Japanese works database(How to join/Help)
Top page: All/Only Reviews

Others
Site map


Search / Outside DB:

Comics ranking: Rank 4,117/in 4,185 titles (Total -23.92/Deviation 43.09) Rank 4,116 <= => Rank 4,118
Comics average points ranking: Rank 595/in 680 titles (Average -0.92(Bad)/Deviation 36.88) Rank 594 <= => Rank 596 (more than 10 evaluatoin)
Comics ranking of 2006: Rank 170/in 177 titles Rank 169 <= => Rank 171

New Star of Giants Hanagata(Comics)

[Other version: RSS/Japanese version]

All
Reviews(Post)

Forum

Images

Information about this title

Ikki KAJIWARA
Noboru Kawasaki
Weekly Boys Magazine
Koudansha

Released:2006/08/09 in Japan

Statics of evaluation(The statics is updated once a day)

	Average	ComicsRank	Deviation(Total)	Evaluation points(Total)	Best of the Best
Inside Japan	Bad(-0.92)	4,117	43.09	-23.92

Statics of activity

	Total Views	Comment	Evaluation
Inside Japan	14,031	37	26
Outside Japan	61	0	0

How others evaluated in Japan

Best

Very Good

Good

Normal

Bad

Very Bad

Worst

People

Percentage

3.8%

11.5%

23.1%

15.4%

19.2%

23.1%

Added percentage

3.8%

7.6%

19.1%

42.2%

57.6%

76.8%

100%

Summary

19.1%

23.1%

57.7%

Views for recent 8 days
Total 6 5 4 3 2 1 31 30
3 0 0 2 0 1 0 0 0

Language Sorted by date Sorted by recommendation
English Good
(Only Evaluation) Normal
(Only Evaluation) Bad
(Only Evaluation) All
(Only Evaluation) None
Japanese Good
(Only Evaluation) Normal
(Only Evaluation) Bad
(Only Evaluation) All
(Only Evaluation) None
This reputation board

Language	Sorted by date	Sorted by recommendation
English	Good (Only Evaluation)	Normal (Only Evaluation)	Bad (Only Evaluation)	All (Only Evaluation)	None
Japanese	Good (Only Evaluation)	Normal (Only Evaluation)	Bad (Only Evaluation)	All (Only Evaluation)	None

Post your review / Top page

The below reviews are translated automatically from Japanese ones. To post to English version, please click here.

2008/08/11 Comment(normal) [Original Japanese review]
by Keroggu Provider: 37996 Host:37991 Browser: 8593
well ...
making some the character white of the eye たり -- line attachment まくって force -- "-- incorrect -- an evil spirit ---izing -- " -- shining ..
[ like ] The deployment which raises 星飛雄馬 superfluously continues, and the past several weeks are read and gennari(ed).
In 菊月, it kept up appearances [ Shakespeare ] everywhere.
Disagreeable ?
It is also annoying that a metaphor enters.
since it is not the level which cannot be read for the time being -- private -- "-- although it is usually " ...
this -- surprising [ to original 知ってる people ] probably -- it could do .
Since I do not have 原作知 and others, although there are few portions attached to a nose.
but -- well ...
the same -- as the masterpiece remake of the past magazine "new abbreviation tomorrow's Joe" -- if it says and does not start not coming, although it will probably strike and will go out (smile)

2008/08/11 Very bad [Original Japanese review]
by Kaitsu Provider: 18003 Host:17862 Browser: 2058
depiction with the story (there are baseball and no pattern) and production violent [ the first direction ] which touch [ not good / as baseball comics ] carries out although it thinks that a picture is nice as it is -- きに -- although it became, there was no impression bad to there -- it is like / as long as it comes out and the latest talk is seen also by thinking that a setup of sushi and a character was also very much good (it flew away and there was also る部分) / tenipuri (kana which it is not to although it flew, it seemed to have been reduced to sport comics -- regrettable, since the vector correction from here is probably merely the impossible the direction which assumed a defiant attitude rather as it is, and aimed at tenipuri 越え may say (it is a joke --) There are also quite a few characters and depiction which aimed at the fan of some layers the back even if it was a joke.
Since the original of a giant's star does not have having seen, himself who thinks such a place is also unpleasant and is resembling tenipuri very bad, although it is severe, since it cannot think that へん about there only carries out becoming unrelated to evaluation, and becomes deployment very honest from here since nothing can be especially said about that -- it comes out and evaluates

2008/07/04 Very bad [Original Japanese review]
by goodday0220 Provider: 40360 Host:40264 Browser: 2462
Although it is the comics appropriate for the anazaa story of "the giant's star" which it will be in this work, since the image with a giant's star has collapsed, this work is not felt like seeing.
once -- about one volume -- saw -- a Yankee -- there is みたいな deployment and it does not eat on a its mind somehow For the time being, this work is not felt like [ "very bad" ] seeing somehow, and if it is the baseball comics of a magazine, touch sufficient by "A of a diagram" will carry out it.

2008/07/04 Normal [Original Japanese review]
by Fuerishidaa Provider: 8932 Host:8884 Browser: 8090
I think that they are the baseball comics of a normal very much.
although the necessity of being a giant's star is not felt at all -- if there is probably no title, nobody will notice that it is a giant's star -- it is the point of the remake of a giant's star is added to there -- as -- I cannot consider -- it carries out and is not related at all -- it was better to announce as another comics -- if --

2008/04/18 Good [Original Japanese review]
by Kyoota Provider: 19867 Host:19829 Browser: 6306
If it thinks that いちゃもん will be attached, I will think that it is the work which it has how much and which can be kicked.
(Thinness of shadows other than a leading role character, thinness of the contents of a baseball portion, etc.) However, the drama of human relations is hot!
There is deployment which cannot be predicted too much and I like it.
It was especially surprised at deployment per last of one part.
Since it is per four volumes, it is alike involuntarily in baseball comics, and I want you to read entirely to there.
Since the contents are fundamentally darker, we do not recommend you a person with weak saying so.

2008/04/17 Normal [Original Japanese review]
by 才也電卓 Provider: 4446 Host:4243 Browser: 5234
If it has not thought that it is extraordinarily interesting about especially this work, I will not have thought that it is boring.
Although it goes into the direction of the comics which can be once read in the serial comic strips of the present magazine ...
(it is ..
that it cannot read too much in many cases recently) Although it roared with laughter when made neta by the despair teacher.

2008/04/17 Worst [Original Japanese review]
by Namekujikinoko Provider: 52344 Host:52451 Browser: 8090
- Reappraise.

[a good point]
- nothing
[Bad point]
Before -, although the method of 仰っていた was in them when the baseball comics of "magazine were " enough only in A of a diagram, they think that they are right.
alone, this author that will not be obtrusive and push, だろ, and baseball which have licked baseball absolutely come out in large numbers, and are carried out as the star and star of a game whose structure is too sweet are obtrusive This "which cannot be pulling out the fun of baseball at all" thinks that it is the greatest demerit of a trash called a new abbreviation "giant's star" star.
- Recently, although there was almost nothing, the violence scene was able to be shown severely at the beginning of a start.
Saying so should cut down because it is not Yankee comics.
although this tale begins from the place where several punks are going to threaten gold of Mr.
婆, past [ aftertaste wrong ] and the comics which the start dash has not become so far have not been seen until now - It looks more dirtily because the uza い character which cannot be said that a picture is also nice is wandering about many persons.
- The treatment of a sub character or a supporting player has served as the setoff of main characters to very bad completeness.

[Comprehensive evaluation]
When saying well and saying bad [ the setoff of A of a diagram ], it just called it the burden on a magazine.
It is not the thing praised, even if it sees as baseball comics and sees as one work.
The trash located in a line with fairy teiru with the work under series from the present magazine for me.
The evaluation of those other than the worst cannot be considered.

2008/04/01 Worst [Original Japanese review]
by 絶 Provider: 30158 Host:30306 Browser: 4184
Well ...
When it states from a conclusion and obtains very, it is the remake of a giant's star.
って touch -- it is ...
For the time being, any persons other than main characters, such as a star and a star, are not conspicuous.
There is admiration to which the star and the star won the game alone.
Moreover, I feel that the interval to a game is too long.
By the time it goes into a game, it will have got tired of reading ...
It obtains and - and evaluation are the worst.

2008/03/16 Normal [Original Japanese review]
by ジャンボーグQ Provider: 19676 Host:19692 Browser: 8090

[A good point]
It saw and talks from a star side.
Although it will probably be natural, is the point which makes 飛雄馬 the greatest rival good?

[A bad point]
There is unreasonableness also in present age replacement た設定 just for a moment, and there is also too much confused fighting.....
(being unable to be a lie although it says, "a rich quarrel is not carried out" ?)
[Comprehensive evaluation]
Although there is also a field which can be enjoyed very well, is it impatient that a star cannot do as for inside 々野球?
.....
It is at a "normal."

2008/03/10 Good [Original Japanese review]
by LILY Review history[Good:2(100%) Normal:0(0%) Bad:0(0%)] / Provider: 14425 Host:14576 Browser: 6034
I did not think that it was criticized severely so far.
Although nothing can be said about the point since an old giant's star is not read, I think to a normal that it is interesting.
し [ it draws very powerful drawing ].

2008/03/08 Very good [Original Japanese review]
by Somebody Provider: 12377 Host:12491 Browser: 5717
The work I am allowed to read to pleasure every week at a normal although it is incomparable since an original giant's star is seldom known.
I think that there is especially no bad point so much as comics for which it competes in hot blood with the rival.
It was very likable to the hero and the star who strange 嫌味 does not have, either and cut 啖呵 to 星飛雄馬 individually, saying "I am genius." The driving-without-a-license っていう way of a large-sized motorbike had the good junior high school student to it rather than driving without a license of a sports car etc.
to come exactly.
well, it is called the fate of the work remade -- it is -- although it seems that there is also much severe criticism, it thinks that it is not necessary to remake at all if it is said that the talk together and a character are good, and I change touch of a character or think it good to arrange some talks I want you to surely continue for a long time as myself.
By the way, it is [ the Major Leagues ball, desperate special training of a star, or ] whether to come out supposing it meets the original ...
I do not want that to come out too ...
remarkable, in order to draw by the present sport comics -- unreasonable -- being certain -- と -- considering .

2008/02/07 Bad [Original Japanese review]
by Baakureo Provider: 11816 Host:11825 Browser: 6391
It arranges too much and it carries out first that it is incomprehensible in where is the remake of a giant's star.
Is it the greatest tsukkomi place?
is this work continued until stars and stars pro enter sure enough?
"serialized by the same weekly boy magazine -- good-bye -- despair teacher" was also made into neta of gag -- naturally -- と -- it will be natural if it says Are the contents itself "common" high-school baseball comics?
There is neither a good place nor a bad place.
Since the portion with the unknown meaning of a remake will surely be read too and will become て気, although it is usually what, evaluation must be dropped just for a moment.
It is the cause of not the author's cause but the magazine editorial department which started the plan of these comics completely.

2008/01/31 Normal [Original Japanese review]
by Purisuto Provider: 18003 Host:17762 Browser: 4671
although it was remade at first, and it passed and being come out and pulled, it can see comparatively recently However, it is going to make each character stand too much, and cannot be called baseball comics.
It seems that baseball becomes that a highlight is [ home run 打ったり飛雄馬 ] as giving up one shot たり for a star somehow or other alone now.

2007/12/31 Best! [Original Japanese review]
by 天野ジャック Provider: 12350 Host:12232 Browser: 5234
Since it thinks that it becomes quite unpleasant evaluation for the direction of anti, please give me perusal by accountability.
Didn't you think that it was honestly full of severe criticism so far?
Tendentiously [ the site of まぁこ ], a work like a star is by no means even here, although it thought that it was likely to become the suitable target criticized.
baiasu って on a network -- it felt that it was truly actually There is a point which surely is criticized.
Everythings, such as numerousness (I do not think many [ I / to there ]) of violence depiction, cannot be denied.
Probably, the まぁ hereabouts neighborhood will already be good.
However, there is also a point praised plentifully.
The star of the giant whom readers including burogu or such sites can discuss so far is the point which the view of the world which showed the different directivity, a deep setup, and this do not have complications, either, and should be praised.
Although the opinion "don't soil a giant's star" is also often seen, it does not seem to lead to it lowering evaluation of a giant's star, though a star is a trash.
Probably, there are not those who say [ "since a star is excrement, a giant's star is also excrement", and ] as there are not those who read only comics, without reading the original of batoroワ and say [ "since the comics version batoroワ is excrement, the original version batoroワ is also excrement", and ].
Moreover, although there are those who complain about the point that there is little efforts depiction, I have a feeling that efforts are what would be shown off to people last.
& which there are many those who are trying hard in the place which is not visible to people even when it is actual, and does not have efforts depiction (or few) and of which = efforts are not done; I think that a foolish thing concludes a talent supreme principle readily.
だろ in which holds people's 胸ぐ and others in my opinion, and its best is done with my ".
だろ which burns.
it is hot blood -- he has a feeling that ろ ?" and the work which is being made to say are more unnatural Although putting baseball comics on the two same magazines also had the opinion how it is, since two baseball comics are carried also in the champion, I have a feeling that the point is seldom a problem.
Be related as how compared with 種死.
first of all, making into a comparison theory other works and the work with which a genre is moreover different itself -- although it thinks how it is -- まぁ -- since [ with it appropriate for a boom ] -- once .
the place which looked at えーっ and evaluation of 種死 -- "-- as for it, in the case of a star, a kitchen is different, although Singh was a hero primarily and it seemed that kira was obtrusive and -」っていう opinion occupied The first title is a star.
Even if the star who is the hero who considered as the listing plays an active part, where is not wonderful?
Some are a certain thing in the first hero compensation etc.
also at a work of what.
Individually, the point was not worried at all.
Although it is evaluation of believer slippage, only the star of the ability of himself to have been enjoyed so far by baseball comics is the "highest" why.
it needs -- or [ all / whether it closes は楽 or he cannot be enjoyed ] I was able to enjoy myself in such meaning and think that it will be made this evaluation.

2007/12/30 Comment(normal) [Original Japanese review]
by 十傑集 Provider: 11009 Host:11078 Browser: 5234
the baseball part which the star entered should pass a welcome game -- the place which has coiled -- a tale -- a 飛雄馬 side -- shifting -- here -- an ordinary means -- it is -- kana さ -- that is right Since tsumaranai was thought with not taking out 飛雄馬, the deployment which draws these two heroes by turns is glad.
Although it is the same as the deployment which drew the drama of a rival and Moriyama by turns with the hero in the middle of "B.
B", the 惹きつける power like that work does not feel.
The author is still a newcomer.
Does 酷 expect the storyteller to there?

2007/11/29 Comment(good) [Original Japanese review]
by よっしー愛 Provider: 9168 Host:9171 Browser: 8090
With the viewpoint of junior high school student Calah Even if it calls it "a giant's star", there are a pin and those [ a lot of ] not coming.
Although it is probably, I think that it is not so severe.
The match heart from a man called 花形満, the heart in which its best is done again if it loses The highest says!
Since there are not excessive and a giant's 星じたい ends It can see by appropriate 目線.
Also future つずけていって -- it wants

2007/10/12 Comment(good) [Original Japanese review]
by Metako Provider: 39923 Host:39892 Browser: 3874
I like it.
the liver of these comics regarded as individual also regards drawing making an once masterpiece revive or highly complete baseball comics as it being in drawing the figure of two rivals (花形満 and 星飛雄馬) who there are not, are merely alike intently and fight aiming at the peak anything Although it considered "it to be [ oh, ] only a modern picture" when the first talk of a series was seen, when 飛雄馬 had come out, the は俄然 tension went up.
I think that it is good only by saying [ that the two rival story supporting the original "a giant's star" is drawn by new interpretation ].
Even so, I did not think that my Akiko elder sister became reader service charge.

2007/10/06 Comment(good) [Original Japanese review]
by 中1の目線 Provider: 26878 Host:27007 Browser: 8090
although I buy these comics and it is つずけているん, it is very easy to read these comics -- coming out -- peevish ...
although it is the worse one in graph -- me ---like -- these comics -- liking -- he buys it also from this and it is つずけて stylish たい

2007/09/21 Worst [Original Japanese review]
by Tamekichi Provider: 8072 Host:8157 Browser: 19200
it is uncanny - Only name.
it can call in "a new abbreviation giant's *", completely drawing another talk on entire another person -- say Expectation was betrayed although he liked that at absurd kyara which was carrying out star って driving without a license.

2007/08/21 Bad [Original Japanese review]
by 葉隠侍 Provider: 27679 Host:27547 Browser: 8097(Mobile)
Do you want to say as ?
whether it is the remake version of "a giant's star" to honto?
too much -- a gag face -- it sprouted, and there is much neta っぽい's and an original atmosphere is lost mostly It may be felt as the kana in which the cause [ that there were much shocking deployment of the quarrel with defects, a friend's traffic accident, etc.
and depiction ] or the scene of a game lacks in force for a while in the end of the volume on junior high school.
Although 星飛雄馬 and 伴宙太 appeared, it is anxious in whether kyara is broken down according to these comics.
It is -- which forgets the remake of "a giant's star", or a time will already be [ -- ] different and spread well and which may be able to read a few happily if unavoidable [ to become ] and it will read [ it is businesslike and ].

Next / Post your review / Top page

ALERT: You cannot use open proxy or TOR for posting your review. If it is detected, your access to this site will be prohibited.

Rule for reviews

This site allows you to write reviews for each title, but we don't allow you to criticize others' comment. Too bad or meaningless words are also not allowed. The comment which doesn't follow the rule will be deleted. If you find any comment which doesn't follow the rule, please notify us by clicking Suggest to delete.

Example to be deleted frequently

Favorite side
You dislike this one, then don't see it or comment this title
- Please go to the fan site. Anyone has the right to say what they feel in this site.

Disliking side
Do you like this one? You are stupid.
- Your view is only your view. Please concentrate on only the content of the title, not on others' comment.

Please use only English. If not, the comment will be deleted.

Your Name(Required)

Password (Required. more than 4 characters)

Your comment about this anime(Required)

Your evaluation of this title(Required)
You can choose the evaluation only once. After you post your evaluation, please choose comment instead of evaluation from the options.

Evaluation of this title(You can choose this only once)

Best!!
Very good
Good
Normal
Bad
Very Bad
Worst

If you evaluated this title once, please choose comment instead of the evaluation.
Comment by the person who thinks this is good
Comment by the person who thinks this is normal
Comment by the person who thinks this is bad

Please choose appropriate option for readers.

Caution: Please post the evaluation which follows the rule.