Japanese works database(How to join/Help)
Top page: All/Only Reviews

Others
Site map


Search / Outside DB:

Comics ranking: Rank 4,119/in 4,168 titles (Total -33.90/Deviation 40.82) Rank 4,118 <= => Rank 4,120
Comics average points ranking: Rank 605/in 673 titles (Average -1.13(Bad)/Deviation 35.14) Rank 604 <= => Rank 606 (more than 10 evaluatoin)
Comics ranking of 2005: Rank 136/in 139 titles Rank 135 <= => Rank 137

The Melancholy of Haruhi Suzumiya(Comics)

[Other version: RSS/Japanese version]

Other media
Anime:The Melancholy of Haruhi Suzumiya / Novel:Suzumiya Haruhi's melancholy

All
Reviews(Post)

Forum

Images

Goods
(Books)

Latest Books: 2008/10/28 ():

The Melancholy of Haruhi Suzumiya $99

Books(1hit) Sales/Latest	DVD(17hit) Sales/Latest						Music(19hit) Sales/Latest	VideoGames(8hit) Sales/Latest	Toys(146hit) Sales/Latest
Rank:73451 Paperback:The Melancholy of Haruhi Suzumiya Tag:$99 2008/10/28 ()	Rank:5663 The Melancholy of Haruhi Suzumiya: Complete Collection Tag:$98 2008/07/29 () Eval.:***** 1.Great series but too short!	Rank:5753 Code Geass Lelouch of the Rebellion, Part 1 Tag:$98 2008/08/05 () Eval.:***** 1.What the heck?	Rank:14614 Azumanga Daioh - Class Album (Complete Series) Tag:$98 2005/09/20 () Eval.:***** 1.AMAZINGNESS!!!!	Rank:16712 Maria Watches Over Us - Season 1 Tag:$99 2008/07/29 () Eval.:***** 1.Great Title	Rank:18253 The Melancholy of Haruhi Suzumiya, Volume 1 Tag:$98 2007/05/29 () Eval.:***** 1.Spreading excitement all over the world with...	Rank:18525 The Melancholy of Haruhi Suzumiya, Volume 4 (Limited Edition) Tag:$98 2007/11/06 () Eval.:***** 1.The Last Review! (Or is it?)	Rank:113954 Audio CD:The Melancholy of Haruhi Suzumiya: Character Song, Vol. 1 Tag:$98 2007/09/25 ()	Rank:153207 Toy:Melancholy of Haruhi Suzumiya Vol. 2 Yuki Nagato Soundtrack 20884 Tag:$95	Rank:3919 Apparel:Hand Bag: The Melancholy of Haruhi Suzumiya - Checker Tag:$99

Information about this title

Nagaru Tanigawa
Makoto Mizuno
Ito Noiji
Monthly Boys Ace
Kadokawa Shoten Publishing Co.,Ltd.

Released:2005/09/26 in Japan

Statics of evaluation(The statics is updated once a day)

	Average	ComicsRank	Deviation(Total)	Evaluation points(Total)	Best of the Best
Inside Japan	Bad(-1.13)	4,119	40.82	-33.90

Statics of activity

	Total Views	Comment	Evaluation
Inside Japan	16,192	30	30
Outside Japan	264	0	0

How others evaluated in Japan

Best

Very Good

Good

Normal

Bad

Very Bad

Worst

People

Percentage

0.0%

10.0%

3.3%

10.0%

33.3%

26.7%

16.7%

Added percentage

10%

13.3%

23.3%

56.6%

83.3%

100%

Summary

13.3%

10.0%

76.7%

Views for recent 8 days
Total 20 19 18 17 16 15 14 13
18 6 4 0 1 1 1 1 4

Language Sorted by date Sorted by recommendation New!
English Good
(Only Evaluation) Normal
(Only Evaluation) Bad
(Only Evaluation) All
(Only Evaluation) None
Japanese Good
(Only Evaluation) Normal
(Only Evaluation) Bad
(Only Evaluation) All
(Only Evaluation) None
This reputation board

Language	Sorted by date	Sorted by recommendation New!
English	Good (Only Evaluation)	Normal (Only Evaluation)	Bad (Only Evaluation)	All (Only Evaluation)	None
Japanese	Good (Only Evaluation)	Normal (Only Evaluation)	Bad (Only Evaluation)	All (Only Evaluation)	None

Post your review / Top page

Other media
Anime:The Melancholy of Haruhi Suzumiya / Novel:Suzumiya Haruhi's melancholy

The below reviews are translated automatically from Japanese ones. To post to English version, please click here.

2008/06/11 Good [Original Japanese review]
by kana=Clownlord Provider: 12867 Host:12635 Browser: 4184

[Good point]
Skill of drawing should be improved gradually.
Well [
[point / bad]
] ...
It is not especially.

[Comprehensive evaluation]
I think that it is good.
It is better than the fellow whom the former cartoonist was writing at least.
The picture which had a part of sense of incongruity at first is regarded as it being good (especially Taniguchi www), and the talk of a picture is also faithful to an original.
Is it good?
However, when it is comics, Mr.
kyon's tsukkomi in an original is ...
if it does perfectly -- the number of characters -- し it will be uncanny Since he was enjoyed on the whole, it is good evaluation.

2008/04/30 Very good [Original Japanese review]
by Tamae Provider: 18003 Host:17891 Browser: 4658
If it tries to think the kana which cannot be intelligibly seen with a crunching sound if it browses and a novel will become comics, since it saw by chance at the secondhand bookseller, although there is also a scene different from animation a little, I 々楽(ed) inside and had you become precocious.
it is better to think that the view of the world of haruhi is further circulated by the thing with an increasing criticism which read these comics although like -- illustrating regarded as it being ....
haruhi and others different from Mr.
のいぢ's illustrating which is not bad again is drawn, and favorite skill of drawing is low -- if high, it will be only the problem of others' convenience and let's see warmly Teacher 頑〓辰討〓蕕譴泙〓currently drawn.

2008/04/30 Worst [Original Japanese review]
by 炎髪君 Provider: 4300 Host:4372 Browser: 9070
はぁ -- the picture of かこ which is ..
.
あのぉ -- what intention is it to make into comics ...
and the picture which is less than the step of Mr.
のいぢ's skill of drawing?
the same -- Mr.
のいぢ -- comics Ver.
of "shana of 灼眼" of an original illustration -- Mr.
Sasakura -- Mr.
[ のいぢ / more than ] -- skillful く描いている's -- と -- saying .
Doesn't comics Ver.
of haruhi have the value to read?
Because original ranobe is liked, something feels irritation excessive.
Evaluation is the "worst", inserting such a personal feelings.
.

2008/04/08 Bad [Original Japanese review]
by 日守綾 Provider: 13247 Host:13318 Browser: 7087
although it thinks that the talk is good along an original -- too -- you -- 仰っている -- is the problem a picture like?
It is the work which we cannot not much recommend to people of an original lover.
It is ..
which does not have this picture with where and has a 雑っぽい impression in me.; Evaluation is "bad" ..

2008/03/30 Very good [Original Japanese review]
by Fuerishidaa Provider: 8932 Host:8884 Browser: 3875
bad, if it considers that it is the handicap karaizu work regarded as it not being a bad work, although it is an original fan -- it can do -- coming out -- is it above the work of the teacher who does not conclude at least whether to put in well in the range which is not, and in which it appears and sushi and the original talk do not break an original, either?
Is that it merely reads and there are て and the occasionally coarse time a fault?

2008/03/24 Bad [Original Japanese review]
by ガン0123 Provider: 20872 Host:20566 Browser: 8090
A bad point -> picture.
An original element.
The hama ったけど comics version did not care for it into animation and a novel.
It is in the charm of Suzumiya haruhi.
Although it answers immediately and there is no れ even if heard, these comics will 失くして and wait for the charm.
Incidentally it has only four volumes (it is a figure skating guide).
to put it bluntly -- て言う and me -- he likes いぢ絵 obtained as yes ...
ってこ is not found

2008/03/02 Worst [Original Japanese review]
by 宇宙刑事ジャンギャバン Provider: 33223 Host:33285 Browser: 8643
はあ ...
ふむ.
It was the comics version of a light novel with which popularity was won and animation-ization etc.
was carried out.
the place sake of insolent haughty and selfish girl and Suzumiya haruhi which will be misunderstood if everyday life is tedious and worthless -- it is -- a hero -- kyon -- saying that a boy is involved in various troubles and is in difficulties -- the main line -- like .
this hand [ try ] to exist, so that it already sweeps and throws away -- haughty -- courtesy -- the talk which しょう with which it trifles so that often [ it may be weak to a not knowing small daughter and / the boy whom the piece of 欠 of autonomy does not have, either ] does not have, either -- recently Although it is good and is honestly already touch.
the ton on which it looked like [ ton ] somehow whether any of these girls were the universes, and it has had various influences by ん while it is unconscious -- existence [ demo ] If there is a party of doubtful existence who is gazing at the ton demonstration girl.
ははん ...
Although it is comics full of gags, it flys away too much and cannot follow.
ま -- anyhow -- haruhi -- a girl with the existence troublesome [ society ] itself -- a hero -- kyon -- a change is not for 寸毫 not to be likable to a deplorable boy, either し [ honestly, it cannot regard drawing as skillful い, either ] ...
Although I will attach only two worst characters, there is nothing.

2008/02/27 Normal [Original Japanese review]
by 蒼芽 Provider: 24546 Host:24625 Browser: 6520

[Good point]
Well, it is even if it is called a good point ...
But I think that it is good at the composition of the talk.
If a picture is also compared with the comic of the direction which is not this, し [ it will regard it as dear ].

[Bad point]
Although it is superior, a picture does not become precocious as you say too.
Can't Mr.
いぢ of いとう recommend the favorite one?

[Comprehensive evaluation]
I think saw in time with the kana which is not so severe.
Mr.
いぢ of まぁ私 -- since he likes, there is no mind read by preference It is whether the いぢ fan with an original had better not read.
If it enters from a comic, doesn't it arrange yet?
since I entered from the original -- not much -- not liking -

2008/02/19 Worst [Original Japanese review]
by 634 Provider: 10597 Host:10799 Browser: 6342
Although the comics here were touching haruhi besides animation or the original novel ...

[Good point]
Nothing.
Charm does not spring in drawing at all.
Although it was also that a favorable impression did not seethe with the illustration of いぢ of いとう from the first, it did not pass over this to what degraded it, but it is read as for the contents talking, steps displeasure sprang and caused it, and the bad meaning showed it "it became true in the world which such a bad laver work receives." It is only it.

[a bad point]
-- even if it makes it an original and makes it animation -- "-- ねん with where [ interesting ] It was nothing less than ", and charm did not spring at all, the character with which a favorable impression does not seethe can be seen as the bad laver disturbance is only developed in the talk, and it will make a "movement battleship pink" the school drama in the 21st century, and possibly the character also became 創れば and such forms.
The mind read deeply faded away immediately.

[Comprehensive evaluation]
It is only clear to have symbolized the work which received in the present age people's opinion also often and bad.
however, bad laver -- he does not so like a style -- carrying out -- the tension of the style of haruhi -- not-good 乗る -- things were not made -- it carried out, and although the tension and invigoration like other gag works or a comedy work were to it when calling it the difference in a view, they did not suit me Well, I think that there having not been an attractive person and how to use the laver were fatal in haruhi.
Having been felt by haruhi had other comedies and no merit of a gag work.
There is no right cousin only in the comic of such a work.

2008/02/04 Worst [Original Japanese review]
by クックック〜 Provider: 10906 Host:11018 Browser: 9070
Evaluation of the comics version is the "worst." It is because a picture is not oneself liking just for a moment if it says why it is.
The contents itself think that they are practically equal with the novel version.
What was necessary was just to have made comics draw on いぢ of いとう.

2008/01/09 Worst [Original Japanese review]
by Aiu Provider: 25769 Host:25829 Browser: 6520
Too much, by "buton", the contents were and carried out honest boss influence....
Is it this comics picture lower part the back?
Therefore, it is the worst.

2007/07/25 Very bad [Original Japanese review]
by Sharu Provider: 1407 Host:1248 Browser: 5598
The handicap karaizu work of a masterpiece light novel brought into the limelight by animation-ization.
The story is advancing in the form which inserts original episode and small neta there, developing in the form based on the original.
Text expression is also the form where an original is followed and I regard it as the ability to have improved as a talk.
However, on the whole, illustrating is hard compared with animation or an original, receives a coarse impression, and is very minus.
illustrating -- evaluation "is worsened very much" by making a field into a big subtracting point

2007/07/15 Very bad [Original Japanese review]
by Main Provider: 15655 Host:15356 Browser: 4184
Drawing is dirty anyhow.
Although there is no complaint in a story, I think that there is a problem in the dirtiness of this drawing.
Probably, it will be far better to see an original and animation.

2007/07/08 Bad [Original Japanese review]
by 過去の栄光 Provider: 40756 Host:40736 Browser: 5234
The comics version of haruhi with a famous reputation of a picture.
I think that a picture is not so severe as is severely criticized to there recently well.
However, time of the beginning ...
especially kyon is severe -- elapsing -- it is .
For itself, the feeling of disappointment to the comics version when seeing original ほうを was uncanny.
[ who is not in an original even from animation, either and said from this comics version ] Others [ まぁ ] ...
I think that there is also no place which only changed original turn and was deteriorated to there.
Evaluation is bad.

2007/05/22 Very bad [Original Japanese review]
by CTU Provider: 34156 Host:34054 Browser: 4649
A picture is too severe as you have also said.
Mr.
いぢ whom also makes this the close and it obtains with the same stake individually wants the comics version author (a name is memorized and does not become precocious) of shana of 灼眼 who is taking charge of an illustration to write

2007/05/05 Very bad [Original Japanese review]
by 虚構の旅人 Provider: 18003 Host:17886 Browser: 4772
It is a good impression to have added the story which is not in an original.
However, 画力 ...
It does not understand [ whether a picture is coarse and poor and ].
まぁ, Dan Dan, and progress are carried out.
In Boy A, it will read in why.
It will criticize in the heart to whenever [ the ].
After evaluation wavered, it is stopped by "it is very bad."

2007/04/24 Very bad [Original Japanese review]
by god Provider: 18003 Host:17888 Browser: 3023
The original was a work shocking to so so favorite me.
The addition of a story is splendid.
However, that 画力 cannot be allowed.
There is no memory in which alike kyara was!
The boy ace also carries well and it is a shelf ...

2007/04/07 Normal [Original Japanese review]
by Surasshu Provider: 13078 Host:13330 Browser: 5234
Even now, it is book 持っています.
It is w, although close how to finish was adopted and two volumes did not put on the market after all.
Is deki of a work common?
Illustrating is not good although other people are said well.
Mr.
Asakura merely thinks that he was able to draw lovelily.
I think that it is more interesting than the tsuganogaku version serialized about the contents also now.

2007/04/02 Very bad [Original Japanese review]
by Torahamukun Provider: 34156 Host:34117 Browser: 4708
whose quality was very as high as an original and animation, and was quite good -- として it shuts an eye if かこれ which is what is poor at ?
picture, that there is no sense of stability -- that rose -- rose deployment is not possible Surely, before meeting Mr.
Asahina, wasn't the thought carried out to Nagato vs Asakura being seen, either?
This sympathizes with the person (although it thinks that it is extremely few --) who entered from comics.
But the place which is growing although the direction of 画力 is gradually though small as the talk progresses is the place to praise.
Moreover, the story (carrying-with za sneaker kana ?) which is not in an original at three volumes thinks that it was good with it being private.
It could sympathize with the utterance of 古泉 and especially Mr.
Asahina's feeling was painful very.
Although there is also a good place, is the direction of が conspicuous a too bad place?
Evaluation is "very bad." Shall I expect まぁ and future?

2007/01/07 Very bad [Original Japanese review]
by afterglow Provider: 30606 Host:30431 Browser: 3875
Although it was a popular light novel and the work which was は期待(ing) by moreover calling it cartooning of favorite series just for a moment, honestly it is the impression which only expectation has gone far ahead of.
From the first, since there was feeling that comics 映え and animation 映え were the works which are likely to be hard to carry out, I carry out [ mind as it was proved that the anxiety of primary your place was more exact ].
First, the problem of 画力 as a fundamental portion.
Although there is no mind upon which it looks down 毛頭 independently just because there is no skillful く, it is hard to accept that the atmosphere of the character drawn between the same volumes changes rapidly just for a moment.
Honest evaluation must be dropped.
moreover, a motion of a character is also splendidly superficial and it is said that it does not have a feeling of a lively motion -- it is -- I think that the fun of a work cannot be expressed directivity has recently been decided little by little -- since like, although the fixed style is shown, since 迷走っぷり still becomes invisible from time to time in some parts in addition -- ちょい -- it is regretting And the problem of a story.
About the trial in which it changes so that comics may be suited more by it not only tracing an original faithfully, but mixing the story which was not partly looked at by this editing, I do fixed evaluation.
However, in the case of this work, it is "strange [ composition ]" rather than "composition is strange." The tempo to which an original flows splendidly is run through and it is ちゃっています.
it is そん, although lenience and severity stick and it will be "thrilling", if it says well -- it is ironic -- with the novel (bitter smile) version which cannot be heard, a delicate feeling drifts even by "melancholy [ 涼宮 haruhi ]" book editing which it estimated "is very good" -- it can do -- だった and 思えっています it says or does not load rather -- there is nothing -- this It is quite a good impression to have taken in the original story which is not in an original in the way of the talk recorded on まぁ and the maximum new publication.
I want the author to carry out such measures rapidly.
Although 酷 will compare with the original book of the former neta since I hear that the existing popular original was caricatured, the impression of the literal degradation work "fun cannot exceed even in the original liable to stagnation a little" for the moment cannot be denied.
I will estimate standard evaluation and a general comment "are very bad." まぁ -- although a standby is still carried out for a while ......
the kana to cut -- soon .

Next / Post your review / Top page

Other media
Anime:The Melancholy of Haruhi Suzumiya / Novel:Suzumiya Haruhi's melancholy

ALERT: You cannot use open proxy or TOR for posting your review. If it is detected, your access to this site will be prohibited.

Rule for reviews

This site allows you to write reviews for each title, but we don't allow you to criticize others' comment. Too bad or meaningless words are also not allowed. The comment which doesn't follow the rule will be deleted. If you find any comment which doesn't follow the rule, please notify us by clicking Suggest to delete.

Example to be deleted frequently

Favorite side
You dislike this one, then don't see it or comment this title
- Please go to the fan site. Anyone has the right to say what they feel in this site.

Disliking side
Do you like this one? You are stupid.
- Your view is only your view. Please concentrate on only the content of the title, not on others' comment.

Please use only English. If not, the comment will be deleted.

Your Name(Required)

Password (Required. more than 4 characters)

Your comment about this anime(Required)

Your evaluation of this title(Required)
You can choose the evaluation only once. After you post your evaluation, please choose comment instead of evaluation from the options.

Evaluation of this title(You can choose this only once)

Best!!
Very good
Good
Normal
Bad
Very Bad
Worst

If you evaluated this title once, please choose comment instead of the evaluation.
Comment by the person who thinks this is good
Comment by the person who thinks this is normal
Comment by the person who thinks this is bad

Please choose appropriate option for readers.

Caution: Please post the evaluation which follows the rule.