Japanese works database(How to join/Help)
Top page: All/Only Reviews

Others
Site map


Search / Outside DB:

Comics ranking: Rank 130/in 4,169 titles (Total 57.92/Deviation 61.67) Rank 129 <= => Rank 131
Comics average points ranking: Rank 40/in 673 titles (Average 2.12(Very good)/Deviation 62.30) Rank 39 <= => Rank 41 (more than 10 evaluatoin)
Comics ranking of 1997: Rank 5/in 58 titles Rank 4 <= => Rank 6

Q.E.D. Shomei Shuryo(Comics)

[Other version: RSS/Japanese version]

All
Reviews(Post)

Forum

Images

Information about this title

Koudansha
Monthly Boys Magazine Zoukan GREAT

Released:1997/07 in Japan

Statics of evaluation(The statics is updated once a day)

	Average	ComicsRank	Deviation(Total)	Evaluation points(Total)	Best of the Best
Inside Japan	Very good(2.12)	130	61.67	57.92	2

Statics of activity

	Total Views	Comment	Evaluation
Inside Japan	5,468	16	16
Outside Japan	100	0	0

How others evaluated in Japan

Best

Very Good

Good

Normal

Bad

Very Bad

Worst

People

Percentage

43.8%

50.0%

0.0%

6.2%

Added percentage

43.8%

93.8%

93.8%

100%

Summary

93.8%

6.2%

Views for recent 8 days
Total 21 20 19 18 17 16 15 14
8 1 1 1 1 2 2 0 0

Language Sorted by date Sorted by recommendation New!
English Good
(Only Evaluation) Normal
(Only Evaluation) Bad
(Only Evaluation) All
(Only Evaluation) None
Japanese Good
(Only Evaluation) Normal
(Only Evaluation) Bad
(Only Evaluation) All
(Only Evaluation) All
This reputation board

Language	Sorted by date	Sorted by recommendation New!
English	Good (Only Evaluation)	Normal (Only Evaluation)	Bad (Only Evaluation)	All (Only Evaluation)	None
Japanese	Good (Only Evaluation)	Normal (Only Evaluation)	Bad (Only Evaluation)	All (Only Evaluation)	All

Post your review / Top page

The below reviews are translated automatically from Japanese ones. To post to English version, please click here.

2008/05/03 Very good [Original Japanese review]
by Kuzumi Provider: 2630 Host:2741 Browser: 2265
For a picture, the maximum charm with which it is seldom related to evaluation how it is is [ how and a character ] the fun of a story (an incident and inference) as comics.
The originality which specialized in the inference monochrome which became chronic in noted detective Conan, Kindaichi --, etc.
is felt.
The subject matter chosen was also fresh, and there was no 寝れ until there is the moment of becoming it tense in the talk, and did not go "next time" in the middle of an incident, but 1 talk solution was [ however ] uncanny, a feeling was good and it finished reading.
-- It is good mystery novel みたい.
I think that it is Ryosaku clearly.
However, compared with desunooto or Kindaichi, the picture thought that an ordinary woman probably did not take out a hand from the first impression by boy ぽい's.
Just that to which a hand comes also out of a woman thinks that it carries out good evaluation with it being general.
(if it says which it is) It is regrettable that this is in a minor position.

2008/04/20 Very good [Original Japanese review]
by u3u1 Provider: 6926 Host:6831 Browser: 11694
A few inference comics in which theory is solid inside with much absurd inference comics ....
Are they disagreeableness and the only inference comics?
し [ for the moment, ton demonstration theory does not come out in comics ].
reason じゃあ to which he also knows all inference comics -- natural -- it is -- it is -- although -- there is self-confidence of liking and reading inference comics in the favorite field more than ordinary Invigoration to the way the simple trick which is not almost and which is not felt draws gaiety, and the hero draws solution mostly, therefore intelligibly!
Or [ that it is better than the inference comics in which a picture excels poor and which put power into skill of drawing from a skillful くて story although the place which the author's skill of drawing cannot tell a compliment easily is high in a comics house, either is also regrettable ].
In this case, it is whether it is the style with which the thing was made to tell skill of drawing, and the direction of a line simpleer than a gochagocha 描く comics house suited inference comics of a trick also by intelligible って点.
It has not exceeded まぁ skill of drawing to have been.

2008/03/23 Worst [Original Japanese review]
by Guranzon Provider: 8953 Host:8844 Browser: 4926
It is boring.
If knowledge is abundant and it is genius's human being, he intend [ natural ] じゃん [ to solve in a mystery etc.
and ].
It is the MIT graduation at the age of 15.
"Conan" is caused new 1 and Tati is a bad setup.
Are a partner's Suibara 可奈 sport omnipotent and Dutch みたい of "Conan"?
It is almost related みたい of Shin-ichi of "Conan", and 蘭.
It bakabaka more than "Conan" and hakkiri 言って and a character setup are さ.
Although 1 of "Kindaichi" is the genius of IQ180, portions other than inference (study) are useless, and do not almost have special knowledge, either.
A certain semantic じゃ balance is maintained.
"Conan" is new -- although it is genius with special knowledge abundant [ 1 ] -- a poor university and the part which has not come out -- it is still good し [ it may not たまにゃ知 be ].
being such -- if it reads and time is wasted, is the direction which still read "Conan" mashi?

2008/02/05 Best! [Original Japanese review]
by engage Provider: 26490 Host:26715 Browser: 6520
the young gifted mathematician who graduated from Outline MIT (Massachusetts Institute of Technology) at the age of 15, and entered the high school in Japan and who was otherworldly just for a moment, and 燈馬 A vicious horse woman quantity student good-natured at 想 (うま so), the brightness of there omission, and the owner of transcendence athletic ability, and Suibara Formal inference comics in which two persons of 可奈 (not seeing は s kana) solve various incidents in the theft foods now of a cake from the murder case.
[Good point] Readability developed with 1 short story work only Although there is that if it is been lazy and is hard to read as one of the reasons inference comics are 倦厭(ed) by some readers, the hint having been coiled, having passed and checking get tired The short story around 100 pages has pierced through a style called two talks exactly to one volume, and these comics are easy to read it as inference comics overwhelmingly.
2 Clean production Although the showy production of those other than pure inference elements, such as a love element and an appearance of an organization of evil like a human drama and adventure comics, is liked in order that ordinary inference comics may compensate the difficulty of reading, since these comics can be made easy to read as above-mentioned, superfluous production was not made but the indifferent production which is easy to enjoy an inference element purely rather has been adopted at このん.
Although various themes have twined mathematics, the subject of other learning, etc.
around an incident, since it is used in order to make the whole incident image intelligible, it is the production which raises the ease of reading rather.
3 deployment which was compatible in an idea and precision mass-producing the interesting incident which had it in the short page with the idea which pulls a reader's interest in accordance with two of the precision of the logic deployment at the time of solving as an incident is being continued -- even if series ten years pass, I think it uncanny to continue maintaining the stable (for it not to be the early stages of a series -- be alike and carry out) result Moreover, incidents other than a murder case and the thing which cannot get bored with them easily since one talk is treated to two talks are one of the charm.
[Bad point] 1 picture is modest.
Although it is legible and is not independently poor, it is a quite simple picture.
2 Lowness of notability There is also a thing with a quite minor printing magazine, and notability is low considering evaluation.
[Comprehensive evaluation] Although 画力 is a degree in the middle, preeminence and the deer of a story are [ an idea or composition ] also readable.
It is not an overstatement even if it calls it the monumental work of inference comics.

2008/01/11 Best! [Original Japanese review]
by Autsuo Provider: 2688 Host:2560 Browser: 5232
In inference comics, I think that it is work -- which is proud of the extremely excellent quality.
In the inside which I have read at least until now (smile) Whatever it may say, it is large that the talk is completed in one talk.
An incident is not prolonged vainly, but it is not coarse, and introduction development turn and conclusion are solid.
"Proof" of 燈馬想 is preeminent for impressiveness.
Possible phenomena are crushed one by one and room to pinch a mouth here is not given.
It is the wonderfulness admired involuntarily.
I want to recommend to prominent inference comics with many mere child's play tricks very much in the direction of sorrow.
Although notability is low, I think that sure ていて can also be enough enjoyed to a detective story.

2007/09/27 Very good [Original Japanese review]
by Erumoa Provider: 49041 Host:49014 Browser: 4611
"Formal" inference comics just a little bit different from other inference comics.
Since other people have already written, what should be written is comment ordinarily here.
Although I am story serious consideration fundamentally, a story and logic are solid and these comics can be osusume(ed) in anyone.
Especially an early work has much talk which can be made to cry, and a pattern is drawn in the characters who show an expression simply rich nevertheless.
It is also careless enough to summarize the epilogue after inference (proof) well, though it is short, and to have shed tears at the last of "the star map which faded." (Even so, 可奈 is a stylish child thoroughly) Is it it a demerit mark that it is merely as that there is too little writing たり [ and ] just for a moment?
[ that the latest work has an incomprehensible trick ] Individually, even about ten volumes are osusume.
Pattern [ -- 7 (it is 9 the first stage - the middle) synthesis evaluations / -- 8 (evaluation is ten stages) ] -- Five stories -- Seven (it is 10 the first stage - the middle) character "Good" synthesis of the evaluation is carried out recently which "is very good" the first stage the "highest" and the middle, and it is "very good."

2006/11/29 Very good [Original Japanese review]
by SOUTA Provider: 13852 Host:14147 Browser: 6342
Although challenge " to "intellect, "intellectual entertainment ", etc.
are 々 and the influence sentence of the belt which can be regarded also as exaggerated, I regard them as their being the high comics of only the quality corresponding to it.
A hero is the genius and 燈馬想 which graduated from MIT a little at the age of 15, and the Suibara 可奈 with the athletic ability which it was full of curiosity and stood high.
It is the appearance to which the mystery is explained by logical logic [ highlight / of 本作 / 燈馬 / not a character but ] deployment although ...
to which two persons challenge these various incidents is the flow of the fundamental talk.
...
Although it can take even if it is simple and is not showy, if the reverse side is returned, this is because emphasis is put on the fun as a mystery rather than the fun as comics, and although it is not gay, "formal " of a reason is tasted.
し [ the rate in the part of 謎解き is also farther / than other mystery comics / large ].
Moreover, it is a brilliant word that only murder cases do not arise like each time, but the trifling trouble in that by which the special knowledge of a 理 system is treated, or a school etc.
is going across the genre of an incident variably, and all are materialized as a good mystery.
I feel that the fixed idea of "not becoming interesting if mystery comics have no murder case" was reversed.
...
I am "the mirror of a rainbow" especially whose favorite talk is the "inside" where the past of 燈馬 is revealed and sequel of a witch's hand, saying that the charm of a character is not the highlight of 本作 (smile).
It was the first episode on which the human drama which coils round 燈馬 was drawn, and the figure to which he agonizes and is in trouble was very impressive, and interesting.
..." which had big influence on 燈馬 individually -- I want you to re-appear in that man " someday After 燈馬 indicates it as "Q.E.D.", it may also be interesting to infer an incident personally, without reading immediately and advancing.
Although .....
but he are not likely to be "inference " (smile).
"Inference.
It is different.
It is not such an ambiguous thing that I talk from now on.
It is the fact" which happened here.

2006/10/25 Very good [Original Japanese review]
by Iii Provider: 6047 Host:5914 Browser: 3875
As inference comics, he likes better than Kindaichi.
I think that differences are overall quite interesting comics although it is according to the talk.
Are 2 talk conclusion れてるって's good just first at one volume?
A continuation is not worrisome in a good meaning.
They are the contents by which admiration is carried out to it being as that a high quality trick and the latest mathematics can be incorporated in the talk たり each time.
the most favorite talk -- "the inside of a witch's hand" -- the story was considerably elaborate because a long piece Is Mr.
Kato genius?

2006/09/26 Very good [Original Japanese review]
by mizunasi Provider: 31396 Host:31651 Browser: 4665
It has been late completely.
the necessities of it being completely pointed out to you and writing anew the attractive portion which thought having written, such as stoicalness pulled on a full-scale inference play and fresh fun of mathematical 〓t〓 have been lost irrespective of dramatic elements, such as easy readability of one-volume 2 talk printing and a 1 talk conclusion, a dreary homicide scene, and a dramatic crime motive, (でも -- it writes) Since it has rushed into the Sazae-San space-time, although it is somewhat regrettable that neither 燈馬 nor growth of my 可奈 is drawn (probably), I continue wanting you to pursue the fun inferred as a mystery from now on.

2006/09/16 Best! [Original Japanese review]
by Norumato Provider: 12713 Host:12795 Browser: 7461
It is the highest peak of inference comics rightly.
Is it good that it is not a reason only treating murder cases, either?
って from which people die -- so much -- coming out -- fairly -- information -- it will be able to hide -- 人死 -- a bitter inference which is not also gets and it makes very well -- would not it be difficult?
subject mathematical as the body of 理系 also comes out well -- a point -- it is high

2006/08/17 Very good [Original Japanese review]
by 美代子 Provider: 32756 Host:32773 Browser: 2850(Mobile)
Was the title heard first at the time of Kodansha Manga Award?
Although he forgot whether it was able to take or not (oi), it remembered somehow, and evaluation of you, other controversialists here, was seen, in addition, interest boiled, and the title was read in network cafe.
Comment ....
It is interesting!!
It is 巧く conclusion てある that it is stored in one volume in about 2 talks, and the talk of the United States which was one only one talk does not have dare る事, either.
Although a sequel is carried several volumes after, perfectly, the line passes also along this in the story or the inside story, and it has not failed in them.
Although characters are also individual and the head of 想 is good, it maintains 巧い balance that it is the も emotional & reality group to whom 可奈悪戦苦闘s on a somewhere world gap and its side with incomprehensible expression.
a magazine which carries the article cannot look for the only difficulty easily (bitter smile) If まぁ and it also pierce through a comic group, it will be satisfactory in any way.
He buys this and it is kana.

2006/08/12 Best! [Original Japanese review]
by Teihoshi Provider: 42456 Host:42293 Browser: 7325
The place which is not the inference comics of the type that a murder case almost surely arises at the point for which the hero went out like the inference comics which often exist thinks that it is very good.
(People still die about once in 2 times) Since a hero's 想 has graduated from Massachusetts Institute of Technology by grade-skipping, although many mathematical technical terms come out, since it explains in detail in the form where the genius of 想 or others explains to 可奈 since the heroine's 可奈 is the so-called man in the street, a reader can also understand an outline perfectly.
Furthermore, although I am comic and being read, since comics like a weekly series forget the contents of a front volume and may reread a front volume once again when the contents of the talk read a new volume ranging over a volume mostly, it is very appreciated that it is 1 talk conclusion.
Even if it calls it 1 talk conclusion, it never becomes the thin thing of the contents, but since all rather excessive things are excluded, it is the deep thing of the contents conversely.

2006/06/15 Very good [Original Japanese review]
by Fake Provider: 37856 Host:37921 Browser: 7321
As boys' comics of inference monochrome, it is quite the ii result.
Is it farther [ than Conan or Kindaichi ] interesting at least?
Since an excessive human drama is deleted and the mystery element is thought as important, "authenticity" is read with a novel and he can be enjoyed also by る人間.
Inference of 燈馬 is also very logical.
As kyara comics ...
To be sure, it is weak.
There are ま and a relation still beta in 燈馬 and 可奈.
Isn't there Koto who cannot enjoy himself with such a viewpoint, either?

2006/03/05 Best! [Original Japanese review]
by JOY Provider: 20030 Host:19839 Browser: 4928
sugee [!!
] be fastidious -- if it reads -- Conan -- it can read -- ね-よ maji [!!
] authenticity -- authenticity I think that the author's knowledge is also considerable mon.
Although it gets tired with the technical term of mathematics or science major, し [ at least 〓t〓is / but / interesting ].
"gifted" kyara って comics じゃ mere-child's-play っぽく vanity るけど and these comics -- such a thing -- all 然 could not be found It was made to think that 燈馬 is genius truly.

2005/12/30 Best! [Original Japanese review]
by Orutanateivu Provider: 32756 Host:32743 Browser: 2771(Mobile)
They are the comics which can also enjoy knowledge only with mathematical like the cause-books of noted detective Conan or the Kindaichi boy only guessing neither a trick nor a criminal.
Does the conversation of characters make Mr.
Hirotsugu Mori's work regard as somewhere?
し [ it is just like that of "those two persons" in the pair of So and my 可奈 etc.
].
Is it solving by the volume, without an incident continuing [ delightful one ] even to the following book by taking to a reader most?
Therefore, stress is not felt, either.
Although it thinks that the charm as a character thing is somewhat thin, the direction to taste formal さ like a detective story is recommendation.
Does the direction of 理系 suit?

2005/12/16 Best! [Original Japanese review]
by Ofuu Provider: 6495 Host:6100 Browser: 5234
A hero's 燈馬想 is the super-genius who graduated from MIT (Massachusetts Institute of Technology) a little at the age of 15, and reentry study is carried out to the high school in Japan now.
Although it has abundant knowledge to things, there is a tendency to see things too much logically, it is weak to touch people's feeling with people unacquainted, and eccentric person treatment also of the class is carried out.
Although it is unconscious, it is going to choose, recognize and protect an important thing for itself.
It is pulled about by emotional 可奈 in response to influence.
The heroine's Suibara 可奈 is full of the sense of justice which cannot overlook drive preeminent sport omnipotent and those who are in trouble.
Meddlesome baking which applies 燈馬 of eccentric person treatment to mind in a class.
The role which moves the bodies, such as information investigation and information, 燈馬 is asked, and it is managed faultlessly.
The inference comics in which two persons of this opposite character play an active part are this Q.E.D.
proof end.
Q.
It is the initial of Latin meaning the end of proof with E.D., and it will be called solution section, if this language comes out, since it is shown by 燈馬 when the mystery of an incident is able to be solved.
The tale serves as structure which excluded the unnecessary portion which can be called drama so to speak as much as possible, while being the orthodox school which can taste the pleasure of inference simply, it does not adhere to a murder case but the story which used the everyday little occurrence etc.
as the motif can also fully be enjoyed.
Without being carried over by the following volume, waiting for solution section or forgetting the contents of a front volume in it, in order that the talk may finish as each volume just, it is wonderful that stress is unbearable, it is handy, and can finish reading one talk at the unoccupied time.
[ of the length of the talk of each talk ] Moreover, since it can consider even if the person who appears in an incident is fearful when he does a meaningful face, how to write expression is very wonderful.
(Since it is the type which takes out a feeling to a table, 可奈 is pleasant if expression is seen.) It is the touch which is reading the short story detective story by comics, and the contents are quite full-scale inference comics.
Although he likes the detective story, inference comics are recommendation at those who say unsatisfactorily.

Post your review / Top page

ALERT: You cannot use open proxy or TOR for posting your review. If it is detected, your access to this site will be prohibited.

Rule for reviews

This site allows you to write reviews for each title, but we don't allow you to criticize others' comment. Too bad or meaningless words are also not allowed. The comment which doesn't follow the rule will be deleted. If you find any comment which doesn't follow the rule, please notify us by clicking Suggest to delete.

Example to be deleted frequently

Favorite side
You dislike this one, then don't see it or comment this title
- Please go to the fan site. Anyone has the right to say what they feel in this site.

Disliking side
Do you like this one? You are stupid.
- Your view is only your view. Please concentrate on only the content of the title, not on others' comment.

Please use only English. If not, the comment will be deleted.

Your Name(Required)

Password (Required. more than 4 characters)

Your comment about this anime(Required)

Your evaluation of this title(Required)
You can choose the evaluation only once. After you post your evaluation, please choose comment instead of evaluation from the options.

Evaluation of this title(You can choose this only once)

Best!!
Very good
Good
Normal
Bad
Very Bad
Worst

If you evaluated this title once, please choose comment instead of the evaluation.
Comment by the person who thinks this is good
Comment by the person who thinks this is normal
Comment by the person who thinks this is bad

Please choose appropriate option for readers.

Caution: Please post the evaluation which follows the rule.