Table

Yamato Gensouki (Comics)

Reviews' statics

Comics rank	Rank 672/in 4,246 titles (Total 9.02)	Rank 671 <= => Rank 673
Comics average pnts rank	Rank 540/in 710 titles (Average -0.11(Good))	Rank 539 <= => Rank 541
Comics rank of 1999	Rank 18/in 61 titles	Rank 17 <= => Rank 19

All
Reviews(Post)

Forum

Image gallery

Information about this title

Kentarou Yabuki
SHUEISHA
Weekly Boys Jump

Released:1999/12 in Japan End:1999/29 in Japan

Statics of evaluation(The statics is updated once a day)

	Average	ComicsRank	Deviation(Total)	Evaluation points(Total)	Best of the Best
Inside Japan	Good(-0.11)	672	50.44	9.02	1

Statics of activity

	Total Views	Comment	Evaluation
Inside Japan	7,116	21	18
Outside Japan	284	0	0

How others evaluated in Japan

Best

Very Good

Good

Normal

Bad

Very Bad

Worst

People

Percentage

5.6%

27.8%

11.1%

Added percentage

5.6%

11.2%

39%

66.8%

77.9%

89%

100%

Summary

39%

27.8%

33.3%

Views for recent 8 days
Total 18 17 16 15 14 13 12 11
2 0 0 0 0 0 2 0 0

Language Sorted by date Sorted by recommendation
English Good
(Only Evaluation) Normal
(Only Evaluation) Bad
(Only Evaluation) All
(Only Evaluation) None
Japanese Good
(Only Evaluation) Normal
(Only Evaluation) Bad
(Only Evaluation) All
(Only Evaluation) All
This reputation board

Language	Sorted by date	Sorted by recommendation
English	Good (Only Evaluation)	Normal (Only Evaluation)	Bad (Only Evaluation)	All (Only Evaluation)	None
Japanese	Good (Only Evaluation)	Normal (Only Evaluation)	Bad (Only Evaluation)	All (Only Evaluation)	All

Post your review / Top page

The below reviews are translated automatically from Japanese ones. To post to English version, please click here.

2008/06/09 Very good [Original Japanese review]
by TOK Provider: 38207 Host:38094 Browser: 7931
it was the work which feels an inside 々 sense for a newcomer -- be -- は -- although the picture of present Mr.
Yabuki who was the work which fully feels something that is drawn although composition etc.
cannot be evaluated, since [ being dear ] it carried out and Mr.
Sion has also been closed over a smart short period was markedly boiled in skill of drawing and it has evolved -- the picture at this time -- very much -- the taste -- it is -- liking -- since the library version will seemingly come out shortly, it is expectation just for a moment

2008/06/08 Best! [Original Japanese review]
by BXT Provider: 6412 Host:6449 Browser: 5234
the time of reading these comics in a jump at the time of a junior high school student -- a picture -- uncanny -- liking -- a setup -- any -- or -- although -- when it was fond, and it comes out, next time enjoyed itself, came out, enjoyed itself and comes out truly and it becomes the close which was an unavoidable work, I want Mr.
Yabuki who is the really shocking even now most favorite comics to write when or this continuation

2008/03/29 Good [Original Japanese review]
by 陣兵 Provider: 18696 Host:18447 Browser: 3875

[Good point]
A picture is well and it is 。.

[Bad point]
How to finish is halfway.

[Comprehensive evaluation]
I did not want you to finish it as two volumes.
When continuing more, it cannot have carried out in the way which finishes being halfway --

2008/03/28 Comment(good) [Original Japanese review]
by sh Provider: 43836 Host:43909 Browser: 5234
this work -- surely -- small -- although it read at the time of 4 and fitted in considerably, I reread recently and think that it is interesting too Although it was not criticism, it felt fully that browsed the jump recently, read this author's of the comics, and directivity changed considerably.
I like the account of 邪馬台 fantasy individually.
Surely there is so and so of the technology of a picture, and although it is rough-planed, I feel what shines in this work.
し [ it felt what has also at the the same time of gaki ].
a sequel -- although I want you to write a みたいな thing -- that present author of the -- being impossible -- it is not -- it is felt as kana The talk of a hint, the past of 1 与, and the key of 紫苑, and when it seemed to have become fairly interesting, it finished, and it was quite shocking and fell those days.
But this work is good too.
Although I did not want you to carry out such a way that finishes being tekitoo and it carried out, when it could do ...
It is as regrettable a work as the kana which was not possibly able to be enjoyed more is thought if it serializes in not a jump but a magazine, Sunday, or its hit.

2008/01/03 Normal [Original Japanese review]
by TCC Provider: 50988 Host:50917 Browser: 4184
TOLOVE る has no great work house mistake of the future to a certain extremely rich professional baseball team's famous alumnus ばり at drama CD, animation-izing, etc.
"a best tone [!!
]" -- (?) -- although it seems to be debut 作 of Mr.
Yabuki who should love .........
[A good point] - The subject matter itself .........
Though what is not known was not, as it is, the volition which a location does not yet hakkiri and which took up Yamatai was felt.
- Pattern Although there was a little rough impression compared with present, I think that it was still above the average.
When saying so, the number of teachers was still ten those days.
My 1 与 are the kana in which the loveliness like my [ next my Eve or / rara ] was not simply felt although it was a joke (smile) that he also wants to return at the time.
[A bad point] - kyara knowledge is thin.
Too, being mentioned first is this.
Although the heroine is described and cooks by the above-mentioned pattern, as for renza, it is the first comment which it is not only kyara which was the grade by which foolish っぽい所 remained in the impression as it is, and was seen by somewhere with an enemy's 紅真 and the typical Machiavellian, and empathy was not necessarily carried out so much, and have been passed entirely just for a moment.
- All is well that ends well ..........
Because looked at the sadness of the close, although he belonged with the hero as a result, it is also regretted that the relation and that hint of connection of the organization which is also a father's enmity were not fully digested.
It was able to be said that 結 of introduction development turn and conclusion was lacked ordinarily.
[Comprehensive evaluation] Although these comics were a total of two books, self-introduction is written to the author comment column of the kabaaura of two volumes despite the digression, and a thing called a certain kind of innocence was felt.
(Smile) Although Mr.
Yabuki was commented "I want to write when or a continuation" about the black cat of a previous work, after TOLOVE る with remarkable media advance is settled temporarily, I think that it is not bad, either, although there is a feeling of wanting surely to also see a black cat and to see it.
[ of drawing a remake of this ] 晋 replaced with 魏 which was the mightiest in Mikuni is uncertain (although that was actually right --) Since the heroine of this work and my iyo took out usage there in A.D.
266, although it has not turned out to be hakkiri with the history of our country and Japan being called "the 4th century of a mystery" so, I think that an interesting dish can be performed according to a maker's way of thinking.
since it is the 3 pillars of jump truth with which TOLOVE る is already located in a line with tenipuri or emuzero though it realizes well, although it is the thing of a number of years or the point ........
evaluation .......
well -- "-- the kana which is usually "

2007/09/21 Very bad [Original Japanese review]
by Sharu Provider: 1407 Host:1250 Browser: 5598
Is illustrating good like a black cat trouble?
し [ the story was also interesting so so ] ...
However, it is sorry that the series has been completed with a short number of turns called two books to be the stage where stretch various hints and a story rises after this.
Since it is the work which a continuation and an end worry, although it thinks that I want you to surely resume a series ...
illustrating - story -- good -- although it is an impressive work, it is big minus that the series has been completed in a halfway stage Expectation of resumption of a series is put, and evaluation avoids the "worst" and "is worsened very much."

2007/06/29 Worst [Original Japanese review]
by Tamekichi Provider: 25985 Host:25854 Browser: 4184
For a hint, the close is also 。 from which it should collect.
it is what -- how depending on which increasing that hint only finishes .....
As [ be / the comics of the author of a black cat / the battles ]

2007/05/15 Normal [Original Japanese review]
by カミナリ頭の小童 Provider: 18003 Host:17791 Browser: 4655
It is pakuri of comics "雷火" (past [ the likeness of a setup ]), and a "dragon ball" (he so likes that it opinion !
acts as a fan personally).
If a pakuri highway is dashed as itself with that, I will think that it is the work which was able to be read pleasantly.

2007/01/08 Good [Original Japanese review]
by Naooki Provider: 33146 Host:32904 Browser: 4928
Kana with a sufficient black cat which is not too [ impressionist school ] although this work of a previous work was also seen and cooked and kore was also regarded as interesting, since it did.
What it fought with the friend just for a moment, and was finished when thinking progressing [ a tale ]-how kana, after the fellow who takes to the heroine's thing on the way became a friend is the done kana regretfully.
Kana which looked at and extorted 話し of an adventure of such China っぽい fantasies with the number of volumes of about 20 volumes although the black cat was also privately interesting.

2007/01/06 Normal [Original Japanese review]
by 武信君 Provider: 16175 Host:16188 Browser: 4928
Are history comics difficult too in a weekly boy jump ....
Although it is debut 作 of Mr.
Kentaro Yabuki who became a legendary cartoonist by the "black cat" and "TO LOVE る", in a word, it is the work which is not bad.
you 仰っている -- is 画力 high and is [ like ] also imagination of a story impossible from present Mr.
Yabuki on whom it will put a label that the contents describing the accession-to-the-throne back of 1 与 whose Yamatai it carries out and is Himiko's successors in which the foundation is solid have no scenario capability?
Were there also few fields which were not simply bad but were good?
it is this -- that kyara with the impact !!
is not たり -- etc.
-- hear also about the sweetness of the final stage in character with a newcomer -- better た I merely think that the greatest failure of this work is having serialized in the weekly boy jump famous for the unusual numerousness, the questionnaire supreme principle, and the too severe labor conditions of reinforcement.
Or [ that the high level of 画力 had also large-transformed itself conjointly when possibly it had become the evaluation different to a slight degree when serializing in the youth magazine neighborhood, and carrying out the lower part ] ....
In such meanings, it may be an unhappy work.
I think that deer っり of the contents as comics was merely carried out also often and worse than the black cat of only volume.

2005/12/23 Good [Original Japanese review]
by Blaze Provider: 17244 Host:17138 Browser: 3875
since like those who know that it is unexpected -- few, is it debut 作 of Mr.
Yabuki who became the thin existence of a shadow because of a notorious black cat and the close?
but I think that this is markedly boiled from a black cat rightly, and is honest comics By other comics, the new portion which can seldom be seen can see the old time background which made Yamatai the stage, and it is known by that the author was going to take out originality.
Now, about [ which cannot be regarded as it being a writer's work struck by pakuri ].
A hero's 紫苑 is calm character as to [ it / which ] it is, and it is the portion in which this is also seldom found by other comics.
kyara of such character usually tends to become a hero's rival.
& I gt; Wright Mr.
agree.
This work is read to series that time, and Mr.
Yabuki was expected.
し [ it has finished the past of 1 与 which are hints without being collected ].
Doesn't a number of turns have the contents as for 1/10 of the 10 or more-time close works of a black cat?
Although he fairly liked at the time of a series, having finished in about several months is regrettable.

2005/10/25 Good [Original Japanese review]
by JOH Provider: 205 Host:364 Browser: 6494
He liked the talk and the picture individually.
I wanted you to continue this to the last.
a hint calls it most -- it is -- having finished being collected at all is regrettable It seems to have not been bad although the way of thinking which is a new setup which carried out the stage of Yamatai, and generates arms by sushi and mind is also common.
Although it was a problem whether the talk can give [ which ] 深味 as for the back ...
Although it is まぁ and an incomplete work, since he was enjoyed moderately, evaluation is "good." Although it was unnecessary addition, although an eye is not applied, either, it becomes in a part to have expected and was shocking [ a reckless run of the author after kono ] ...

2005/10/24 Good [Original Japanese review]
by DEE Review history[Good:2(100%) Normal:0(0%) Bad:0(0%)] / Provider: 13505 Host:13879 Browser: 4184
Although I read not in our journal but in the book well, when saying which it was and serializing a work with the regrettable close, and kyara which the continuation worried in the present jump in the more attractive one, didn't it have the close, either?
a picture -- this -- about -- for there to be あ and others likes -- if it says honestly well, although it will be minus a picture more favorite than a black cat and that there was あ and others also in production and a setup, if it lets ..., however the whole pass, they will be not so bad comics but the battle comics which can be read lightly -- that -- don't become cowardly -- I want you to write the volume ....
and on extra, and what Rather good kana whose feeling of minus to a black cat or this author was not such severe comics that it "bad" Attaches individually well, either.

2005/10/24 Normal [Original Japanese review]
by ミルク&カフェラテ Provider: 12904 Host:12804 Browser: 5234
excessive -- although it was not pleasant -- on the way -- is it slightly shocking for having come out and stopped?
A continuation is worried once and, for the way of evaluation, a tale is [ ってこ ] with あり common ってこ the middle too...

2005/07/09 Worst [Original Japanese review]
by 破壊大帝 Provider: 8533 Host:8564 Browser: 4184
Since there was an opportunity to reread at a secondhand bookseller on the other day, evaluation is changed.
-- It being convinced well with being [ it / a natural conclusion ] kana to have converted the style by 次回作, or becoming sad たり ....
When 1 与 were seen anew, appearance was the heroine imaichi in any way with there there.
severer one in other works -- a grounder -- a grounder -- います is kyara of the category which is not individually likable A setup which probably became the hint which is not revealed and cancellation is felt, it closes, and the sadness of a work is felt thoroughly.
Although it seems that the black cat is in the limelight by the media mix recently, does the day by which 本作 is reappraised like Mr.
Araki 飛呂彦's "baoo visitor" come?
2005/06/04 22:25:29 -- very bad -- the fantasy system work which used Yamatai as the motif to the last -- it was .
The work itself was a mediocre impression although the author was the author, Mr.
Kentaro Yabuki, of that "BLACK CAT." It was not likable to honesty and a hero at the heroine, either (it says or, on the whole, kyara is), and has stopped reading immediately.
Does it seem that it did not become not much interesting, considering the place closed by carrying out soon after that?
Did it fight with the spy of Gi who had ingratiated himself with the complete version (or series opening part ?)?
[ 与 / 1 ] (曹叡 which is the grandchild of Taso Tsao with famous for the Mikuni mind it having been the emperor of 当時魏 which was incidentally being interchanged with Himiko) Although it was the bundle which suggests being connected with the Yamato Imperial Court in narration after that, I thought those days, "Does it say?" (bitter smile).
Although I honesty-carry out and high evaluation is not attached, since it seems to have fought more healthfully than a next style, I will consider as an estimate, with "very bad" evaluation indulgently.

2005/06/24 Comment(normal) [Original Japanese review]
by Nonoka Provider: 11739 Host:11848 Browser: 5440
Although the author of a black cat got to know with this work, he feels myo - dejavu also for this work.
-- Why is it?

2005/06/24 Very bad [Original Japanese review]
by Raito Provider: 3618 Host:3505 Browser: 3646
if it says right [ that ] -- it was -- the comics of such a title --sad (?) recollections -- it is -- [ that these comics were pleased very well at the time of a series, and he was disappointed at the author at a stretch in the black cat of the next new series since the close was very shocking ] Although just a setup of this work was old and there was no freshness -- It is although it thought whether they were the contents which can be read as it is.
-- (it bounds from a black cat at least, and is --) That whose 1 与 of the heroine were only dear merely remembers.
-- Is her past sorry about having finished, while it has been unknown after all?
-- after pakurineta is mean, is disclosed and is disclosed to there -- super- -- the black cat which was able to be regarded only as the trash continued for about four years, and this work has finished in only three a little less than months -- very much -- regrettable -- not changing -- This one regards a black cat as having exceeded and it having been with it being clear.
-- (it is -- although it is the talk of れば compared with a black cat to the last) Some evaluations are made sweet.
pakurineta from other natural works etc.
is nothing entirely, and is only perfect original tea of Mr.
Yabuki.
-- "worsened very much" -- from now on -- also coming out -- to which I want you to reveal the sublime past of kana -- 1 与 which does not carry out resumption of a series since it is not late -- Although he wants thank you for your consideration and it is another whether comics can be drawn without pakuri on Mr.
-- Yabuki -- (direction kana [ of the black cat which animation-ization will have determined supposing it carries out resumption of a series but ] -- although I want you to carry out and there is nothing --)

2005/06/04 Normal [Original Japanese review]
by Tsunakite Provider: 12676 Host:12322 Browser: 4184
Was it a close くらった work?
It was slightly shocking, when it became the close, since it was interesting so so.
Most contents are already memorized and it does not become precocious.
He does not know about pakuri and is also this pakuri?
The way of BLACK CAT is read and does not become precocious.

Next / Post your review / Top page

ALERT: You cannot use open proxy or TOR for posting your review. If it is detected, your access to this site will be prohibited.

Rule for reviews

This site allows you to write reviews for each title, but we don't allow you to criticize others' comment. Too bad or meaningless words are also not allowed. The comment which doesn't follow the rule will be deleted. If you find any comment which doesn't follow the rule, please notify us by clicking Suggest to delete.

Example to be deleted frequently

Favorite side
You dislike this one, then don't see it or comment this title
- Please go to the fan site. Anyone has the right to say what they feel in this site.

Disliking side
Do you like this one? You are stupid.
- Your view is only your view. Please concentrate on only the content of the title, not on others' comment.

Please use only English. If not, the comment will be deleted.

Your Name(Required)

Password (Required. more than 4 characters)

Your comment about this anime(Required)

Your evaluation of this title(Required)
You can choose the evaluation only once. After you post your evaluation, please choose comment instead of evaluation from the options.

Evaluation of this title(You can choose this only once)

Best!!
Very good
Good
Normal
Bad
Very Bad
Worst

If you evaluated this title once, please choose comment instead of the evaluation.
Comment by the person who thinks this is good
Comment by the person who thinks this is normal
Comment by the person who thinks this is bad

Please choose appropriate option for readers.

Caution: Please post the evaluation which follows the rule.