Japanese works database(How to join/Help)
Top page: All/Only Reviews

Others
Site map


Search / Outside DB:

Comics ranking: Rank 4,194/in 4,218 titles (Total -63.96/Deviation 34.32) Rank 4,193 <= => Rank 4,195
Comics average points ranking: Rank 602/in 696 titles (Average -0.78(Bad)/Deviation 38.00) Rank 601 <= => Rank 603 (more than 10 evaluatoin)
Comics ranking of 1998: Rank 68/in 68 titles Rank 67 <=

Syamankinngu(Comics)

[Other version: RSS/Japanese version]

Other media
Anime:Sharman King

All
Reviews(Post)

Forum

Images

Information about this title

Hiroyuki Takei
Weekly Boys Jump
SHUEISHA

Released:1998 in Japan End:2004 in Japan

Statics of evaluation(The statics is updated once a day)

	Average	ComicsRank	Deviation(Total)	Evaluation points(Total)	Best of the Best
Inside Japan	Bad(-0.78)	4,194	34.32	-63.96

Statics of activity

	Total Views	Comment	Evaluation
Inside Japan	62,131	96	82
Outside Japan	472	0	0

How others evaluated in Japan

Best

Very Good

Good

Normal

Bad

Very Bad

Worst

People

Percentage

1.2%

7.3%

19.5%

13.4%

22.0%

15.9%

20.7%

Added percentage

1.2%

8.5%

28%

41.4%

63.4%

79.3%

100%

Summary

28%

13.4%

58.6%

Views for recent 8 days
Total 16 15 14 13 12 11 10 9
9 1 2 0 0 2 2 1 1

Language Sorted by date Sorted by recommendation
English Good
(Only Evaluation) Normal
(Only Evaluation) Bad
(Only Evaluation) All
(Only Evaluation) None
Japanese Good
(Only Evaluation) Normal
(Only Evaluation) Bad
(Only Evaluation) All
(Only Evaluation) All
This reputation board

Language	Sorted by date	Sorted by recommendation
English	Good (Only Evaluation)	Normal (Only Evaluation)	Bad (Only Evaluation)	All (Only Evaluation)	None
Japanese	Good (Only Evaluation)	Normal (Only Evaluation)	Bad (Only Evaluation)	All (Only Evaluation)	All

Post your review / Top page

Other media
Anime:Sharman King

The below reviews are translated automatically from Japanese ones. To post to English version, please click here.

2008/10/11 Good [Original Japanese review]
by 海月さん Provider: 30269 Host:30458 Browser: 7505

[Good point]
It is generally good except the final stage.

[Bad point]
Although it is the last, make it - (seemingly, with the perfect version, made ど -).

[Comprehensive evaluation]
Although it ran recklessly considerably from the neighborhood where the inflation of 巫力 and character revival started, the result till then can be evaluated.
iron meiden -- it is dear

2008/09/16 Good [Original Japanese review]
by goodday0220 Provider: 40360 Host:40264 Browser: 2460
a certain meaning have a form of the close as a result of a setup being considerably impossible too much, although the Sherman king is reading and it thought that it was interesting -- it is also a regrettable work in fact -- individual -- a charm remarkable in this work -- it is -- a battle etc.
-- reading -- でい -- that a book is also assembled since it is intelligible たり -- てい -- it is the work which can be enjoyed after [ but ] unreasonableness has arisen to the talk gradually -- that dream -- a punch line -- it was sorry that-like has finished coming out to feel It is clear that it may get used to a work with more interesting probably suppressing a setup of hao to a slight degree.
Since a true climax's being due to be drawn is clearer than the perfect version, it is also the place which what end this becomes worries.
Although evaluation has become bad because of the close which "is good as for evaluation", it is thought with it being individual that this work has improved.

2008/07/13 Good [Original Japanese review]
by 仲村良一 Provider: 19923 Host:20085 Browser: 3234

[Good place]
A make lump of a feeling of - world is deep.
- Freshness of Mr.
macho 爺 who appeared in 18 volumes.

[Bad place]
It specialized in - legal ability person battle too much, and the inflation happened.
- The naming sense of a character is bad.

[Synthesis]
Comics which are peculiar for a signboard of - jump.
Even if it makes it a view of the world and makes it a character, it is not so straight and he has a feeling which became perverse.
- 18 volumes are musts.
The wonderful talk which macho Mr.
爺 fights by stark nakedness is recorded.
It is a shock since "bus taado" in mammoth ぶ lowering て戦う etc.

2008/05/19 Normal [Original Japanese review]
by SSP Provider: 8452 Host:8241 Browser: 5234
って which was regarded as this author having the really sharp view which sees things and "which will be done and returned if it does" was well versed in the internal trouble of such and such a place, or war, and was a wonderful message.

[Battle]
The world which the method of comrades does not have, either, if the strong soul is made into 持霊 or he does not become strong.
Charm was missing as the work battle was seen rather than a battle.
Were these comics setup quite deficient in application power, although supernatural powers and 巫力 became a base?
The character can be utilized thoroughly, and it twists, and feels and is full.
a character can be employed efficiently -- saying -- kana-り -- do you say that it is painful or with what understand at least it?
I consider.
Well [ なあーって思 / with the lower more interesting character of 巫力 ].
ぼず.
たまおは単 -- Mr.
mojimoji It is not needed.
BOZ followed hao with て or what.
Has it appeared even in the fan book?
About a battle, it subtracts for the time being.
The contrary of the words of the father of Jolo Jolo.
The law of the jungle is the language of abandonment.
Set in these comics.

[Story]
A story is [ nothing ] and is inadequate until it says.
It omits, after trying to want to complement well.
It takes and solves...
There was a place which bows its head in assent very well.
Only it.
Although Jolo Jolo-related episode was the best ...
the whole -- letting it pass -- "-- this -- what ぞ」って thought better た.
The talk is not connected.
It is all barabbara.
after all -- a leaf -- the reason for the Sherman king 指す -- って何 I want to carry out comfort.
hao is pushed down.
Friends are made.
Say foolishly.
There is no consistent theme.
Therefore, it is all episode.
the fellow who wounds "friend -- taking -- Kyo Mr." Therefore, ?
Is friend 守る's these comics?
The author wants to tell in many cases too much.
Couldn't he be collected?
They are really unclear comics.
not quite satisfactory, when it turns round like this -- they were the comics which are not carried out rapidly

2008/04/03 Bad [Original Japanese review]
by 心憂 Provider: 8709 Host:8574 Browser: 4926
This time comes, a friend is recommended and animation is seen [ made / have you / it ].
It was likable to the hero the opening part.
After actually entering in the end, it was likable, and even if looked at to the last, I considered.
However, may I finish it as "kore from the way of the last of the final stage?
The place called " is several places or ....
It is a regrettable word when it says honestly.
There was unexpected nature.
It is the unexpected nature in another meaning.
It is only it with ....
about whether I may finish it as such halfway deployment.
In order to regain the part which finished halfway, that you are newly drawing comics will waver [ whether will buy it honestly and ], although that is right.
Although there is a feeling to worry ....
This work is favorite.
It tells.
Although I was not also the social position which can be criticized, since I was a favorite work, it dared have written.
Poor writing I am sorry.

2007/12/16 Very good [Original Japanese review]
by 豚まんじゅう Provider: 7305 Host:7560 Browser: 4184
[Good point] Each characters of a work are fresh and attractive.
[Bad point] It became in the second half of a tale, and became the good tendency to use it too much, especially about the ability of people to be revived now (it is made to revive although a friend dies).
[Comprehensive evaluation] My having read this work and having been surprised from anything is that the view of the world of a work and the preparations for it have improved.
The characters who appear into the Sherman king's work I think that the all move very attractively because it is the data in front of it or the preparations of reference etc.
and a character setup have been performed firmly.
If a work with such a view of the world like this with until [ various ] is built, I will think that absurd preparations have probably been needed.
I feel strong the passion turned to a work called Mr.
Takei's Sherman king for this work.

2007/12/16 Worst [Original Japanese review]
by 海上 Provider: 19847 Host:19737 Browser: 7781(Mobile)
I think that it was interesting at first.
Also the view that a leaf is loose being also peculiar and thinking like this that a ゆう view is also interesting たり.
Fighting in an exaggerated soul also liked and, as it is, kyara also liked.
-- At least in the Sherman fight 本選, all of body wax and kyara began to become disagreeable.
The view of a leaf and action are also exceeded through ゆるい and began to be visible to a mere egocentric thing.
If such a way will probably be interesting or carries out like this on a story, the view of a leaf will regard the unexpected nature that it will be reader 驚く as the author having attached too much, rather than it says.
since -- as for a leaf, free [ along which a line does not pass ] is random -- lose -- it is excrement gaki as realized by carrying out (Being dirty language.
I am sorry.) but I have done the rank in of the leaf to the disagreeable hero best 3 by this cause still better [ わず / friend and foe, ] in a leaf -- it is carrying out and raising -- it carries out and a story also instigates it As for the leaf with right thinking of a leaf, that it is an uncanny fellow looks like the right course of the talk, and there has been a displeasure pole ball so that it may be the advertisement comics of a bad (the contents of the talk also suiting and waiting for them) religion.
[ no ] If that peculiar view of a leaf is taken out to the whole surface and it will be the deployment which gives ideology firm, respectively to other kyara, throws and unites it, and grows up to be れて and each other, I think that a few became interesting.
Since the leaf is too one-sided.
It is regrettable that the exaggerated soul evolved too much rapidly and stopped stopping about a battle.
It is on the level which is hard to understand truly although a certain grade is a welcome.
-- It progresses at tempo also with the frightful inflation of strength.
What can be evaluated about a battle is the unexpected nature (it is a question at resuscitation) to which the chocolate love of No.
1 became strong in the ally.
Although disliked, these comics are used about and carry out kyara too much, and the comics which often take out disposable kyara are 。.
Even if the enemy who is not attractive pushes down, it comes out repeatedly.
Quite exclusive [ quite using a rate with much kyara / since there was much 回し / the battle itself ].
kyara which was an only lover to the last is Jolo Jolo.
since -- last Jolo Jolo -- having fought (with no depiction) -- a certain meaning -- satisfactory the close -- そりゃ -- the impression of probably being probably unavoidable I think that there is a sense.
It becomes the work which was therefore merely conceited of or somehow, and there is also a feeling of being wasteful, much.
this author -- although it often hears that become the deployment which kyara which the -- cartoonist in whom something has made a mistake in the fundamental place although it is well nondescribable says well begins to go out of control, and is not expected by the cartoonist, either, and it will become interesting, as for this work, the touch to which the author did kyara and the story 100% and which was carried out for being drifts from beginning to end induced kyara -- a walk machine -- the price -- with た状態 -- a string -- the price -- the author grasps てそれ and does not release it It does not carry out in independence etc.
Therefore, it is at having become the view along which the line of leaves does not pass, and such story deployment.
(It is a strictly selfish guess) Although repeated, since there is a sense, it is a wasteful work.
There is a feeling of wanting you to do one's best, although evaluation gives the "worst." I am sorry to be a poor writing.

2007/08/06 Bad [Original Japanese review]
by e,t Provider: 34601 Host:34609 Browser: 5533
[Good point] Since he liked, kyara was also individual at first and it was interesting, animation and comics are seen, and it is a better seed.
A leaf was not disagreeable, either, although he liked 連.
[Bad point] The second half was regrettable too.
It stopped reading from the middle.
Wasn't the last so good although it thought whether to become interesting deployment to a slight degree?
The story was also halfway.
Couldn't the individuality of a character be pulled out more?
[Comprehensive evaluation] A very regrettable work is the close.
Although it was bad that the second half collapsed, the first directions were interesting comics to the extent that the continuation was worrisome.
Was the place which kyara divides into the leaf 惹かれて変 good?
When it was synthetic and having been said, the last story nature was lacking.

2007/08/02 Very good [Original Japanese review]
by 時雨月 Provider: 12301 Host:12394 Browser: 6520
I think that it is not a by no means interesting work.
the way of thinking which arranged the psychic medium's capability of 憑依 union of the opening part -- truly -- と -- 。 which should be said Furthermore, because essence which pulled the middle stage from there and which is called 憑依 union in an "exaggerated soul" is not changing, I think that it is a very much good place.
Moreover, I think that a character is also attractive and it is the point that balance is maintained, it should have even so and combination with the soul should also be evaluated although touch called past [ zorozoro 出てき ] cannot be denied a little final stage.
furthermore -- it should mention especially -- I think that it is in an individual intention and an individual view He is likable, and other characters of the hero who there is an intention carried out just though called yuru い and yuru い, and lets a line pass firmly are individual, and he is good.
I think that it pushes too much, and how to finish surely is, and can be called work in order to evaluate the whole only by it although it may not be what was praised.
Therefore, evaluation is "very good."

2007/07/21 Very bad [Original Japanese review]
by 斬 Provider: 42529 Host:42609 Browser: 6287
He liked the talk beginning of those who are called Sherman which employs the soul, it also collects books, and the bottom makes it spread it now...
The thing battle of since it goes into the Sherman fight book game also became that in which characters' (especially human being) character does not have charm rapidly, either.
First of all, there is no difference in the strength of a hero and an enemy so much at a battle primary something.
From this game, which or one of the two carried out fighting using the head very well however is extremely strong.
Are neither once nor 2 times and repeat repeatedly it from which the strong one [ it ] is the serious petty thing of on the other hand pushing down the weaker one on a target.
In and the ice man game which the partner who can push down with one blow if it becomes the mind is not easily done [ game ] so, but a reason is given [ game ] suitably, and prolongs a battle if it becomes the mind, a talk which you are made to finish with one talk will be extended to one book -- although it was made to melt, it was alike and I thought that this was severe -- again If the ally side for which the last can buy as an unexpected attack and one of the two did earnest appearance in fact and did not become precocious though the same strength's fighting started, and a game is finished by deployment becomes losing, a hero will come out.
until now Although Jolo Jolo VS Brocken which does not almost have an honest battle after this game which beats the enemy who was having a close game with one blow starts was still mashi Save the soul which the hero who is waiting (I want to carry out) wanders about, and raging human being by the power of Sherman usually to which it was likable at the time in early stages of an appearance kyara tale to the hero.
Risk one's life, in order to tell the enemy who does tool treatment of the soul that the soul is a friend and not to pass the soul (friend).
Are and it only carries out having carried out kyara.
in fact, there is no hot blood 漢みたい as considered as boo っ -- Although the man who died from the second half can be revived now and a friend dies, are carrying out the comparatively calm face, or Changed into unpleasant kyara with it being as making the remark near "what is necessary is just to make it revive, when dying" たり.
Although it was attractive when the soul called friend at first also appeared in these comics also at the others in which most last directions do not have the depiction it fears and which are just treated as a tool and much kyara which became unpleasant rapidly are, since a sentence will become long further if it is all said, it stops and solves.
Although this work is the close, I also wanted the last to show well the intention of a severe old hint being written and finished for the princess figure of rasubosu (man), with no 投げっぱ having, and collecting hints at least, after all.

2007/06/28 Good [Original Japanese review]
by Sennuki Provider: 38066 Host:38154 Browser: 4203
Unfortunate comics.
Exfoliation with the author's message nature and the contents with catharsis and deployment is a hint とっち et al.
and primarily conflicting in becoming diffuse or disorder being in illustrating as (it is sometimes dirtily visible) and battle comics, sense of incongruity.
Various elements seldom appeared and have carried out the theme used as a "good with much trouble thing 言ってる" core.

2007/06/20 Worst [Original Japanese review]
by Tamekichi Provider: 25985 Host:25854 Browser: 4184
The speech and conduct of kyara are unpleasant anyhow.
As for favor kyara of hao, Anna, or the author, being strangely glorified also by the character worst is painful.
it is hao beautification to the last last ...
[ since ] A thing cannot be said in disgust, either.

2006/12/14 Worst [Original Japanese review]
by Edei Provider: 13471 Host:13344 Browser: 5234
If it becomes before the Sherman fight inrush, surely there is an outstanding thing.
However, it is clear that it was not what is being seen by having failed after it.
Although written [ somewhat ] severity from here ...
It is not likable in a hero's leaf.
although strike the party who regarded it as the enemy better if it was a setup that he who is Sherman sent the soul and the heart merciless, it crushes, abusive language is occasionally vomited and the human being (unrelated -- it contains a sacrifice person) of which dies at hand, it will not even turn pale, but it will be coped with simply [ a friend's life and death ] at revival this boy is just an evil spirit ...
the elements "revival" which the author added capriciously as many directions were pointed out including the destructive Great have insulted the life itself -- しか -- it cannot consider ...
what especially I was amazed at is the postscript of the author of the last volume The utterance "he does not think that this end is the worst result", and this did not seem to be the minimum courtesy to the reader who supported himself about the close after extending the series.
Anyhow, "worst" evaluation will not be escaped at the time of work abandonment.

2006/12/13 Worst [Original Japanese review]
by Pepo Provider: 43847 Host:43897 Browser: 4184
The comment of these comics are expressed honestly.
Why did this work become such a thing although having read purely at first every week was pleasant?
Although it was the fact which surely steps and fun reduced by half from the middle, I thought that it would still read to the last.
...
but -- such close っぽく -- it is unreasonable and a meaning should not make it finish not understanding -- I think that it is excessive with it being a direction The author really thought what is considered.
I cannot consider, as this work was only made to finish forcibly.
if it thinks that that is right -- somehow -- himself -- bakabaka(ing) -- く思い -- better -- た .
true .
He does not completely have a feeling which betrayed the reader.
It is becoming uneasy to read new work of this author's next time by favor ...
Naturally, the evaluation of it being the "worst" is natural.
The back, when any works were that it is important that the talk makes it finish perfectly finely, as for having understood one, they learned.
& The lt; December 13 newest >↓ author is straying [ to which new work serializes in the weekly boy jump of next week ] with whether it will read honestly, although that is right ...

2006/10/09 Very bad [Original Japanese review]
by 大王トカゲ Provider: 23455 Host:23470 Browser: 3874
While beginning, they were very well favorite comics.
Although the character was also attractive, was carried out the bottom and had the story and the favorite portion ...
However people may die, since it revives simply, it has 興ざ carried out of the way of the last gradually.
Although it thought with what one of the revival system 呪文, such as zaoriku, could not be used although it must be the considerable party of a high level whenever it was good and was reading the comics of RPG, such as a large adventure of dai, and a crest of roto, when it was actually, I thought that there was nothing that withers this much.
zaoriku is unnecessary for the comics version too...
(although it may be unable to use like DQM+ according to a device ..) Although it has said severely, the last round is the worst too.
It presupposes that a fool is made that only that is with 引っ〓〓and makes it finish with such a random form to an honest reader, and it cannot buy him.
Although I was good since I was not still so passionate a fan, having considered the feeling of the person who loved these comics truly, I memorized even anger to the author and the editor.
Generally, since it is serialized by even the overseas jump, he doubts [ whether he plan to put such the self-satisfaction-last round even on overseas, and ] of these comics.
rather than -- or [ that it cannot but carry ] Although evaluation changes if you plan to resume these comics in a certain form, if the mind does not exist, even if the author and an editor should apologize to a reader clearly, they will consider.

2006/10/02 Bad [Original Japanese review]
by ヘッポコ王子 Provider: 11994 Host:11875 Browser: 5234
Animation is an original although it was seemingly the way which finishes being comparatively honest ....
It was pitiful that a story became more nearly incomprehensible and more nearly incomprehensible.
That the "mandarin orange" is drawn as やたら at the end is the thing [ a thing ] called close in short to say probably, "It is incomplete." If it has completed perfectly, although appropriate evaluation can be performed .....

2006/10/02 Worst [Original Japanese review]
by Rokku Provider: 6455 Host:6307 Browser: 3646
It is this comics worst.
That way of finishing was seen and surprised.
Those in whom that it was worrisome first is bringing the book together depending on such how to finish do what!!
って thought better た.
It will be past [ impoliteness ] at a reader.
Even by paying money for these comics purposely with a favorable impression with much trouble, those who are collecting a jump and comics do not have an impoliteness pole ball.
use the shortage of ability of the author, or popular inactivation (is the author's ability insufficient also as for this?) kiln ぁ理由 as what -- or [ that the way which finishes being better to a slight degree would not be thought of ] I carry out [ mind like a いっちゃった work ] the true contrary of "all is well that ends well." I think that the contents were good.
on the way -- reading -- めんど -- stinking time -- it is (as [ be / long / old recollection ]) .
.) Although mind which changed the meaning very much is also considered as the time of beginning, until just before still finishing, it was reading happily.
Although said が and numbers of times, that way of finishing is as severe as ほん.
All kana ?
which they were for series about five to six years is pars.
As how to finish, it is severe [ exceeding the comics which are not interesting ] out of else.
that -- it cannot read as comics of じゃあ 1 continuation Since it was not 1 talk conclusion type comics, I wanted you to carry out somehow.
The worst must be given in that way of finishing.
Although the last volume was read very much at the front secondhand bookseller, if the author's comment and useless thing were carried, I thought that it should carry out [ retouch ] in correction and the talk should have been made to end exactly.

2006/09/26 Bad [Original Japanese review]
by Masukato Provider: 56540 Host:56420 Browser: 4483
The middle thinks that it was interesting.
Characters were also likable and liked the trio of go rem usage's boy, a girl, and the father of a leaf individually.
How to finish the last will close too.
Is it ...?
That is too severe anything how much.

2006/09/17 Worst [Original Japanese review]
by 隼人 Provider: 33385 Host:33255 Browser: 5234
Evaluation is bad too...
Although these comics also liked me a long time ago, it is gakkari too.
The story after 20 volume did not feel it interesting at all.
Doesn't this author understand wanting what to say well, and does the last last make a fool of a reader with the self-satisfied close?
A picture collapses from the final stage and a lack [ the author's motivation ] is felt clear.
A story also smashes after 20 volume and its treatment of a character is also severe.
These comics forget what is said in the importance of people's life from the final stage.
In order to improve capability, kill forcibly, and it revives or is below a dragon ball.
Steps 見てて腹 stood.
There is no bad work made this much.
It is the trash which just remains in a tradition.

2006/09/17 Worst [Original Japanese review]
by Nokokkusu Provider: 24711 Host:24605 Browser: 4184
the grade at which even not only a play king but a dress, naruto, and bleach will have an illusion, ordinary popular comics, if compared with these comics -- it is clear that they were the comics which are not fearfully got blocked the life and death of terrible and a man are drawn and it is simply revived in supernatural powers -- carrying out -- hao -- after all -- unreasonable 苦茶 -- it is only gaki of a strong little offense party 30 or more trashes of only this used to be continued.
The place sake which has not secured popularity by the postcard questionnaire of a jump system, and since it became the close, they are the comics which remained in the history of a certain semantic jump which finished the talk as the punch line which threw and played a trick.
They are the worst comics which can be declared never draw comics.
Even the qualification for giving one's name in a cartoonist cannot be found.
Is it grade also with the worst lukewarm evaluation?

Next / Post your review / Top page

Other media
Anime:Sharman King

ALERT: You cannot use open proxy or TOR for posting your review. If it is detected, your access to this site will be prohibited.

Rule for reviews

This site allows you to write reviews for each title, but we don't allow you to criticize others' comment. Too bad or meaningless words are also not allowed. The comment which doesn't follow the rule will be deleted. If you find any comment which doesn't follow the rule, please notify us by clicking Suggest to delete.

Example to be deleted frequently

Favorite side
You dislike this one, then don't see it or comment this title
- Please go to the fan site. Anyone has the right to say what they feel in this site.

Disliking side
Do you like this one? You are stupid.
- Your view is only your view. Please concentrate on only the content of the title, not on others' comment.

Please use only English. If not, the comment will be deleted.

Your Name(Required)

Password (Required. more than 4 characters)

Your comment about this anime(Required)

Your evaluation of this title(Required)
You can choose the evaluation only once. After you post your evaluation, please choose comment instead of evaluation from the options.

Evaluation of this title(You can choose this only once)

Best!!
Very good
Good
Normal
Bad
Very Bad
Worst

If you evaluated this title once, please choose comment instead of the evaluation.
Comment by the person who thinks this is good
Comment by the person who thinks this is normal
Comment by the person who thinks this is bad

Please choose appropriate option for readers.

Caution: Please post the evaluation which follows the rule.