] / Magazine / Group / Machine
Sorted by fan number	People[Voice / Actor / Supervisor / Story / Music / Singer / Writer / Drawer] Company[Anime / Game / Comics / Book / Drama / Movie / Music / Office / Tv] / Magazine / Group / Machine

Sorted by:Newness / Oldness
All including comments Only Evaluation	Good Evaluation:Best/Very Good/Good	Normal Evaluation	Bad Evaluation:Bad/Very Bad/Worst