Japanese works database(How to join/Help)
Top page: All/Only Reviews

Others
Site map


Search / Outside DB:

Comics ranking: Rank 244/in 4,169 titles (Total 27.06/Deviation 54.63) Rank 243 <= => Rank 245
Comics average points ranking: Rank 261/in 673 titles (Average 1.23(Good)/Deviation 54.86) Rank 260 <= => Rank 262 (more than 10 evaluatoin)
Comics ranking of 2005: Rank 10/in 139 titles Rank 9 <= => Rank 11

Shakugan no Syana(Comics)

[Other version: RSS/Japanese version]

Other media
Anime:Shakugan no Shana (movie) / Game:Shakugan no Shana / Novel:Shakugan no Shana

All
Reviews(Post)

Forum

Images

Information about this title

Yashichiro Takahashi
Ito Noiji
DENGEKI DAIOH
Media Works

Released:2005 in Japan

Statics of evaluation(The statics is updated once a day)

	Average	ComicsRank	Deviation(Total)	Evaluation points(Total)	Best of the Best
Inside Japan	Good(1.23)	244	54.63	27.06

Statics of activity

	Total Views	Comment	Evaluation
Inside Japan	49,498	26	22
Outside Japan	317	0	0

How others evaluated in Japan

Best

Very Good

Good

Normal

Bad

Very Bad

Worst

People

Percentage

22.7%

40.9%

0.0%

9.1%

4.5%

Added percentage

22.7%

45.4%

86.3%

86.3%

95.4%

100%

Summary

86.3%

13.6%

Views for recent 8 days
Total 21 20 19 18 17 16 15 14
2 1 0 0 0 1 0 0 0

Language Sorted by date Sorted by recommendation New!
English Good
(Only Evaluation) Normal
(Only Evaluation) Bad
(Only Evaluation) All
(Only Evaluation) None
Japanese Good
(Only Evaluation) Normal
(Only Evaluation) Bad
(Only Evaluation) All
(Only Evaluation) None
This reputation board

Language	Sorted by date	Sorted by recommendation New!
English	Good (Only Evaluation)	Normal (Only Evaluation)	Bad (Only Evaluation)	All (Only Evaluation)	None
Japanese	Good (Only Evaluation)	Normal (Only Evaluation)	Bad (Only Evaluation)	All (Only Evaluation)	None

Post your review / Top page

Other media
Anime:Shakugan no Shana (movie) / Game:Shakugan no Shana / Novel:Shakugan no Shana

The below reviews are translated automatically from Japanese ones. To post to English version, please click here.

2008/07/02 Best! [Original Japanese review]
by kana=Clownlord Provider: 12649 Host:12481 Browser: 4184
Is it very good?
Did you caricature original merit as it is?
Illustrating was also the result of " to the extent that I of いぢっ子" am also likable.
starting reappearing by comics how much, since a pace is late since it is a monthly and the original is long, supposing there is a place where only is bad -- と -- I considered It is afraid whether a pause finish sticking the middle.
Evaluation is [highest!
It is ]!

2008/05/17 Good [Original Japanese review]
by Marioneto Provider: 18732 Host:18568 Browser: 5234

[Good point]
A hot battle scene and deployment carried out in great fear.
It is manly in a hero being unexpected.
The way of thinking of a "torch" is new.

[Bad point]
Place where a picture sometimes collapses.
The end of furiagune.

[Comprehensive evaluation]
It is interesting.
Was the place which Yuji, a hero, already says, "Is dead" surprise?
how to start -- very well -- abrupt -- it was -- although -- it -- as a grip -- enough .
Although Yuji hung down to free [ which is full of about there ] and thought whether to have been a hero at first, he was the fellow who it has had steady nerves very much and is likable.
the inside which is frank with Yuji although the heroine's shana is also tsunken(ed) at first and is cooked better -- being dear -- it becomes a certain daughter -- a seed yakimochi 妬いている, time, and the place that stuffs melon bread into its mouth were quite dear to Mr.
Yoshida.
furiagune of a villain's part was also attractive with the enemy, and the love to Marianne was also a genuine article.
honest -- in the decisive battle of him and shana, it becomes that he is likely to be aided involuntarily -- a seed That end of furiagune was sad.
It never makes a mistake and the feeling of "wanting to be together with favorite 1" although it has made a mistake in the way of そりゃ彼 is since it does not carry out now something.
It was a character quite regrettable for being pushed down in that place.
When the re-appearance was behind achieved as strongest old enemy by Marianne's grudge, or it became a preferable thing friend and it was, possibly it was interesting at it.

2008/04/15 Best! [Original Japanese review]
by 炎髪君 Provider: 52119 Host:51974 Browser: 9070
The picture which Mr.
Sasakura draws is wonderfully beautiful.
I think that it is nicer than Mr.
のいぢ (original charge) and Mr.
Otsuka (animation charge).
It elapses especially well [ Marjorie ].
Important contents are also made by meeting an original.
However, "しゃなたん of the comics version 灼眼" of the addition which rubs, is peevish and is written to the last of ww comics troubled by series speed so that everybody might say is straw えます.
Of course, evaluation is the highest!
.

2008/01/09 Best! [Original Japanese review]
by 金色の闇 Provider: 6643 Host:6797 Browser: 6287
[Good point] Since sushi and a picture are also now beautiful, a story also progresses along with an original, and doesn't he have any complaint?
The face which eats めろんぱん of shana is the highest!!
[Bad point] The sale period of one volume is a messy 長いこと (smile).
[Comprehensive evaluation] Doesn't he have any complaint, if sale removes a late thing?
Since an original is also a great fan, I want to expect from now on.

2007/11/03 Comment(bad) [Original Japanese review]
by Nokokkusu Provider: 15127 Host:15380 Browser: 4730
Although there is a growth hope which can expect for the first time in [ which has followed the talk carefully and exceeds 画力 of "いぢ of いとう with a negligent peculiarity" ] although the place and the deployment which checked the neighborhood edited by ramie by browsing are slow, unless the improvement which exceeds original scenarios, such as "Yuji Sakai is irresolute", the "eternal triangle", and "a battle" etc.
which can say it as "an original malignant cancer cell", is carried out, "worst" evaluation does not escape like an original The alteration of a "misago festival" and the "study meeting" neighborhood will be the chance to show the skill.

2007/07/25 Good [Original Japanese review]
by Sharu Provider: 1407 Host:1248 Browser: 5598
It is the work which the picture and the story are based on the original and is likable.
However, like an original, in order that various technical terms may come out, it is likely to be bewildered by understanding them completely.
It is thought that the scene of the every day of each character which touches and suits is more interesting than the time of carrying out the battle individually.
It will be softened, if the loveliness of kyara and the "portion of base" are expressed the skillful く table and are reading.
Based on the above point, evaluation is made "good."

2007/07/10 Very good [Original Japanese review]
by CTU Provider: 34156 Host:34205 Browser: 4649
Three volumes were read today.
I think that the upper trick of the original atmosphere is carried out.
A picture is also just like that of the picture of Mr.
いぢ of いとう, and is good.
Incidentally he has noticed the charm of いぢ絵 which reads this comics version.
I think that the picture of shana is very dear.
I want a few to merely translate writing speed already.

2007/06/24 Good [Original Japanese review]
by 濁流の魔手 Provider: 18500 Host:18655 Browser: 4184
There is nothing bad.
Although it cannot say that a picture is not much nice, since it thinks that the feature of kyara something can be held well, I think that it is tolerance level.
Although only one volume had been read, I thought "it is interesting" with it being pure.
I think that there is no necessity of telling since the original is traced about the story.
Evaluation is "good."

2007/06/05 Worst [Original Japanese review]
by 宇宙刑事ジャンギャバン Provider: 33223 Host:33285 Browser: 6287
Oh, seemingly it is cartooning of the light novel whose something is popular.
The leading role's boy is the appearance which is the useless man of 120% of deplorableness which it is cowardly, is irresolute and is brandished by the woman increased, so that it has already been disgusted these days.
....
is あ and ふむ when that fellow will be told to the cool-headed girl of ちんちくりん who brandishes the man murder kitchen knife which appeared abruptly on her head if he is the dead body, and he is already involved in fighting also unreasonable by ん.
If it is called the coarse thing of drawing even if attached to it, there is nothing.
this kind of the so-called "-- it sprouts and" work is fascinated with saying that that which is worthless in addition to a picture is most with a picture -- ら意味 is not accomplished then -- even if there is nothing -- this -- being insolent -- being dear -- likable [ in the reverse side / to the boy of a blue gourd ] also in the girl who is not -- saying .
It can do and can do...
It reads, the stripes of the time are carried out vainly, and it is a shelf.

2007/05/24 Very bad [Original Japanese review]
by 虚構の旅人 Provider: 18003 Host:17891 Browser: 4772
The work which made the novel comics.
The work of かこ which is what.
It turns out that it is insisting as an original being reproduced faithfully.
However, 画力 ...
Is it said that it is coarse rather than low?
The picture of Mr.
いぢ of いとう was imitated and shana has gone wrong utterly.
busaiku っぷり of Sato and Mr.
Yoshida cannot be saved.
"狩 people" furiagune -- although Mr.
いぢ of ...
has seemingly also extolled coarseness [ like ] as how it is ...
Since only that is deep, origin thinks that an unavoidable thing has late tempo.
If it improves monthly that it is a few page, し [ a pace will also go up ].
Although it was well opened to the extent that it was frightful between two volumes and three volumes ...
Did the good impression draw Alastor?
Hecate of an appearance and Mr.
Marjorie of new kyara also resemble the volume on extra the back.
Although Mr.
Yoshida's picture is improving ...
Is Mr.
yuuji poor as ever?
Mr.
Nakamura was the severe result the back.
the beginning and "-- it is whom -- since supporting player ?" which よこれ and a name do not have, either was thought ...
Did the good impression put in the talk of Neenah?
Since I did not know with the work of drama CD original, either.
Or [ although I want you to also make the talk of "rishaffuru" into comics, if it is this pace, when will come / ...
] It is are bottom it is before a cultural festival surely.
Is evaluation "very bad"?
Since it thinks that 画力 is improved as it is this tune, and it goes, probably it may expect and wait, and an original can also read a story in comfort, because it is good.
If it is avaricious and says, do I want you to raise tempo too?
If only that lengthens one settlement, it is called mannerism and there is no ょう.
Let's expect a future comeback!

2007/04/10 Best! [Original Japanese review]
by 春夏秋冬 Provider: 18735 Host:18507 Browser: 6342
April 27 ...
three shana of long-awaited 灼眼 come out...
It was long..
Is it the first time in about nine months?
The expression which it sprouted, it was a system writer, depiction was [ skillful-] and it carried out it although the action scene could not be called highest, and has held the feature of kyara is the remarkable result.
The expression with which regret and anger of 178P of two volumes were mixed is very impressive.
an original atmosphere and an original pattern -- no fault is found Hamah り past て I think that skillful くなってる of the 画力 is carried out and it is a Hideyasu work in handicap karaizu of ranobe with it being certain.
Since the original is faithfully reproduced without putting in 端折ったり and an arrangement.
Probably, the popularity to strange episode ON れたらここ did not come out rather.
し [ it is a professional, kyara is drawn lovelily and it shines ].
It thinks that advance is slow because the contents and explanation are deep, and one original is kana which is not common.
けど which will exist since it is a monthly comics magazine.
An original is also accelerated and a few also already regards deployment as くなる from now on.
(It wants without catching up, if it can do.) There will also be comics of ten volumes in まぁ 12 years, and it is not like [ which is called a fault ], either.
Those whom are the issue exactly united with the theater edited by furiagune, and a view of the world seldom grasps, and those who do not understand a term osusume entering from comics.
evaluation of a present stage -- an original -- natural as oneself -- it is the highest [ banzai ] The conclusion edited by furiagune and Alastor are pleasure about how it is drawn.

2007/04/04 Very good [Original Japanese review]
by γ Provider: 37377 Host:37394 Browser: 5978
Two volumes [ two ] were somehow read in medieval times.
[Good point] Place where - picture is beautiful.
the direction of others -- 仰る -- like -- Mr.
いぢ of いとう -- being alike -- て .
- The place whose battle scene with furiagune was smart.
There is such responsiveness and hot (?) battle scene is interesting.
[Bad point] Place where - pace is late.
What may make the size of a top a little smaller.
[Comprehensive evaluation] A story is fairly good, although it does not know in detail, since original ranobe does not have having read.
Evaluation is "very good."

2007/03/13 Very bad [Original Japanese review]
by god Provider: 34156 Host:34170 Browser: 3023
Tempo is somewhat late although one faithful to an original is good.
From まぁ and 駄作っぷり of animation, it is mashi.
Is that he wants to say the low level of 画力?
...
It is Mr.
いぢ of いとう to a slight degree.
I wanted you to model.
However, was Mr.
furiagune good?
The point was put into evaluation and a judgment was made.

2006/11/17 Good [Original Japanese review]
by 新戸 Provider: 3949 Host:4085 Browser: 6287
very much -- long -- becoming -- て -- I want myself (if late, there will be some persons who take けど) to maintain this pace although what became comics from the game which he knows is late at first mostly -- on the way -- when coming out and accelerating and entering in the second half of an original, it is praying that shana of 灼眼 (it knows -- few -- although it comes out and becomes empty) which has remarkable speed does not become so it is not related -- it is -- although -- is the direction of the usage evil spirit of zero supiido っぽい of about one original in one volume (as long as complete [ of a site ] is seen)?

2006/09/26 Very good [Original Japanese review]
by 武力行使 Provider: 5559 Host:5239 Browser: 6271
Is deployment very long unlike a novel?
Since two volumes finish and Yuji is just going to review to furiagune at last, if it is going to catch up with a novel, I will think that it will exceed 40 volumes lightly.
Although it thinks that it is serious, please draw to the last enduringly.

2006/09/16 Good [Original Japanese review]
by 印鑑 Provider: 22196 Host:22128 Browser: 6250
an original -- first -- easy -- does grasp of a view of the world also have some easier this one?
Although illustrating is well modeled in the picture of Mr.
いぢ of いとう and roughness is also seen somewhat, it is a level more than the passing mark.
Since the story is also reproducing the original faithfully, can an original fan also read in comfort satisfactory?
Moreover, or [ also considering some explanation of a view of the world also in the direction containing comics, since it is intelligible, as mentioned above ].
If an original is completed, do I also want the comics version to catch up to the conclusion, although the halfway close is fearful since the speed of sale is slow?
Evaluation is "good."

2006/08/19 Good [Original Japanese review]
by Akoo Provider: 18877 Host:19038 Browser: 5234
It was faithful to the original and 画力 was also able to be enjoyed very much highly.
Is merely the lateness of deployment fatal?
One volume of an original has not finished yet, either.
If it says that it is unavoidable, although it is unavoidable, is it hard too?

2006/08/17 Best! [Original Japanese review]
by ツンデレ好き(中二) Provider: 22196 Host:22277 Browser: 5234
A novel, comics, animation 全部見 better た.
The comics version comes out and is peevish.
animation -- just for a moment ...
is its furiagune long?
something -- this -- 終わっちゃい -- is [ feel that that is right and ] it anxious?
12 volumes of the novel version -- a teacher -- is it stolen like, furthermore isn't subsequent deployment known?

2006/06/12 Good [Original Japanese review]
by 山口 Provider: 29615 Host:29732 Browser: 6287
A setup finer than an original is intelligible for a top faithful to an original.
((Those who are not seem to be difficult also by kore) it is original 読ん -- things -- it seems) difference removes a lunch foods poor place (a classroom -> outdoors), the victim (a pond -> Yoshida) of an attack, and spare clothing -- an original puts on the trousers 穿いてるけど comics version on ?
scene -- saying -- と -- it is こかな However, it is clearly late.
It is one comics and is a pace about [ of one original library ] a half.
kore makes it only and it is with whether it is the greatest minus.

2006/03/25 Good [Original Japanese review]
by Chestnut Review history[Good:1(100%) Normal:0(0%) Bad:0(0%)] / Provider: 3078 Host:2960 Browser: 5234
It saw the one comic version shana.
The way of a picture did not collapse more strangely than the animation version, and it was good.
Moreover, it is thought that the story was more intelligible than the way of animation.
Blow off of the voice of the man in pendant ?
of shana seemed to have roared out, and was pleased [ something and ].
The comics version is "now" pleased from the animation version.
It is expectation at future.
Although evaluation was compared with "it being bad" and thought the method of comrades, it puts expectation and presupposes "It is good".
[ which the animation version usually depends ]

Next / Post your review / Top page

Other media
Anime:Shakugan no Shana (movie) / Game:Shakugan no Shana / Novel:Shakugan no Shana

ALERT: You cannot use open proxy or TOR for posting your review. If it is detected, your access to this site will be prohibited.

Rule for reviews

This site allows you to write reviews for each title, but we don't allow you to criticize others' comment. Too bad or meaningless words are also not allowed. The comment which doesn't follow the rule will be deleted. If you find any comment which doesn't follow the rule, please notify us by clicking Suggest to delete.

Example to be deleted frequently

Favorite side
You dislike this one, then don't see it or comment this title
- Please go to the fan site. Anyone has the right to say what they feel in this site.

Disliking side
Do you like this one? You are stupid.
- Your view is only your view. Please concentrate on only the content of the title, not on others' comment.

Please use only English. If not, the comment will be deleted.

Your Name(Required)

Password (Required. more than 4 characters)

Your comment about this anime(Required)

Your evaluation of this title(Required)
You can choose the evaluation only once. After you post your evaluation, please choose comment instead of evaluation from the options.

Evaluation of this title(You can choose this only once)

Best!!
Very good
Good
Normal
Bad
Very Bad
Worst

If you evaluated this title once, please choose comment instead of the evaluation.
Comment by the person who thinks this is good
Comment by the person who thinks this is normal
Comment by the person who thinks this is bad

Please choose appropriate option for readers.

Caution: Please post the evaluation which follows the rule.