Japanese works database(How to join/Help)
Top page: All/Only Reviews

Others
Site map


Search / Outside DB:

Comics ranking: Rank 4,028/in 4,217 titles (Total -9.00/Deviation 46.47) Rank 4,027 <= => Rank 4,029
Comics average points ranking: Rank 567/in 696 titles (Average -0.36(Good)/Deviation 41.55) Rank 566 <= => Rank 568 (more than 10 evaluatoin)
Comics ranking of 2001: Rank 69/in 80 titles Rank 68 <= => Rank 70

Tantei gakuen Q ( Detective School Q / Detective Academy Q )(Comics)

[Other version: RSS/Japanese version]

Other media
Anime:Detective school Q (Tantei Gakuen Q) / Drama:Tantei Gakuen Q

All
Reviews(Post)

Forum

Images

Goods
(DVD)

Latest Music: 2007/09/10 ():

Tantei Gakuen Q $49

DVD(1hit) Sales/Latest	Music(1hit) Sales/Latest
Rank:26047 2007 Japanese Drama - Tantei Gakuen Q - w/ English Subtitle	Rank:821027 Audio CD:Tantei Gakuen Q Tag:$49 2007/09/10 ()

Information about this title

Seimaru Amagi
Fumiya Sato
Weekly Boys Magazine
Koudansha

Released:2001 in Japan End:2005/07/20 in Japan

Statics of evaluation(The statics is updated once a day)

	Average	ComicsRank	Deviation(Total)	Evaluation points(Total)	Best of the Best
Inside Japan	Good(-0.36)	4,028	46.47	-9.00

Statics of activity

	Total Views	Comment	Evaluation
Inside Japan	37,633	27	25
Outside Japan	1,236	0	0

How others evaluated in Japan

Best

Very Good

Good

Normal

Bad

Very Bad

Worst

People

Percentage

0.0%

8.0%

16.0%

40.0%

12.0%

16.0%

8.0%

Added percentage

24%

64%

76%

92%

100%

Summary

24%

40.0%

36%

Views for recent 8 days
Total 15 14 13 12 11 10 9 8
19 4 1 2 1 1 0 4 6

Language Sorted by date Sorted by recommendation
English Good
(Only Evaluation) Normal
(Only Evaluation) Bad
(Only Evaluation) All
(Only Evaluation) None
Japanese Good
(Only Evaluation) Normal
(Only Evaluation) Bad
(Only Evaluation) All
(Only Evaluation) All
This reputation board

Language	Sorted by date	Sorted by recommendation
English	Good (Only Evaluation)	Normal (Only Evaluation)	Bad (Only Evaluation)	All (Only Evaluation)	None
Japanese	Good (Only Evaluation)	Normal (Only Evaluation)	Bad (Only Evaluation)	All (Only Evaluation)	All

Post your review / Top page

Other media
Anime:Detective school Q (Tantei Gakuen Q) / Drama:Tantei Gakuen Q

The below reviews are translated automatically from Japanese ones. To post to English version, please click here.

2008/06/10 Very bad [Original Japanese review]
by goodday0220 Provider: 40360 Host:40264 Browser: 2459
Although this work is a work which became animation-izing, drama-ization, etc., when compared with Kindaichi, it is boring, and it is bad for there to be also no unexpected nature also about an incident rather, and to understand in the twinkling of an eye.
Since DDS called a boy detective team is formed, it cooperates in all five persons and it does not solve, when the most, although gone underwater and crowded in an incident, but it is solving with the rose rose, it cannot be obtained that the teamwork of an incident has not become.
It is better to still do the Kindaichi boy's cause-books which will be solved together with Miyuki if it is this.
It is too regrettable that a meaning is lost in the existence of the detective school Q itself.
I think that this work is a work which did not need to be purposely made into the story as a detective school Q.

2008/04/29 Very bad [Original Japanese review]
by H&J Provider: 6838 Host:6966 Browser: 8090
If the main members who treat a murder case like an event are seen, instruction of a "detective school", "a victim's human rights", etc., etc.
can guess what probably was not done.
Moreover, also about having always neglected the police and having carried out only kitchens, it turns out that it was teaching thoroughly "Don't cooperate in the police." Although it can still be convinced that the boy with whom "Kindaichi boy -" is "there was the hero and he united on that occasion by chance", and age does not go, either also begins inference, it could be said that it has destroyed the view of the world of a boy detective from the bottom on the contrary because it affirmed making a reason and a child positively concerned with a crime, although this work completed the occupation of "a boy detective." Evaluation: It is very bad.

2008/03/05 Good [Original Japanese review]
by Hauru Provider: 1181 Host:1001 Browser: 8090

[Good point]
It has temporarily fitted in.

[Bad point]
It has not been called this.

[Comprehensive evaluation]
It is good.

2007/11/07 Normal [Original Japanese review]
by 風の旅人 Provider: 12203 Host:12217 Browser: 4483
It is not so interesting as "Kindaichi." is resembled and a crime organization is involved one by one in by "Conan" wanting to see -- he does not like ...
since Takatoo of "Kindaichi" is an individual, although it is still good Deployment which is going to die from mesmerism if the wires are almost pulled [ criminal ] the back in Pluto and an incident finishes.
Since it was the same deployment ばっ loan, it 飽きed bored.
Although it was still good when having finished it as 棲龍館 (is different?
...
[ Character ]), was the short story which was being done recently severer?
It did not read any longer.
If it has also finished with kirei, finally Kerberos will come out better, and it is the Pluto revival...
King hadesu died for what purpose.
It is regrettable that what is pulled by the picture of these comics あ and the back, and the face of kyara of "Kindaichi" serialized after this has changed the front (mind which returned by "雪霊山荘" just for a moment is also carried out).
For the time being, evaluation is made "common."

2007/10/31 Good [Original Japanese review]
by Metako Provider: 39923 Host:39892 Browser: 3874
It is the second step of the boy inference thing comics which the author pair of "the Kindaichi boy's cause-books" sends.
Although written also to one comic, I consider [ having just aimed at making a work on condition of being "comics", and ] the difference with a previous work.
I think whether the rival of a capability higher rank and the portion of the long-term hint incorporated between episode called -- become a difference by existence of how to build a character with unique capability, the point that the hero forms the group, and the adult that leads heroes, and seniority.
[ many ] That is, 本作 could be called work which set the short episode of a long piece everywhere to so to speak having been [ to which the previous work applied only the setup "Kosuke Kindaichi's grandchild" to each episode ] the aggregate of a novelette.
And he likes this one individually.
by the way -- although it seems that a murder case occurs too much in a familiar place, and there is also criticism called だ very well in an inference thing like 今作 (not only evaluation here but previous work 含めて -- it is a general talk) -- it -- "-- dramatization -- calling it upper promise" and putting in an inquiry there -- a comic storyteller -- going -- "-- だ which is not talking by one person why I think being [ it / the boorish thing / a thing / an inquiry is put in as you should perform by two or more persons since" a comic storyteller is in others ] kana ?.
If it dares say 野暮 based on such a thing, I will also think the kana which could not increase inference episode other than homicide to a slight degree.
Or [ it looks for the search for a man, and the lost whereabouts of a thing ] the direction of such inference should be rather involved the knowledge of a computer well in memory capability at the moment -- there is the thought kana ?
which was able to enjoy the trick of て and a comics no one but I think individually that the point is a fault of 今作.
I think that recovery of a hint, the quiet curtain influence which gave hope with future are still read, and there was a comfortable feeling of after reading.
Evaluation is "good."

2007/10/07 Very good [Original Japanese review]
by 在原健太郎 Provider: 13675 Host:13687 Browser: 5234
天樹征丸 and さとうふみ of "the Kindaichi boy's cause-books", and が -- the newly induced inference school thing Five persons who won straight victories in the selective examination for Mr.
detective and team Morihiko No.1 by the founder of a team detective school of Japan finding their successor become the member of Q class, and play an active part in various incidents.
although it is made to blow natural dotage usually -- if compelled -- と -- although it has kyuu which demonstrates sharp power of reasoning, Meg who has memory at the moment, sharp kinta of muscular power and a can, kazuma which has data collection capability by the expert of a personal computer with a schoolchild, and gifted brains when becoming, rryuu with many mysteries serves as a body, and challenges all difficult matter affairs [Good point] Although it has special ability here to Kazuichi Kaneda's having natural gifted capability, respectively, they are persons ordinary type.
That is, characters including kyuu which comes out here are the persons almost near us the actual persons.
I hear that kyuu and others are the persons of touch which is required close.
(し [ moreover it is all the members minority ]) The posture in which such ordinary persons of touch are going to solve a difficult matter affair unitedly is good.
Although there is a place which exists too much and cannot follow sensitivity in those who have a natural talent like Kazuichi Kaneda, since the kyuu and others is ordinarily nearer, if it is said [ which ] whether be, even if the way of kyuu will have a sense of closeness and will make it inference, it can get used somehow and is cheap.
Therefore, if it pulls together not rubbing by the ordinary person and tackles, I will think that it is teaching that it can lead to solution in any incidents.
Moreover, Kazuichi Kaneda is famous Kosuke Kindaichi's grandchild, and if an incident does not build the appropriate stage according to a grandfather, either, he cannot demonstrate a characteristic.
But although the incident started close is tackled here, it does not have sense of incongruity, and it can take charge of various incidents irrespective of a scale.
Moreover, since the school of detective training is a stage, it is good for detective activities that it can be used [ teaching materials / various / a required tool, ].
[Bad point] In order that a reader may be compared with a previous work "the Kindaichi boy's cause-books" and may never lower motivation for the reason, the talk is continued to a subject, therefore the voltage of a work falls in the end, and the touch which the last is unsatisfying and the conclusion has attached carries out an incident with the debt by old enemy ` Pluto'.
I think whether it was able to delve into the talk to a slight degree.
Although the school was a stage and teachers, such as the 7 seas and Hongo, the student of a school, etc.
had appeared in it mostly besides Q class, it was regrettable that there was no place where they play an active part not much.
(し [ the party of a first class has finished with free ironic existence after all ]) [Comprehensive evaluation] Everybody will be the inference comics which were able to improve perfectly directly, if it concludes but ordinarily that it surely compares with "the Kindaichi boy's cause-books." Evaluation is [very good] because the form as inference comics is realized, although surely it is inferior to Kindaichi by the force of a trick or an incident.

2007/10/02 Normal [Original Japanese review]
by 前田清貴 Provider: 9818 Host:10088 Browser: 6520
The work which arranged Kindaichi with the chocolate chocolate.
There is no difference so much.
About the place where that it is different has fighting with a character and an organization "Pluto." Since especially differentiation with Kindaichi is not felt, I want to make it the evaluation of "being common."

2007/09/22 Very good [Original Japanese review]
by uuuuuu Provider: 40722 Host:40507 Browser: 8090
The trick was very pleasure reading each time.
The incident about the disappearance village in three volumes was surprised very well.
Although there was also a portion worn with Kindaichi just for a moment although a trick is interesting, I think that they are comics with sufficient まぁまぁ.

2007/09/10 Normal [Original Japanese review]
by RaRF Provider: 23812 Host:24071 Browser: 6214
The thing to the effect the concept of this work "offers [ a mystery is not made into comics but ] a mystery from comics" in author comment kana was written (-- is memorized).
Although there is much talk unsatisfactory as a mystery to be sure, as comics, the spy of Pluto considers being finished by him in what rryuu becomes who to be after 最, and the work which thought story nature as important.
An impression halfway as a story serious consideration reason and an inference thing is received.

2007/08/27 Worst [Original Japanese review]
by murasame Provider: 13120 Host:13077 Browser: 6306
as seeing the bottom -- Kindaichi's No.
2 -- brewing -- it is .
Although the talk and the trick were extracted, there was much time and there was little impact.
The appearance of kyara or character cannot be taking out the nature of kyara with the touch "it is individuality forcibly" at all.
Is also rorihiroin of pink hair and a twin tail past [ an aim ]?
-- still carrying out fixed printing of Kindaichi more than it たり -- etc.
-- the dependence to the past of a magazine is too high It is the bad peculiarity of the magazine editorial department which is going to take popularity easily.
In consideration of there being no novelty with the badness of the nature of Kodansha, evaluation is the [worst].

2007/08/08 Worst [Original Japanese review]
by 消しゴム Provider: 19880 Host:19932 Browser: 5234
I think that the greatest failure which the author committed by these work and "the Kindaichi boy's cause-books" is having neglected the care to a reader.
If it guesses not only with this work but with the ruler which says the inference work of animation and the boy magazine drama-ized as a "boy detective team" recently, inconsistency will be thrown into relief.
The Edogawa random step received the request referred to as drawing the inference work for children, and drew the "boy detective team." an Edogawa random step should be involved the bizarre murder which self made specialty till then -- た作風 was sealed, it is changing into a style with the high enjoyableness which says the contents that the boy detective team centering on the Kobayashi boy challenges the theater crime announced one after another by the hand of 怪 people 20 looks, and consideration of a reader was not neglected, but the breakdown of the concept called "inference work for children" was prevented Since heroes touched a murder case with the feeling which challenges a theater crime in the case of this work, it was visible only to the imprudent party and the speech and conduct of characters in the work of consideration of a reader being missing were also clear only about the thing which feels displeasure like a previous work "the Kindaichi boy's cause-books."

2007/08/05 Comment(bad) [Original Japanese review]
by 十傑集 Provider: 11009 Host:11078 Browser: 5234
Although the incident by which a teacher is murdered serializes [ be / it ] now -- what, wax and one short in stature and fainthearted student are plainly made into a criminal in the pillory, and are enjoyed -- that -- truly -- "-- it kills -- having -- natural teacher" -- depiction of-like If it is doing that commonness and the person who looked good are dampishness and 悪辣 in the shadow, although it understands, psychology or society of that what does not have the human being who is not roku so far, either about the long period teaching profession (close to a deputy schoolmaster in age), etc.
and a man are not such simple monochrome.
The evaluation with mental suspense high in the work which carries out depiction which treats such human being's subtlety and inflames a reader's feeling easily in which a murder case arises is not attached.

2007/06/23 Normal [Original Japanese review]
by Meteo Provider: 40410 Host:40427 Browser: 3162
It was expected that I wanted a book to become early by post Kanada 1-laver those days.
however -- although he bought one volume -- unsatisfactory one -- a word .
Although it is by no means bad, as mystery comics, it is unsatisfactory.
Although accepted, I wanted one [ have / rich individuality / a character ] to be fastidious in a mystery to a slight degree.
It is only unsatisfactory, and since there is especially no disagreeable portion, it is common.

2007/06/23 Good [Original Japanese review]
by 濁流の魔手 Provider: 18500 Host:18655 Browser: 4184
it is alike, and if compared, I will feel [ "Kindaichi" and ], on the whole, "it is light" It seems that the vocational "mystery-element" is thin.
a "story -- being related -- although it cannot say that it is bad, it cannot be said that it is" very good -- being such -- it feels and comes out Although it thinks that the members of a regular of a character are very individual and very very well, it will not be able to get tired of saying that it is individual except them.
とは -- since it is a favorite work individually, saying, the evaluation of "being good" is added [ make / have you / it ]

2007/04/09 Normal [Original Japanese review]
by Naooki Provider: 8516 Host:8589 Browser: 4928
Although it sometimes read, it cooked, when animation was carried out and it thought that it was fairly interesting, it was regrettable that was a little expensive.

2006/12/23 Bad [Original Japanese review]
by 十傑集 Provider: 11009 Host:11078 Browser: 5234
Illustrating seldom comes to a jar from Kindaichi's time.
They are already the wire rice field 1 and this level in story.
Is this one mashi so so in kyara?
Adult kyara of the experience richer than boys called a teacher by the favor of a setup (a thing like a detective admission classroom actually exists) called a detective school had also appeared perfectly.
However, the contents which were "common" barely in this are are lowered to "it is bad."

2006/01/29 Bad [Original Japanese review]
by Supan Provider: 2176 Host:2125 Browser: 5234
Was there nothing too pleasantly?
It skips the second half.
Not each incident independent almost had the element which excites interest as for an overall flow of a work.
The admiration which has already arrived at a stereotyped polar zone 謎解き ...
Isn't it an attractive pattern although it thinks that 画力 is the higher one?
Compared with the cause-books of this author's Kindaichi boy, a imaichi impression also regards characters as charm having been missing only by about thin kyara.
Favorite kyara was not.
It is whether although the series had changed to Kindaichi unawares, since it thought that it was like both being alike, even if it finished, there was especially any influence.

2006/01/02 Bad [Original Japanese review]
by 爆音 Provider: 15545 Host:15538 Browser: 5234
He had a feeling like Kindaichi's mere imitation, and an important story was not so interesting, either.
Since there were various talks here besides a murder case very well well, it was likable there.
since it was finely finished by the last, although it thought that it did not need to be extended by unreasonableness -- next time -- Kindaichi -- again .....
[bitter smile]

2005/11/03 Normal [Original Japanese review]
by 無線機 Provider: 17193 Host:17093 Browser: 4487
Having begun to read from a magazine is from the middle.
since -- the comic was read from the beginning Although the examination for going into the first DDS was able to be enjoyed, the point is not much interesting [ with the same 話ばっ loan as Conan ] less.
It is that the last rryuu finally becomes by no means in the incident which was being made into the criminal ...

2005/09/10 Very bad [Original Japanese review]
by somnia Provider: 6666 Host:6602 Browser: 3875
It did not care for what or imaichikyara.
It is し [ the contents were not so interesting, either ] something.
Mind that hints all have not been collected ...
Did Kindaichi start again?
He likes Kindaichi individually.
evaluation is very bad -- coming out -- 。

Next / Post your review / Top page

Other media
Anime:Detective school Q (Tantei Gakuen Q) / Drama:Tantei Gakuen Q

ALERT: You cannot use open proxy or TOR for posting your review. If it is detected, your access to this site will be prohibited.

Rule for reviews

This site allows you to write reviews for each title, but we don't allow you to criticize others' comment. Too bad or meaningless words are also not allowed. The comment which doesn't follow the rule will be deleted. If you find any comment which doesn't follow the rule, please notify us by clicking Suggest to delete.

Example to be deleted frequently

Favorite side
You dislike this one, then don't see it or comment this title
- Please go to the fan site. Anyone has the right to say what they feel in this site.

Disliking side
Do you like this one? You are stupid.
- Your view is only your view. Please concentrate on only the content of the title, not on others' comment.

Please use only English. If not, the comment will be deleted.

Your Name(Required)

Password (Required. more than 4 characters)

Your comment about this anime(Required)

Your evaluation of this title(Required)
You can choose the evaluation only once. After you post your evaluation, please choose comment instead of evaluation from the options.

Evaluation of this title(You can choose this only once)

Best!!
Very good
Good
Normal
Bad
Very Bad
Worst

If you evaluated this title once, please choose comment instead of the evaluation.
Comment by the person who thinks this is good
Comment by the person who thinks this is normal
Comment by the person who thinks this is bad

Please choose appropriate option for readers.

Caution: Please post the evaluation which follows the rule.