DB Top > Works > Comics >

[Comics]SCRAP SANDAYUH

[Other version: RSS/Japanese version]
If this is not the work which you are looking for, please use above search box or various list or DB's top page.

Reviews' statics

Comics total pnts rank=Avg. x Eval. num	Rank 4,666/in 4,775 titles (Total -21.00)	Rank 4,665 <= => Rank 4,667
Comics avg pnts rank(minimum:10 evals)	Rank 849/in 896 titles (Average -1.75(Very bad))	Rank 848 <= => Rank 850
Comics total pnts rank of 1989	Rank 62/in 63 titles	Rank 61 <= => Rank 63

All
Reviews(Post)

Fan forum

Image&Wallpaper

Information about this title

Yudetamago
Weekly Boys Jump
SHUEISHA

Japan Released:1989 / End:1989

Statics of evaluation(The statics is updated once a day)

	Average	ComicsRank	Deviation(Total)	Evaluation points(Total)	Best of the Best
Inside Japan	Very bad(-1.75)	4,666	42.70	-21.00

Statics of activity

	Total Views	Comment	Evaluation
Inside Japan	4,300	13	12
Outside Japan	347	0	0

How others evaluated in Japan

Best

Very Good

Good

Normal

Bad

Very Bad

Worst

People

Percentage

0.0%

8.3%

16.7%

8.3%

50.0%

Added percentage

8.3%

25%

41.7%

50%

100%

Summary

8.3%

16.7%

75%

Views for recent 8 days
Total 21 20 19 18 17 16 15 14
1 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0

Forum for the special topic (Create topic)

Sorted by:Newness / Oldness
All including comments
Only Evaluation Good
Evaluation:Best/Very Good/Good Normal
Evaluation Bad
Evaluation:Bad/Very Bad/Worst
This reputation board

The below reviews are translated automatically from Japanese ones. To post your review to English version, please click here.

2009/12/12 Worst [Original Japanese review]
by たつ一郎 (Send message) Provider: 53649 Host:53587 Browser: 15418
I'm sorry.
It boils and it is clear that this is the most are work with a work.

[Good point]
It obtains and is with -....
Or [ that what should be mentioned ]
[Bad point]
Had much lower neta depiction first.
Why does a robot use work in a xxx machine gun etc.?
It does not すいま.
In this, it did not become precocious conviction stylish anyhow.
and the place by which a route change was made to the battle thing again -- abrupt -- it is -- or [ having done again what was considered also by the ゆうれい boy ] And there was no last uoozuman.
I'm sorry [
[evaluation / comprehensive]
].
He became feeling that it was reading and many things could not be said not at all, and sometimes got angry just for a moment.
Even if it did the battle thing with the subsequent lion heart and a subsequent total fighter, there was completely admiration with which OK passed over this and the ゆうれい boy with the birthmark, and the route change to a battle thing was spoiled.
I boil for the time being and think that it is the most are work with a work.

2009/05/14 Worst [Original Japanese review]
by 消しゴム (Send message) Provider: 15738 Host:15557 Browser: 5600
A rehash of the kin meat man before the volume on superman Olympic Games.
If this work is said at a word, it will become like this.
When the pair of the judo expert who became a ghost and did the possession to the police robot house steward of the minimum rank and the bucket of a head became the pinch by fighting with the robot which committed the crime, they were the contents which judogi jumps out of the bucket of the head and say an enemy as 蹴散らす in judo work.
It was quite obvious that the number of the author's drawers had not changed to the condition said that the pair of the judo expert [ house steward and judo expert ] of the leading role is just like that of a "kin meat man" before it resembles well the kin meat man denounced as the useless superman in the relation of a meat and deployment of the talk and a house steward's also fighting change to a battle route from that time describing the "kin meat man." For the reason, it can be said that the appearance of uoozuman is the result of the shortage of study of the author inviting.

2009/04/20 Worst [Original Japanese review]
by KAMIKAZE (Send message) Provider: 1957 Host:1629 Browser: 6652
It is looking truly and is only the work with which feeling becomes bad.
The ring was further applied to the ゆうれい boy and it was a severe work.
A robot with a hero's strange bucket head.
It is past [ dasa ].
Probably, in the xxx machine gun of the mortal work of this, a xxx bazooka (they are a hiragana or the katakana of three characters to x) will be the worst also at lower neta.
He does not feel inclined to laugh.
I thought that there was probably no mind that the original author draws comics seriously, to moreover having made a kin meat man's character appear in an end in the end in the worst form in the way of the last.
I can consider, as comics were probably only drawn by omission.
Although it seems that muetai comics strange otherwise were also drawn, the original author of this was what can consider as the hand is only extracted clearly.
the jump of those other than the first work -- three evils -- even if a trash is closed -- naturally -- と -- it was only the severe work which can be considered Does ability have only a kin meat man as for this author?
Or [ that it is better to retire ] ...

2009/01/14 Normal [Original Japanese review]
by ジャンボーグQ (Send message) Provider: 25881 Host:26185 Browser: 8455

[A good point]
no, a "kin meat man" -- the same -- It was a start from the useless robot of the lump of an inferiority complex at first.
It was fairly interesting to have had judogi on and to have changed strongly.

[A bad point]
The Michael jakusonmodoki thinks a disagreeable fellow by the rival, and becomes a good fellow in the middle of きや.
Are they a kore って mailbox and teriiman っす well?
て and uoozuman 出すなよ!

[Comprehensive evaluation]
obtaining -- ~ ん ....
the kana which can be allowed if it is a short story (Although it is the mere close sweat) "Normal"

2007/08/15 Worst [Original Japanese review]
by 武信君 (Send message) Provider: 24056 Host:23939 Browser: 8090
If a kin meat man is a work "with some which remain in the heart hotly", this work will have a way of speaking only with the work "dust does not remain, either" correctly.
When it said, or the kin meat man was drawn and it is going to serialize such halfway gag, there is no deer way of speaking that it was a defeat game.
it was able to be thought of only as the insult of truly as opposed to [ carry out, furthermore ] not only uoozuman but a kin meat man's fan in that treatment which the ugliness which dragged the glory of this to the past although it did not know whether it would be shocking somehow that, especially as for uoozuman of the final stage, the close was decided [ you ] by 仰って cage ます oozes, is looking, and was very much offended and there was no activity which was not much conspicuous in this editing -- this work -- an insult -- receiving -- "-- when kin meat man 2nd" is also regarded as whether it will be made half-murder after this at helmet in pakushonzu, uoozuman is unavoidable at 可〓hi〓

2006/06/05 Worst [Original Japanese review]
by 十傑集 (Send message) Provider: 11009 Host:11078 Browser: 5234
へっぽこ kyara would return the author from reflection of stray of "the ゆうれい boy came" to the battle thing which becomes strong gradually -- he has the feeling -- however, for the first time in [ of the author / yakekuso ] should ask honto about -- uoozuman which will be rounded off with the punch line which anything does not have as for impression that 本作 was the after story of a "kin meat man" before a work got off the ground, since it would be a kin meat man's mere imitation, if the reverse side is returned -- ますな As for evaluation, it is the "worst" on a minus point that also had much removed lower netagyagu.

2006/06/05 Comment(bad) [Original Japanese review]
by 宇宙刑事ジャンギャバン (Send message) Provider: 33223 Host:33285 Browser: 4314
truly -- the appearance of uoozuman -- doing -- passing -- it is .
And it is 取っちゃってます from a house steward about the role which pushes down the can head (a time is felt) which became the last enemy.
Even if attached to it, if you, a coworker, are the supermen from whom he protected the earth once, with what don't you notice?
A figure form is having not changed.

2006/05/26 Very bad [Original Japanese review]
by 634 (Send message) Provider: 20897 Host:20886 Browser: 5234
After all, it boils and works of an egg other than a "kin meat man" are useless!
Useless!
The contents which said useless !
with a background are ぶっちゃ beam impressions.
It seemed that failure was symbolized also by muetai in the judo + robot of 本作 or failure, and the back by 本作's being a supernatural creature thing and going wrong.
robo of 本作 was the robot of an image like 介 of the "こち亀" throat anger flame which used the bucket as the head, and although it was doing things as consuming and memorizing the paper used with the gag of old taking an examination, it had the empty image already called "what and it ?" from that time.
When 本作 starts, it is a work in case Heisei, such gag of the Showa 40s, etc.
are already forgotten away, and it cannot have received.
Although neither the author's drawing lack of ability nor a house steward's character had れ of imaichi although the place which a mechanism's design calls retrospective was also one of the tastes, and phantom こぞう-neta was taken in to judo neta at an upgrade like a kin meat man, it will idle with the author's skill and be cold, and it may be what may be called pakuri and the impression near it of the "cancer dam SEED" said in now.
and it will be that 本作 finished without the good impression after all, and the complaint came [ たり / taking out uoozuman finally ] by pakuri of the robot of a certain Toho special-effects movie in the villain's part from beginning to end since it progressed in such an image -- it carried out (the Sato positive of "the elder brother who burns" did the same thing, and anger of a movie fan was incurred), and a kin meat man's reincarnation たり得る事 etc.
was not made a next work -- a large -- koke(ing) -- after all -- the author -- from a jump -- separating -- another work -- drawing -- after that -- again -- a kin meat man -- a hand -- dyeing -- a previous work -- because disappointment and anger are incurred from a fan, it has become since the image of the author's hit was too strong -- 本作 -- again -- such -- great -- (?) -- it can be said that it is clear to have imitated introductory notes called the image, therefore the work which was not able to shine of a masterpiece And the author and Shueisha do not yet continue not taking out an answer to a reader to it.

2005/06/01 Bad [Original Japanese review]
by 羽幌炭鉱 (Send message) Provider: 10445 Host:10448 Browser: 4487
Although he was able to be enjoyed at the complete time as it is, there was an impression which has not been unsatisfactorily overcome somewhere after going into a series.
Although it was able to enjoy so so that the enemy robot which the rival of the teacher of the judo of sui Hearn, the enemy of the beginning of a series, or a house steward made fought, it has burst unsatisfactorily whether it says very and is shallow.
Honestly the machine gun of that excrement was pulled.
If it is only it, it is having made it think at any rate that it was in that cyborg superman that came out lastly.
This will be the run although the foolish attempt of having made that of a perfect superman give a guest performance occurred when it transferred to another magazine.
The thing which use the past inheritance in such forms and which was regarded with it being unsightly as there being nothing with what times --

2005/04/08 Normal [Original Japanese review]
by Nanatsuman (Send message) Provider: 16430 Host:16503 Browser: 3875
Why or uoozuman carries out a guest performance in the direction of the last of these comics, and it is a better seed.
Although a setup completely differs from uoozuman out of which a setup has come to the present kin meat man II world ...

2005/04/08 Good [Original Japanese review]
by Raito (Send message) Provider: 3618 Host:3441 Browser: 3646
おお -- !
This work had also come out!
-- uoozuman which has not been read specially the contents only by --, however itself knowing this work to a site with a network It u.
two talks of the last which achieved the friendship performance -- "闘将 -- since it boiled and was contained in egg", although it cooks better [ reading ] -- uoozuman -- what -- being such -- being also alike -- if pitiable treatment is not received, isn't there any なら?
the comics grade which made the mistake in appearing on having been blessed neither with an opportunity for this editing also carrying out 殆んど activity nor a highlight specially could appear by setup treated favorably -- if -- after all --??
uoozuman Also after that, it is tormented alone, without relations becoming as good as house stewards, without the ability meeting [ men / kin meat ] again with 2 times in that world, and is whether a lifetime will be finished lonesomely one person.
-- It will become.
-- Although it also regards attaching evaluation to having read only last 2 talk as how it is It is the appearance which is the work closed at any rate for a short period of time.
Since it thinks that great trouble cannot be found, it attaches [ make / have you / it / Exempt Mr.
uoozuman!
Possibly it was made the "worst" when he had not come out -- ].
-- It is although it is the place "worsened very much" if true.
-- It is made "good" here!

2005/04/08 Worst [Original Japanese review]
by 破壊大帝 (Send message) Provider: 8533 Host:8564 Browser: 4184
Supernatural creature [ -- It boils.
How is the egg's work hard to be called high level which will differ from a superman (sweat) except the kin meat man of a masterpiece ....
] -- Robot policeman -- muetai fighter Did the robot use a real judo expert's name in part?
Michael -- although kyara used as a complicated mental state was also when seen now (Since the house steward was born by that talk and appearance in the work and depiction which passed was done suddenly several years, it was surprised) Although kin 消し's present plan of the eraser doll (molding is the complete version conformity) of a loach aim of the second animal etc.
was done, it is the close after all.
for running fire of lower neta, it pulled anyhow -- the large explosion by -- dropbehind robots' examination みたいな話 etc.
-- especially .
However, even now, the last round which makes it the highlight (?) of this work of No.
1, and has been a tradition is impressive.
Since that uoozuman changed the battle man and the name and was ruined to a drunk's robot policeman anyway.
Although the leading role's house steward was left, the enemy robot was 撃破(ed) and the pause was decided last, it has been transmitted, so that for the first time in [ of the authors / yakekuso ] is painful (bitter smile).
Even so, did you never (moreover, also often and bad, observed from WJ successive generation close comics) think that the "kin meat man II world" to which boiled, egg both also made it become familiar with, and 嚆矢 of second popular comics monochrome was released was announced?
Although evaluation is severer, it cannot be laughed for gag, but it will be taken as the "worst" from the point using the serious も白 beam and the past inheritance in a bad form.

2005/04/07 Bad [Original Japanese review]
by 宇宙刑事ジャンギャバン (Send message) Provider: 33223 Host:33255 Browser: 5978
They are the robot comics full of gags which were boiled and the egg serialized after "a ゆうれい boy comes." Although a hero's house steward was the dropbehind robot made from rubbish and he was a policeman, since the result was too bad, only the license of Class S, i.e., the scrap class, was able to be got.
However, it is the meaning which is referred to as using as the head the bucket with which a legendary judo expert's soul was put, releasing the power at the time of the pinch, and thrown and beating a bad robot.
Well, although the result is good also for a compliment, you are as it was closed immediately, and doesn't it become precocious?

Post your evaluation or comment.(Evaluation can be posted only once)

You need
1 other people's posts to post your evaluation or
30 other people's posts to post your comment
after you post your evaluation or comment.

Your Name(Required):

Password (Required. more than 4 characters) [If you want to create secure password: Online mkpasswd service]

Your comment about this anime(Required)

Your evaluation of this title(Required)
You can choose the evaluation only once. After you post your evaluation, please choose comment instead of evaluation from the options.

Evaluation of this title(You can choose this only once)
Your evaluation
If you evaluated this title once, please choose comment instead of the evaluation. Or you can use forum.
Comment by the person who thinks this is good
Comment by the person who thinks this is normal
Comment by the person who thinks this is bad

Please choose appropriate option for readers.

Pleaase confirm that your post is satisfing the following rules

Rule for reviews

This site allows you to write reviews for each title, but we don't allow you to criticize others' comment. Too bad or meaningless words are also not allowed. The comment which doesn't follow the rule will be deleted and access will be denied.

Caution: Please post the evaluation which follows the rule.

DB Top > Works > Comics > SCRAP SANDAYUH[Comics]:Review/Information

All
Reviews(Post)

Fan forum

Image&Wallpaper

Sales top 100

Anime(EN)	1. Ponyo TwoDisc / 2. Astro Boy / 3. Ponyo TwoDisc / 4-100
Game(EN)	1. God of / 2. Pokemon SoulSilver / 3. Wii / 4-100
Comics(EN)	1. Warriors / 2. Warriors / 3. Twelve Kingdoms, The - Hardcov / 4-100
Figure(EN)	1. Bakugan 7 / 2. ScoobyDoo Figure / 3. Avatar Navi / 4-100

Other: Anime(JP) / Game(JP) / Game machine(JP) / Comics(JP) / Movie(JP) / JP movie(JP) / Figure(JP) / Anime/Game Music(JP) / SF/Fantasy(JP) / Mistery(JP) / History(JP) / Romance(JP)

Sorted by alphabet	People[Voice / Actor / Supervisor / Story / Producer / Editor / Camera / Music / Singer / Writer / Drawer] Company[Anime / Game / Comics / Book / Drama / Movie / Music / Office / Tv] / Magazine / Group / Machine
Sorted by related works number	People[Voice / Actor / Supervisor / Story / Producer / Editor / Camera / Music / Singer / Writer / Drawer] Company[Anime / Game / Comics / Book / Drama / Movie / Music / Office / Tv] / Magazine / Group / Machine
Sorted by fan number	People[Voice / Actor / Supervisor / Story / Music / Singer / Writer / Drawer] Company[Anime / Game / Comics / Book / Drama / Movie / Music / Office / Tv] / Magazine / Group / Machine

Sorted by:Newness / Oldness
All including comments Only Evaluation	Good Evaluation:Best/Very Good/Good	Normal Evaluation	Bad Evaluation:Bad/Very Bad/Worst