Japanese works database(How to join/Help)
Top page: All/Only Reviews

Others
Site map


Search / Outside DB:

Comics ranking: Rank 71/in 4,211 titles (Total 94.98/Deviation 69.49) Rank 70 <= => Rank 72
Comics average points ranking: Rank 136/in 692 titles (Average 1.69(Very good)/Deviation 58.81) Rank 135 <= => Rank 137 (more than 10 evaluatoin)
Comics ranking of 2004: Rank 5/in 88 titles Rank 4 <= => Rank 6

Minamike(Comics)

[Other version: RSS/Japanese version]

Other media
Anime:Minamike

All
Reviews(Post)

Forum

Images

Goods
(DVD)

Latest DVD: 2008/01/15 ():

Minami-Ke 1 [Region 2] $49

DVD(2hit) Sales/Latest		Music(8hit) Sales/Latest
Minami-Ke 1 [Region 2] Tag:$49 2008/01/15 ()	Minami-Ke 1 [Region 2] Tag:$99 2008/01/15 ()	Rank:665626 Audio CD:Colorful Days Tag:$49 2007/11/27 () Eval.:***** 1.First Series Title Tune and end themes.	Rank:897254 Audio CD:Minami-Ke DJCD Minami-Ke No Mina, Vol. 1 Tag:$49 2008/04/01 () Eval.:***** 1.Not music, but lots of talking!	Rank:905541 Audio CD:Minami-Ke Tag:$99 2008/01/29 () Eval.:***** 1.A Drama CD in Japanses	Audio CD:Minamike-Owari Ed. Theme Tag:$99 2008/01/29 ()	Audio CD:Minamike-Owari Ed. Theme Tag:$98 2008/02/12 ()	Audio CD:Minamike Caracter Song Album Tag:$98 2008/04/29 ()	Audio CD:Vol. 2-Djcd-Minamike No Minakike Tag:$49 2008/05/27 ()	Audio CD:Minamike No Minakike-Sp1 Tag:$49 2008/07/01 ()

Information about this title

Koharu Sakuraba
Koudansha
YOUNG MAGAZINE

Released:2004 in Japan

Statics of evaluation(The statics is updated once a day)

	Average	ComicsRank	Deviation(Total)	Evaluation points(Total)	Best of the Best
Inside Japan	Very good(1.69)	71	69.49	94.98	2

Statics of activity

	Total Views	Comment	Evaluation
Inside Japan	27,701	47	42
Outside Japan	436	0	0

How others evaluated in Japan

Best

Very Good

Good

Normal

Bad

Very Bad

Worst

People

Percentage

31.0%

26.2%

28.6%

11.9%

0.0%

2.4%

0.0%

Added percentage

31%

57.2%

85.8%

97.7%

100%

Summary

85.8%

11.9%

2.4%

Views for recent 8 days
Total 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 30
9 1 3 2 0 2 0 1 0

Language Sorted by date Sorted by recommendation
English Good
(Only Evaluation) Normal
(Only Evaluation) Bad
(Only Evaluation) All
(Only Evaluation) None
Japanese Good
(Only Evaluation) Normal
(Only Evaluation) Bad
(Only Evaluation) All
(Only Evaluation) None
This reputation board

Language	Sorted by date	Sorted by recommendation
English	Good (Only Evaluation)	Normal (Only Evaluation)	Bad (Only Evaluation)	All (Only Evaluation)	None
Japanese	Good (Only Evaluation)	Normal (Only Evaluation)	Bad (Only Evaluation)	All (Only Evaluation)	None

Post your review / Top page

Other media
Anime:Minamike

The below reviews are translated automatically from Japanese ones. To post to English version, please click here.

2008/07/26 Good [Original Japanese review]
by 果汁オレンジ Provider: 11059 Host:10838 Browser: 9363
You are drawing three sisters' every day indifferently.
Are you interesting?
The supporting players who come out in this work may be individual one by one.
w uncanny Hosaka's illusion and unpleasant [ illusion ] In the direction to laugh that is くすり, it is osusume.

2008/07/04 Normal [Original Japanese review]
by armada Provider: 23395 Host:23357 Browser: 10308

[Good point]
A picture thinks skillful い considerably on the individual target with which a lack [ the feeling of minerals of a quite interesting picture and a motion ] is taking out a peculiar atmosphere by some time.

[Bad point]
Although it is reverse, it cannot be laughed as a good point at all by the time (opinion with honest って's with more time at which it cannot laugh).
time: at which it can laugh -- time = which is not interesting -- it is also slightly weak to carry in the serious talk suddenly about 1:3 Since a character writes it as it and a part injury has not been carried out "whom.
Is there " very well?
It reads very well and this is て疲れます.

[comprehensive evaluation]
-- he also buys the book -- carrying out -- comrades -- although it worried with like -- "-- made to usually strain oneself by " -- too much -- surrealism past る's -- these comics -- air -- the cause carried out to みたいな existence -- it will be -- how to keep between, as for the animation version, although it is unnecessary addition -- being bad -- so much -- interesting ...

2008/07/03 Best! [Original Japanese review]
by ゆかり御飯 Provider: 18003 Host:17796 Browser: 2144
The feeling of air of the width which is a honto lover although it entered from animation.
Isn't it suitable for people with the tendency to ask comics for many?
It is white, in addition a background is everything.
But he is favorite.

2008/06/22 Best! [Original Japanese review]
by Tanpo Provider: 22916 Host:22973 Browser: 6287
The everyday warm-heart comics of such school things are favorite.
it thinks actually and they are ちゃう and " -- a place which it regards as " -- being certain -- かもしれませ -- although -- they are comics to put it bluntly -- carrying out -- that -- this author's characteristic (?) it is -- と -- I consider し it can read freely -- which character -- it is lively -- てい -- reading -- て -- it is pleasant The atmosphere of the comics which this man makes is very good....
Supposing it is dissatisfied ...
Although it is about [ regrettable ] that it is a series with little number of pages carried in one week biweekly comparatively, now, it has got it used whether that pace is good one rather regardless of evaluation of the work itself.

2008/06/21 Good [Original Japanese review]
by Aiu Provider: 25769 Host:25829 Browser: 6520
There was no impact at first, and although it had an instinctive dislike, it was able to be laughed very well that it read.
good -- coming out -- 。

2008/06/19 Best! [Original Japanese review]
by 黒銀猫黄 Provider: 18003 Host:17764 Browser: 2051
の, ~ んびり every day is passed.
Although such a thing may be considered whether to be interesting ....
It is interesting.
Kana (hero) runs recklessly, chiaki (hero) stops it, and haruka (hero) is watching with a smile like the Buddha (it is the overstatement kana which is called ....).
Is it touch?
It does making ~ んびり to まぁ bitter taste into a motto.
in the general world's evaluation, those who fit in fit in to where -- らしい -- although it comes out and becomes empty -- それって ....
natural -- it is -- It is !
anyhow.
Since it is an interesting work even if it takes, please take in your hand by all means!

2008/06/12 Good [Original Japanese review]
by Torahamukun Provider: 34156 Host:34123 Browser: 2067
It is common every day until it gets tired.
Is it 漫画 which can be enjoyed with the looser style made leisurely as the language although read how many times and which is very a light?
and the work said like this -- a style -- 作 -- although that there is neither impact nor gaiety etc.
will receive some unsatisfactory impressions because a style, the individuality which compensates this work with it is shining particularly It is in the words of a character with the individuality.
dotage and tsukkomi -- 一つにしても -- the expression -- one by one -- fine -- a peculiarity -- it is -- for example, a certain dotage -- receiving -- "- It is not made to bite tsukkomi with the 風な quick action ", but a thing is said in argument.
Although expression a little roundabout for tsukkomi may be carried out, it is exact, since it is convinced strangely, tempo is good rather, and nature and a smile also light up.
How to take between is also exquisite and it is sushi.
May any nonchalant warmth be how depending on which those three sisters' relations and a surrounding character touch, and in it the back?
This work is one of the pleasure of atmosphere.
Evaluation is "good." While the contents are readable with a crunching sound by the short story, the shortness, therefore talk finished halfway can also be seen every now and then.
So, or [ that cautions are required since a surprising dodge will be received if がっつり読 is also うと(ed) ].
Although a style passes, it is leisurely as.
It comes out and is peevish and is 。.

2008/06/11 Best! [Original Japanese review]
by kana=Clownlord Provider: 12867 Host:12635 Browser: 4184
It is interesting if it says clearly.
this -- being interesting -- a joy which goes into kotatsu dimly on a cold day of winter which is called not stimulative pleasure, such as unreal in roaring with laughter fighting, but common every day, and which makes people quiet, and eats a mandarin orange, and pleasure It is a work with such pleasure.
Privately, the mismatch of the character of characters can be enjoyed very much.
A picture is also legible, and I think that it can be pulling out fully, without the individuality of a character also darkening.
Is it intoxicated by the Sakuraba world certainly?

2008/06/07 Good [Original Japanese review]
by 豊饒 Provider: 11248 Host:11441 Browser: 4666
It cannot laugh, so that it says clearly and a belly becomes painful.
However, it is looking, and it is not irritated and くすり and laughter are invited.
Although it is about the negligent condition of an after background, it especially seems somehow whether to be this man's characteristic, and is not recently worrisome (smile).

2008/04/21 Normal [Original Japanese review]
by 眠い Provider: 1472 Host:1509 Browser: 4184
They were the comics in which three sisters and surrounding men pass everyday life freshly.
With a work which remains in an excessive impression, I think whether there was nothing and that they are the comics read without thinking deeply.
Do you only find the Ryosaku animation which developed the strong point further after this understood the original, and having pushed a wish of the supervisor itself and ego, and become the origin of each unpleasant animation?

2008/04/17 Good [Original Japanese review]
by goodday0220 Provider: 40360 Host:40264 Browser: 2459
I think that it is a work exactly good for exceeding tiresomely.
Although a background and a character are a little coarse, if it reads thoroughly unlike animation, since sense of incongruity will not be felt to there, it is not scrupulous to there.
Moreover, although the contents are also comedy みたいあず comics Daio and きすたみたいな every day and, as for あず comics or きすた, individuality is felt [ many ], since the touch from which it escaped somewhere is carrying out the Minamike rather than it calls it individuality, it is not peculiar.
Therefore, is it 漫画 which is recommendation for reading to kill time?

2008/02/26 Very good [Original Japanese review]
by Noosan Provider: 3245 Host:3051 Browser: 4184
Since animation was interesting, he bought a four-volume breath and step was kept with it.
It is very interesting after grasping this work, and the name and character of a character generally.
Therefore, although the 1st week "thought whether it would be slightly delicate", the 2nd week was able to be enjoyed extremely.
even so, Hosaka is good -- it is 味出(ing) Since there is much indifferent talk, it is a good spice.
The character which No.
1 incidentally likes is atsuko.
It is weak.
Is the place from which I do not have a talk heard very much dear?
It is superior (?) about an after can.
Are they things when it opens?
since there are many negotiations like a comic dialog -- a comic dialog -- it is recommendation in the favorite one

2008/01/31 Good [Original Japanese review]
by 濁流の魔手 Provider: 13357 Host:13470 Browser: 4184
it was alike and interesting Although it was the comics of a system the every day developed with peculiar paste "だろ.
It.
truly .
There was also a thing to come to call " plentifully.
It is slightly regrettable.
Although he wants to say about illustrating that there is especially no complaint, there is no motion.
Although it is a yuruyuru system, a feeling of a lively motion was deficient in the picture.
But inside of tolerance level.
It got used immediately.
It was able to laugh about the story (gag).
Although I browsed by animeito, it might often blow off.
It will be splendid if it is at least it.
し [ the comics full of gags at which it cannot laugh at all are sad ].
There is especially no complaint about a kyara setup.
Individuality is in character.
Based on the above thing, evaluation is "good."

2007/12/16 Comment(normal) [Original Japanese review]
by 我流側転 Provider: 6163 Host:6236 Browser: 4184
[Good point] It is interesting.
[Bad point] It is not real.
[Comprehensive evaluation] It has not said well....................

2007/11/18 Very good [Original Japanese review]
by 古代米ダブル Provider: 35109 Host:35055 Browser: 7395
Yes, is it a comedy work favorite food I every day?
It is written to the belt of these comics etc.
"this tale draws 南家 3 sister's common every day with たんたん.
Although there was a phrase do not carry out too much expectation", too much expectation etc.
was not carried out and this work met my expectation earnestly.
First, are all talks the short short story of 8-page composition except for the talk of the one-volume beginning as a feature of this work?
They are the comics which can be read with さくっ with snack feeling.
Although this readability is also one of the charm, the essence of this work is in the gag which poked by surprise [ the ].
although merely passing and reading also has an interesting thing, if it reads thoroughly -- the words of each kyara -- what -- it is -- one will notice the meaning put This will become still more interesting, if you it-examine and it reads.
For example, the last one character was extracted and what has been visible while [ of "the pure white bread" of four talks ] looking for bread, even if it carries out for going down is well formed into an incorrect evil spirit.
Does this work have fun just like a comic dialog using language skillfully?
Moreover, it is also the mind which has much kyara like air while very much good kyara is also about the character of this work....
Does the greatest demerit of this work mass-produce excessive kyara too much one by one?
It is ねぇ although the leading role's 南家 3 sisters are still まぁ and really wonderful kyara.
May a reaction although it was the elder sister who may be gentle, when a weak point is usually grasped about haruka, and somewhat untidy character be interesting first again?
Isn't there "any baka guy" calculating so far so about kana?
I think that it is kyara which is just "the slight difference of baka and genius." About chiaki, the gap of tsukkomi without forgiveness and character child-like somewhere does not accumulate.
It can laugh at a tangle in kana truly.
Is 跳ねっ毛 of the head worrisome as me the back?
Do I like others (smile) and Hosaka something who want to hold?
also coming ....
I am sorry it is the 2nd sheet -- as -- the 3rd sheet -- touch is interesting About 画力, I think that it is the comparatively higher one.
....
of the picture at the two-volume time is also pretty with a sufficient degree as me.
Well, does he like it?
The latest pattern is the touch which has changed very much compared with the beginning and has separated a few from my liking.
Moreover, although it seems to have extracted the hand apparently only with white grounds about the background, in the meaning of turning a vector to the expression of kyara etc., I think that it is comparatively effective production.
Evaluation presupposes "It is very good." I think that this work is what has many gag of an exhaustion system heterogeneous in a comedy every day since it has the jar of strange laughter.
Do I recommend the direction which the comics treating every day like "あず comics Daio" like, or the direction which likes the laver of a comic dialog?
Although the present animation is broadcast and being looked of course as an original fan every week, I think soon like [ that one / evaluate and ].

2007/11/17 Best! [Original Japanese review]
by Sharu Provider: 1407 Host:1254 Browser: 5598
It was viewing and listening to the animation version, and since it was very interesting, 今作 which hits the original was also read.
Since there are neither a sound, nor operation and a color, although inferiority with the animation version cannot be denied too, I think that it is the work which can still be enjoyed fully.
illustrating -- a background is hardly described but the field consists of only character sketches mostly The direction of it feels it refreshed and is readable, and since a character sketch looked nice, while reading and advancing, it stopped being not much worrisome, although it was dissatisfied a little when beginning read about the point with little depiction of a background.
The direction of a character sketch has a deep line drawing, it is drawn sharply firmly, and I think that the dress and looks of each character are expressed firmly.
Although a line drawing is deep, neither depth nor sultriness is felt for the expression of each character, but it is felt refreshed, and I am a good impression and also regard change of sushi and its expression as it being very colorful, looking and not 飽きing bored.
It stopped moreover, being not much worrisome, although distinction of each character sometimes thought several times that it was difficult when beginning read as it reads and advanced.
Story deployment is mostly based on the animation version, and a story is developed focusing on individual 3 sisters and the friends of those.
The pattern of various debts of each character can be enjoyed, and it is very broad to a system in gag twining a 腹黒 system, it is reading, and is very interesting.
It is individual, and the whole of every character has intense impact, and it regards it as not reading and 飽きing bored.
Moreover, although there is a scene where some sex appeal element is felt as well as the animation version, since it is not a kitsu potato so much, I think that he feels easy fundamentally and can read.
Whenever the talk progresses, is the point that an individual appearance character increases rapidly and the view of the world becomes busy a good impression?
Since it thinks that it gets used while also reading and advancing the direction which each character distinguishes in writing, I think that it is not a problem so much.
Moreover, the number of pages for every talk is short, and illustrating and the point which reads with sarasara easily and is advanced since it is sharp and very readable are good impressions.
I think that illustrating is sharp and simple, it is very readable, all the characters that appear are individual, and it is Ryosaku who can enjoy the pattern, the gag in which lenience and severity are free, and tsukkomi of various debts.
I think that it is reading and a tedious feeling is not felt on the basis of peaceful everyday depiction since it is a very busy style, though and.
Moreover, since a view of the world is brightly positive and very busy, I think that it is a very sociable work.
Since it thinks that especially the point that is reading and thought was dissatisfied is the work which there is nothing and was able to be enjoyed very much, evaluation is made into the "highest."

2007/10/31 Best! [Original Japanese review]
by Naooki Provider: 4076 Host:4085 Browser: 8090
although he bought it to four volumes -- individual -- from three-volume grade -- also distinguishing in writing -- it became intelligible -- carrying out -- kyara -- めっちゃ -- dear in whether the presence of interesting and favorite sewing [ two volumes to ]-based ふじおか is uncanny -- it carries out, and it is individual, and the big brothers of touma are also interesting and he likes them Having animation-ized also occurs and I want you to come out popular more from this month.

2007/09/23 Very good [Original Japanese review]
by 黒呂 Provider: 12835 Host:12944 Browser: 6308
[a good point] - it talks and even が is touch that there are not すら読めます and especially big climax, either and the talk continues indifferently - great laughter is impossible although there are my each time and the omission which are the talk of a 1 talk conclusion fundamentally ...
it is laughter to the extent that a smile is floated for a while -- however, that thinks that it is also a place with these sufficient comics - since individuality (the characteristic -- is it ...?) has clarified, 南家 3 sister also regards surrounding kyara as seeing in comfort I throw away every kyara and think that not a piece but the place which is required kyara is also good.
- the thing with this author's pure white kyara picture or background should not be in the talk of these comics very -- it was felt as ..
- There is also a pattern which is made to draw every day since it is a non-日常-place and comics, and he likes.
- I thought that the thing of the touch called delicate expression could be drawn well.
[a bad point] - although already stated -- a face -- drawing -- a part injury ...., and the color and dress of a hairstyle and hair -- since -- all faces look the same to the extent that it is bad, if kyara is not judged Touch which has increased kyara is received especially by the hairstyle.
If a hairstyle is made the same ...
Who is not likely to understand anymore who it is ...
[Comprehensive evaluation] There was especially no point of a face that draws and is worried except a division.
or [ that the direction of animation-izing becomes what sure enough ] ...
since it is the comics which may not have the honest motion which is just going to be worrisome ...
if I have the atmosphere of comics taken out even if it animation-izes -- then, good kana -- I consider Evaluation is "very good."

2007/09/21 Good [Original Japanese review]
by 八郎太 Provider: 18003 Host:17799 Browser: 4663
Is it the work with which Mr.
Sakuraba koharu's sense shines?
It is interesting.
Only always the people which cannot hate all kyara, either.
They are the baka guys who should love.
Especially Hosaka is saying and 味出(ing).
it is unpleasant -- it can say -- it can say -- certainly [ parenthesis ] -- him if a difficulty is not read 2 or 3 times, it is being unable to grasp kyara -- it is Other people think that writing part injury a few has not been carried out as his statement れている.
At this point, it is inferior to a previous work "today's 2 of 5." (others -- it is not said that there is no point of being inferior) Since he can be enjoyed with surasura if even the face and name of まぁ and kyara are grasped, evaluation is "good."

2007/08/14 Very good [Original Japanese review]
by Shirasu Provider: 32507 Host:32497 Browser: 5234
It thinks that kyara may be valid, and although there is no momentary laughter, I think that it may be interesting on the whole.
As shown in "today's 2 of 5", simple laughter may suit.
About [ that there is much kyara supposing it gets a fault ] But it is the touch which this is likely to say again.
It is bought, and I spoil and think that they are comics.

Next / Post your review / Top page

Other media
Anime:Minamike

ALERT: You cannot use open proxy or TOR for posting your review. If it is detected, your access to this site will be prohibited.

Rule for reviews

This site allows you to write reviews for each title, but we don't allow you to criticize others' comment. Too bad or meaningless words are also not allowed. The comment which doesn't follow the rule will be deleted. If you find any comment which doesn't follow the rule, please notify us by clicking Suggest to delete.

Example to be deleted frequently

Favorite side
You dislike this one, then don't see it or comment this title
- Please go to the fan site. Anyone has the right to say what they feel in this site.

Disliking side
Do you like this one? You are stupid.
- Your view is only your view. Please concentrate on only the content of the title, not on others' comment.

Please use only English. If not, the comment will be deleted.

Your Name(Required)

Password (Required. more than 4 characters)

Your comment about this anime(Required)

Your evaluation of this title(Required)
You can choose the evaluation only once. After you post your evaluation, please choose comment instead of evaluation from the options.

Evaluation of this title(You can choose this only once)

Best!!
Very good
Good
Normal
Bad
Very Bad
Worst

If you evaluated this title once, please choose comment instead of the evaluation.
Comment by the person who thinks this is good
Comment by the person who thinks this is normal
Comment by the person who thinks this is bad

Please choose appropriate option for readers.

Caution: Please post the evaluation which follows the rule.