Japanese works database(How to join/Help)
Top page: All/Only Reviews

Others
Site map


Search / Outside DB:

Comics ranking: Rank 177/in 4,217 titles (Total 40.04/Deviation 57.32) Rank 176 <= => Rank 178
Comics average points ranking: Rank 107/in 694 titles (Average 1.82(Very good)/Deviation 59.91) Rank 106 <= => Rank 108 (more than 10 evaluatoin)
Comics ranking of 2001: Rank 10/in 80 titles Rank 9 <= => Rank 11

Mobile Suit Gundam the origin(Comics)

[Other version: RSS/Japanese version]

All
Reviews(Post)

Forum

Images

Information about this title

Hajime Yatate Yoshiyuki Tomino
Yoshikazu Yasuhiko
OKAWARA KUNIO
Monthly Gundam Ace
Kadokawa Shoten Publishing Co.,Ltd.

Released:2001/06 in Japan

Official sites
1. :: GUNDAM BASE :: (Translation)

Statics of evaluation(The statics is updated once a day)

	Average	ComicsRank	Deviation(Total)	Evaluation points(Total)	Best of the Best
Inside Japan	Very good(1.82)	177	57.32	40.04

Statics of activity

	Total Views	Comment	Evaluation
Inside Japan	11,891	27	22
Outside Japan	256	0	0

How others evaluated in Japan

Best

Very Good

Good

Normal

Bad

Very Bad

Worst

People

Percentage

22.7%

50.0%

22.7%

0.0%

4.5%

0.0%

Added percentage

22.7%

72.7%

95.4%

99.9%

100%

Summary

95.4%

4.5%

Views for recent 8 days
Total 13 12 11 10 9 8 7 6
23 3 8 4 2 2 2 0 2

Language Sorted by date Sorted by recommendation
English Good
(Only Evaluation) Normal
(Only Evaluation) Bad
(Only Evaluation) All
(Only Evaluation) None
Japanese Good
(Only Evaluation) Normal
(Only Evaluation) Bad
(Only Evaluation) All
(Only Evaluation) None
This reputation board

Language	Sorted by date	Sorted by recommendation
English	Good (Only Evaluation)	Normal (Only Evaluation)	Bad (Only Evaluation)	All (Only Evaluation)	None
Japanese	Good (Only Evaluation)	Normal (Only Evaluation)	Bad (Only Evaluation)	All (Only Evaluation)	None

Post your review / Top page

The below reviews are translated automatically from Japanese ones. To post to English version, please click here.

2008/09/14 Comment(good) [Original Japanese review]
by 十傑集 Provider: 12865 Host:12897 Browser: 4928
Compared with this comic version and animation, hospitality and amuro treat shaa coldly.
the state which does not move by the gerugugu game held now, either, as amuro considers [ the cancer dam in front of magnet coating ], but comes out although the direction of amuro consisted of per [ a zugokku game ] only by the zaku time more than equal, and that it was able to be called shaa predominance by direct confrontation or animation although the former turn was increasing by the volume on pre-makes cut right-hand man -- moreover -- shaa -- a sharia bull -- "unripe new type" denouncement By animation, although shaa is the neighborhood where raraa dies, it is carrying out the 目線 utterance kiln of he having realized with the new type from sirocco ばり -- Although reunion with a sailor is also a near reason, he plans to carry out what explanation for the point of "the kyasubaru elder brother who killed Mr.
shaa of the azunaburu house made intimate, and took the place" to aruteishia -- ((Although the circumstances which ↑ kyasubaru begins to declare itself in shaa were various-views あった reasons, the dignity of the name of shaa faded and deployment of honesty and this work was ちゃう deployment.) As)

2008/02/10 Best! [Original Japanese review]
by Papi Provider: 38961 Host:38734 Browser: 7590
Although it has stopped thinking that my 1st cancer dam is too good, and a subsequent work is different in " etc.
...", and seeing immediately, now which passed through the long time from that, it is excited at a long time and this work is read.
Although there were many backgrounds imagined from the conversation of characters with the TV version, it is the touch [ work / this ] "it was connected at last." carrying out that it is reckless just because it knows especially the past of shaa and a sailor and a calm sailor always thinks of an elder brother in animation, and committing たり -- a bed -- one person -- the 泣いていた feeling was found well Were the bonds of the young brothers and sisters who lived both severe fate fairly deep?
Moreover, it is drawn in detail with the relation by shaa, the circumstances of the sailor which could not but become strong and the zabi house, and ranba raru's and others TV version story which turned into the demon of revenge, and is substantial.
The individuality of a character is also emphasized, delicate human relations are expressed with reality by the skillful psychological description, and it is interesting.
A continuation is very pleasure.

2007/12/27 Very bad [Original Japanese review]
by 634 Provider: 10597 Host:10886 Browser: 6342
[Good point] The fineness of the Yasuhiko touch no one but, a story, and contents according to television series.
So, if television series is known, it is nature and the contents which can enter, and it will advance, reading the point easily, since it is intelligible even if it makes it the story.
the thing although kicked, a skillful く描いた portion sends applause for it obediently, and receive, and as books and magazines, it is alike literally, is not bored, and highly complete which a portion which surely cannot but ask Yasuhiko when drawing 1st cancer dam only on Yasuhiko who became a comic writer may also be should hear -- る 1st cancer dam world -- still more .
[a bad point] -- as the impression over the latest cancer dam -- "-- it is already good ......
the feeling of fatigue " -- it is .
Even if it has succeeded in respect of performance and a character, from the "cancer dam SEED" or before which became big failure with the style One-track is truly felt for the cancer dam continued without learning by experience, and it is "daitaan 3".
the thing "whether there is any nothing that is not a cancer dam 創れ" -- feeling -- I have you -- Ups and downs call it "an appearance shelf and eye [!!
] a formula", or by "zabunguru" Can think that the portion "zabunguru of pattern 破り" came out and a part and its pattern 破り have finished "∀ cancer dam" at the end, and It seems to be opposite to such Tomino's idea with BANDAI and Kadokawa having given up the manufacture concept for the cancer dam itself to have formula-ized.
Of course, if the income side in such meanings is considered while the hit of a character thing is cried for and the situation for which it cannot but depend on a thing called a cancer dam is also in sight, it comes.
However, the tendency for which seldom feels a good impression and it depends on it follows too much the work manufactured in respect of such.
although kicked, carry out and make it work of 本作 what thought Yasuhiko was in such meanings in the field of comic-izing of a cancer dam which is not known and which possibly thought, "You are what.
do you draw a cancer dam now?" -- the necessity of drawing the work of about 30 years ago now cannot be felt, and approval is seldom possible, either [comprehensive evaluation] -- し the good impression was performed to BANDAI still bound by spell called a cancer dam and Kadokawa recently in in the paper [ it was that the publication of is suspended until now even if it carried out and made it comic-ization of 1st cancer dam / comic bonbon ] nothing is -- it -- a kyara design -- it is -- illustrating -- it seldom admires making a supervisor's Yasuhiko draw again make it a success of the cancer dam SEED, and both sides of failure -- make it the style of the cancer dam which continues in addition now -- Although what thought it is does not know [ although written in the treatment of the present cancer dam, ] about 本作 even if necessity is never felt for having become the work which merely comic-ized 1st faithfully in such meanings, and it makes it the Tomino 由悠季, and it makes it the Yasuhiko right sum If it is made persons in question, it is imagined that it will think not a little, "It is a cancer dam now ......" Because, the cancer dam for them is "having finished" long ago.
Even though it transmits the work which has finished also to a new fan also at an old fan, even if 1st cancer dam carries out at video, the present condition which is DVD-ized and is re-broadcast repeatedly, and various game software, even though it is drawing such portions, it is comic, and it will be supported into such portions ......, with a birthmark, and will be felt for them.
Since it is neither a remake nor such a thing, it has become the thing that it is only to merely draw ancient times for a long time and 1st cancer dam already has the consciousness also for itself of "having finished", it is severe however 本作 with such a strong impression.

2007/09/14 Very good [Original Japanese review]
by H&J Provider: 22725 Host:22557 Browser: 4184
[Good point] Explanation of circumstances and shaa birth which result in the jion independence whose fine change, such as a mechanism design and a course of WB, is increasing the reality further while using the animation version as the base on the whole etc., It is [ what deployment it becomes after this and ] pleasure although it is still (he has no 褒めっぱ) under series also with whether it is all right that are drawing carefully the portion which could not but be a back setup, and strong GM which looks at and is convinced to the image of those days anew is also reliable, and the GOOD human-being drama is also described deeply.
[a bad point] -- while a tank and canon are moreover past [ weakness ] in outdated treatment -- a cancer dam -- mechakucha -- ねぇ -- which is strong [Comprehensive evaluation] Since it has not completed yet, it is "very good."

2007/05/26 Very good [Original Japanese review]
by ST-14D Provider: 43269 Host:43454 Browser: 5234
The design of a mobiru suit is pleased individually.
long in the nose of gufu etc.
unlike the TV version -- new, although it carries out and is not Garcia in zugokku etc.
although the head of a tank had resistance a little -- 3 fingers of canon -- the highest the amount of [ of a gym ] waist was smart at cancer dam みたい -- carrying out -- that, and the point of the heat rod of gufu breaks or the Balkan Peninsula comes from the arm of zaku たり ...
[ that a missile comes from the yellow place for the chest of a cancer dam to others ] It is なっ about when it goes to the universe!?
P-S They are a core booster or ...
too.
The theater version following.

2006/12/05 Good [Original Japanese review]
by JG Provider: 11085 Host:11338 Browser: 6363
It is that the work already completed as a story at once can be made interesting so far.
Although it thinks it unavoidable that it thrusts in with something and there is どころ, I will set without being able to touch about it.
If it says, this work will be an original but good thing rather.
Is what is necessary just to call it the difference between the head family and the originator?
ん- a little different kana That it is the fun in consideration of there having been animation series is the portion which cannot deny.
However, by animation, such as shaa personal history and the past, the story of the 本作 original which is not drawn is interesting and has many portions felt more natural in setup than animation.
Although future carries out comfort and is also a work wholly since it has not completed, do I feel that evaluation will be divided according to future deployment?
At a present stage, it can be said that it is finished in the very interesting work.

2006/05/30 Good [Original Japanese review]
by 十傑集 Provider: 11009 Host:11078 Browser: 5234
The work with which Yasuhiko did the reorganization collection of the contents of 1st.
That mechanism depiction as which the coarse portion was also regarded is refined those days also has some scenes which regret in story, although it is glad.
Even what becomes what by one ace pilot although it seems that an effort for for helping ?
そりゃ garuma which shaa deludes with 本作 the affair in which shaa which can be said also as the main of the first work of a theater murders garuma, and has not taken action etc.
was not made.
At the time of amuro desertion, he got angry to the direction of buraito rather.
If it fights at 本作 to non-[ by the side of amuro of not being realized as an army in there being no affirmation of arbitrary decision and execution since amuro disregarded the command by TV, it has sortied by the cancer tank freely and it is an ace pilot, and through being carried out ] があった's as ordinarily as gufu of ranba raru and cannot win as a result, it is 降ろすって about a cancer dam -- a mechanism -- Mr.
" needs to move a cancer dam with responsibility in the boy of only the civilian to like -- if a result does not follow on having said high-handedly in " etc.
and having done one's best desperately just for a moment, it is not useful, and it will treat and will be made it -- having -- りゃ kire -- ます .
Didn't a commander's duty comfort amuro, saying "If we, the amateur group depending on newest Eiki's performance, can win easily [ the pro of long record of active service ], explanation will not stand on them"?
Even if it carried out cancer dam stealing off to non-tasting too, it sympathized with amuro very at this time.
Being reminded of bell seruku somehow by deployment, if it comes out and the volume on pre-continues for a long time now たり.
the neighborhood which makes unrelated people involvement for a genuine article, and displays for the first time in [ which is called murder / 腹黒 ] since jion daikun becomes genuine kyasubaru [ of having been deified after death / the point or kyasubaru ] shaa -- although it is interesting, I want you to draw the talk after the jab low of this editing soon Or [ raraa and shaa which came out when, or called ?, or the degree of 腹黒 increased from TV with her are involved how ]

2006/05/23 Good [Original Japanese review]
by 美代子 Provider: 32756 Host:32766 Browser: 2850(Mobile)
Although it is the generation who looked at 1ST on real time, they are very skillful く纏められている and such a work.
kyara and others is perfectly drawn for a tale despite an end chip box here and there, and smelling carefully can evaluate the episode after shaa & sailor brothers and sisters' past, and father death especially a jion side (quite long one is worried).
Since it read to the previously published book by comics tea drinking, I think whether henceforth will be read without missing.

2006/05/22 Good [Original Japanese review]
by Kurashi Provider: 30383 Host:30173 Browser: 2876
It is thought whether this handicap karaizu became the model of "a new translation Z" in respect of being certain.
Even if it is the same kyara, the same mechanism, and the same tale, an impression changes this much by the difference in the way and viewpoint to draw.
the work (it is carrying out) which still proved what "a cancer dam is a cancer dam too" (Therefore, it was a Z cancer dam mist beam Z cancer dam) .
shaa sailor - outbreak-of-war section is drawn as a tale which results in the story of the origin version to the last -- having -- the relation by the television version -- taking into consideration -- てはい (existence of a cancer tank etc.) -- however, a back setup (a mass house, and sasuro, the history etc of MS development) which was not reflected in the television version was adopted as the maximum, and the deployment which fleshes out further and is very persuasive is shown If a fine portion is removed, so that the "past itself" of shaa which appeared in the television version, and a sailor can be interpreted.
If it is made the fan who was looking at the first on real time, can't years carry out skilled [ of it ] in an ideal form considerably, although the portion which was not told with the television version at last passed?
Moreover, the cancer dam ace who has the substantial reading made into kachiri also as only comic, and does not have this work is touch not to imagine just for a moment.

2006/03/23 Best! [Original Japanese review]
by Gunguniru Provider: 45196 Host:45303 Browser: 5978
although it is the midst currently collected now -- "-- this -- the starting point or あ [!!
] -- " -- it is filled with deep emotion amuro of dignity suitable to starting point 足る, shaa.
Daringly retrospective MS group.
The formal story by the original author which complements the past of the originator animation version.
Isn't there any じゃ which already zokuzoku only now!!
(smile)

2006/03/01 Very good [Original Japanese review]
by Zerao Provider: 15476 Host:15459 Browser: 5234
Although it is a work very wonderful to 1st fan, on the whole, it is somewhat hard to see somehow.
Especially battle depiction is unclear in whether does it gochagocha too much and to shine で何 8.
Since it is ordinarily interesting well if it is removed, it is at "it is very good."

2005/12/09 Very good [Original Japanese review]
by masuo Provider: 22318 Host:22126 Browser: 5234
There are many scenes about which the person is speaking unlike the animation version, and some stories which are different touch (especially gufu thinks that it became very smart) also differ from MS with the sufficient place which an inside understands well by the effect of a comics no one but until now again.
It does not become somehow that a book is 560 yen and it serves as it.

2005/09/29 Very good [Original Japanese review]
by 壺 Provider: 41856 Host:41682 Browser: 5234
since it is Yasuhiko's comics -- illustrating -- a level does not have a method of the stingy beginning a tear is drunk and very good [ which took charge the first cancer dam of kyaradeza ], since it cannot be called without-holding extolment even by MS's having appeared in part but the place to make without a complaint into the highest and deducting the omission of episode, such as 7s い点, salt, doan, a mulberry run, and miharu, since it is him and the comics on which the man who knows well draws a cancer dam so to speak -- I fail to be allowed to be alike now -- although the episode which looks back upon the past continues considerably long -- now -- me -- this point -- when expectation, simultaneously when what deployment can be encountered come, it is in the state where the uneasiness [ return / to the original talk (since the jab low finished, it is original 31 talk neighborhood kana ?) / it ] ?
is intermingled But it has a hope as Yasuhiko will cook there well.
But at least a feeling is a word to the last.
It is goggu truly.
ぜ which is not not at all although there is no 出ちゃい in an origin!

2005/07/04 Very good [Original Japanese review]
by ビグザムinソロモンの帝 Provider: 17461 Host:17343 Browser: 5234
Do you carry out comfort unlike [ again ] this editing, and does Misa have?
This editing and a bee can also enjoy くて that sense of incongruity does not have massage.
し [ the scene and origin original kyara with which amuro, the scenes, for example, three binary stars, which are not in this editing, meets also come out ].
It goes into outbreak-of-war section now, and the talk of better seed next time is pleasure.

2005/05/05 Best! [Original Japanese review]
by Katoru Provider: 16955 Host:16887 Browser: 6016
Monthly cover [ 洗練 ] The contents of + & Bold refinement of MS is evaluated.
The highest !
" It carries out.

2005/04/08 Comment(good) [Original Japanese review]
by スペ9 Provider: 19247 Host:19009 Browser: 5623
if it is called inquiry どころ -- "mulberry -- fatty tuna -- the name of - bajiina" -- from "the 4th name" -- it must have been kyasubaru rem daikunedoワu mass shaa azunaburu -- a red comet It is "a number does not suit" when it becomes.
まぁ and such a thing are trivial things, do you carry out comfort now and isn't it wrong that it is one of the comics wholly?

2005/04/08 Comment(good) [Original Japanese review]
by Guruguruneko Provider: 27495 Host:27230 Browser: 4356
& haro and himself also considered to Mr.
gt;>C.Q.
As an individual interpretation, haro currently sold is a mere toy, and although there is nothing, it thinks that did simple operation, however grown-up amuro convert it, and did incorporate the artificial intelligence (?)-thing, and it would build the present haro.
Although considered [ only following these comics and an original and ], I think that an original interpretation is also put in variously and it is becoming still more interesting.
The volume on shaa sailor is pleasure about what becomes.
Although kyara called shaaazunaburu came out in this month number, does it probably die?
It is [ what how to draw the neighborhood becomes and ] expectation.

2005/03/27 Comment(good) [Original Japanese review]
by C.Q. Provider: 3553 Host:3475 Browser: 5978
It is an inquiry to this month number.
haro って sure amuro -- work -- although it thought that it was haro MK-II out of which it came to Z that each one of a white base became a hero the bottom after the war [ んじゃなかったっけ ?
], and the toy company (various views baOdaO) made haro which had appeared with the photograph then -- Since it is Mr.
Yasuhiko's work, if it is reading and will wear with rainbow-colored Trotski occasionally, there is mind.

2005/02/28 Comment(good) [Original Japanese review]
by Katoru Provider: 16955 Host:16884 Browser: 5533
this month number was able to be enjoyed.
Chicken type of MS 01 "Formula Splendid." It went into めっちゃ気.
MS - New design which can equal ORIGIN version zakuII etc., brewing an atmosphere old somewhere since it is naturally more nearly outdated than 05 zaku I.
On the scene in which the test prototype which orudega 准尉 controls carries out an imitation battle with the replica of a MBT cancer tank, and an individual target "Volume shaa and on sailor The highest shiin っ su which can be set." "Blue giant star ranba - raru "Three black binary stars A leader's Gaia is also 邂逅."" It seems to be the acquaintance from ancient times.
One-week war Their activity with the role of - ruumu game is also expected.

Next / Post your review / Top page

ALERT: You cannot use open proxy or TOR for posting your review. If it is detected, your access to this site will be prohibited.

Rule for reviews

This site allows you to write reviews for each title, but we don't allow you to criticize others' comment. Too bad or meaningless words are also not allowed. The comment which doesn't follow the rule will be deleted. If you find any comment which doesn't follow the rule, please notify us by clicking Suggest to delete.

Example to be deleted frequently

Favorite side
You dislike this one, then don't see it or comment this title
- Please go to the fan site. Anyone has the right to say what they feel in this site.

Disliking side
Do you like this one? You are stupid.
- Your view is only your view. Please concentrate on only the content of the title, not on others' comment.

Please use only English. If not, the comment will be deleted.

Your Name(Required)

Password (Required. more than 4 characters)

Your comment about this anime(Required)

Your evaluation of this title(Required)
You can choose the evaluation only once. After you post your evaluation, please choose comment instead of evaluation from the options.

Evaluation of this title(You can choose this only once)

Best!!
Very good
Good
Normal
Bad
Very Bad
Worst

If you evaluated this title once, please choose comment instead of the evaluation.
Comment by the person who thinks this is good
Comment by the person who thinks this is normal
Comment by the person who thinks this is bad

Please choose appropriate option for readers.

Caution: Please post the evaluation which follows the rule.