Japanese works database(How to join/Help)
Top page: All/Only Reviews

Others
Site map

AllAnimeGameComicNovelDramaSp. effectJP movieMovie	Info:voice,game..	Reviewers	Diary
Search / Outside DB:

Comics ranking: Rank 5/in 4,125 titles (Total 471.24/Deviation 155.29) Rank 4 <= => Rank 6
Comics average points ranking: Rank 294/in 661 titles (Average 1.08(Good)/Deviation 53.60) Rank 293 <= => Rank 295 (more than 10 evaluatoin)
Comics ranking of 2003: Rank 1/in 89 titles => Rank 2

Gintama(Comics)

[Other version: RSS/Japanese version]

Other media
Anime:GINTAMA / Game:Ds gintama / Novel:Ginntama-sannenzkumiginpatisensei-

All
Reviews(Post)

Forum

Diary
2007/05/15

Images

Goods
(Books)

Latest Books: 2008/02/28 ():

Gintama 3 $95

Books(5hit) Sales/Latest					DVD(3hit) Sales/Latest			Music(3hit) Sales/Latest	Toys(12hit) Sales/Latest
Rank:1763846 Perfect Paperback:Gintama 01 2007/01/31 ()	Paperback:Gintama 1 Tag:$95 2007/06/30 ()	Paperback:Gintama 2 Tag:$95 2007/06/30 ()	Paperback:Gintama 3 Tag:$95 2008/02/28 ()	Perfect Paperback:Gintama 02 2007/03/31 ()	Rank:17988 Saiyuki: Complete Seasons 1 & 2 Tag:$98 2006/10/31 () Eval.:***** 1.Bad Boys saving people?? Ok way not something New	Gintama Season Sono 2 05 2007/12/04 ()	Gintama Season2 06 2008/01/01 ()	Rank:397606 Audio CD:Gintama Tag:$99 2006/10/09 ()	Rank:43907 Toy:Gintama Characters Trading 4 Figure Gashapon Set Bandai

Information about this title

Hideaki Sorachi
SHUEISHA
Weekly Boys Jump
OKAWARA KUNIO

Released:2003 in Japan

Official sites
1. http://annex.s-manga.net/gintama/main.html (Translation)
2. http://jump.shueisha.co.jp/gintama/index.html (Translation)
3. http://www.j-gintama.com/ (Translation)

Statics of evaluation(The statics is updated once a day)

	Average	ComicsRank	Deviation(Total)	Evaluation points(Total)	Best of the Best
Inside Japan	Good(1.08)	5	155.29	471.24	8
Outside Japan	Good(0.00)	82	41.48	0.00

Statics of activity

	Total Views	Comment	Evaluation
Inside Japan	217,315	391	303
Outside Japan	3,187	1	1

How others evaluated in Japan

Best

Very Good

Good

Normal

Bad

Very Bad

Worst

People

Percentage

31.4%

20.1%

19.5%

8.6%

5.0%

5.9%

9.6%

Added percentage

31.4%

51.5%

71%

79.6%

84.6%

90.5%

100%

Summary

71%

8.6%

20.5%

Views for recent 8 days
Total 19 18 17 16 15 14 13 12
27 12 1 1 2 1 1 4 5

Language Sorted by date Sorted by recommendation New!
English Good
(Only Evaluation) Normal
(Only Evaluation) Bad
(Only Evaluation) All
(Only Evaluation) None
Japanese Good
(Only Evaluation) Normal
(Only Evaluation) Bad
(Only Evaluation) All
(Only Evaluation) All
This reputation board

Language	Sorted by date	Sorted by recommendation New!
English	Good (Only Evaluation)	Normal (Only Evaluation)	Bad (Only Evaluation)	All (Only Evaluation)	None
Japanese	Good (Only Evaluation)	Normal (Only Evaluation)	Bad (Only Evaluation)	All (Only Evaluation)	All

2007/03/18 Normal [Edit/Delete//Only this reviewer/Only this review/post sympathy comment/]
by Love and peace Review history[Good:15(83%) Normal:3(17%) Bad:0(0%)] / Provider: 15264 Host:15441 Browser: 3008
[Good points]
Sometimes the joke can be laughable.
Black joke is interesting.

[Bad points]
The story which tries to make people have tears
are so boring.

[Total]
As the comics for boys comics magazine,
it is intersting because black joke is rare
for magazines for children.
But if this one is in the magazine for adults,
I think this one cannot be so impessive.

Post your review / Top page

Other media
Anime:GINTAMA / Game:Ds gintama / Novel:Ginntama-sannenzkumiginpatisensei-

The below reviews are translated automatically from Japanese ones. To post to English version, please click here.

2008/07/19 Comment(bad) [Original Japanese review]
by SSP Provider: 17594 Host:17610 Browser: 5234
They are the comics to skip recently.
When you want to use the Edo period, I want characters to carry out at least in an utterance which makes Edo symbolize.
It is very lonely if it was set up only in order to only take laughter since there was no depiction in which this is told to and Edo is impressed.

2008/07/07 Best! [Original Japanese review]
by 努力家その一 Provider: 11601 Host:11740 Browser: 4184

[A good point]
- Understand through the silver, お登勢, etc.
(there may be prejudice) Edo's humanity and tenderness of people - A gag system, an impression system, usage with a system exquisite dimly (occasionally だけど) - Subtitle
[A bad point]
- There are many characters which are alike by the female character.

[Comprehensive evaluation]
I think that they are really interesting comics.
The author's autograph column etc.
is liked.
Since the character which is likely to be forgotten is also, I want you to take out.

2008/07/06 Comment(bad) [Original Japanese review]
by Anjieriina Provider: 26412 Host:26360 Browser: 9135
Does it seem that 24 volumes were put on the market?
I think that the too severe blood type discriminating utterance has appeared in 24 volumes also out of a problem in the talk of Shinpachi's correspondence.
It is 。 for which the author should apologize to a B type woman although it seems that it is tedious.
new [ speaking concretely, ] -- although 8 is the scene about which it consults by the thing of the letter of correspondence at the times of silver -- suddenly -- Hijikata -- appearing -- correspondence partner's woman's letter -- reading -- "-- it takes and where such a woman's is good This is a B type woman.
B type woman talks so that only its talk may be wound and it may build by the oneself kitchen, and she is [ whether it is 聞 and ] completely e about people's talk.
But even if it shakes the talk here forcibly, it is [ whether it is 聞 and ] e first.
It is necessary to do well fairly." like -- an utterance -- although it is not in the present hand since I did not buy a book but this scene was read in the jump, he remembers only this discriminatory utterance quite well Wasn't it corrected in the book?
Is also Hijikata a grudge to a "B type woman angrily without knowing why at Kondo?
It is not said that who is discrimination if it is prejudice only by " being heard.
a sermon -- it does not get angry at the time of favorite silver, either Hijikata -- Kondo's question -- "- !
Is it unreasonable although it reverse-gire with "?
This is not what gag is managed.
It is discrimination.
Discrimination.
A thing which will be the same level as racial discrimination or sexism and which is called discrimination of a blood type.
Is it allowed, whatever it may say, if it is comics full of gags?
Is it what may write a discriminatory thing?
Since it is comics full of gags even if it wounds a reader, or since it is 銀魂, is it allowed?
Since there was no depiction [ remark / of Hijikata ] "it was wrong", have I already been disappointed also at the author also at these comics?

2008/07/02 Normal [Original Japanese review]
by NIKONIKO999 Provider: 7456 Host:7532 Browser: 7395

[a good point]
-- a gag sense -- inside 々 -- it is interesting It is also individually good to feel risupekuto for the dragon ball.
With the Edo in the universe, and a thing also with an unprecedented setup sufficient as comics full of gags
[bad point]
battle - degradation is remarkable when serious - Skill of drawing is unripe and it has become a battle without an interest.
Moreover, since there is also no diplomacy, it is boring.
- Words are explanation tones and cannot be impressed.
It is bad for there to be a picture in comics, and for a picture to be disregarded and to talk so far.
A highlight cannot be well written like a hunter, either (although it deteriorated so that the hunter was out of the question).

[Comprehensive evaluation]
As the opinion of those who are seldom reading.

2008/07/02 Best! [Original Japanese review]
by kana=Clownlord Provider: 12649 Host:12481 Browser: 4184
Doesn't gag say?
It shines and is visible when main characters are gag in that there is an impression thing occasionally.
Is already 銀魂 the pillar of a jump for itself?
Of course, it is [highest!
It is ]!

2008/07/02 Very good [Original Japanese review]
by goodday0220 Provider: 40360 Host:40264 Browser: 2462
It reappraises anew.
Although are considered even now and tempo thought that it was bad since there were quite many characters of these work って words, when getting used, it turns out that it is a fairly interesting work.
These comics are the comics of practice.
A person that a favorite person likes it thoroughly and disagreeable is a thoroughly dislike.
However, I like this work.
The work with which the style has said my way has individuality, and it is quite good.
the contents say by comics by the breaking pitch considerably -- if it becomes -- "-- cutting -- alike -- reconstruction It is the style of touch equal to ", and since a character etc.
has individuality by actuality considerably, the rest is also in those who think is likable in this character for those who read.
(I am as strange as the silver -- him -- he likes madao and zura) it is also the work which remained in the jump that that is not right and well but until now when it was called those for everybody (Even if it thinks to a normal and becomes the close, I think that I am not amusing.) Since the thinking which that individuality is also quite strong has and people consider may be different, anti, the number of criticism, and many things are natural.
It understands, if it says that it also turns out that a fool of a time setup to which lower neta is considerably contrary from the common sense of the dislike and the world is made.
Therefore, there are also many people who are satisfactory even if there is a disagreeable person, and do not understand the merit of this work in my friend, either.
However, since this style is a work with which my way is said, a reckless run does not stop, and this work will continue until the author 飽きs bored.
However, since what to draw is a work currently drawn, probably this of it reading and being full of life may be the cause.
various -- explanation -- although it is writing that it is tedious, I like this work Since it thinks that it probably reads from now on, it aids.

2008/05/27 Normal [Original Japanese review]
by Kikona Provider: 23597 Host:23360 Browser: 5234
There are various talks fundamentally and I think that it is interesting.
He has a feeling that the picture is becoming suitable.

2008/05/25 Comment(good) [Original Japanese review]
by 夏野 Provider: 3797 Host:3866 Browser: 3875

[Good point]
All
[Bad point]
Although it is not bad, 創った people are neglectful feeling a little.

[Comprehensive evaluation]
Highest.
I want the skill of drawing of Mr.
Sorachi.
It is the first cause which began to buy a jump.
It carried out now [ hamatt てしま ].
Also younger brother.
Also mother.
...
Seemingly, a father is delicate.
What, this family.
Is it 銀魂 fever wholly?
...
I want to see It is very interesting.
It is interesting to the author (Mr.
Sorachi) highest at ん.
supposing skill of drawing carries out or, it is excessive -- I am favorite although those who are called ...
may also be Although having gone into animation ranking not showing a child can say nothing ...
(sweat)

2008/05/20 Good [Original Japanese review]
by 目〜日津字 Provider: 7948 Host:7886 Browser: 8090
Although it is interesting, it cannot laugh twice.
Although he bought it to ten-volume grade, it has sold to a friend.
In me, they are "the comics which borrows from a friend and is read." But it is since it laughed so that the belly became painful at the time of the first sight of the score...
It is although it wavers in evaluation...
It is "good."

2008/05/18 Worst [Original Japanese review]
by Anjieriina Provider: 9310 Host:9073 Browser: 9135
He liked a long time ago.
As to [ it / why ] it is, after the ikemen character had come out for comics full of gags, it is merely only it.
軽, - it is, and it sprouts, it reads with comics-feeling, and is better た.
し [ gag was not liking ].
although it might consider as the Hamah れば at the jar and possibly たま - might consider as niyari well, it was more common to get angry -- the speech and conduct of a character Although it sprouts well and skill of drawing is insufficient as comics -- It is the wonderful picture which looks dirty in why although how to draw the balance of a face or the body clearly is not necessarily amusing.
it is after irinuki of a line is not made but being drawn by the thin uncertain line -- it is At the time of sermon supernatural creature and silver of って and a hero with which what gets angry this and a curtain -- yatsu comparatively halfway nothing [ 倒幕 or nothing, and support for the Shogunate ] which is valid to the fantasy world [ parody at last ] It is a nonpolitical person.
not having a policy rather -- kakkoii and it -- porishii って思って -- yatsu with that right It comes out, and although there is no thought, it has the strongest fighting power.
But since there is no mind, the power cannot be used effectively because of a world.
It uses only to the extent that a neighboring trouble is crushed.
It comes out, and it is regarded as kakkoii and it meets.
something -- the uncanny past -- although he tries to want to be -- the past glory when two former friends will change a world, because it is doing its best in them, puu さんっぷり of the bear of this is conspicuous -- it is conspicuous If it comes out and nothing is only carried out, since there is nothing, although it is good and nothing is carried out, it preaches a sermon earnestly from whether it is troublesome.
Probably, there is no right which preaches a sermon at the time of the silver which nothing carries out.
ぎ which an attitude commits.
Although it preached a sermon, and good 事っぽい事 was said and being shown with a sufficient parenthesis, since a daily deed is are, I regret the character preached for such a man.
Or [ that it will be haughty since it is strong ].
Although there is also that the hero's character does not receive well Is having got angry extremely here recently slander related to a blood type?
In a certain scene, fortune-telling was trusted most, and the character which is not likely to be takes character to task in a blood type, and slandered B type woman earnestly.
And since especially the character was scolded, it did not become precocious.
As for the place limited to sex, 2 double belly stood by twice as many discrimination as this.
The words that A type is shameless also in the following talk Supposing it is gag, it cannot laugh at all.
What does the author consider?
How about considering [ naturally there are those who will get damaged if such depiction is carried out, and / since they are the comics which a child also reads ] to a slight degree?
Since the impression to the author became the worst before the character, it already reads and does not become precocious.
Sign [ why Takasugi is bandaging one eye the back and that a reason is drawn ] pear.
Variously neglectful.
Do only design and isn't there any reason?
天導衆 -- probably, he already (at 暁みたいな yatsu and others of NARUTO, it was the husband of the management of a government in the heavenly being) forgets

2008/05/17 Good [Original Japanese review]
by TKM Provider: 2393 Host:2280 Browser: 6342
Although it must be interesting comics ...
There are many causes which it is going to impress, and words.
swerve, carry and come out [ be and ] -- not seeing -- らい A picture is not necessarily so nice, either.
Although it is good anyhow well.
As [ be / shadowless / just for a moment / recently / thin / the hero / ...
] When those bad places did not exist, these comics were evaluated more.
But in the comics of a jump, I think that they are honest comics.
What was necessary was just to have carried out like this.
there being lower neta is not making [ many / not much ] it, although it is independently good -- it is Make it 1 talk conclusion.
It will not depend only for words but I will put in impression from which a picture is also transmitted.
Recently, the time of silver seldom appears and becomes precocious.
Since it is the hero of these comics, let's make it appear more.

2008/05/15 Very good [Original Japanese review]
by Ingurandokarakonnichiha Provider: 24292 Host:24035 Browser: 5234
although he planned to criticize severely and being read -- どっ -- deep -- it was rather interesting Tempo is also good.
Is it light at especially the time of the first stage?
The badness of tempo is worrisome rather than the numerousness of lower neta recently.
While each makes a fool of each other, in spite of progressing, an ironic place feels a favorable impression few there.
Although lower neta is dirty, since it is not almost written visually, it is not worried as me.
If compared with the comics which have a female dangerous picture strangely, I will think that it is dear.

2008/05/14 Worst [Original Japanese review]
by Matomaru Provider: 8267 Host:8073 Browser: 4925

[Good point]
Nothing
[A bad point]
Cold gag is conspicuous.
I will bite, saying "send a gal's panties"...

[Comprehensive evaluation]
It is boring.
This is useless.

2008/05/11 Comment(bad) [Original Japanese review]
by SSP Provider: 18834 Host:18864 Browser: 5234

[A good point]
The eye stopped at the abundance of the knowledge about lower neta, and quantity.
Well.
Isn't it the highest?
Those who rank with superbness and the right about obscene neta and illusion do not break, but have ability to the extent that it does not understand [ why it is carried by the weekly boy magazine and ].
Where was the ability cultivated?
It is individually interested.

[A bad point]
Since there are tastes about the view of the world which has looked down on Edo, reference is not made.
Putting in order only the beautiful things only for which it does not understand wanting whether do want to make it impressed or to receive sympathy is disgusted.
薄ら -- the place it is not noticed that is the act which fastens its cold head -- taking its hat off
[Comprehensive evaluation]
These days which thinks whether it is in obscenity that these comics exist itself.
It did not stop at considering but has changed to firm belief.

2008/05/11 Very good [Original Japanese review]
by Marioneto Provider: 18732 Host:18568 Browser: 5234

[Good point]
Gag is the highest!

[Bad point]
Lower neta is conspicuous.

[Comprehensive evaluation]
In the comics full of gags which met until now, it is the fun of the highest class.
And it is good that the serious talk is taught between such gag again.
Although "true 選組 disturbance editing" which also did animation especially recently is read how many times, it is moved to tears.
"Mr.
Ito -!
don't die - " て -- even if it turned out that it is useless, it was not alike involuntarily But those [ some ] who see since there is somewhat much lower neta may hold a feeling of dislike.
Please read at once the one where saying so is more nearly OK.

2008/05/11 Best! [Original Japanese review]
by 未菜瀬 Provider: 34284 Host:34138 Browser: 6287

[Good point]
It is interesting to use the historical person.
Are and it memory[ semantic ]-comes to be easy.
I also regard a picture as fairly good.
Various kinds may be also in a heavenly being.
May that there are also many 1 talk conclusions be readable?
There is lower neta very well, and since the talk of a long piece has many portions which can be impressed, it is good also there.
I feel that the high sensitivity to a reader is raised also for the individuality of each character.
I think that it may be idle, may be tsukkomi, may have a good appetite, or may be different one person [ one ] also in a stalker, mayoraa, do S, and others.

[a bad point]
-- the comics itself -- lower neta -- a few -- many -- animation -- a broadcast line -- it is last-minute -- it is
[Comprehensive evaluation]
Since a picture and a character are favorite, comprehensive evaluation is the highest.
The back, since the way of thinking is interesting, these comics are likely to continue very well.
the close -- a child's parents -- since -- a too much severe complaint does not come -- it seems to be infinite Since one of the sale of these comics is lower neta.
I want you to do my best from now on -- coming out -- peevish -- Mr.
Sorachi

2008/05/10 Best! [Original Japanese review]
by Chonmage Provider: 17630 Host:17532 Browser: 7590

[Good point]
A gag sense is やばい!
A picture is legible.
a normal -- saying -- the talk -- it is There is neither a naked body nor direct eroneta.

[Bad point]
There is much shimoneta on words.

[Comprehensive evaluation]
Although general comics will be thrust into a battle route, Mr.
Sorachi is protecting comics full of gags.

2008/05/10 Normal [Original Japanese review]
by pom Provider: 14055 Host:14209 Browser: 11343
Although it thought that it was the unique work which has a taste at first.
Once it thrusts comics of this sort into mannerism structure, can't it escape from them too?
Gag is very more interesting than the comics full of gags of the neighborhood (my - of same magazine printing).
It is ていう and comics full of gags, and is this ...
Although it is the feature of these comics that composition divides by the impression system and the gag system, a belch is already likely to come out of an honest impression system.
Although it is good so so as humanity monochrome, since not every talk has great difference so much, it is made or and the feeling ...
again.
But the direction which thought what もん kana will be killing time if a leg is carried even to a secondhand bookseller.
As it is, it is because it is interesting until it 飽きs bored.
smile free そん which does not see and become precocious since the animation version did not have the silver's voice -- since a work with what [ bad ] cannot be thought, either, it is made a normal

2008/05/09 Good [Original Japanese review]
by YSR Provider: 34839 Host:34708 Browser: 5292
He likes, it is peevish and I am this work.
the muddiness condition (≒ uncle condition) of the silver's eyes -- very much -- alike -- saying -- it is .

2008/05/09 Very bad [Original Japanese review]
by シロ犬 Provider: 19029 Host:19098 Browser: 4184
What is interesting and the work which is not known.
Since there is a fundamental flow of making it fade forcibly about gag and making it thrust in, it is thought that it is boring.
moreover -- the talk of an impression system -- each character (especially hero) -- a sermon -- since it becomes stinking, it cannot be immersed in sentimentality I cannot think that illustrating is also nice.
It does not care for the tale itself and the touch which is doing the thing favorite each time suitably by carrying out.

Next / Post your review / Top page

Other media
Anime:GINTAMA / Game:Ds gintama / Novel:Ginntama-sannenzkumiginpatisensei-

ALERT: You cannot use open proxy or TOR for posting your review. If it is detected, your access to this site will be prohibited.

Rule for reviews

This site allows you to write reviews for each title, but we don't allow you to criticize others' comment. Too bad or meaningless words are also not allowed. The comment which doesn't follow the rule will be deleted. If you find any comment which doesn't follow the rule, please notify us by clicking Suggest to delete.

Example to be deleted frequently

Favorite side
You dislike this one, then don't see it or comment this title
- Please go to the fan site. Anyone has the right to say what they feel in this site.

Disliking side
Do you like this one? You are stupid.
- Your view is only your view. Please concentrate on only the content of the title, not on others' comment.

Please use only English. If not, the comment will be deleted.

Your Name(Required)

Password (Required. more than 4 characters)

Your comment about this anime(Required)

Your evaluation of this title(Required)
You can choose the evaluation only once. After you post your evaluation, please choose comment instead of evaluation from the options.

Evaluation of this title(You can choose this only once)

Best!!
Very good
Good
Normal
Bad
Very Bad
Worst

If you evaluated this title once, please choose comment instead of the evaluation.
Comment by the person who thinks this is good
Comment by the person who thinks this is normal
Comment by the person who thinks this is bad

Please choose appropriate option for readers.

Caution: Please post the evaluation which follows the rule.