Japanese works database(How to join/Help)
Top page: All/Only Reviews

Others
Site map


Search / Outside DB:

Comics ranking: Rank 4,014/in 4,213 titles (Total -8.06/Deviation 46.68) Rank 4,013 <= => Rank 4,015
Comics average points ranking: Rank 528/in 693 titles (Average -0.13(Good)/Deviation 43.49) Rank 527 <= => Rank 529 (more than 10 evaluatoin)
Comics ranking of 1983: Rank 34/in 34 titles Rank 33 <=

Oishinbo(Comics)

[Other version: RSS/Japanese version]

Other media
Anime:The Gourmet (Oishinbo)

All
Reviews(Post)

Forum

Images

Goods
(Books)

Latest Books: 2009/01/13 ():

Oishinbo, Volume 1 $99

Books(3hit) Sales/Latest
Rank:785221 Paperback:Oishinbo: Ramen and Gyoza: A la Carte (Oishinbo: a la Carte) Tag:$99 2009/05/19 ()	Rank:785222 Paperback:Oishinbo: Sake: A la Carte (Oishinbo: a la Carte) Tag:$99 2009/03/10 ()	Rank:785223 Paperback:Oishinbo, Volume 1 Tag:$99 2009/01/13 ()

Information about this title

Tetsu Kariya
Akira Hanasaki
Big Comic Spirits
SHOGAKUKAN

Released:1983 in Japan

Statics of evaluation(The statics is updated once a day)

	Average	ComicsRank	Deviation(Total)	Evaluation points(Total)	Best of the Best
Inside Japan	Good(-0.13)	4,014	46.68	-8.06

Statics of activity

	Total Views	Comment	Evaluation
Inside Japan	27,599	68	62
Outside Japan	359	0	0

How others evaluated in Japan

Best

Very Good

Good

Normal

Bad

Very Bad

Worst

People

Percentage

0.0%

19.4%

22.6%

11.3%

9.7%

14.5%

Added percentage

19.4%

42%

64.6%

75.9%

85.6%

100%

Summary

42%

22.6%

35.5%

Views for recent 8 days
Total 11 10 9 8 7 6 5 4
11 1 2 1 3 2 1 1 0

Language Sorted by date Sorted by recommendation
English Good
(Only Evaluation) Normal
(Only Evaluation) Bad
(Only Evaluation) All
(Only Evaluation) None
Japanese Good
(Only Evaluation) Normal
(Only Evaluation) Bad
(Only Evaluation) All
(Only Evaluation) All
This reputation board

Language	Sorted by date	Sorted by recommendation
English	Good (Only Evaluation)	Normal (Only Evaluation)	Bad (Only Evaluation)	All (Only Evaluation)	None
Japanese	Good (Only Evaluation)	Normal (Only Evaluation)	Bad (Only Evaluation)	All (Only Evaluation)	All

Post your review / Top page

Other media
Anime:The Gourmet (Oishinbo)

The below reviews are translated automatically from Japanese ones. To post to English version, please click here.

2008/10/11 Worst [Original Japanese review]
by 海月さん Provider: 30269 Host:30458 Browser: 7505
I take in the author's extreme political thought in comics, and think that it is the worst pattern which is pushed out on the whole surface.
However, I think that it is in that place just [ as if / recognition of the author ] and absolute currently drawn on the tale like to many social problems that it is the most dangerous with this work though research and knowledge are clearly insufficient.
although it may be thought that only the knowledge which is a famous work and which was investigated correctly is written since it carries out and there is explanation at full length, I do not think that the knowledge acquired with this work is absolute -- as .

2008/09/17 Good [Original Japanese review]
by mind Provider: 29983 Host:29908 Browser: 8090

[Good point]
The knowledge of - food sticks and the problem of modern society is in sight from food.
- Since extreme VS 至 quantity is not "the routine pattern" said that either surely wins, it can enjoy the whereabouts of a match purely.
- Presence of 海原 Oyama, and deep discord with Yamaoka.
A thing called a family and parent and child is made to be considered.
- It cannot become desperate with the taste of food, or mome たりする and characters hard to deal with cannot hate somewhere.
- Gag of the custom unfolded in the Cultural Affairs Department.
- The treatment of a character is nice.
it is not throwing away, either, only the same persons use, and it is made mannerism -- also coming out -- there is nothing --
[Bad point]
That - author's opinion and tastes come out makes a fool of the United States and Kansai too much, although not mattered, and it is 。.
It becomes the evaluation like "being very good" inevitably.

2008/06/07 Good [Original Japanese review]
by Guranzon Provider: 8732 Host:8458 Browser: 4926
Did he like at the time of the beginning?
Also comics and animation.
Animation is a place difference and I do no evaluations.
Confrontation of the menu of ultimate menu VS 至 quantity has many ultimate defeat or draws.
Henceforth [ middle stage ], it might seem that 海原 Oyama threw away the match and had yielded the victory.
Henceforth [ middle stage ], Oyama which was kitsui character like super-がつく has softened at the time of the beginning considerably.
Being talked down by Yuko たり.
The attitude [ as opposed to Oyama in some Yamaoka ] is soft...
Kana.
If it is called a dissatisfied point, is it a quarrel of the 3rd person?
The pattern which denies totally each other's food which a partner says, and Yamaoka enters in between and arbitrates.
Henceforth [ middle stage ], I especially think whether to be a quarrel of a child.

2008/05/28 Good [Original Japanese review]
by Bakaboke Provider: 29382 Host:29405 Browser: 7783(Mobile)
no, - are they a series, then る漫画 for a long time?
The viewpoint was changed and dishes various each time were shown, when it was the extreme and 至 quantity.
Although it does not become precocious, you read recently, and do the talk that a pickled plum rots, the talk which made chewing gum from flour remain in the impression?
Kana which was also able to enjoy parent-and-child confrontation of extreme 対至 quantity each time.
evaluation is good -- coming out -- 。

2008/03/15 Very bad [Original Japanese review]
by 消しゴム Provider: 50744 Host:50612 Browser: 5234
It is deficient in people feeling.
This thinks that it is the greatest fault of this work.
Although the original author's abundant knowledge and amount of researches have been grasped from 〓t〓about the food of Yamaoka announced by appearance in the work, and Oyama, and foods, the thing with expensive foods and dish to treat and the thing which rarely goes into a hand were most.
the episode in which it did not appear so much and politics and the social problem were involved with this work -- many -- the narrow sense of values of theirs and the original author -- a tag -- constructing -- a reader and a dish -- the case where width is used by the け there was conspicuous For the reason, it became the style with which enjoyableness was missing and the problem of the original author who does not understand the essence of cooking has been thrown into relief.
Since the series became long too much, it had also attacked severe [ of a work ] that it is the mudslinging which cannot manage confrontation of "extreme 対至 quantity."

2008/01/27 Worst [Original Japanese review]
by 闇夜のフェンリル Provider: 33466 Host:33448 Browser: 6391
The character which comes out is unpleasant.
Although it is the stance of dividing, and a hero entering and making it solve between the characters which are quarreling, charm is not felt for the fellows who are quarreling at all.
He cannot understand why the opinion of people cannot be asked to until so much.
Probably it is thought that this has difficulty in the author's humanity.
Probably, all the fellows that cannot consent to a hero's view are drawing character bad.

2008/01/27 Normal [Original Japanese review]
by ちょんまげVer.2 Provider: 10931 Host:11092 Browser: 5235
Unnecessary addition cooking comics which continued too much too much long.
This work is a great work which having created the gourmet boom and having not only made in fashion the word "extreme" but performed the great contribution to the reader to making the meaning of food ask etc.
"a meal." Although it is --, it is only the first half portion of this work that this language is accepted, and it has changed into the long work of a breath vainly like haribote which took clearly about the second half and was attached.
After Yamaoka it is [ whose ] the hero who was able to be pleasantly read with this work, and the Kurita two men get married, indifferent contents are conspicuous after that even by the appearance on gold.
Although a few can enjoy a child's birth and the crisis of Oyama something also in it, the rest is the touch which flat deployment continues and goes like neither barrel the better herring.
I will think that the taste of a character of the appearance which an original atmosphere when ups and downs also of characters are lost according to it, they go and appear fades, becomes to a common person, and goes may be lost, and it is what thing although it is cooking comics.
Now, holding a doubtful thought to the author seems to be a natural result.
Although it has said "Don't do to a company only for money-making by appearance in the work", is it only itself whom it thinks of that a counterargument is likely to come back in just you who are continuing writing it as daradara like this for money-making?
But since it is clear to have wonderful (for it to be foolish ?) senses, such as a ramen-noodles research institute, an international conference of a fried egg, etc.
which hang up the slogan which an interesting place has plentifully and was referred to as "Ramen noodles save the earth", I want to expect future deployment (it is -- although it is [ whether it has a sense to the extent that the expectation is met now, and ] a doubtful place).
Since it is from 50 volumes that the gold top appeared, I will consider having reached to 100 volumes now, and evaluation will presuppose "It is common" by 50:50.
Since he likes individually Jeff (are nice guy which a first appearance tells one hand in a color that itself's belief is for a kitchen knife), it is very regrettable that the position was consumed by black.

2008/01/17 Bad [Original Japanese review]
by 剣舞大使 Provider: 34156 Host:34147 Browser: 4749
Cooking comics which probably mistook time to quit.
It is the concept which people who are in the vortex of trouble in practice are made to eat cooking, and is arbitrated although I feel that it was for handing down meal culture correctly to future generations surely, or it was a big target that a newspaper publishing company is going to begin the plan "an ultimate menu", and is going to complete it.
Does the heart become quiet if people eat a nice thing?
Cooking comes out one after another and a few also becomes the study about a meal.
Although he was able to be enjoyed a long time ago, the quality of a work became burning down after "water confrontation" (it sees from me).
Is it the grade which rose for a while by "the crisis of Oyama" at most?
It is thought whether per Japanese all-prefectures taste circulation is gudaguda.
The time of Yamaoka and Kurita getting married, when a child is born among them, or when Oyama has returned from the deep pool of death, himself who has always reconciled others thinks that it is that reconciliation -> Loved with parents, and it loved, and was easy to come out.
It is safer to carry out by about 60 volumes, if it reads anyhow, and not to read after it.
A hit has a gap according to the talk well.
Since it is already hard to receive this present work, evaluation is "bad." Although the talk with the depiction which is going to make new kyara "飛沢" inherit making an ultimate menu was read, doesn't it get used to the already read mind?

2008/01/08 Good [Original Japanese review]
by 赤い水性のシャア Provider: 12661 Host:12506 Browser: 3034(Mobile)
Probably most famous cooking comics exceeding 100 volumes at last.
the picture is delicate -- although kicked -- cooking -- comment with frank saying that it becomes study ordinarily for itself [ favorite ] but good, since the hit blank of the interesting talk and the petty talk is intense -- it carries out [ it is alike and ] and solves

2007/10/29 Worst [Original Japanese review]
by toil Provider: 8709 Host:8504 Browser: 5234
Since it was too much hard to read a comment with some overheating, it reappraises.
Reflection does not become precocious by carrying out.
Although the owner of what thought is satisfactory for the author, is the character which becomes harder [ which makes its thought right ] with an enemy fabricated, and do you refute using Yamaoka, and can never allow only the posture of making unsightly appearance expose?
Although the author says all the same things as I consider in a general case, I burn and think how it is that there is [ for which I will express the intention of granting plural opinions ] nothing.
From such talks, there are much more tangle talk of light human relations and talk which carries out only cooking ordinarily, and it thinks that it is interesting.
However, a few dissatisfied points exceeded them and it also became strangely to already touch a book.
Although it is 100 volumes in one more volume, it does not see any longer.

2007/09/29 Normal [Original Japanese review]
by 前田清貴 Provider: 9818 Host:10088 Browser: 6520
These comics also greet 100 volumes at last, and it is better shelf -.
by cooking comics, it is the first inspiring feat -- he liked 海原 Oyama in early stages of ?
Well, it is [ whether it is しょう and ] now [ what / to say soon / word ].
"Although it does not know [ 雁屋哲 and ] somehow whether it is curious, if comics are drawn on the stage at all, live Japan in Japan!" I think that it is as こ which is not understood even if it will ど - Carry out, if it does not live in Japan.
Although it thinks that it lives in Australia and て is also looking over media of Japan well.
The nerve to live in Australia at comics 描いている's which made Japan the stage is a great abhorrence.
If it lives in Australia, should you move to Australia whole Mr.
and Mrs.
Yamaoka, and should not develop the talk?
But these comics are not disagreeable.
They are the comics which were very well suitable for acquiring the knowledge of cooking.
Is it "common"?

2007/09/28 Comment(normal) [Original Japanese review]
by Meteo Provider: 19923 Host:20075 Browser: 3162
The episode in which these comics are pleased reads.
I think that the episode which is not pleased has the rightest reading of not reading.
Individually, the talk of 30 volumes that the start is the most devouring, and the last pretentious couple's talk were quite good.
It was interesting.

2007/09/07 Bad [Original Japanese review]
by H&J Provider: 22725 Host:22557 Browser: 4184
Although it is the agricultural chemicals which are talks like asking for the moon rather than this work and meal culture (there is probably no opportunity he to eat at least one kind of high-class dish which comes out in that work) and by which やたら criticism is carried out About chemical-free vegetables having caused parasitic shortly, the discord over the many years which are the things I would like you to surely explain by somewhere The deployment in which reconciliation is completely materialized with one dish of dish is a great abhorrence, and in order to justify thinking of sushi Oyama, the point that a sense of values is contradictory the whole talk is also disagreeable.
However, since I am allowed to make characters' abusive language abuse into various parodeineta (it is the craftsman of sure" who has me and Mr.
ancient-times 2CH"海原 scold 種死 in fact), evaluation is discounted that much, and it is at "it is bad."

2007/09/05 Normal [Original Japanese review]
by Naooki Provider: 2140 Host:2162 Browser: 8090
Although Kurita is dear and liking, a picture is weak kana fundamentally.
The schoolchild had also read at the time of after, and since the contents were cooking, they were not understood too.

2007/08/26 Worst [Original Japanese review]
by 宇宙刑事ジャンギャバン Provider: 33223 Host:33285 Browser: 6287
As for the feature, there are many protests of the left [ やたら ] about whether the original author's thought is reflected.
Well, even if it sets it aside, it is amazed at a lack [ Shiro / progress ].
the fool degree which dances on the palm of a father and 海原 Oyama forever, does not notice the feeling of its 父憎し obstructing that itself grows [ humane ], and does not consider earnestly the meaning of the warning which a father emits, but is carrying out only total negation -- well, it is ざり

2007/08/19 Very bad [Original Japanese review]
by Bari Provider: 7447 Host:7264 Browser: 4483
It reads to 99 volumes and honesty is also obtained.
is it a limit at itself?
Since Windows criticism, the anti-Japan utterance, etc.
are seldom interesting, he is [ "A hero's Yamaoka does not grow" is worrisome from anything.
] good for according to anyhow...
It is although there is also no って事...
It is it!
"in five volumes -- having stopped the favorite horse race from could have and having been exhaustively talked down from Oyama by nothing cardiac" (it being made behind unawares again) Still, it is not shortened by the merit difference with Oyama, but Mr.
[ Yamaoka / itself ] accepts the defeat [ till then ] till then which it includes privately [ formula ] and is called six-win and 13-loss 15 draws in the talk in the wedding reception in 47 volumes.
by future confrontation, I will surely fight with worst 5 minute 5 minute victory or defeat -- although ...
was thought ...
Was it betrayed splendidly?
So that the number of times which the confrontation with 至 quantity won after it counts just it single hand ...
It is whether it is and the grade ?, awfully, and has lost in most.
rather than -- it is this draw clearly -- the match ろ!?
is also made into defeat -- honesty -- it is too amusing (Japanese all-prefectures taste circulation and Nagasaki editing of 98 volumes are the example) There is also confrontation which does not have a twist not at all of losing after all, atmosphere in which it is likely to lose clearly from the beginning again being.
((Edited by etc.) Japanese all-prefectures taste circulation and Yamanashi) Does Oyama become empty already somehow with carrying out to "Shiro does not grow" clearly at a mouth etc.
in the talk in 97 volumes again?
If it is this, I will also think ...
by it having been better to already make Oyama into a hero from the beginning.
Although only this continues for a long time, "a hero does not grow" has dozens times worse than seed fate.
no, "it not growing up"'s -- では -- is it righter for there to be nothing and to say, "be allowed to grow up and there is nothing"?
If it is that author, is it how to be allowed to carry out and twist?
Already, it is useless, and is sulky about the portion which does not have most important "growth of a hero" of the talk first, and they are these comics.
although it changed into honesty and the "worst" and like was thought -- the talk good for inside to be sure -- it was (7s ど which allow bullying) -- it stops for "it to be very bad" Finally, by impolite consent, know your own vessel before making the author a word as "Windows criticism, the anti-Japan utterance, etc.!!"

2007/08/18 Normal [Original Japanese review]
by Meteo Provider: 19923 Host:20020 Browser: 3162
The level of 画力 is quite high although it is these comics.
It is looking and a feeling is good.
The various human relations which surround Mr.
Yamaoka are interesting to the highest.
It was very agreeable in the talk into which love is well developed with curry bread.
However, it does too much just for a moment, and there is also the portion ちゃう or ?.
For example, this is not accepted although it is Windows criticism.
People's taste is each.
An utterance which denies low-malt beer is also with how it is.
However, there is too much depiction whose most disagreeable thing makes food useless.
If food is not pleased even if it makes it Oyama, し [ it is calm, it leaves, Mr.
Yamaoka is calm and it throws away spaghetti into a garbage can ].
It remains in honesty and an eye.
A thing with many after anti-Japan utterances is also disagreeable.
However, there is also much good talk and there are many opportunities to read very well.
although it is good anyhow -- north, south, east and west -- even if it goes where -- Mr.
Yamaoka -- 達 -- it will be in what to meet a male 3 suddenly -- ?
(smile) The supervising maidservant who interferes in love of people too much does not receive the back, either.

2007/07/28 Good [Original Japanese review]
by Sennuki Provider: 38066 Host:38071 Browser: 4203
I think that the problems in connection with the safety of food are a life-and-death problem and recognition with desire common to 10,000 people for a living thing of being just the dead oaa live and wanting to eat sushi and a delicious thing.
In such meanings, いち tackles the problem which will be translated and to say, and 本作 which reached even the major company by the expression medium called comics thinks that it was uncanny with it being gentle.
Especially usually [ of Mr.
Yamaoka / "] at the time of the first stage, although it was unsociable and being considered as むすっ, when deciding, it was able to decide firmly, and "非 is obediently permitted to itself, although it is muka つく uncle" (he liked episode of duck and sauce individually) kyara was also stabilized very occasionally at the time of non-がある, and it was interesting and was able to read happily also as a human drama.
[ of だけ smiling face" Oyama ] (about one - five volume order) correspondence of the government [ as opposed to / although it is good anyhow / a Food self-sufficiency rate or chronic agricultural depression of Japan ] -- although it already says from before for many years, it is yaba い variously It is at least to ぞっていう in やばいって level じゃ.
Among those, touch which starve to death wholly, or only a strange thing becomes impossible to a mouth, and is likely to ruin itself.
if it is sayoku when the author's thought is uyoku well -- honesty -- although it is uninteresting, since shokuyoku is important

2007/07/08 Normal [Original Japanese review]
by Kyandeii Provider: 26614 Host:26517 Browser: 3874
Don't make tofu and wine travel...
it needs to Yamaoka which grew fat -- there is nothing は ....
it was criticism at the gourmet -- ねぇ ...
long -- elapsing -- it is -- if there is no neta -- the one good at the original author -- いっちゃう(ing) ...

2006/10/17 Worst [Original Japanese review]
by K コバヤシ Provider: 17548 Host:17423 Browser: 7856
Evaluation is deserved as a few comics which took up cooking.
However, I do not want you to carry in the political talk into such comics.
And the place which some neta are fabrication without a basis and is truly writing the author's own illusion like the fact is not also whom other than displeasure.
Moreover, in Japan by which freedom of speech is secured, of course, like him, although it is also good to write a leftist opinion, this he that is criticizing present Japan feels that it is too incoherent to have emigrated to Australia.
Supposing it carries out Japanese criticism more than this, I will want you to come back to Japan and to criticize based on the fact fairly.
If it was not made, I would like you to stop a series at once.
Of course, evaluation is the worst.

Next / Post your review / Top page

Other media
Anime:The Gourmet (Oishinbo)

ALERT: You cannot use open proxy or TOR for posting your review. If it is detected, your access to this site will be prohibited.

Rule for reviews

This site allows you to write reviews for each title, but we don't allow you to criticize others' comment. Too bad or meaningless words are also not allowed. The comment which doesn't follow the rule will be deleted. If you find any comment which doesn't follow the rule, please notify us by clicking Suggest to delete.

Example to be deleted frequently

Favorite side
You dislike this one, then don't see it or comment this title
- Please go to the fan site. Anyone has the right to say what they feel in this site.

Disliking side
Do you like this one? You are stupid.
- Your view is only your view. Please concentrate on only the content of the title, not on others' comment.

Please use only English. If not, the comment will be deleted.

Your Name(Required)

Password (Required. more than 4 characters)

Your comment about this anime(Required)

Your evaluation of this title(Required)
You can choose the evaluation only once. After you post your evaluation, please choose comment instead of evaluation from the options.

Evaluation of this title(You can choose this only once)

Best!!
Very good
Good
Normal
Bad
Very Bad
Worst

If you evaluated this title once, please choose comment instead of the evaluation.
Comment by the person who thinks this is good
Comment by the person who thinks this is normal
Comment by the person who thinks this is bad

Please choose appropriate option for readers.

Caution: Please post the evaluation which follows the rule.