Japanese works database(How to join/Help)
Top page: All/Only Reviews

Others
Site map

AllAnimeGameComicNovelDramaSp. effectJP movieMovie	Info:voice,machine..	Reviewer sorted by	Diary
Search / Outside DB:

Comics ranking in Japan: Rank 4,096/in 4,101 titles (Total -206.85/Deviation 1.48) Rank 4,095 <= => Rank 4,097
Comics average points ranking in Japan: Rank 632/in 655 titles (Average -1.97(Very bad)/Deviation 28.18) Rank 631 <= => Rank 633 (more than 10 evaluatoin were posted)
Comics ranking of 2005 in Japan: Rank 135/in 135 titles Rank 134 <=

TAKAYA(Comics)

[Other version: RSS/Japanese version]

All
Reviews(Post)

Diary
2006/02/28

Forum

Images

Information about this title

Yujiro Sakamoto
Weekly Boys Jump
SHUEISHA
Aomaru JUMP
Akamaru Jump

Released:2005/05/23 in Japan End:2006/05/29 in Japan

Statics of evaluation(The statics is updated once a day)

	Average	ComicsRank	Deviation(Total)	Evaluation points(Total)	Best of the Best
Inside Japan	Very bad(-1.97)	4,096	1.48	-206.85
Outside Japan	Good(0.00)	95	41.41	0.00

Statics of activity

	Total Views	Comment	Evaluation
Inside Japan	68,016	159	105
Outside Japan	2,433	2	2

How others evaluated in Japan

Best

Very Good

Good

Normal

Bad

Very Bad

Worst

People

Percentage

1.9%

1.0%

1.9%

13.3%

8.6%

21.9%

51.4%

Added percentage

1.9%

2.9%

4.8%

18.1%

26.7%

48.6%

100%

Summary

4.8%

13.3%

81.9%

Views for recent 8 days
Total 4 3 2 1 30 29 28 27
4 0 1 1 0 0 0 1 1

Language Sorted by date Sorted by recommendation New!
English Good
(Only Evaluation) Normal
(Only Evaluation) Bad
(Only Evaluation) All
(Only Evaluation) None
Japanese Good
(Only Evaluation) Normal
(Only Evaluation) Bad
(Only Evaluation) All
(Only Evaluation) All
This reputation board

Language	Sorted by date	Sorted by recommendation New!
English	Good (Only Evaluation)	Normal (Only Evaluation)	Bad (Only Evaluation)	All (Only Evaluation)	None
Japanese	Good (Only Evaluation)	Normal (Only Evaluation)	Bad (Only Evaluation)	All (Only Evaluation)	All

2006/08/17 Normal [Edit/Delete//Only this reviewer/Only this review/post sympathy comment/]
by myu Review history[Good:26(63%) Normal:10(24%) Bad:5(12%)] / Provider: 43349 Host:43140 Browser: 6310
Drawing is not so bad.
But the story as the battle story is bad.
Ignoring the damage, TAKAYA wins finally by the special attack.
And it is quite big mistery that the characters were drawn into fantasyz world suddenly.
I think it is too sudden for readers.

2006/01/01 Normal [Edit/Delete//Only this reviewer/Only this review/post sympathy comment/]
by TAKARAYA Review history[Good:78(58%) Normal:57(42%) Bad:0(0%)] / Provider: 18922 Host:18802 Browser: 3646
If anything, this funnies are comparatively tedious.
I do not feel the charm against the hero of this funnies.
However, I somewhat feel the charm against the heroine of this cartoon.
The author of this funnies is experience shortage.
Therefore, this funnies is comparatively low-level.
This funnies somewhat lacks freshness though this funnies is not trash.
This funnies are not the bad funnies that have a bad influence on children.
However, it is a mediocre funnies.

Post your review / Top page

The below reviews are translated automatically from Japanese ones. To post to English version, please click here.

2008/04/01 Very bad [Original Japanese review]
by 闇夜のフェンリル Provider: 33466 Host:33442 Browser: 6390
A gag face is too unpleasant although it thinks that it is not bad at the time of a serious face.
Is it skill of drawing and not that problem but the problem of a sense?

2008/03/31 Normal [Original Japanese review]
by Gyaroppu Provider: 25356 Host:25322 Browser: 3646
If even the turn of a mystery is removed ...
It is delicate kana even if it removes.
however, the meaning of the expectation of as opposed to [ since it came out and there were also sushi and a portion which was able to be enjoyed ] a teacher which was legible as for the picture -- putting -- "-- it is usually made "

2008/03/28 Normal [Original Japanese review]
by Fuerishidaa Provider: 8932 Host:8884 Browser: 3875
As a work, it is not disagreeable.
It is the fan of Mr.
Sakamoto also in the present condition.
The volume on school was enjoying itself, and if it has finished in that place, it will not think that it is a work bad to there.
し [ probably there was also superfluous expectation with a golden future cup ].
As [ omit / however, / even the human being who was a fan till then in that / route change would elapse not much abruptly and said that there was no specification of protection, will not reinforce in already slightly another form, or ] -- Although it is a favorite work as said also at the beginning, since route change was too severe, evaluation usually comes out.

2008/03/26 Good [Original Japanese review]
by 小島かじり虫 Provider: 28890 Host:28967 Browser: 3674

[Good point]
With the level with skill of drawing high above all, the background and the building were drawn in three dimensions.
As for the character, skillful く描写 of expression, the character, etc.
was carried out.
It was shocked by the ability which a story and a setup were also very new and carried out the newcomer detached building at the beginning.
It can be said that it is a wonderful achievement that this work has been serialized for a long time.

[Bad point]
It will be impossible to become the story which a translation does not understand by change of a fantasy route from a sudden school thing, and to hold the last flow.
Moreover, it can be said that it was sad that the last talk by no means had greeted the end in the line of an end.

[Comprehensive evaluation]
I also regard a week boy jump as going into Ryosaku's category.
However, it is surmised that it is because there was probably change of a route although it does not understand well why the unfavorable criticism increased [ this Ryosaku ] rapidly so far.
It is anxious about the nova of the expectation which the jump induced in a week boy jump in the ability of new work to be serialized sure enough again.
Evaluation presupposes "It is good."

2008/03/09 Worst [Original Japanese review]
by 剣舞大使 Provider: 34156 Host:34137 Browser: 4749
Is it 力尽きた in complete?
A series will be uncanny.
"炎刃王 of dawn" which is wanting to run especially in the direction of a fantasy of the second half is how to finish a mystery by making me, and perplexed ていう or reader into desertion, and dashing.
It expressed vividly what a reckless run in a comics community was.
It was not able to become strangely to draw a grapple scene and it is ?.
I want to ならいっそ-fantasy-描こう and to see.
Although the fact is not known, the side currently read though I am pleasant to draw temporarily is boring.
A grapple did not remain in an impression somehow, either.
or it was not spiral circle -- but rakousen -- once -- a technique -- it was in that there is a みたいな thing I think that it must not accept as serial comic strips.
Evaluation is the "worst." Although displeasure was also differed from, such a thing existed why -- It has confidence and can be called a 見ちゃ situation.

2008/03/08 Bad [Original Japanese review]
by 海上 Provider: 19847 Host:19737 Browser: 7781(Mobile)
if the volume on school is as a schoolchild -- infallible -- hamatt てただ -- wax -- と -- they were the contents to say, laver, and deployment Especially a story does not necessarily have a twist and is royal road-deployment of grapple monochrome boys' comics fundamentally.
Although object age was quite lower, there was admiration which can be read in comfort.
although the tournament of a school was allowed to enjoy itself -- on the way -- since -- "(it can take also with ってゆ - or completely different comics )炎刃王 editing of dawn" of a fantasy route -- completely -- と -- I am painful to be so boring that you may say to an understanding in why it became such deployment It has become still lower when the object age which was low from the first became a fantasy route.
Is the last round unavoidable well, at such touch, since the close was deterministic?
The general comment which "is very bad as for 炎刃王 editing of the dawn the volume on school of evaluation "is good"" "is worsened".
[ dawn ] When finishing it as the volume on school finely all the time, he also bought comics.
-- It is very regrettable.

2008/02/29 Worst [Original Japanese review]
by 葉隠侍 Provider: 29382 Host:29389 Browser: 8099(Mobile)
Not a year was able to allow the series for this work why, and a jump is ?.
The character which the background took out only woods and was deformed was strange in various meanings, and the story was amusing.
Was the tsukkomi place a full load with -- -- Because a route change was suddenly made in fantasy comics from the grapple battle, it is also pitiful that it has all become nothing meaning the practice (appropriate practice not being carried out even if it says) which the hero has stacked until now -- such deployment -- a friend -- because it is alike and shows, I want to say "solve by carrying out" It is still くってる gag (?) now [ 喰 ] about many readers to severe criticism.
Although there are comics, printing ranking still saves the higher rank.
The jump was really kept why --

2008/01/22 Worst [Original Japanese review]
by 赤い水性のシャア Provider: 12661 Host:12513 Browser: 3034(Mobile)
A picture is the work which became the form betrayed completely although he liked and being expected comparatively.
a story -- unreasonable -- 惹き -- the price -- れる物 -- there is nothing and 炎刃王 editing of the dawn of the comic last volume is completely incomprehensible It has run recklessly.
The last is the close [ do / overly by force ].
Is evaluation the "worst" well?

2007/11/23 Worst [Original Japanese review]
by Mansurii Provider: 34156 Host:34197 Browser: 4767
The work with which the author of real lack of ability mistakes and ran wild.
It has given the tengu freely willfully that the editorial department did the やたら push with the incomprehensible composition which develops and cannot exist.
Naturally, it is forsaken frankly, printing ranking is also rapidly driven away back by the reader, and the last has made it finish it with a pattern pitiable No.
1 also as the close.
the author's end way by which series duties were carried out by まぁ merit 足らず -- a large object -- being such -- it rubbed

2007/08/24 Worst [Original Japanese review]
by murasame Provider: 13120 Host:13077 Browser: 6306
[Good point] Battle depiction is very hot at the royal road until - girl goes into the volume on so so dear (to the last so so level) - fantasy and a story goes into the volume on - fantasy for boys intelligibly.
[Bad point] From where of the deformation picture and takaya of - fantasy editing and kyara, it does not understand well whether it came, is struck, and is strength.
- Imitation of multiple use and baki of overall displeasure and comic studio [Comprehensive evaluation] When having finished it only as the volume on school, they were "it being very bad" or "bad" evaluation.
spring people game is useless -- although it was useless, Angie and the voido game had written the partner as a worthy rival, and were uniquely fresh in the jump whose kyara of a muscular system has decreased The enemy was also asking only for strength and they were very simple and hot comics.
But on the whole, the sense was young, the influence of other comics was strong, and it was dissatisfied that the source of the strength of takaya was not found.
The picture was the picture grade of the person who did his best so so in the comics classroom.
And it is fantasy editing whose protection is impossible at all.
Setting kyara in the different world and all deployment had broken from the introductory portion.
In a genre called the fantasy comics of a sword and magic, I think that it is the minimum only in ぶっち.
The last round was also the worst.
Therefore, evaluation is the worst.
The eroticism & as Mr.
Yabuki with the same following work; although it thinks that what is necessary is just to do the comedy which sprouts, since at least ToLove る is [ but ] disagreeable, rushes, bunbun, an electric shock system, or a cancer cancer system is osusume(ed).

2007/06/20 Worst [Original Japanese review]
by Nebusokunotaka Provider: 16572 Host:16324 Browser: 5234
It has realized with "It is the confidential relation って serious happening of a reader and the author" by these comics.
When a hero is flown in the latter part in the world of a fantasy, with most works, a reason is first expected to be "?
why flown." however -- this work -- not the world in comics but "-- again -- this author はてき - an idea -- comics 描き -- " -- the author -- the thing in the world in the head was considered and it is dumbfounded after that -- once -- は "-- the chemistry of this school -- that from which こ makes virtual reality within a brain to matrix みたい as it is 部みたいな was developed, and it was involved in the experiment -- I considered the deployment which can carry out reason attachment somehow " (although it was the idea of this and an amateur) が -- too -- "-- it was only made the fantasy from a disagreeable -- fantasy or りたい -- ろ -- " -- どうしても -- the future -- it was believed that the author considered things and く and the idea have been negated out of part I -- it can have -- き - a hero's upgrade and grapple depiction remain in the impression, and since there is no reliance that the author thinks firmly to subsequent deployment, it has come to suspect as "it is しょ?
at てき and - at any rate" in spite of itself if it already becomes like this -- this work -- me -- 惹き attachment れる -- there are nothings No matter what deployment [ dramatic ] it may prepare, because I am amazed to "author " and I turn over a parapara page by the cold eye, I have already become.
improving the comics it was once thought that were boring and being interesting -- feeling -- れる -- it does not become like that it cannot be although it is quite difficult However, the work it has been thought to such winds that is boring to the author itself is that recovery stops already sticking --

2007/06/20 Worst [Original Japanese review]
by Tamekichi Provider: 25985 Host:25854 Browser: 4184
It was disagreeable from 炎刃王 of dawn or before.
kyara which changes the bodies [ given occasion ] is unpleasant anyhow.
The background in woods is also seen and it 飽きs bored.

2007/04/13 Worst [Original Japanese review]
by ディルfan Provider: 328 Host:253 Browser: 3646
[a good point] -- having become insane -- しか -- route change of a radical work to the extent that it cannot consider [Bad point] It does not understand wanting what to draw.
- displeasure unpleasant [ the whole work ].
[Comprehensive evaluation] Although it is "atrocious" tsugihagi and an equal level, this one of a series is [ the long part and a crime ] heavier.
Severe [ of the last round ] is !
which also exceeds God.

2007/04/07 Very bad [Original Japanese review]
by Parabonaantena Provider: 2816 Host:2772 Browser: 5533
なが and others evaluates now.
But an opinion is although it is the same as most persons -- While doing at the beginning with front reading which this work serializes, it had a good impression considerably.
This reads with!!.
?
which will become what if ?
series of is done.
If it そ, it will have returned in the form of a series.
The direction of deer しまぁ and the start withers rapidly, after becoming も and the sport-combative convention which まぁ良しと, and was the decisive blow received by fantasy route change?
I read and try to want to also pass て vacantly.
a setup -- although it seems that it was, し it did not check to there in detail why began and had a good impression in this work -- ?
-- it is a point with a first setup which is a beta setup of "becoming strong in order that a hero may protect the heroine" although it kicks A sport combative is not only the means of that and thinks that it is not an essence this reason.
Although it returns to around the beginning and he rewants to draw if it is being able to do, it is the doctor after death.
It is an impossible talk.
I think that it is really wasteful.
This work --

2007/04/04 Worst [Original Japanese review]
by 劉備 Provider: 26384 Host:26201 Browser: 4184
[a good point] -- being such -- being certain -- it does not divide [Bad point] All.
A picture, unprecedented excrement deployment of making a route change suddenly at a fantasy, etc.
for which it had depended on the personal computer when the example was given.
[comprehensive evaluation] -- this ぞまさ -- "kinguobu -- a trash -- it is a work (it is too severe and cannot be called a work, either) suitable to the name of " Not the "greatest trash in the history of comics" but the "greatest trash in the history of creation" and I can already declare this.
About a sudden fantasy route change, sense of incongruity will be felt even by the kindergartener.
although there are some persons who say that what was necessary was to come out constantly and just to have done occasionally, there is no it it is alike and impolite If paper is used for such comics, I will think that only the way into which paper is torn and thrown away is mashi very much.
Although evaluation is not substituted for the worst どころ, since there is no evaluation worse than the worst here, it is made into the "worst" for the time being.

2007/02/22 Worst [Original Japanese review]
by 無尽 Provider: 51450 Host:51510 Browser: 5234
takaya -- you -- すげぇ -- the physique difference was overcome for a short period of time, and the ほこる rival has been beaten for fierce god-strength -- also coming out -- how much -- it is also, although there is kenichi if [ similar ] it thinks that it is limited compensating clear merit さ with concentration and nature compared with it with the admiration which has only taken out that that is in practice and is fighting it, takaya which invents the coping-with method immediately has become the deployment which was genius and which a reason does not understand unawares from the beginning -- carrying out -- a partner's woman reads in time with dress arrival 始めた -- it stopped

2007/02/01 Normal [Original Japanese review]
by 道端の雑草 Provider: 12522 Host:12872 Browser: 6287
It is the work in which depiction of efforts has made a mistake.
it is not slightly severe to become strong for a short period of time although it is common to a boy magazine -- ?
-- this I carried out [ mind as skillful く表現 of the story had not been carried out ], and, on the whole, it was not easy to be quite satisfactory.
Although atmosphere is not so disagreeable, probably, it was successful in the style [ the second half ] of a fantasy too.
Since whole composition and whole balance collapsed and it carried out now [ ちゃ ].
I think that a picture is not so bad.
If the talk itself is made interesting, isn't there any なるんじゃあ fairly well?
Although this is my personal opinion, I think that comics and a novel make progress in the way on which ordinary every day is involuntarily drawn with a big work being made suddenly.

2007/01/14 Worst [Original Japanese review]
by LOVEN Provider: 5027 Host:5224 Browser: 3875
Although it did not get used to the mind to evaluate before, either, since it is less so as the time passes, I will evaluate.
although ...
was thought, if it thinks anew in this way -- you -- since it is also the futility of time that carries out, and is earnest in such neta comics and being struck severely puts tsukkomi into them -- a word ...
"Please also make it general to lick us the readers." It is above.

2007/01/07 Worst [Original Japanese review]
by 消しゴム Provider: 27451 Host:27300 Browser: 4925
However the house where the teachings obtained through these comics have poor "foundation (concept) may add a hand, it is calling it futility." reading -- the love of an as -- rice -- it used as it is, there being neither a concept nor へったくれ about the character of a work, and having applied matchless compensation in the grapple and the fantasy route -- being incoherent -- しか -- contents without a way of speaking The act of the author, such as using a machine to draw pakuri and a background so that it may be also in the indication in the direction of others, was the new 鱈墓栄 itself which appeared in "high school 奇面組."

2007/01/07 Best! [Original Japanese review]
by Suusan Provider: 25899 Host:25856 Browser: 4483
These comics are the comics of the lowest ever highest in various meanings.
kyara of a common story and a stopgap, a setup [ だらけ / with after ], and the beginning -- a thing -- although very expected, if it swerves, and it goes to a steps byroad and it is noticed -- the surroundings -- whom -- いねぇ- seeing -- better た with なっ sufficient to the touch / た / touch ] These comics taught けど and various things truly.
also seeing -- reality wants to see the merciless last talk and to attach so 甘, the highness which seems to be ねぇな, and evaluation of the highest [ himself ] already

Next / Post your review / Top page